Piardi call in Australia-Lions test should be accepted, Erasmus says
South Africa coach Rassie Erasmus believes the decision to award the British & Irish Lions a series-winning try in last weekend's 29-26 win over Australia was "touch-and-go" but World Rugby's explanation of the contentious call should be accepted.
The Lions won the test with a try from Hugo Keenan in the final seconds but Australia believe a ruling from referee Andrea Piardi at a ruck immediately beforehand was incorrect.
Australia coach Joe Schmidt said the call was an error in his post-match press conference, suggesting Jac Morgan's clear-out of Carlo Tizzano was dangerous, and Rugby Australia chief executive Phil Waugh said he would seekg "accountability" from World Rugby over it.
But Erasmus, who received a two-month ban from World Rugby for a 62-minute video that was critical of Australian referee Nic Berry after the first Lions test in South Africa in 2021, said he could see both sides of the argument.
"I had Australia (winning) by four points in the game, so I lost our internal (coach's competition) on that one," Erasmus told reporters with a smile on Tuesday.
"It's such a tough decision. World Rugby has come out to say it was the right decision. It was a very tough call for the referee to make.
"If I was Joe, I would be really disappointed, and if I was (Lions coach) Andy (Farrell), I would be really happy. I think it was touch-and-go, so I can understand both sides of what each coach sees.
Top stories
Swipe. Select. Stay informed.
Singapore Grace Fu apologises for Tanjong Katong sinkhole, says road may stay closed for a few more days
Singapore Terrorism threat in Singapore remains high, driven by events like Israeli-Palestinian conflict: ISD
Singapore S'pore can and must meaningfully apply tech like AI in a way that creates jobs for locals: PM Wong
Singapore 7, including child and firefighter, taken to hospital after fire breaks out in Toa Payoh flat
Sport IOC president Kirsty Coventry a 'huge supporter' of Singapore
Singapore Man on trial for raping woman who hired him to repair lights in her flat
Singapore Doctor who forged certificates for aesthetic procedures gets 4 months' jail
Singapore ICA inspector obtained bribes in the form of sex acts from 6 foreign men in exchange for his help
"But World Rugby has ruled on it and that is what everybody has to accept."
World Rugby chief Alan Gilpin backed the call from Piardi earlier on Tuesday.
"We do share with Joe and the coaching team why the match officials made that decision," he said.
"Joe's got a view about what was wrong with that decision and there'll be a debate so that Joe and his players can go into the next test understanding how that game's going to be officiated."
South Africa will host Australia in two Rugby Championship tests in Johannesburg and Cape Town next month.
Italian Piardi will officiate the defending champion Springboks' final match in the competition against Argentina in London in October. REUTERS
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CNA
an hour ago
- CNA
Ledecky throws down the gauntlet ahead of 800 freestyle showdown with McIntosh
Katie Ledecky showed it will take a monumental effort to pry the 800 metres freestyle title from her grip after the American great came home more than five seconds quicker that Summer McIntosh in the world championships heats on Friday. Ledecky, a four-time Olympic and six-times world champion in the event, posted a time of eight minutes and 14.62 seconds, with Australian Lani Pallister second quickest (8:17.06) and 18-year-old Canadian McIntosh third fastest (8:19.88). McIntosh is attempting to match Michael Phelps's record of five individual titles at a single world championship and while she already has three in the bag, beating Ledecky in the 800 looks like her biggest challenge. Ledecky, 28, broke her own 800 world record in May, swimming 8:04.12 to improve a mark she set nearly a decade ago at the Rio Games, but McIntosh has been making waves in the event. She posted the third-fastest time ever in June and ended Ledecky's 13-year unbeaten streak in 2024 when she bested the American at a sectionals meeting in Florida. McIntosh said she had been conserving energy for the final. "My goal was just to win my heat, to pretty much secure that I'll get a lane for tomorrow night's final, and do that with the least amount of energy possible," she added. Serbian Andrej Barna was quickest in the men's 50 freestyle heats (21.44), with Olympic champion Cameron McEvoy of Australia fourth (21.53). McEvoy's compatriot Kyle Chalmers, a former Olympic and world champion in the 100, failed to make the semi-finals while David Popovici pulled out of the event after sealing both the 100 and 200 titles this week. Kaylee McKeown topped the women's 200 backstroke heats with a swim of 2:08.01, while her American rival Regan Smith was fifth fastest with 2:08.65. Defending champion Claire Curzan, who completed a world 50, 100 and 200 backstroke treble in Doha last year, was third quickest. Swiss Noe Ponti was top seed into the men's 100 butterfly semi-finals with a time of 50.68, leading a tight field of 16 swimmers who were all separated by just 0.9 seconds. There were some concerns over Gretchen Walsh's fitness when she withdrew from the 100 freestyle prelims on Thursday, after sickness swept through the U.S. team camp in the lead-up to the meet, but she squashed those fears by topping the 50 butterfly heats with a time of 25.22. Olympic champions Britain will be favourites for the men's 4x200 freestyle relay gold in the evening session after finishing quickest (7:03.98) in the heats. The evening programme will begin with Australian Mollie O'Callaghan's attempt to add the 100 freestyle title to her 200 crown.
