logo
Sugar price surge: FBR willing to share info with NA panel

Sugar price surge: FBR willing to share info with NA panel

ISLAMABAD: The Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) on Tuesday expressed willingness to share detailed information about sugar mills with the National Assembly panel, including strict monitoring measures and potential stock takeover mechanisms.
'We want to present the full facts regarding sugar prices, including the names of sugar mills that have been penalized. Tax collection from the sugar sector has increased from Rs 65 billion to Rs 100 billion — a 56 percent rise — despite low sucrose content,' said Dr Hamid Ateeq Sarwar, Member (Strategic Transformation) FBR, while briefing the National Assembly panel headed by Atif Khan.
The panel, which includes MNAs Tahira Aurangzeb, Mirza Ikhtiar Baig, and Shahida Rehmani, was tasked with investigating the recent surge in sugar prices and examining the patterns of sugar export and import over the years.
Two PTI MNAs Usama Ahmed Mela and Mobeen Arif also participated as special invitees, demanding a chronological explanation for the price hikes. They claimed that a group of 25–40 individuals effectively control the entire sugar sector.
Dr. Sarwar stated that FBR teams are continuously monitoring sugar stock releases using the track and trace system. He noted the immense influence of sugar dealers, claiming that a single dealer can book the entire stock from five mills.
He proposed that the panel invite the Chairman of the Sugar Sector Deregulation Committee, Sardar Awais Ahmed Khan Leghari, to provide input on long-term strategies.
'When the sugar sector is deregulated, the number of mills may drop from the current 78 to around 40. These mills can then operate year-round by importing raw sugar and re-exporting it—similar to the UAE model,' Dr. Sarwar added. He emphasized that Pakistan appears to be moving in that direction through deregulation.
Regarding shareholder data, Dr. Sarwar said that the SECP had submitted a combined list of 190 companies, rather than focusing solely on sugar mills with shareholders holding over 20 percent stakes. Among the mills mentioned were Ramzan Sugar Mills and Arabia Sugar Mills, owned by the sons of Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif.
MNA Tahira Aurangzeb (PML-N) described the price hike as a 'huge manipulation,' stressing that the issue is not one of supply shortage but of inflated pricing.
Panel Convener Atif Khan criticized the lack of clarity in the information provided. 'We asked for a list of sugar mills, but received a mix. We didn't request dealers' names,' he said. 'We deserve a complete list—every sugar mill, every owner. No more shadows. No more secrets. This sugar problem isn't new. It's been eroding our system for decades. Even during General Ayub's era, there were chants of 'sugar thieves.' These people aren't just businessmen—they're politicians, lawmakers. They help write the very laws they manipulate.'
Responding to a question, Dr. Sarwar clarified that GST has been removed only on imported sugar, along with the input tax. However, an 18 percent GST still applies to local sugar. He also revealed that this year's sugarcane output reached 60 million metric tons (MMT), but the sucrose content was only 6.9 percent, far below the expected 10 percent yield. He added that when production is in surplus, growers suffer. Last year, they sold sugarcane for as low as Rs 550 per 40 kg.
Usama Ahmed Mela raised the issue of wheat, noting that while exports are banned due to supposed abundance, sugar—despite being in short supply—is still being exported. 'If wheat is abundant and can't be exported, why is scarce sugar being sent out of the country?' he asked.
Atif Khan reiterated his stance: 'This won't end until we deregulate the sugar industry. Let anyone build a sugar mill. Bring in competition.' His voice grew firmer. 'New players will bring new prices—and lower ones. Right now, it's a monopoly.'
Joining via Zoom from Karachi, Mirza Ikhtiar Baig stressed the need to investigate irregularities in sugar import and export. 'Were these mistakes—or deliberate manipulation?' he asked.
A representative from the Trading Corporation of Pakistan (TCP) informed the panel that the landed cost of imported sugar ranges between $555 and $586 per ton, averaging $559, which translates to Rs 168.50 per kg. With transport and other costs around Rs 10 per kg, the final cost is approximately Rs 180 per kg.
Dr. Sarwar pointed out the inefficiencies in the current import process: 'We need to rethink the entire mechanism. Just shipping costs $60 per ton. When we imported from India, it was only $10.' He suggested sea routes as a viable alternative. 'It's time,' he added. 'The only real solution is deregulation.'
In conclusion, Panel Convener Atif Khan directed SECP officials to provide a complete list of sugar mills, their owners, and all shareholders holding more than 20 percent equity.
Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

