Biden team wanted to ‘get rid' of Netanyahu for opposing its Gaza plans
The Biden administration considered ways to 'get rid' of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu when he wouldn't go along with their plans for the Gaza Strip, Channel 13's weekly investigative news show 'HaMakor' ('The Source') revealed on April 27.
'The White House got tired of Netanyahu and started to roll around a revolutionary idea … : how to get rid of Netanyahu,' said Raviv Drucker, who hosts the hour-long Sunday show.
Advertisement
The April 27 broadcast, titled 'All the President's Men,' involved in-depth interviews with nine members of former U.S. President Joe Biden's administration, including former U.S. ambassador to Israel Thomas Nides, former national security advisor Jake Sullivan, former White House national security communications advisor John Kirby, former senior advisor for energy Amos Hochstein and former senior Biden aide Ilan Goldenberg.
5 According to investigative news show, 'HaMakor,' the Biden administration wanted to 'get rid' of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu due to Gaza Strip plans.
REUTERS
Worth noting is that the program was an apologia for the Biden administration, and that Drucker is a long-time critic of Netanyahu. The episode criticized the prime minister throughout, portraying him as ungrateful, as torpedoing potential hostage deals for political reasons and missing a chance to sign a normalization agreement with Saudi Arabia, among other missteps.
According to the program, the Biden administration became aggravated by Netanyahu's refusal to discuss the end goal of Israel's ground invasion of Gaza, specifically, who would take charge of the Gaza Strip after Hamas had been ousted.
Advertisement
The Biden team proposed handing security to a foreign force, which would then turn Gaza over to Palestinian control, Goldenberg told 'HaMakor.'
'We actually had a pretty good program of training Palestinian security forces in the West Bank … But in the short term you needed something, probably Egyptians, Arabs … to come in and temporarily hold it because those Palestinians wouldn't be ready for a while,' he said.
Reflecting the Biden team's assessment that Netanyahu was standing in the way, Goldenberg told 'HaMakor's' Drucker that Israeli opposition leaders Benny Gantz and Gadi Eisenkot of the opposition National Unity Party, as well as the Defense Ministry and Israel Security Agency (Shin Bet), 'were willing to have those conversations … but the Prime Minister's Office is saying no.'
Advertisement
Goldenberg expressed the opinion that Netanyahu didn't want to discuss the 'day after' because it would open a 'Pandora's box' and risk the stability of his coalition as its most right-wing members, namely Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich of the Religious Zionism Party and National Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir of the Otzma Yehudit Party, would not stand for a solution that put Palestinians in control of the Strip.
5 President Joe Biden speaks with national security advisers after a bilateral meeting with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu on July 25, 2024.
White House
Goldenberg, who now serves as senior vice president and chief policy officer at J Street, a U.S. nonprofit that calls for the creation of a Palestinian state, told the program, 'There were a lot of people who are talking about, including in the Oval Office, at times, the idea of … the president going out and giving a speech.'
The speech apparently would have been geared to helping Gantz, as he was perceived as being more open to the White House's plans.
Advertisement
'Gantz was at 37 and Bibi was like at 15 … he was very weak,' Goldenberg said, referring to winter 2023 polls showing Gantz's party strengthening to 37 or 38 Knesset seats while Netanyahu's Likud Party dropped to between 16 and 18.
5 Biden meets with Netanyahu to discuss the ongoing conflict between Israel and Hamas, in Tel Aviv, Israel, in October 2023.
via REUTERS
'Joe Biden was still incredibly popular in Israel,' Goldenberg added, appearing to suggest Biden would parlay that popularity into votes for Netanyahu's opponents.
'The idea was that President Biden would place before the Israeli public two options,' Drucker explained.
'You can end the war, get all the hostages out, get a deal … Or, you keep doing what you're doing … Israel is in a forever war … Your sons and daughters are going to keep fighting. Most of the hostages are going to come home dead,' said Goldenberg.
'The idea would be to either force Netanyahu to come on board with that, or scramble Israeli politics and see if you could trigger elections … That's what people are saying. Let's just break this up because it's not going anywhere good,' Goldenberg added.