Straits Times
2 hours ago
- Straits Times
Gauff fights back to advance in Canada, Medvedev crashes out
Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox Top seed Coco Gauff staged a thrilling comeback to reach the last 16 of the Canadian Open on Thursday, while former U.S. Open champion Daniil Medvedev was knocked out of the men's tournament by Australian Alexei Popyrin. World number two Gauff clawed her way back from a set down to defeat Russian Veronika Kudermetova 4–6 7–5 6–2 in a match that stretched over two and a half hours. "It was a tough match today," the French Open champion said. "I thought I did well mentally, especially on the return. I was playing an opponent who served really well. Obviously, I would have liked to serve better, but I'm just happy to get through." Ukrainian Dayana Yastremska stunned American eighth seed Emma Navarro 7–5 6–4 while Russian fourth seed Mirra Andreeva also exited the tournament, losing 7–6(5) 6–4 to American McCartney Kessler. Ninth seed Elena Rybakina from Kazakhstan saw off Romanian Jaqueline Cristian 6–0 7–6(5). On the men's side, Alex Michelsen toppled third seed Lorenzo Musetti 3–6 7–6(4) 6–4 in a gripping third-round contest. The American 26th seed shrugged off a sluggish start to unleash a barrage of big hitting and keep the Italian on the ropes. The shocks kept coming as 10th seed Medvedev was stunned by 18th seed Popyrin 5–7 6–4 6–4, while German top seed Alexander Zverev had to come from a set down to defeat Italian Matteo Arnaldi 6-7(5) 6–3 6–2 to claim his 500th tour-level match win. Eighth seed Casper Ruud from Norway beat Portugal's Nuno Borges 7–5 6–4, fifth seed Holger Rune cruised past Alexandre Muller 6–2 6–4, and Francisco Cerundolo defeated his Argentine compatriot Tomas Etcheverry 6–3 6–4. REUTERS
CNA
3 hours ago
- CNA
Australia lose two hookers ahead of Lions series finale
SYDNEY :The Wallabies have been forced to call Brandon Paenga-Amosa into the team for Saturday's final test against the British & Irish Lions after hookers Dave Porecki and Matt Faessler both picked up injuries in training. Porecki, who started last week's second test, suffered a heel injury and Faessler, who started the first, picked up a calf issue in training on Thursday. Billy Pollock moves up from the replacements to start in place of Porecki on Saturday, while Paenga-Amosa will come off the bench as the Wallabies look to grab a consolation win after losing the first two tests. Captain Harry Wilson said the team had great faith in the powerful Paenga-Amosa, who played the last of his 20 tests against Ireland last November. "Brandon joined us yesterday afternoon after a bit of a tough Thursday training session, it's obviously gutting to lose great players in Porecki and Fez," the number eight told reporters at Stadium Australia on Friday. "But we've got a lot of confidence in BPA, he's been around this group for quite a long time over the last year and he's already faced the Lions three times. So he's got a lot of confidence and ... he has fit in very quickly." Paenga-Amosa, who faced the Lions in tour matches for Western Force, the Australia-New Zealand selection and the First Nations-Pasifika XV, will bring power to the front row but his lineout throwing has sometimes been wayward. Coach Joe Schmidt had already been forced into three changes to his team by injuries but Wilson said it had been good to have fresh faces Taniela Tupou and Dylan Pietsch in the matchday squad. "What they've given us is fresh legs on the training park, fresh energy, more chatter around the training field. Just been nice and they're just raring to go," he said. "They've had to watch the last two test matches so they're all very excited at this opportunity and I've got no doubt they'll take it." The fourth change Schmidt made in his initial selection was a call-up for Nic White, who announced on Thursday that he would be retiring from test rugby after Saturday's match. The Wallabies players all wore fake moustaches at Friday's training session in honour of the scrumhalf's famously hairy upper lip. "He's a competitor, and he's loved by the group," Wilson said. "He will be missed in this gold jersey, because he really does represent what it is to be a Wallaby." Wilson admitted the players had been crushed after losing the second test to a last-minute try last Saturday but spirits had risen during the week. "We just want to keep improving. We want to keep being a better team," he said. "We need to play an 80 minute game and get the result which I think we deserve for each other." Revised team: 15–Tom Wright, 14–Max Jorgensen, 13–Joseph Suaalii, 12–Len Ikitau, 11–Dylan Pietsch, 10–Tom Lynagh, 9–Nic White, 8–Harry Wilson, 7–Fraser McReight, 6–Tom Hooper, 5–Will Skelton, 4–Nick Frost, 3–Taniela Tupou, 2–Billy Pollard, 1–James Slipper
