Beyond Expeditions criticised for planning and safety lapses during Madagascar trip

Straits Times

15 hours ago

Some participants have left online reviews of a charity expedition to Madagascar in June organised by local travel agency Beyond Expeditions, citing poor planning and safety lapses.
SINGAPORE – Local travel agency Beyond Expeditions has drawn negative reviews for its handling of an 11-day charity expedition in Madagascar, with some participants criticising the 'safety gaps' and 'limited communication' online.
The trip to the island nation off the south-eastern coast of Africa took place from Jun 2 to 12. It involved 15 Singapore participants and was led by both Beyond Expedition founders, Mr Scott Tay and Ms Kavita Kaur, as well as personal trainer Mr Nicholas Leong, who has worked with the company as an expedition leader on various occasions since 2017.
Each participant paid $6,990 for the tour, which included accommodation, meals, ground transport, local guides and national park fees, and excluded airfare.
Since returning from the trip, some participants who felt like their safety had been compromised have voiced their dissatisfaction.
On Jun 24, Ms Cheryl Tay, 38, owner of a sports marketing agency, posted a one-star review of the trip on Beyond Expeditions' Google Maps profile relating what she calls 'safety gaps during treks, and limited communication or clarity around what to expect'.
For example, she says pre-trip briefing materials, such as a set of slides and an expedition handbook seen by The Straits Times, did not inform the group of any caving activities.
'We were all just shuffling into the cave and came to a sudden stop because a fellow participant realised the dangers of the cave. That got us stuck and for around 10 minutes, the rest of us were waiting to move with no idea what was going on,' says Ms Tay.
Top stories
Swipe. Select. Stay informed.
Singapore July BTO launch to have over 4,600 balance flats, 2 BTO projects with under than 3-year wait
Singapore Acute psychiatry services to be expanded across all healthcare clusters: MOH
Singapore 'Kpods broke our marriage, shattered our children': Woman on husband's vape addiction
Singapore Asia-Pacific will need over 230k new pilots, 250k aircraft maintenance technicians by 2042: ICAO chief
Business Tycoon Robert Kuok's daughter Kuok Hui Kwong appointed CEO of Shangri-La Asia
Business US tariffs may last well after Trump; crucial for countries to deepen trade ties: SM Lee
Life Walking for exercise? Here are tips on how to do it properly
Multimedia Telling the Singapore story for 180 years
She leads an active lifestyle and has completed Ironman triathlons and other overseas expeditions, such as a five-day trek in the mountainous Annapurna region of Nepal.
Ms Cheryl Tay (pictured), owner of a sports marketing agency and one of the participants, says the group was not informed of caving activities prior to the trip.
PHOTO: COURTESY OF CHERYL TAY
Another participant, local comedian Mr Jaikishan, 32, says Mr Tay surveyed the cave after some in the group voiced their concerns about unsafe obstacles. The activity was eventually canned.
Mr Jaikishan says: 'I'm not an avid expeditioner or hiker and went into the cave even though I was quite afraid. To only hear from our overall expedition leader that the caves had certain risks after we all had entered and exited was not reassuring. It felt like the whole situation could have been avoided and a lot of communication was lacking.'
One participant who says he is trained in land navigation, wilderness survival skills and basic first aid from his extensive experience in the outdoors told ST he was among the first in the group to enter the cave. Due to the nature of his job, he declined to reveal any identifying information.
He says: 'We were not told that it was going to be so claustrophobic and so technical to navigate. After just a short while in the cave, I noticed people were already panicking and struggling.
'Among the most dangerous possibilities was that someone could've got seriously injured in the cave and because of how narrow it was, getting medical attention would have been an issue. Also, entering environments like these requires considerable mental preparation beforehand. If anyone had a nervous breakdown, it would have been hard to help them recover in that space,' he adds.
In another instance, Ms Tay says while participants were informed that there would be 'at least three river crossings' via pre-trip briefing slides, the extent and duration of these river crossings were not well communicated.
She says the group completed around 10 river crossings over four days, and that they did not expect one of the crossings to take around four hours.
Ms Tay adds that she and other participants sustained blisters and cuts on their feet from prolonged water exposure in 'improper footwear' as they were instructed to change into sandals prior to the crossings.
Ms Tay (pictured) says the cave passages were cramped and narrow. After some in the group voiced their concerns about unsafe obstacles, the activity was eventually canned.
PHOTO: COURTESY OF CHERYL TAY
More on this topic Singaporean man injured in Hungary cave rescued in 2 hours
More on this topic Injured Italian caver rescued, again, after four days underground
Mr Jaikishan was brought on the trip by the organisers as an ambassador and the cost of his trip was fully sponsored, including airfare.
As an ambassador, he led several marketing initiatives such as arranging slots on local radio stations 98.7FM and Kiss92, where he, Mr Tay and Ms Kaur spoke about the trek's mission to raise funds for a Madagascan charity working with underprivileged children.
Ms Tay received around a 20 per cent discount off the tour price for providing 'pre-trip marketing services', and paid for her own airfare which cost around $2,400.
'We were charged a premium for this trip so I think it is reasonable for us to have expected basic risk management and communication. Instead, it felt like we were relying excessively on the local operators who mostly were unable to speak English,' says Ms Tay, who is also a content creator with around 81,800 followers on Instagram.
At least two other participants left one-star reviews on the company's Google profile in early July, citing 'poor decision making', 'a lack of route planning' and dismissiveness from organisers when they gave feedback.
Since posting a reel about her experience on Instagram on Jul 7, Ms Tay says she has received accounts from more than 40 individuals regarding negative experiences with Beyond Expeditions. Her three-minute video has garnered over 241,000 views .
However, not all participants had brickbats for the company, which has 51 five-star reviews out of the 74 on its Google profile, as at Jul 16.
One such review from a participant on the Madagascar tour applauds the expedition leaders and a local guide named Lanto for 'being great leaders during the journey and showing immense patience towards all the queries posted by the team'.
Yoga teacher Lim Li Shan, 32, who has been on five expeditions with Beyond Expeditions since 2017 – four to Mongolia and one to Ladakh, a region in northern India – also spoke out positively about her experiences.
While her trips were neither charity expeditions like the Madagascar trek nor as physically taxing, she says Mr Tay – who was present on three of her trips as a 'tour leader and coordinator' – had sufficiently communicated what to expect and adequately planned the itineraries with safety in mind.
'I felt like the organisers fulfilled their basic responsibilities to the travel group. For example, they always made sure that I could chat with them through WhatsApp and would check in regularly with the local guides when we were abroad,' she told The Straits Times.
The Straits Times reached out to the company for comment on July 11. In a July 16 post on Beyond Expeditions' Instagram account, the company acknowledged recent feedback from participants and announced new safety measures. These include enhanced pre-trip briefings, terrain guidance and direct participant feedback channels during expeditions.
Beyond Expeditions started in 2017 and has organised over 1,000 tours specialising in remote destinations such as Mongolia and Central Asia.
A 10-day trip to Kazakhstan, for instance, costs $7,990 a person and includes flights, meals, an English-speaking local guide and ground transport.
The Madagascar trip, which has raised $12,285 of its $80,000 target for Madagascan non-profit Mamiratra ho an'ny Ankizy Association (Shine for the Children Association) so far, was part of the company's Beyond Limits expedition series, where participants raise funds to support a charitable organisation.
The June trip is the ninth Beyond Limits expedition since the series began in 2017, with previous editions featuring treks in destinations like Kyrgyzstan and Mongolia.
More on this topic Off-grid getaway: Go camping, learn survival skills and sleep in a Mongolian yurt