5 'The idea would be to either force Netanyahu to come on board with that, or scramble Israeli politics and see if you could trigger elections,' former senior Biden aide Ilan Goldenberg said.
via REUTERS
Biden did start criticizing Netanyahu publicly at the time. In February 2024, Biden said Israel's military offensive was 'over the top.' The following month, he said Netanyahu is 'hurting Israel more than helping Israel.'
Advertisement
Also in March 2024, then-Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-N.Y.) condemned Netanyahu on the Senate floor, saying he had 'lost his way by allowing his political survival to take precedence over the best interests of Israel.' Schumer called for elections to replace Netanyahu.
According to 'HaMakor,' Biden told his people, 'I don't understand how Netanyahu is holding onto power.'
5 Biden has previously said Israel's military offensive was 'over the top.'
REUTERS
In the end, Biden 'didn't dare turn his statements into policy,' Drucker said.
Advertisement
Said Goldenberg: 'There was a real debate about that. I think at the end of the day he was uncomfortable with the idea of going out that directly against Netanyahu.'
While Biden stopped short of going all-out to challenge Netanyahu, according to Goldenberg, the apparent willingness to consider the possibility once more raises questions about U.S. interference in Israel's internal politics.
The Biden administration has previously been accused of funneling money to Israeli groups opposed to the government's judicial reform plan via the U.S. Agency for International Development (USAID).
Advertisement
The Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE), formed by the Trump administration to investigate improper funding, found that basic oversight was lacking, making it unlikely a smoking gun will be discovered pointing to USAID grants going to Israeli NGOs.
However, the accusations were enough to lead the Netanyahu coalition to introduce a bill in the Knesset 'to reduce the indirect influence of foreign government and political entities on the State of Israel.'
The bill, still working its way through the legislative process, would impose an 80% tax on donations from foreign entities to Israeli nonprofits. Such donations are currently tax-free.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
33 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Seized Gaza aid boat Madleen carrying Greta Thunberg taken to Israeli port
A Gaza-bound aid boat illegally seized in international waters by Israeli forces has been towed into Ashdod Port, with the dozen international activists who were on board now facing detention and deportation. The Freedom Flotilla Coalition (FFC), which launched the ship to draw international attention to the looming famine in besieged Gaza, said it was captured at about 4:02am (01:02 GMT) on Monday, about 200km (120 miles) from Gaza, arriving at Ashdod as night fell. Earlier, the coalition released a video from the vessel, which left Sicily on June 1, showing the activists – among whom are climate campaigner Greta Thunberg and French member of the European Parliament Rima Hassan – with their hands up as Israeli forces boarded the vessel and 'kidnapped' them. Adalah, a Palestinian legal centre representing the activists, said they were expected to be held at a detention facility before being deported. It said that Israel had 'no legal authority' to take over the ship, which was in international waters, heading not to Israel but to the 'territorial waters of the State of Palestine'. The arrests of the 12 'unarmed activists' amounted to 'a serious breach of international law', it said in a statement. Huwaida Arraf, an FFC organiser, told Al Jazeera there had been no contact with the activists since they had been detained in the early hours of Monday. 'We have lawyers on standby who are going to demand they have access to them tonight – as soon as possible,' she said. The Madleen, she noted, was sailing under a United Kingdom flag when it was forcibly seized by Israeli commandos. 'So Israel went into international waters and attacked sovereign UK territory, which is blatantly unlawful. And we expect strong condemnation, which we have not yet heard from the United Kingdom,' she UK government urged Israel to handle its detention of the activists 'safely with restraint, in line with international humanitarian law'. 'We have made clear our position in relation to the humanitarian situation in Gaza. The PM has called it appalling and intolerable,' said a spokesperson for Prime Minister Keir Starmer. Francesca Albanese, the United Nations special rapporteur for the occupied Palestinian territory, said: 'Israel has absolutely no authority to intercept and stop a boat like this, which carries humanitarian aid, and more than everything else, humanity, to the people of Gaza.' Al Jazeera's Nour Odeh, reporting from Jordan's capital Amman, said the activists would be accused of entering Israel illegally. 'These activists had no intention to enter Israel. They wanted to reach the shores of Gaza, which are not part of Israel,' she said. 