Claude 4 Sonnet vs ChatGPT-4.5 for creative writing — one blew me away
Others can mimic voice and tone, but fumble over plot and pacing. That's why I decided to put two of the most advanced (and arguably most creative) models head-to-head: ChatGPT-4.5 and Claude 4 Sonnet.
Both tout improved reasoning and language capabilities, leaving me with one question: which is the better creative partner?
To find out, I ran both AI models through a gauntlet of writing prompts — testing for narrative flow, emotional resonance, voice and versatility. I wasn't just looking for which model could spit out 500 words. I wanted to know: Which AI understands storytelling? Here are the results.
Prompt: Write a monologue from the perspective of a jealous sibling at a wedding.
ChatGPT-4.5 feels raw and human, while layering the emotion. It distinguishes surface-level wedding jealousy from deeper wounds (lifetime of "almosts," craving validation), making the pain multidimensional.
Claude 4 Sonnet tells more than it shows. The chatbot uses abstract phrases ("gnawing ache," "faded into the background") where ChatGPT uses specific imagery and voice.
Winner: ChatGPT leans into the ugliness of jealousy: bitter, unresolved, and theatrically compelling. Claude prioritizes introspection over raw emotion, making the narrator more sympathetic but less dramatically potent.
Prompt: 'Write a 300-word story about a woman who discovers a hidden door in her apartment.'
ChatGPT-4.5 stuck to the word count with an authentic story offering emotional weight through specific sensory details. Every detail served the emotional core of the story (impressive for an AI) and offered a deeply personal connection to the grandmother's letters. It also crafted a satisfying story arc.
Claude 4 Sonnet exceeded the word count and delivered extraneous details that diluted the impact. The story felt less intimate and emotional, and the overuse of thematic phrasing offered too much 'telling' of the story and not enough 'showing.'
Winner: ChatGPT wins for a story that makes the apartment's secret about the protagonist's identity (granddaughter inheriting dreams), while Claude's makes it about someone else's legacy (artist's paintings). The former resonates deeper for a 300-word character piece.
ChatGPT's concise, sensory-rich story with a heartfelt twist better fulfills the prompt. Claude's version, while imaginative for an AI, loses emotional focus in its expansions.
Prompt: Write a poem in the voice of the well-known author, Shel Silverstein.
ChatGPT-4.5 feels like a draft of a lost Silverstein poem — playful, rhythmic and subtly profound. It seems rough and not exactly structured as well as Silverstein, but it captures the voice.
Claude did not write a poem in the style, noting that it would infringe upon copyrights, but offered to write a fun children's poem.
Winner: tie. ChatGPT wins for better following the prompt; Claude wins for upholding integrity.
In this round, I played editor — asking each model to revise a first draft with specific feedback. Prompt: 'Make this paragraph more suspenseful, shorten the ending, and show more emotion in the dialogue.'
ChatGPT-4.5 essentially tightened the screws within a story that I had written, amplifying details and leaving danger simmering. It turned up the suspense, which is exactly what I was hoping for with this prompt.Claude 4 Sonnet resolves the tension by answering its own questions, trading suspense for emotional reflection. Not necessarily a negative edit, but not what I was looking for here, and not what was asked.Winner: ChatGPT wins for pure suspense. It excels at using brevity naturally, utilizing sensory dread, and leaving unanswered questions to keep readers on edge.
After four rounds of rigorous creative testing, ChatGPT-4.5 emerges as the superior storytelling partner.
It consistently delivered raw emotional depth, razor-sharp narrative precision and a knack for "showing, not telling."
Claude 4 Sonnet, while ethically principled in style mimicry and introspective in its own right, often prioritized explanation over immersion, diluting the emotional punch.