SECP introduces ‘Angel Fund' for startups in Pakistan
SECP introduces ‘Angel Fund' for startups in Pakistan

Business Recorder

time2 hours ago

  • Business Recorder

SECP introduces ‘Angel Fund' for startups in Pakistan

ISLAMABAD: The Securities and Exchange Commission of Pakistan (SECP) has introduced 'Angel Fund' a new category of Venture Capital Fund which invests primarily in unlisted securities or financial assets of early-stage startup companies. The SECP has issued a notification here on Monday to amend the Private Fund Regulations, 2015. According to the SECP, the 'Angel Fund' means a sub-category of Venture Capital Fund established in a closed-end Structure which invests primarily in unlisted securities or financial assets of early-stage start-up companies other than Hedge Funds. The 'Eligible Investor' included an individual who has earned an income of at least Rs. 5 million in the preceding financial year or who has net assets of at least Rs. 15 million excluding the value of personal residence and who furnishes a declaration to the Private Fund Management Company that he understands the risks of investment in a Private Fund; a qualified Institutional buyer. Under the revised regulations, 'Financial Close' means the stage when all investment and financing arrangements have been made, funds have been received and the process for commencement of active investment out of Private Fund initiated in accordance with the investment policy as provided in the constitutive documents. The 'Fund of Funds' means a sub-category of a Private Fund established in a close-end structure or open-end structure which invests primarily in units of other Private Funds. The 'Hedge Fund' means a Private Fund established in either open-end or closed-end structure which employs diverse trading strategies and primarily invests and trades in Portfolio Securities and other financial Assets and 'Impact Fund' means a sub-category of a Private Fund established in a closed-end structure which invests primarily in Unlisted Securities or financial assets other than derivatives of socially responsible companies focusing on environmental, social and governance issues. The 'Infrastructure Fund' means a sub-category of Private Fund established in a closed-end structure which invests primarily in Unlisted Securities or financial assets other than derivatives of companies engaged in or formed for the purpose of operating, developing or holding infrastructure projects including transportation, utilities, and energy etc, SECP added. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025

Fragmented climate funding in KP: a costly gamble
Fragmented climate funding in KP: a costly gamble

Business Recorder

time11 hours ago

  • Business Recorder

Fragmented climate funding in KP: a costly gamble

Khyber Pakhtunkhwa (KP) has now endured two climate catastrophes in just three years, and the scale is staggering. In August 2025 alone, flash floods claimed 327 lives, including 158 deaths in Buner in a single week, while more than 1,600 buildings were damaged, 428 livestock lost, and entire tourist families swept away in Swat. These tragedies echo the devastation of 2022, when over 600,000 people were displaced, 7,700 cattle killed, and 326,000 homes destroyed; it is a vivid proof that this cycle is no longer an anomaly but a deepening pattern of climate vulnerability. Pakistan has faced this magnitude before. In 2010, record monsoon rains submerged one-fifth of the country, directly affecting 20 million people, killing nearly 2,000, and inflicting over USD 40 billion in damages to infrastructure, agriculture, and industry. Yet, despite these mounting disasters, KP's climate finance remains fragmented. The province has earmarked billions: Rs 41.1 billion for mitigation and Rs 93.7 billion for adaptation in its 2023-24 budget. On paper, these are impressive figures. In practice, however, this funding risks becoming a costly gamble: poorly tracked, scattered across departments, and dangerously out of sync with escalating risks. The costs of inaction are already visible. Climate shocks are overwhelming local capacity, from catastrophic floods to urban health crises like rising dengue cases in Peshawar, driven by hotter temperatures, erratic rainfall, and higher humidity. In other words, volatility is not just destroying infrastructure, it is driving up health costs and straining already stretched public services. The question is not whether KP is spending money, but whether it is spending it wisely. While mitigation funds are spread across sectors such as forestry, transport, and waste management, there is no central 'climate budget.' This invisibility makes it nearly impossible to track where money goes or how effective it is. Projects that clearly contribute to resilience, say in irrigation or health, are not labelled as climate-related, meaning they cannot be reported domestically or to international funders. This is more than an accounting issue. Pakistan's own National Climate Change Policy (NCCP) and National Adaptation Plan (NAP) stress the need for traceable and transparent financing. By ignoring this, KP not only weakens accountability but also cuts itself off from potential external support. At the national level, reforms are moving in the opposite direction. With support from the IMF, Pakistan has rolled out Climate Budget Tagging (CBT), which integrates climate classification into the federal budget process. A new form, III-C, now tracks climate-related subsidies and programs across ministries. The results are telling. The federal government allocated Rs. 603 billion for mitigation in 2025-26, up 183 percent from the previous year, and Rs 85.4 billion for adaptation, up 83 percent. These are not just inflated figures: they are tagged, traceable, and reportable to international partners like the Green Climate Fund (GCF). This transparency has already improved Pakistan's credibility with global climate finance institutions. In contrast, KP has no such system. Without tagging or a climate-aware financial management framework, even well-intentioned projects risk disappearing into a policy blind spot. The province cannot demonstrate alignment with national priorities, nor can it credibly pitch to global funds. This blind spot is particularly dangerous in a province as climate vulnerable as KP. Floods, forest degradation, and health emergencies are escalating. Without transparent budgeting, every rupee spent on risks becoming a missed opportunity, one that could otherwise attract external finance, build resilience, and reduce losses. For KP, the path forward is clear. The province must adopt climate budget tagging across departments, taking lessons from the federal government's recent reforms, so that climate-related expenditures are visible and traceable. Allocations should be aligned with national frameworks such as the National Adaptation Plan (NAP) and National Climate Change Policy (NCCP), ensuring consistency and coherence with Pakistan's broader climate strategy. Equally important is the disclosure and centralization of climate spending to strengthen accountability and enable external financing opportunities. Departments need to be integrated so that climate action is not scattered across silos but coordinated toward shared outcomes. Climate change is not waiting, and KP cannot afford to either. In a province where over 300 lives were lost in a single season of floods and dengue cases continue to rise, fragmented financing is no longer a bureaucratic flaw. It is a gamble with people's lives. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025