'But that is how they will be processed, and they will be deported because of that.'Israel's Ministry of Foreign Affairs portrayed the voyage as a public relations stunt, saying in a post on X that 'the 'selfie yacht' of the 'celebrities' is safely making its way to the shores of Israel'. It said the passengers were 'undergoing medical examinations to ensure they are in good health', adding that all passengers were expected to return to their home countries. Government spokesperson David Mencer reserved special scorn for 22-year-old Thunberg. 'Greta was not bringing aid, she was bringing herself. And she's not here for Gaza, let's be blunt about it. She's here for Greta,' he said. In a prerecorded video message that was shared by the FFC, Thunberg said: 'I urge all my friends, family and comrades to put pressure on the Swedish government to release me and the others as soon as possible.' The Swedish Ministry for Foreign Affairs said it was in contact with Israeli authorities. 'Should the need for consular support arise, the Embassy and the Ministry of Foreign Affairs will assess how we can best help the Swedish citizen/Greta Thunberg resolve her situation,' said a spokesperson in a written statement to the Reuters news agency. United States President Donald Trump, who targeted Thunberg in 2019, dismissed her statement. 'I think Israel has enough problems without kidnapping Greta Thunberg,' he said. French President Emmanuel Macron's office said the president had asked Israeli authorities to release the six French nationals on board as soon as possible, calling the humanitarian blockade of Gaza 'a scandal' and a 'disgrace'. Turkey condemned the interception as a 'heinous attack', while Iran denounced it as 'a form of piracy' in international waters. Israeli Minister of Defence Israel Katz said the activists would be shown videos of atrocities committed during the October 7, 2023, Hamas-led attack on southern Israel. Hamas condemned the seizure of the boat as 'state terrorism' and said it saluted its activists. On the ground in Gaza, Israeli forces continued their onslaught, killing 60 Palestinians since dawn, according to medical sources who spoke to Al Jazeera. Among them were three medics, killed in Gaza City, as well as 13 hungry aid seekers, killed near an Israeli- and US-backed aid distribution site in southern Gaza. More than 130 people have been killed near distribution points run by the shadowy Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF) since late May. Israel engaged the group to distribute aid amid its total blockade on all imports, including food, fuel and medicine, as Israel ramped up its offensive after breaking its ceasefire agreement with Hamas in United Nations and other aid groups have refused to cooperate with the GHF, accusing it of lacking neutrality and suggesting the group has been formed to enable Israel to achieve its stated military objective of taking over all of Gaza. 'Israeli authorities have blocked the delivery of safe and dignified aid at scale to the people of Gaza for over three months now,' said the UN agency for Palestinian refugees, UNRWA, on Monday. 'We are not asking for the impossible. Allow us to do our work: assist people in need and preserve their dignity,' it said. On Monday, Israeli aircraft also bombed tents sheltering displaced families in al-Katiba square in Gaza City, causing additional deaths and injuries. They also targeted the Shaarawi and Haddad buildings in the Tuffah neighbourhood, east of Gaza City, resulting in multiple casualties. At least one person was killed and others injured in an artillery attack on Old Gaza Street in Jabalia, in the north. Israel has killed at least 54,927 people in Gaza since the start of the war, a figure estimated to be far lower than the actual death toll.
Yahoo
33 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Satellite images show damaged North Korean warship moved to a port for repair, report says
SEOUL (Reuters) -A North Korean stricken destroyer that partially capsized during a botched launching ceremony has arrived at a ship repair factory, a Washington think tank said. The destroyer that suffered a failed launch was moved to the graving dock at Rajin Dockyard, also known as Rajin Ship Repair Factory, by June 8, the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS) said based on satellite imagery. State media reported on Friday that experts would examine the hull for the next stage of restorations, to be carried out at Rajin Dockyard for 7-10 days. North Korean leader Kim Jong Un, who witnessed the failed launch of the destroyer, called the accident a "criminal act". Since the accident in May, North Korea has said it detained several officials, and Kim ordered the ship restored before a ruling party meeting this month. The Rajin shipyard, located near the Russian border, has produced many of North Korea's larger warships for decades, CSIS said. "Once any critical repairs or restoration work are completed, the vessel will likely be transferred to the shipyard's fitting out dock, where its weapons and other systems will be installed and subsequently commissioned," the think tank said in a report. The ship lay on its side in the water after the botched launch, but it was pulled upright, according to U.S. researchers and the South Korean military. The 5,000-ton destroyers launched by North Korea this year are the country's largest warships yet, part of leader Kim's push to upgrade its naval power with vessels capable of carrying and launching dozens of missiles.
