Where does the UK media draw the line on platforming far-right voices?
Welcome to this week's Media Watch! Remember you can get this newsletter straight into your inbox every week by clicking the banner above.
On BBC Newsnight last week, an intriguing concept was raised by former BBC presenter Matthew Stadlen as he criticised the platforming of anti-Muslim 'extremist' Douglas Murray on the programme.
As he expressed his concern about the BBC interviewing the assistant editor of The Spectator – who previously accused ex-first minister Humza Yousaf of 'infiltrating' the UK political system – he mentioned how the Overton window had shifted 'so significantly' that Murray had been given an eight-minute interview on prime time television.
In a video podcast with The Rubin Report – a conservative US political talk show – in 2023, Murray called Yousaf the 'First Minister of Gaza' and described his Palestinian wife Nadia El-Nakla as a 'nasty piece of work'.
READ MORE: BBC quietly edits false report hiding Israel minister's UK visit
Stadlen said of him appearing on Newsnight: "Imagine just for a moment being one of the millions of British Muslims, law-abiding British Muslims, watching him say those things."
Stadlen said he didn't want to criticise the BBC for bringing Murray on, but seemed to suggest the mainstream media was at a tricky juncture where far-right voices have now become so acceptable to the public, major broadcasters are being left with little choice but to platform them.
The Overton window is the range of subjects and arguments deemed politically acceptable to the mainstream population at a given time. It is a term named after American policy analyst Joseph Overton, who proposed that the political viability of an idea depends mainly on whether it falls within an acceptability range, rather than on the individual preferences of politicians using the term or concept.
According to Overton, the window frames the range of policies that a politician may recommend without appearing too extreme to gain or keep public office given the climate of public opinion at that particular time.
What Stadlen said left me pondering what seems to be a chicken and egg situation; does the media feed the public or does the public feed the media? And how much should one feed the other?
Nigel Farage on the BBC speaking to Laura Kuenssberg (Image: Jeff Overs/BBC/PA Wire) As journalists we have to have our ear to the ground on what concerns the public, who they most want to hear from, and the questions they want answering.
A series of polls now have confirmed the rapid rise in support for Reform, with them now predicted to return more MPs than Labour and the Tories.
In Scotland this week, a cross-party summit is being held on tackling the rise of the far right, which the Tories are not even attending. Reform's sudden hold on society is unquestionable, like it or not.
There was a time when there was widespread criticism of Reform UK leader Nigel Farage being extensively platformed when he had had no electoral success to speak of but, as painful as it may be, the Overton window does seem to have shifted so much that we're going to have deal with Farage on our TV screens in the years to come.
READ MORE: MPs call for Donald Trump to be blocked from addressing Parliament
But while more populist politics may have become acceptable to society, where do mainstream media institutions like the BBC draw the line?
While there is a responsibility to platform the figures people want to hear from, is there not is also a responsibility to protect them from misinformation and harmful voices?
And while some may feel they have no choice but to platform hard-right or right-wing voices, isn't there at least a responsibility to robustly challenge what they say?
These are questions media institutions are going to be grappling with a lot in the months to come in what is becoming an increasingly hostile political environment, and it will be fascinating to see which broadcasters and publications become effortlessly subservient to the people and which ones choose to stand up for what is right.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Spectator
an hour ago
- Spectator
How many countries have banned the burqa?
Behind the veil How many countries have banned the burqa? At least 24 have placed some restrictions around the wearing of full-face coverings in public, although in most cases it applies only in public buildings. Interestingly, they encompass liberal democracies and dictatorships, Muslim-dominated and non Muslim-dominated countries. They are: Algeria, Austria, Azerbaijan, Belgium, Bulgaria, Canada, Chad, China, Denmark, France (general ban in public), Gabon, Kosovo, Kyrgyzstan, Latvia, Luxembourg, Netherlands, Norway, Sri Lanka, Switzerland, Tajikistan, Tunisia, Turkmenistan, Turkey and Uzbekistan. In Afghanistan, the wearing of a burqa or niqab (which has a slit for the eyes) is compulsory for women. Degrees of separation Is it still worth going to university? – In 2024 the median salary for graduates of working age was £42,000, up £2,000 from 2023. The median salary for non-graduates was £30,500. – However, graduate salaries have not kept pace with inflation. In 2007 the median graduate salary was £30,000. At 2007 prices the median graduate salary is now £26,500. – 88% of working-age graduates are in employment, compared with 68% of non-graduates. – 68% are in highly skilled employment, compared with 24% of non-graduates. – Students starting a full-time undergraduate course in September will take out an average of £49,470 in student loans. Interest will be levied at the rate of RPI inflation and borrowers will be liable to repay 9% of their salary over £25,000 for up to 40 years. Source: Department for Education Mine own Nigel Farage said a Reform UK government would reopen coal mines. How much coal does the UK produce and how much coal is there potentially to exploit? – In 2024 the UK produced just 107,000 tons of coal, down 99% in ten years. – Yet according to analysis by coal industry trade body Euracoal in 2015 there are 3.56bn tons of known coal resources lying unexploited beneath Britain, with a further 184bn tons estimated to exist. – In 2015, Britain's annual energy consumption – in all forms – was the equivalent of 257m tons. – Therefore, known coal reserves would be sufficient to provide Britain's entire energy needs for just under 14 years, and estimated reserves enough to provide Britain's entire energy needs for around 730 years.