Achakzai is Imran's new pick for NA opp leader
Achakzai is Imran's new pick for NA opp leader

Express Tribune

time14 hours ago

  • Express Tribune

Achakzai is Imran's new pick for NA opp leader

In a move that might have come as a rude shock to many PTI leaders, Imran Khan, the jailed founder of the embattled party, has nominated the maverick chief of PkMAP, Mahmood Khan Achakzai, for opposition leader in the National Assembly. Achakzai's nomination has provided grist to the rumour mill, churning out reports that Imran is increasingly unhappy with the PTI leaders over their failure to mount a formidable challenge against the coalition government which he accuses of stealing his party's mandate. The development comes days after the Election Commission of Pakistan (ECP) disqualified Omar Ayub Khan and Shibli Faraz earlier this month following their convictions in the May 9 cases. Both were formally de-notified as opposition leaders respectively in the National Assembly and the Senate on August 8, along with several other opposition members in the National Assembly and provincial legislatures. PTI Secretary General Salman Akram Raja told reporters outside the Supreme Court on Wednesday that Imran had also nominated Senator Azam Swati as Leader of the Opposition in the Senate. He added that the PTI founder had sought five names from the party for nomination to the post of Leader of the Opposition in the Punjab Assembly. Raja further said that Imran had tasked the party's political committee with finalising its strategy for the upcoming by-elections on seats that fell vacant after the disqualification of lawmakers in the May 9 cases. The committee was scheduled to meet later in the day to make decisions, he added. He confirmed that Achakzai, who currently heads the Tehreek-e-Tahaffuz Ayeen-e-Pakistan (TTAP), would replace Omar Ayub in the National Assembly. In a separate address in Lahore, Raja urged political forces to unite against what he termed oppression and arbitrary arrests. "It does not matter where you come from or which party you belong to - if you have empathy, we are together," he said. "For the permanence of humanity and dignity, this struggle has to be fought." He warned that "anyone can be detained for any reason" under the prevailing circumstances, adding that "the only law in this country is fear." Raja assured party supporters that the PTI leadership would take their struggle to "every available forum." He said the wider movement was not just about the party's politics but about protecting fundamental rights. "What does the supremacy of law and the Constitution mean? It means having the right to protest under Article 17. Article 15 allows free movement. Article 19 gives us the right to raise and spread our voice together," he noted. He also spoke about the plight of farmers and the poor across the country, saying: "I listened to people in Sindh, it brought tears to my eyes. But this suffering is not limited to Sindh - it is everywhere." Calling for a united front, the PTI leader said, "We all have rights and we are all human. If we fail to act, those rights will erode further." Referring to the devastation caused by floods, Raja said they were not purely natural disasters but were aggravated by "human greed and mismanagement." "We need to eradicate this greed in the same way our forests are being cut down. If we do not stand up now, we may lose the ability to raise our voice altogether," he warned.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store