Call from Senedd members over final say on farming support
He said: 'Today, we're simply asking that this Senedd be given the opportunity to vote: a final, binding vote on the sustainable farming scheme before it is implemented. We all remember last year's protests. We know the strength of feeling across the country.
'A scheme of this scale, affecting over 80% of Wales' land, must carry democratic legitimacy. Let us vote. Let the elected members of this chamber, from every corner of Wales and from every party, have their say.'
The former journalist, who is from a farming family, warned of a 'cliff-edge' in the transition from the basic payment scheme (BPS), which is set to fall by 40 per cent, to the SFS.
He said: "If you don't join the SFS, you forfeit your BPS. If you do join the SFS, you forfeit your BPS entitlements. There's no going back… for you and your business. Is it any wonder anxiety is soaring? Is it any surprise that our farmers' mental health is deteriorating?'
Labour's Lesley Griffiths, a former rural affairs minister, was extremely disappointed to see Welsh ministers cut a target of 43,000 hectares of new woodland by more than 60 per cent, with plans for 10 per cent tree cover on every farm ditched.
Peter Fox, a Tory council leader-turned Senedd member, said he was planning to retire as a farmer having 'just about had enough', with the new SFS 'still laden with bureaucracy'.
'Most farmers just want to farm,' he said. 'They want to produce food and they want to look after their farm… but the priority in this SFS is clearly no longer food production.'
Labour's Lee Waters warned the debate around farming has been dragged into 'culture wars', with divisions heightened by political debate.
Deputy first minister Huw Irranca-Davies said Senedd members would get an opportunity to vote on regulations related to payment rates underpinning the scheme in the autumn.
In the final vote before the Welsh Parliament breaks for summer recess, Senedd members voted narrowly, 22-20, against the opposition motion
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
ITV News
22 minutes ago
- ITV News
Strict behaviour policy blamed for 'exodus of 500 pupils' from Ark Alexandra Academy in Hastings
A Sussex school's strict behaviour policy – which includes a total ban on mobile phones and detention targets for staff – is leading to 'exodus of pupils' and 'discriminating against special needs children', parents and politicians have claimed. An ITV News Meridian investigation has discovered that 472 children have left Ark Alexandra Academy in Hastings over the past three school years before the scheduled end of their secondary education. The data, obtained via a Freedom of Information Request, shows that 28% of the children leaving the school prematurely were recorded as having Special Educational Needs or Disabilities (SEND). The Ark Schools Trust told us they have 'high aspirations for students' and 'work hard to support those with additional education needs'. Labour MP Helena Dollimore, who has raised her concerns about the school in Parliament, described the numbers leaving as an 'exodus' and urged Ark to 'acknowledge the scale of the problem' and 'work with the community rather than against it'. The Hastings & Rye MP told ITV News Meridian: 'Everybody agrees we need strict discipline in our schools but the way this is being implemented is causing a lot of issues and ultimately leading to children falling out of the education system.' Laura Wallis removed her son from the school less than a fortnight after he started Year 7 in September 2024. She claims he was discriminated against because of his ADHD and autism – and was effectively forced to leave. 'Within two weeks of being there he'd racked up nearly four hours worth of detentions. He wasn't walking close enough to the corridor wall – that was a detention. Spatial awareness is one of the things he really struggles with. 'There was no support for both his physical needs and his special educational needs. Their no-nonsense policy pushes children out of the education system.' The figures show that 39% of the children removed from Ark Alexandra are initially home schooled, rather than transferred directly to another school. Laura Wallis's son lost 120 days of classroom education before being accepted into another school, where she says he is 'thriving'. Staff whistleblowers have told ITV News Meridian that the school has a target that each staff member should issue 25 detentions per week. One teacher said while student behaviour had improved since the new policy was introduced, staff and student wellbeing has been impacted as a result. Helena Dollimore, Labour MP for Hastings & Rye, says she's extremely concerned Nigel Woodcock said he removed his daughter from the school in recent months, after almost three years at Ark Alexandra, because of the 'immense affect on her mental wellbeing". 'I wouldn't even explain it as being a prison. The kids aren't allowed to laugh in the hallways, they're not even allowed to sit with their friends at lunchtime except on a Friday", he added. Ark Schools declined our repeated requests for an interview. Instead the trust issued a statement, in which a spokesperson said: 'Ark Alexandra has improved rapidly over the past 18 months: suspensions have fallen significantly, attendance has improved, and students are making good progress in all year groups. 'We have high aspirations for our students and work hard to support those with additional education needs. Everything we do is focused on providing a great education for our children and seeing them thrive.' Justin Wynne, District Secretary at the National Education Union, does not support detention targets In response to the criticism of the detention targets, the Ark Schools spokesperson added: 'We monitor behaviour points to ensure the school's behaviour policy is implemented fairly and consistently. 'Staff are encouraged to award four times more rewards for positive behaviour – with the focus on catching students behaving well, rather than catching them out. This has helped us to create a culture of warmth and high standards.' Academies are state schools not controlled by the local authority but by an academy trust, funded directly by the Department for Education. The government is currently making a series of changes to the rules that academy trusts have to follow, to standardise curriculum, staff pay, conditions and recruitment.