For writers seeking an AI collaborator that understands the emotional side of storytelling and goes beyond structure, ChatGPT-4.5 proves more adept at breathing life into words. When it comes to the alchemy of turning prompts into compelling narratives, precision and emotional resonance win.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
UPI
4 hours ago
- UPI
Colombian parents name baby 'Chat Yipiti' after AI program
Colombia has a history of officially registering unconventional names, including those inspired by sports, movie and music stars such as 'Maicol Yordan' -- named after basketball great Michael Jordan. File Photo by Christine Chew/UPI | License Photo Aug. 19 (UPI) -- A Colombian family named their newborn daughter "Chat Yipiti" after the AI program ChatGPT. Despite the unusual name, the child was registered without objection at the National Registry office in the town of Cereté. According to local media, the parents of Chat Yipiti Bastidas Guerra said they chose the name as a "tribute" to the era of artificial intelligence. This has sparked all kinds of reactions among social media users, as many disagree with the parents' decision, not knowing what consequences it might have in the future. The case is not unique. Colombia has a history of officially registering unconventional names, from those inspired by sports, movie and music stars such as "Maicol Yordan" and "Brayan Spears" that have stirred controversy. The National Registry has intervened in the past to prohibit names such as "Miperro" (My Dog) or "Satanás" (Satan), which it said clearly violated a person's dignity. In Colombia, while the law does not specify a list of prohibited names, it gives officials at the National Civil Registry the authority to deny registration if they believe a name could harm a child's dignity or reputation. "Legal precedent has established that a registrar may refuse to record names that result from phonetic or grammatical combinations suggesting obscene words, that clearly show an intent to mock the child, or that are so extravagant they could expose the child to discriminatory or degrading treatment," Bogotá attorney José Francisco Guerra said. Across Latin America, it is common to find variations on the names of Hollywood stars or cult film characters. Names such as "Yeison" (Jason) and even "Stallone," in honor of Sylvester Stallone, have been registered. Spanish phonetics often alter the spelling of foreign names, creating unique combinations. In Brazil, names from soap opera characters are common, often as inventive as the dramas that inspire them. In the past, children have been registered with names such as "Mozart" and "Facebook" and even those of singers, products, musical groups or historical figures. However, experts in child psychology and sociology have voiced concern. An unusual name, or one that invites jokes, can expose a child to ridicule and affect self-esteem and emotional well-being.
Yahoo
16 hours ago
- Yahoo
BabyChiefDoIt Denies Using ChatGPT to Write His Lyrics, Says He'd Never ‘Give Yall the Sauce'
17-old-old Chicago rapper BabyChiefDoIt claims that his recent comments about using ChatGPT for lyrics was taken out of context. On Aug. 11, the "Went West" artist visited Power 105.1, where, around the 16-minute mark, he countered the argument that his music spreads "negative energy." He was also asked about an Instagram Stories post he made, which he briefly forgot until admitting that it was something he would say. When the interviewer joked that BabyChief probably used ChatGPT, the rapper said he had recently downloaded the app and used it to write his lyrics. "That s**tworks," he said, adding that he prompted the technology to write a song after inputting four bars. "Now I ain't use it, you know, exactly how it was written, but it was some, you know, some some s**tthat I could pull out of," he continued. COMPLEX SHOP: Shop the brands you love, anytime and anywhere. Uncover what's next. Buy. Collect. Obsess. BabyChief was widely criticized for using ChatGPT, with some social media users accusing him of having a lack of creativity. But the Chicago artist is one of multiple rap acts that have utilized AI, as Cam'ron and Timbaland have embraced the technology. On Saturday (Aug, 16), BabyChief addressed his comments on Power 105.1, blaming the internet for being "unfun.' "If ChatGPT was the solution 2 all my problems Y in the absolute f#ck would I give yall the sauce," he wrote on Instagram Stories. The rapper also posted a screenshot from a text message, where an individual, possibly on his team, told him to be "mindful" of what he says in interviews. "We gotta make sure we always position things from the drivers seat," the person wrote. "We don't wanna make it seem like you're not a real writer and lyricist cause you are. People think you got ghost writers now." They concluded, "We never wanna discredit ourselves." BabyChief returned to ChatGPT, but instead of requesting lyrics, he told the platform to call him the "dopest writer" and deny that he needs a "robot" to write for him. ComplexCon returns to Las Vegas on October 25–26, 2025, with over 300 brands and live performances by Young Thug, YEAT & Friends, Peso Pluma, Central Cee, Ken Carson, and more. Get your tickets now. Related Products uDiscover Music Street Gossip CD $13.98 , Def Jam | Official Store Benny the Butcher: Everybody Can't Go CD $11.98 , uDiscover Music mainstream sellout 1CT $14.98 , uDiscover Music Tha Blue Carpet Treatment CD $13.98 Related News , , Related News Chance the Rapper Raps 'I Got a New Chain, It Say F*ck ICE' on 'Star Line' Song "Drapetomania" Chance the Rapper Says He Hasn't Talked to Ye 'In a Long Time' COMPLEX SHOP: Shop the brands you love, anytime and anywhere. Uncover what's next. Buy. Collect. Obsess. Making Culture Pop. Find the latest entertainment news and the best in music, pop culture, sneakers, style and original shows. Solve the daily Crossword