Yahoo
33 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Trump's Guard deployment to LA protests puts Newsom in political predicament
By Joseph Ax and Trevor Hunnicutt (Reuters) -Soon after scattered protests broke out in Los Angeles on Friday in the wake of federal immigration raids, President Donald Trump and California Governor Gavin Newsom spoke by phone. Trump never mentioned any federal response, according to Newsom, who described the conversation as "very cordial" on MSNBC on Sunday. Twenty-four hours later, Trump ordered thousands of National Guard troops to the state, bypassing Newsom and igniting another firestorm over his aggressive efforts to deport migrants living in the U.S. illegally. For Newsom, governor of the nation's most populous state and a potential 2028 Democratic presidential candidate, Trump's gambit has created substantial political risks. Throughout Trump's first and second terms, Democratic governors have struggled to find the most effective approach to dealing with the mercurial Republican president; confronting Trump can result in backlash, but conceding ground sometimes encourages him to push harder. Newsom and Trump have often clashed in the past, with Trump calling the governor "Newscum" and Newsom declaring after Trump's election victory that he would "Trump-proof" California. During Trump's first months in office, however, Newsom has often opted for appeasement rather than antagonism - meeting the president on the tarmac when Trump visited during January's devastating wildfires and interviewing leading Trump acolytes such as Charlie Kirk and Steve Bannon on his new podcast. But Trump's decision to send troops into California - the first time in decades that a president had done so absent a request from a governor - and his claim that Los Angeles was being "invaded" by violent mobs appear to have convinced Newsom to abandon his conciliatory approach. "I've always wanted to approach engagement with the president of the United States in a respectful and responsible way," Newsom told MSNBC on Sunday. "But there's no working with the president, there's only working for him – and I will never work for Donald Trump." Speaking to reporters on Monday, Trump said Newsom was incompetent and that he should be arrested. "I think his primary crime is running for governor because he's done such a bad job," Trump said when asked what crime Newsom had committed. 'A DELICATE ACT' The state sued Trump on Monday, seeking to force him to rescind the Guard deployment. Meanwhile, about 700 Marines will be sent to Los Angeles until more Guard personnel can arrive, a U.S. official said. Newsom is trying to navigate choppy political waters, according to strategists from both parties. As the governor of California, a deep-blue Democratic state that Trump has gleefully caricatured at every opportunity, Newsom could struggle to appeal to swing voters as a national candidate without moderating his image. There is also the risk that angering Trump could harm Newsom's 39 million constituents; the governor is still waiting for federal funding to help rebuild after the wildfires, while the president recently threatened to cut the state's education funding after a transgender girl competed in a girls' track and field championship event. At the same time, Democratic voters want to see their leaders fight tooth-and-nail against what they see as Trump's lawlessness and corruption. "He's serving his own ambitions as well as the state of California, and those two things don't often coincide," said Steven Maviglio, a longtime Democratic consultant in the state. "It's a dilemma for Newsom." The protests allowed Trump to tout his hardline immigration policies while claiming California was helpless to stop the violence without his intervention. "On this one, I think the president has really check-mated the governor," Maviglio added. "This fed right into his scenario of what California is all about...a wildly liberal state with lawlessness and immigrants and no rules." Jon Fleischman, a Republican strategist and former executive director of the state Republican Party, said images of burning cars and protesters waving Mexican flags only served to bolster Trump's position. Newsom, he argued, had taken Trump's bait by blaming him for the escalation of violence. "Donald Trump can't force somebody to throw a rock at a police car," he said. Other Democratic governors have grappled with similar predicaments under Trump's administration. In April, Michigan Governor Gretchen Whitmer, also seen as a potential 2028 presidential candidate, visited the White House to discuss the future of a military base in her state, but was caught by surprise in the Oval Office when Trump signed executive orders targeting his political enemies. A photograph of the governor covering her face from cameras went viral. "Balancing your state's needs and working with President Trump, if you're a Democratic governor, is always going to be a delicate act," said Chris Meagher, a Democratic communications consultant. "I think the more that Governor Newsom can keep his head down and do the work and show that he has the situation under control, the better off that he's going to be."
