S&P Global exposes Transnet's operational crisis as it fails to meet targets
S&P Global's downgrading exposes Transnet's operational crisis as reform efforts stall, and it fails to meet its volume targets, burning cash at R13.5 billion per year.
This shows how important it is for government to attach strict conditions to future bailouts and accelerate private sector partnerships in ports and rail concessions rather than continuing unconditional support.
Busisiwe Mavuso, CEO of Business Leadership South Africa (BLSA), says the decision by S&P Global to downgrade Transnet's credit rating was disappointing news for business in the private sector eager to see the utility performing better.
'This downgrade is not just a reflection of Transnet's financial distress but a damning indictment of years of failed leadership, union militancy and a government that continues to bail out state-owned enterprises without demanding fundamental reform.'
She points out that S&P believes Transnet is burning cash without a prospect of turning around its operating performance, and that Transnet Freight Rail will fail to meet its volume targets. 'The business has high fixed costs, major capital expenditure requirements and significant debt. S&P's downgrade reflects its concern that its ability to service that debt is weakening.'
Mavuso says that when a company burns through so much cash every year, resulting in negative free cash flow, while its workers receive 6% pay increases at double the inflation rate, we are witnessing a textbook example of unsustainable economics enabled by government guarantees.
ALSO READ: Transnet capitulating to unions shows lack of leadership on both sides – BLSA
S&P calling out that Transnet is resisting change, moving too slowly
'S&P is calling out what has become clear to many of us: that Transnet is seemingly resisting change and moving too slowly. Compare Transnet to Eskom, which has been able to stabilise its operating performance and is pushing forward deep and fundamental reforms.
'The solution is not more bailouts or government guarantees. It is time for National Treasury to attach strict conditions to any future support, in the form of conditions that enable the private sector competition that Transnet desperately needs. The recent progress in separating rail infrastructure from operations, driven by Operation Vulindlela is a start, but we must move much faster.'
Mavuso says private sector partnerships in ports and rail concessions must be accelerated as companies are ready to invest in our logistics infrastructure. However, they need certainty that political interference and Transnet's resistance will not undermine their investments.
'Fixing the logistics crisis is one of the focus points of the business-government partnership. Through the National Logistics Crisis Committee, there has been some progress as ports reduced backlogs and key rail corridors saw some volume improvements, but the fundamental issues remain, and the pace of reform has slowed just when it needs to be accelerating.'
ALSO READ: Creecy punts private sector investment for five rail and port corridors
Another meeting with government due to slow progress at Transnet
She says when business met with a senior government delegation led by President Cyril Ramaphosa in January, there was a strong commitment to accelerating reform to deliver economic growth. 'When the logistics workstreams fell behind on key targets, we met again in May and agreed to a focused three-month sprint to catch up. That sprint needs additional impetus.
'There are critical structural reforms that must be advanced, particularly enabling third-party participation in rail and ports and operationalising the economic regulator that will regulate the logistics system for all.
'Also, as S&P makes clear, there is an urgent need to improve the operational performance of Transnet, from improving security to ensuring the availability of rolling stock, to fixing infrastructure. The plans to do all this through a partnership between the public and private sectors are in place, but either through intransigence or coordination failures, we have not been able to implement them.'
Mavuso says the S&P decision should be a wake-up call that Transnet is going in the wrong direction. 'We must act urgently. Transnet cannot continue as if it is business as usual, and President Ramaphosa must act to get the agreed reforms implemented fast.'
ALSO READ: Outa welcomes dissolving of RAF board and cancelling of license card tender
Business welcomes disbanding board of RAF
She also welcomes the decisive action of transport minister Barbara Creecy in disbanding the Road Accident Fund (RAF) board. 'This bold step represents the kind of leadership we desperately need to confront institutional dysfunction head-on.
'The RAF serves a critical function as our safety net against the devastating financial impact of road accidents, yet its track record of mismanagement has become a national embarrassment. With the Special Investigating Unit (SIU) now conducting a broader investigation at the minister's request, we have an opportunity to root out the rot that has spawned endless litigation and operational chaos.
'South Africa deserves an RAF that operates with transparency, maintains clean books and delivers efficient service to those who need it most.'
Mavuso would like to see the same no-nonsense approach extended to other state insurance entities that continue to fail South Africans. 'The Unemployment Insurance Fund (UIF) and Compensation Fund have become synonymous with bureaucratic incompetence and public frustration.