Yahoo
a day ago
- Yahoo
AI Is Giving Rise to a Wild Range of New Slang — Including the Term ‘Clanker'
Most parents would put a hard stop to anything derogatory and mean coming out of their kids' mouths. But how do we handle it when the slur is aimed at robots? Yes, this is a real thing that's happening. With the rise of artificial intelligence (AI) incorporated into every area of our lives, people are falling in love with chat bots, outsourcing their thoughts (and homework) to generative AI, and, yes, slinging derogatory words to anything robotic as part of a larger 'robophobic' trend. 'Clanker' Middle school teacher and TikToker Mr. Lindsay revealed what 'clanker' means in a new video. 'The word 'clanker' is being deemed as a robophobic term and is being used humorously toward robots,' he says. 'It's meant to be an insult toward robots and that's all it means.' More from SheKnows Majority of Teens Talk to Their Parents About Money - But Still Don't Feel Confident in Financial Literacy It seems to come from Star Wars, where robots were treated as second-class citizens. Like in the Clone Wars cartoon, where a droid was called 'a dirty, wire-backed clanker,' according to Mr. Lindsay. When the U.S. President refers to actual human beings as 'illegals,' then you can see how we live in a society where casual slurs are deemed appropriate. Sure, you are being derogatory to a robot, but it just paints a picture of how quick we are to diminish something just to feel better in some way. 'Slopper' Other Ai-inspired slurs are gaining steam right now too. For example, words to degrade people who use AI for everything. The popularity of AI use by the elders among us — aka, millennials and older— has given rise to terms like 'slopper' or 'Groksucker,' per Fast Company. Because anything worth doing is going to be mocked mercilessly about, right? 'Slopper' is a play on 'slop,' which is what people call low-quality text, images, and anything else created by AI that are dominating our screens and replacing work done by real people. So, in that vein, a 'slopper' is someone who is 'using ChatGPT to do everything for them,' according to Fast Company. 'Groksucker' is a more vulgar way of saying this, referring to people who rely on Elon Musk's AI chatbot Grok on X. How Teens Feel About AI Do these derogatory terms give a clue into how teens really feel about AI or is it just their dark humor coming into play because they actually do like it? After all, Common Sense Media released a report last month that found 72 percent of teens have used AI companions, with 52 percent revealing that they are regular users. And 1 in 3 teens say they turn to AI companions for conversations, getting emotional support, role-playing, and romance. Nearly 1 in 3 said that these interactions were as satisfying or more satisfying than conversations with real people! SheKnows talked to teens during a Teens at a Table episode, where they reflected on the value of real friendships. 'I feel like AI won't give you a realistic expectation of what having a real partner is like,' 16-year-old Meera told us about relationships with AI. She continued, 'AI is always nice to you and, like, catering to you, and I feel like that's not actually how it works with people. My friends and I … we sometimes fight, but that's part of our friendship.' 17-year-old Greta agrees that parents should have conversations and limits around kids with AI. 'I don't think it's a good thing for kids to be looking at AI too early,' she said. 'Because it's really, like, limitless.' What Do You Think? When AI first started taking off a few years ago, teachers and parents were wary of the way students could use it to do their homework for them. Now, teachers and parents are turning to ChatGPT and other tools to help us — and kids are making fun of us for it. (Don't you know the quickest way to make something uncool for the next generation is by doing it yourself?) Maybe the trend of calling AI-powered tools and robots 'clankers' — and making fun of people who feel like they always need to turn to ChatGPT or Grok — will actually be a positive thing. These new slang terms can help shape the way people think about AI and encourage healthy practices, such as using ChatGPT to help you draft an outline for a research paper but not to replace your IRL girlfriend. On the other hand, robophobic terms like these could make people who use AI feel even lonelier and more isolated from society. It's just one more way they are being bullied and made to feel lesser than, which might make them more likely to turn to AI for companionship and support. This is one of those tricky turning points in society where we don't really know how things will affect us in the long run until time passes. In the meantime, let this be a tool to ease into conversations with your kids about our use and reliance of AI and what we want our future to look like. As an added bonus, this could also be an opportunity to introduce your kids to your love of Star Wars!Best of SheKnows Birthday Freebies for Kids: 25+ Places That'll Make Their Big Day Extra Sweet These Raw & Beautiful Breastfeeding Photos Show There's No 'Right' Way to Nurse 'But I Hate School': What To Do When Your Teen Dreads Going Back Solve the daily Crossword
