Maharashtra scraps order making Hindi 3rd language in schools
Uddhav and Aaditya burn the govt resolution on Hindi language Sunday
MUMBAI: Buffeted by an anti-Hindi campaign led by the Thackeray cousins, CM
Devendra Fadnavis
on Sunday announced that the state cabinet had decided to scrap two Govt Resolutions (GRs) to introduce Hindi as a third language for class 1 students.
The announcement came on a day when public protests against introducing Hindi in primary schools started with
Uddhav Thackeray
present at a symbolic burning of the GRs at Azad Maidan. A stormy start was also expected to the monsoon session of the state legislature on Monday.
Announcing a rollback, the CM also set up a panel led by academic Narendra Jadhav to frame recommendations for implementing a three-language policy. "Our policy is Marathi-centric and Marathi student-centric.
We do not wish to do politics on this issue," said Fadnavis.
Following the announcement, the Thackerays called off a joint protest rally to be held on July 5 and instead hold a 'victory procession'. Both Shiv Sena (UBT) and Raj Thackeray's Maharashtra Navnirman Sena had described the move to start Hindi lessons in primary school as a 'linguistic imposition'.
Announcing a rollback, Fadnavis cited recommendations of the Mashelkar committee set up by his predecessor in 2020 to defend his govt's move. He said Thackeray formed the expert panel to guide the administration on adopting the new National Education Policy. He said the report was accepted by Thackeray, Congress and NCP (SP) when in power. "But as usual when in power speak differently, when out of power speak differently.
Opposition for opposition sake," he added.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
&w=3840&q=100)
Business Standard
25 minutes ago
- Business Standard
Murmu arrives in UP's Bareilly, to address IVRI's convocation ceremony
President Droupadi Murmu arrived in Bareilly on Monday for the 11th convocation ceremony of the Indian Veterinary Research Institute, officials said. Murmu will be the chief guest at the ceremony to be held at the Swami Vivekananda Auditorium, they said. Uttar Pradesh Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath and Governor Anandiben Patel welcomed Murmu on her arrival in Bareilly. In a post in Hindi on X, Adityanath said, "Hearty welcome and felicitation to Hon'ble President Draupadi Murmu ji in 'Nath Nagri' Bareilly." In a post on X, the President's Secretariat said, "Governor of Uttar Pradesh Smt Anandiben Patel, Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath and Union Minister for Agriculture & Farmers Welfare and Rural Development, Shri Shivraj Singh Chouhan, received President Droupadi Murmu on her arrival at Bareilly." ICAR-Indian Veterinary Research Institute (IVRI) in Izatnagar is dedicated to research and development in the field of veterinary and animal sciences.
Indian Express
an hour ago
- Indian Express
To promote Hindi, start with the ‘Hindi belt'
Amid an uproar, the Maharashtra government has withdrawn its decision to make Hindi the default third language in primary schools. Before this, Tamil Nadu, Karnataka, West Bengal, and other states, had opposed Hindi imposition. In fact, the only place where Hindi does not seem to get much attention is in the 'Hindi belt'. Even outrage against opposition to Hindi, whether in mainstream media or on social media, is often expressed in bad grammar, terrible spelling, and poorly constructed sentences studded with English words. Hindi deserves to be nurtured. Hindi deserves love. Hindi deserves pride. Yet all it gets is shrill, insecure chauvinism that wants to shove it down other people's throats, instead of nourishing it for its native speakers. Any conversation about Hindi gets dragged into too many pitfalls. Who is a native speaker? Will advancing Hindi mean killing the many dialects that the heartland talks to itself in? And then there is English, whispering promises of mobility, holding the key to many desired doors. Looking at languages in an either/or binary in a country as blessed with diversity as India is bound to be a flawed approach. Hindi cannot be championed by positioning it as an adversary to other languages, or as yet, a competitor to English. Across the Hindi belt, there are far too many people who speak neither Hindi nor English well. Many people above 20 can't count till 100 in Hindi, fewer still can narrate the Hindi alphabet without stuttering. Asked to name the most popular Hindi author in the last 30 years, the most vociferous of the rashtrabhasha brigade would scratch their heads. A good step towards 'restoring Hindi's glory' would be to honestly examine the causes behind the problem, make a reckoning of its effects, and then take non-jingoistic steps to solve it. Not being able to speak any language well is an issue that runs deeper than poor spelling or bad grammar. Language is the muscle of the intellect. Without this tool for articulation, you