The Independent
an hour ago
- The Independent
Starmer says boosting living standards is central focus of his Government
Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer said he wanted people to feel better-off and more secure by the time of the next election as he set out his priorities in government. Sir Keir said he also wanted people to feel that the National Health Service (NHS) is working better than it was when Labour came into office last year. He also highlighted the need for border security – at a time when small boat crossings of the English Channel are running at record levels – and improvements in defence. After a year in office, Sir Keir was asked what he wanted the UK to look like at the end of his first term in No 10. He told MPs on the Liaison Committee: 'I want people to feel better off and there has to be a central focus on living standards. 'I want them to feel – as they will – that the health service is working much better, is there for them and their families in a way that it hasn't been for many years. 'And I want them to feel safe and secure, both in their immediate neighbourhood and as a country, both our borders and national security and defence. 'So, they're the three things that I'm focused on more than anything else.' Sir Keir's drive to improve the NHS could be derailed if resident doctors in England go ahead with strike action which is due to begin on Friday. The Tory government faced waves of strike action in the NHS which contributed to care backlogs. The Prime Minister has put international co-operation, including a promised one in, one out deal to return small boat migrants to France, at the heart of measures to control the borders. But arrivals are running at record levels for this point in a year, with Home Office figures up to July 19 showed 23,474 people had crossed in small boats. The Liaison Committee, a panel made up of senior MPs who chair the various Commons select committees, was focusing on measures to tackle poverty. The Prime Minister, who is under pressure from within his own party to scrap the two-child benefits cap, said: 'People will not feel better-off or safe and secure if we haven't tackled poverty.' He said there were four 'limbs' to the Government's strategy: increasing incomes, decreasing costs, strengthening local support including measures to get people into work and boosting financial resilience. 'I'm very proud of the fact that the last Labour government drove down poverty and I'm determined this Government is going to as well,' Sir Keir said.
Daily Mirror
an hour ago
- Daily Mirror
Keir Starmer confronted over DWP disability cuts as Labour MP says she was 'ashamed'
Work and Pensions Committee chair Debbie Abrahams told Keir Starmer that the original benefit cuts were 'far removed' from traditional Labour values of fairness and social justice Keir Starmer was confronted by a senior Labour MP, who said the Government's plans to slash disability benefits left her "ashamed". In a tense exchange, Work and Pensions Committee chair Debbie Abrahams said the original plans were 'far removed' from traditional Labour values of fairness and social justice, as well as compassion and common decency'. And she pressed the PM on what he would like to say to the disabled people plunged into "fear and anxiety" before the Government watered down its plans. Ms Abrahams was among the Labour rebels who forced a climbdown on the legislation, which meant proposed cuts to Personal Independence Payments (PIP) were shelved until next year. The clash came as Mr Starmer was grilled by the Commons Liaison Committee ahead of the summer recess - with child poverty and international affairs topping the agenda. Ms Abrahams told the PM: "This was poor legislation. It was designed to save money for the Treasury by cutting support to sick and disabled people. "It was so far removed from Labour values of fairness and social justice, let alone compassion and common decency, I have to say I felt ashamed." Asked what values would drive the Government's reforms, Mr Starmer replied: "I think this is a really important Labour value. "I think the fact that nearly 1 million young people are out of work, not earning or learning, is a huge challenge for our country. None of us should be accepting of a system like that, it is broken and needs to be mended." He added: "We do need to reform the system and we should take that on as a Labour argument in my view." Ms Abrahams replied: "Everybody agrees that reform needs to happen. It is a broken system... reform does not mean cuts to household incomes for already struggling households. "We must do better Prime Minister. You mentioned about reducing poverty. This has the potential of actually increasing it." Earlier, the PM told MPs that "tackling poverty and breaking down barriers" was at the heart of his agenda. He said: "I want people to feel better off and there has to be a central focus on living standards. I want them to feel - as they will - that the health service is working much better, is there for them and their families in a way that it hasn't been for many years. "And I want them to feel safe and secure, both in their immediate neighbourhood and as a country, both our borders and national security and defence. So, they're the three things that I'm focused on more than anything else." Mr Starmer also restated his commitment to driving down child poverty levels. He said: "I'm very proud of the fact that the last Labour government drove down poverty, and I'm determined this Government is going to as well."