ALSO READ: Call for intervention in 'horror show' at Compensation Fund and UIF
UIF and Compensation Fund need same kind of decisive action
'When Business Unity South Africa called for the UIF to be placed under administration late last year, it was because workers were denied timely access to benefits they had rightfully earned. Similarly, the Compensation Fund's failure to adequately support workers suffering from occupational injuries, illnesses, or workplace fatalities represents a betrayal of our most vulnerable citizens.
'While labour minister Nomakhosazana Meth initiated necessary leadership changes, these institutions remain far from delivering the world-class service standards our people deserve.'
She points out that every successful reform sends a powerful signal that we are serious about creating institutions that serve with integrity, efficiency and accountability. 'The private sector stands ready to support this transformation, but government must lead with the courage to make hard decisions and the commitment to see them through. All South Africans depend on getting this right.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
IOL News
an hour ago
- IOL News
Government approves R94. 8bn guarantee to bolster Transnet's finances
This decision made on Friday comes as a part of the government's ongoing efforts to support Transnet's operational stability amid mounting challenges posed by credit downgrades and economic volatility. The government has approved an additional R48.6 billion guarantee for Transnet, ensuring that the entity can cover all debt redemptions over the next five years and maintain adequate liquidity levels. This decision made on Friday comes as a part of the government's ongoing efforts to support Transnet's operational stability amid mounting challenges posed by credit downgrades and economic volatility. The newly approved R48.6bn guarantee follows an earlier allocation in May, which saw the government approving R51bn in guarantees, including R41bn aimed at funding requirements for the 2025/26-2026/27 fiscal years and R10bn designated for liquidity management purposes. The total financial backing for Transnet now amounts to R94.8bn, what the Department of Transport said was a testament to the government's commitment to restoring the financial health of the embattled entity. Transnet, which plays a crucial role in the logistical backbone of the country, has been grappling with operational inefficiencies and financial strain exacerbated by credit rating downgrades. These downgrades have not only affected the company's access to capital but have also heightened the risk associated with its existing debt obligations. Recognising these challenges, the government has allocated an additional R46.2bn to mitigate the risks from potential further negative credit actions, thereby seeking to safeguard the company's financial future. In her announcement last month, Transport Minister Barbara Creecy indicated that the government was committed to working closely with Transnet to ensure both operational and financial improvements. This initiative is part of a broader strategy aimed at accelerating reforms within the logistics sector, which includes encouraging private sector participation to enhance efficiency and productivity. This latest financial intervention is critical in ensuring that Transnet can continue to operate effectively while implementing necessary reforms. The government's steadfast support reflects its recognition of the vital role Transnet plays in South Africa's economy, responsible for moving goods across vast distances and supporting numerous industries. BUSINESS REPORT
The Citizen
an hour ago
- The Citizen
Transnet bailouts? Government bends with R94.8bn more in guarantees
It will ensure all the group's debt redemptions are covered for the next five years and mitigate the risk of credit downgrades on its existing debt, says the Transport Department. The further state support comes as international ratings agencies have in recent months either downgraded Transnet's credit rating or warned that it is running out of cash. Picture: Supplied Government has approved additional guarantee support of R94.8 billion for struggling state-run ports and rail group Transnet. On Friday the government approved an additional R48.6 billion guarantee for Transnet, to ensure that all debt redemptions will be covered over the next five years and the transport entity will maintain sufficient liquidity levels, according to the Department of Transport (DoT) on Sunday. This comes as international ratings agencies have either downgraded Transnet's credit rating or warned that it is running out of cash in recent months. The DoT added that the government had considered the impact of the credit downgrades on Transnet's existing debt and therefore also approved R46.2 billion for it to mitigate the risks of such ratings actions on its debt. This additional 'guarantee support' for Transnet follows government's approval of an allocation of R51 billion in guarantees to Transnet on 22 May 2025. That allocation comprised R41 billion for the funding requirements for the 2025/26 and 2026/27 financial years and R10 billion for liquidity management purposes. The latest additional guarantee support for Transnet follows Minister of Transport Barbara Creecy's announcement on 12 June 2025 that the government had initiated a process to allocate additional guarantees to Transnet. ALSO READ: S&P Global exposes Transnet's operational crisis as it fails to meet targets Creecy said at the time the government had initiated this process given Transnet's debt redemptions, over its five-year corporate plan period of