Spectator
2 hours ago
- Spectator
I've lost control of the kitchen
Looking back, I can pinpoint my fatal blunder. It was lunch. It was like the West allowing Vladimir Putin to help himself to the Crimean peninsula without a peep, basically. This is how it happened. My husband had invited two families to stay over the May bank holiday which bled into half term. For four days. 'Don't worry,' he said, in light tones, ahead of their arrival. 'I've told them they're bringing all the food and doing all the cooking.' As if I'd welcome this wonderful idea, when in fact what he'd suggested was the domestic equivalent of handing over the nuclear football and the codes behind my back. The guests are delightful and I couldn't wait to have them all (five adults and five children), but guests handling the catering was never going to happen under my roof, as my husband ought to have known. One, I am a fast and capable cook. I came second to Ed Balls in the final of the BBC's Celebrity Best Home Cook series (and maintain that he won because he made a pirate cake with full sails out of chocolate and he blubbed). Two, if an Englishman's home is his castle, the female equivalent of the White House Situation Room is a woman's kitchen. The last thing I needed, in other words, was several other bossy middle-class parents occupying my catering HQ on Exmoor. Plus, I'd already ordered a van-busting home delivery from Sainsbury's. On the Art of War principle that 'supreme excellence consists of breaking the enemies' resistance without fighting', I replied: 'Oh no, don't worry! But maybe they can do lunches?' Category error on my part. Perhaps I'm late to the party here but, as it turned out, the families didn't really have a concept of 'lunch' as a separate meal, after breakfast and before supper. They simply prepared and ate fare whenever they or their children were hungry, which was, of course, all the time. In more civilised places than the Johnson compound, i.e. Provence or Tuscany, when you have 12 people for four days it's understood that one of the 'main' meals will be 'out', i.e. at a restaurant to spare mine hosts, and the convention is that the guests stump for this. But the farm is two miles from Tarmac. It's an hour round trip for a pint of milk. A two-hour round trip to a pub. All meals are eaten in and none are 'opt'. The last thing I needed was several other bossy middle-class parents occupying my catering HQ on Exmoor On day one, everyone arrived at teatime after extended drives on the M4 and M5. We had tea and cake, and a late-ish supper. So far, so good. Two meals down! Day two was different. When provisioning, I'd texted my husband's nephew to ask what his three heavenly girls ate for breakfast. 'Bacon eggs toast juice fruit yoghurts porridge etc,' came the detailed reply. I therefore rose at 8 a.m. to slam the first tray of bacon in, yet there were people refilling the coffee jug and boiling eggs and stirring porridge at elevenses. Still, the guests did a fine clear-up and cleared off with the kids to a local beauty spot while I made scones for tea. Everyone returned from Tarr Steps at 1 p.m., making noises about their lunch duty, and invaded the kitchen. For hours. With what I felt was superhuman restraint – I can make an apple crumble in five minutes flat, and on Best Home Cook I made crab ravioli on a bed of fennel with a citrus jus from scratch starting with flour and water for the homemade pasta in 35 minutes – I only said 'But how long does it actually take to boil rice?' loudly around three times. At 3 p.m. (!) there was a simple lunch of delicious dahl (brought from London in Tupperware) and the rice on the table. As I shovelled it in, I worked out that at this rate, there would be half an hour until tea; tea would run straight into children's supper; and then adult supper. I had an awful vision of us all mealing non-stop till bedtime. I therefore put my fork and foot down and made an announcement. First, there would be a 'breakfast window' of an hour. As it was already past 3.30, I went on, we would have the scones for pudding. This went down well. So I went to the kitchen to fetch the scones. It was then that I discovered a full tray of chicken pieces in the Aga bubbling in their juices. Genuinely panicked, I returned laden with the scones, Rodda's and jams. 'And what meal is all the chicken in the Aga for?' I queried, brokenly. The table fell silent. 'Oh I put them in, just in case the children were hungry… later,' one perfect guest replied as a dozen arms shot out to grab the scones as if they'd been deliberately starved by colonial aggressors for months. I sank to my chair and applied golden, crusted Rodda's thickly to my scone. It was clear there'd still be a whole other meal 'later', i.e. between now and children's supper and, after that, two more days of culinary occupation. On day three the dishwasher flooded. On day four, the Aga went out as if in protest and could not be relit. Looking back, yes – it was lunch. Lose lunch, and you'll be out-generalled in your own kitchen by a chicken traybake.
South Wales Argus
2 hours ago
- South Wales Argus
Nigel Farage and the thousands funding Reform UK's campaigns
The big donors included Bassim Haidar, the Nigerian-born Lebanese entrepreneur who gave the Tories more than £670,000 under Rishi Sunak, was there, as was Arron Banks, the former UKIP donor who spent millions campaigning to leave the European Union. Farage was given a rousing introduction by Oswald's owner, clubland impresario Robin Birley, who donated £25,000 to Reform a few weeks before the general election. Reform reportedly took in more than £1m that night at Oswald's in an event that was part of a wider strategy of attracting big money. 'Reform is where the money is going now,' says former Conservative donor Mohamed Amersi, having paid £25,000 to attend the Oswald's fundraiser. Using millionaire money England to fight the Welsh Senedd election, using English-developed policies and with an English MP as its current leader and main campaigner in Wales. A long way from being the man of the working classes. Andrew Nutt, Bargoed
