Justice M.M. Ismail Commission found charges against jail officials during Emergency substantially correct
In April 1978, Law Minister K. Narayanaswami Mudaliar told the Legislative Assembly, the government would neither whitewash any crimes committed by officers nor engage in witch-hunting. 'We will avoid both extremes,' he said while responding to the debate on the Commission's report.
According to a report in The Hindu, the Minister mentioned that the government had 'broadly' accepted the Commission's findings. He emphasised that there was no difficulty in taking action on the findings related to the ill-treatment of MISA detenus. However, regarding other findings, Narayanaswami noted that some members felt the Commission had 'fallen short of the expected standard' due to a lack of or insufficient evidence. 'The government will have the opportunity to examine some of this evidence further,' he said.
Upholding rule of law
Any disciplinary action or punishment, he added, would be in line with service rules. 'We are not an authoritarian government but a democratic polity where the rule of law must be upheld,' he said.
The Minister further clarified there would be no unilateral action without consulting legislators, some of whom were themselves former MISA detenus. He quoted the Chief Minister's statement in the Legislative Council (which existed at the time) that after gathering the views of both Houses, consulting legal experts, and meeting with the Cabinet, the government would take appropriate action.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hans India
2 hours ago
- Hans India
Haryana rights panel takes cognizance of dilapidated govt schools
Chandigarh: The Haryana Human Rights Commission (HHRC) has taken suo motu cognisance of the alarming condition of government schools in Hisar district. As per a media report of August 7, though buildings or major portions of 27 government schools have been declared 'unsafe' by the Public Works Department (PWD), classes continue in them. Students are reportedly being taught in open verandahs, sealed rooms, laboratories and staff halls, often sitting on the floor. The ongoing monsoon season has increased risks, including the danger of snake bites and other hazards, said the report. According to the full Bench comprising Chairperson Justice Lalit Batra and members Kuldip Jain and Deep Bhatia, this is not a matter of mere inconvenience but a direct endangerment to the lives and safety of school children. At Government Senior Secondary School in Mangali, for instance, 480 students are studying in an open verandah after 22 classrooms were sealed due to collapse risk. In Dobhi village, all 24 classrooms are in a bad state, forcing students into cramped libraries, laboratories and staff rooms. Likewise, in Dhansu, Siswala, Arya Nagar, Rajli and other schools, children are being taught in unsafe sections of buildings where the risk of falling walls or ceilings is constant. The Commission noted that such conditions violate Article 21 (Right to Life and Personal Liberty) and Article 21-A (Right to Education) of the Constitution, as well as the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child and the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, which guarantee children the right to safe and quality education. The Bench referred to recent incidents in Rajasthan, including the death of a seven-year-old boy in Jaisalmer when a school gate collapsed, and the deaths of seven students in Jhalawar due to a school building collapse. The Commission warned that immediate action is needed to prevent such tragedies in Haryana. Protocol, Information and Public Relations Officer Puneet Arora on Tuesday said the Commission has directed the Principal Secretary (School Education Department), the Director General (Secondary Education), the Deputy Commissioner of Hisar, the Additional Deputy Commissioner of Hisar and the District Education Officer of Hisar to submit a comprehensive report within eight weeks covering among other issues, the status of each condemned building, the safety measures in place and alternative arrangements. The Commission listed the matter for the next hearing on October 30.
Indian Express
3 hours ago
- Indian Express
‘27 schools in Hisar operating from unsafe buildings': Haryana rights panel seeks report within 8 weeks
Taking suo motu cognisance of reportedly alarming conditions at government schools in Hisar, the Haryana Human Rights Commission (HHRC) has directed authorities in the district to submit a comprehensive report on each building within eight weeks. Taking note of media reports published last week, the HHRC found that 'buildings or major portions of 27 government schools have been declared 'unsafe' by the Public Works Department (PWD), yet classes continue to be conducted in them'. In the order which was made public on Tuesday, the full bench of the Commission, comprising Chairperson Justice Lalit Batra and members Kuldip Jain and Deep Bhatia, observed that 'this is not a matter of mere inconvenience but a direct endangerment to the lives and safety of school children'. It has set October 30 as the next date of hearing in the case. The Commission noted that 'students are reportedly being taught in open verandahs, sealed rooms, laboratories and staff halls, often sitting on the floor. The ongoing monsoon season has increased risks, including the danger of snake bites and other hazards'. At the Government Senior Secondary School in Mangali, for instance, '480 students are studying in an open verandah after 22 classrooms were sealed due to collapse risk,' it said, adding, 'In Dobhi village, all 24 classrooms are condemned, forcing students into cramped libraries, laboratories, and staff rooms. In Dhansu, Siswala, Arya Nagar, Rajli and other schools, children are being taught in unsafe sections of buildings where the risk of falling walls or ceilings is constant'. Dr Puneet Arora, Protocol, Information and Public Relations Officer, said the Commission has directed 'the Principal Secretary, School Education Department; Director General, Secondary Education; Deputy Commissioner, Hisar; Additional Deputy Commissioner, Hisar; and District Education Officer, Hisar to submit a comprehensive report within eight weeks' on the matter. The report, he said, should cover 'the current status of each condemned building; safety measures in place; alternative arrangements made; timeline and budget for reconstruction; number of affected students and any injury/illness data; and reasons for delay in reconstruction/relocation.' Citing key examples of the damaged buildings, the HHRC bench stated that in Dhansu village, the entire school building has been condemned, while the figures for the schools in other villages were: Dobhi (24 rooms), Mangali (22), Rajli (16), Dhani Mohabatpur (12), Sisar Kharbala (11), Bass (10), Arya Nagar (10), and Siswala (8). The Commission noted that such conditions violate Article 21 (Right to Life and Personal Liberty) and Article 21A (Right to Education) of the Constitution of India, as well as the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child and the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, which guarantee children the right to safe and quality education. The bench referred to recent incidents in Rajasthan, including the death of a seven-year-old boy in Jaisalmer when a school gate collapsed, and the deaths of seven students in Jhalawar due to a school building collapse. It warned that immediate action is needed to prevent such tragedies in Haryana.
New Indian Express
8 hours ago
- New Indian Express
'AIADMK's 2026 defeat will begin from western belt': CM Stalin
TIRUPPUR: The AIADMK's defeat in the 2026 Assembly election is going to start from the western region, said Chief Minister M K Stalin in Tiruppur on Monday. He was speaking at a welfare assistance distribution event held on behalf of the district administration in Udumalaipet. Stalin said, 'We see the opposition leader, Edappadi K Palaniswami, calling himself a western region person only when he comes to this area. But I can assure you – more projects have been provided for the development of the western TN under our Dravidian model regime than during the EPS's regime. We will keep doing this good work. It's not going to change. That's why I say, I don't understand with what courage EPS started his campaign from this area. But, I am sure the AIADMK's 2026 election defeat is going to start from here. He has already seen defeat in the 2024 election, the local body polls, and the byelection in this region. It is going to continue in the upcoming Assembly election as well.' Stalin said EPS thinks that people will believe him if he speaks his lies loudly through the campaign. 'But, contrary to his thoughts, our government schemes, including 'Ungaludan Stalin' and 'Nalam Kaakkum Stalin', have become a big hit among the people.