can neither think nor feel coherently. A lack of comfort in your language cuts you off from the wisdom produced and recorded in it over generations, leaving you adrift. You are robbed of clarity, connection, pride, the essential context that gives you your place in history and the present. And a muddled, insecure head takes readily to chauvinism. The result? Confusion turns easily into rage. Hindi has produced a wealth of literature worth reading, quoting, taking pride in. What organised efforts are made to popularise them in rural and small town schools? The Hindi belt is brimming with stories it wants to tell. Which government is making attempts at recognising and nurturing young talent? In fact, most Hindi speakers would be hard-pressed to name a high-quality translation of even the Ramayana or the Mahabharata in Hindi, which, religious beliefs aside, are superlative works of literature. T-shirts are sold with quotes by Shakespeare or Bob Marley or Descartes. Why has no one had the bright idea to do the same with quotes by Mahadevi Varma, Ramdhari Singh Dinkar, Harivansh Rai Bachchan, made beautifully, universally accessible? So what has led to Hindi's less-than-felicitous position in its heartland? Blaming English alone is the lazy way out. The deeper problem is the lack of secure pride in the language. This could be because for too long, the Hindi-speaker has had to migrate for jobs. It could be because all policies to boost Hindi are misguided, treating some other language — English, Urdu — as the enemy, rather than focusing on Hindi itself. It could be because even today, with all the noise about honouring Hindi, a Hindi or a Hindi-medium graduate would find herself shut out of most jobs. It could be because not enough honest efforts have been made to promote an intellectual discourse in Hindi. Raining death wishes upon English will not help anyone. The Hindi heartland needs jobs and mobility. What needs to be done is acknowledging English as a necessary tool of self-advancement, but delinking it from ideas of superiority or 'coolness'. Policy decisions like making Hindi the primary mode of education, before creating an ecosystem where Hindi speakers will be employable, put the cart before the horse and are bound to fail. Authorities need to work to make Hindi a road to profit, or pride, or ideally both. And start with the Hindi heartland for this. yashee@
&w=3840&q=100)
First Post
an hour ago
- First Post
Maharashtra scraps 3-language policy in schools, to form new panel amid backlash over Hindi 'imposition'
Facing strong public backlash, the Maharashtra government has cancelled its order making Hindi the third language in primary schools and will set up a new committee to review the policy. read more Amid public backlash for 'imposing' Hindi, the Maharashtra government on Sunday cancelled its revised order on the three-language policy and announced it will form a new committee to review and rework the plan. Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis said the decision was taken at a cabinet meeting after strong opposition to the government's move to introduce Hindi as a third language in primary schools. 'In the cabinet today, we decided to form a committee led by Dr Narendra Jadhav to study how the three-language policy should be implemented. We will act based on the committee's report,' Fadnavis told reporters. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD 'So, we are cancelling both previous orders on the three-language policy. This committee will consult all stakeholders. For us, Marathi remains central,' he added. The controversy began when the Mahayuti government issued an order in April stating that Hindi would be the default third language for Classes 1 to 5 in Marathi and English-medium schools. This was part of implementing the National Education Policy (NEP) 2020 at the primary level. Political parties, social groups, and cultural organisations strongly criticised the move. Facing pressure, Fadnavis clarified that Hindi would not be mandatory and that students could choose any regional language as the third language. Earlier this month, the government issued a revised order saying Hindi would 'generally' be taught as the third language. However, the order allowed schools to offer another Indian language if at least 20 students in a class opted for it. Schools could appoint a teacher or provide online classes for those subjects. Despite the changes, criticism continued, with opposition parties and activists accusing the government of favouring Hindi at the expense of regional languages and cultural diversity. The Maharashtra Navnirman Sena (MNS), led by Raj Thackeray, led protests against the policy, urging Marathi speakers to take to the streets. The opposition grew so strong that Raj Thackeray decided to join forces with his cousin, Shiv Sena (UBT) chief Uddhav Thackeray, to lead a joint protest in Mumbai against the 'imposition of Hindi.'