R99.6 billion, and to at least cover the entire redemptions over the corporate plan period. She said this support from government will allow Transnet to ensure: That all debt redemptions will be covered over the next five years. The execution of its capital investment programme. Short-term liquidity risk is adequately mitigated. Creecy added that the government is determined to work with Transnet over the corporate plan period to focus on structural solutions to improve its capital structure to reduce its debt levels. She said the government will monitor Transnet's performance to ensure it provides adequate support as Transnet implements government's required reforms. The DoT said on Sunday the government will also continue to work with Transnet to ensure operational and financial improvements in the company and to accelerate implementation of reforms for the logistics sector, including private sector participation. ALSO READ: Creecy punts private sector investment for five rail and port corridors Creecy told the Southern African Transport Conference earlier this month that her department had just concluded a request for information (RFI) process to guide private sector investment in its five-priority rail and port corridors. She stressed that the limited availability of state resources to fund infrastructure development makes private sector investment critical. Speaking on the sidelines of the conference, Creecy said there had been 'an excellent response' to the RFI, with almost 163 submissions. 'We are now processing those submissions so that Transnet can begin the formal procurement process at the end of August 2025, through the issue of requests for proposals,' she said. Creecy said the DoT will at the end of this month release the second batch of the RFI, which will be focused on passenger rail initiatives. ALSO READ: R26 billion rescue from World Bank: Can the loan save Eskom and Transnet? Infrastructure funding She said funding sources for immediate rehabilitation of the five priority rail corridors include the current Transnet budget for rail and rolling stock maintenance and purchase of port equipment, submissions to the National Treasury's Budget Facility for Infrastructure, and private investment in refurbishing or expanding line capacity through existing customer agreements. Creecy said Transnet itself makes annual allocations for maintenance, but this is insufficient, and they have also put in an application to the Budget Facility for Infrastructure. Overall, it will be applying for more than R30 billion. 'This would allow us to do maintenance and to buy equipment for the rail corridors and also in the ports,' she said. The minister noted that there are two tranches: the July window application is already in, while they are still working hard on preparing the application for the October window. ALSO READ: Government delivers R51 billion support to Transnet. Will it last? 'We won't be able to do all of the ports and corridors all at once, but we will be doing so incrementally as we process the information. 'What we can look forward to is some major investment in our rail corridors and also in our ports. Obviously, it's going to take our infrastructure to a different level moving forward,' she said. Four of the six targets that Creecy highlighted in her Budget Vote speech in Parliament earlier this month are to: Ensure by 2029 that Transnet moves 250 million tons of freight on its network each year. Improve the speed at which ships are loaded and unloaded in South Africa's ports to the international benchmark of 30 gross crane movements per hour. Ensure the passenger rail system provides safe, reliable and affordable transport to workers and their families, with the aim of ensuring 600 million passenger journeys a year by 2030. Move 1.2 million tons of airfreight a year through the Airports Company of South Africa network of airports by the end of this political term. This article was republished from Moneyweb. Read the original here.
TimesLIVE
4 hours ago
- TimesLIVE
Transnet secures nearly R95bn in fresh government guarantees
The government will give Transnet an additional R94.8bn guarantee facility to support the ailing state-owned logistics firm's recovery plan, the transport ministry said on Sunday. The facility comes on top of a R51bn guarantee the government announced for Transnet in May, including R41bn to cover the company's funding needs over the 2025/26 and 2026/27 financial years, and R10bn earmarked for debt servicing and capital investments. The new guarantee comprises R48.6bn to cover all debt redemptions over the next five years, and an additional R46.2bn to mitigate against further credit rating actions, the ministry said in a statement. The government is supporting Transnet's five-year turnaround strategy, which seeks to restore freight rail volumes to 250-million metric tons per year by the end of the period. The volumes fell to 152 million metric tons in the 2023/24 financial year, from a peak of 226 million metric tons in 2017/18. Transnet has failed to deliver reliable freight rail and port services due to equipment shortages and maintenance backlogs after years of under-investment. Its capacity has been further constrained by widespread cable theft and vandalism. The company's debt has risen to R145bn from R138bn at the end of the 2023/24 financial year, according to its chairperson Andile Sangqu. Its loss widened to R7.3bn in 2023/24, from R5.7bn the year before . Transnet's struggles have cost mineral exporters, primarily coal and iron ore producers, billions in lost revenue. The exporters account for nearly 70% of Transnet's freight volumes. Due to a lack of railway capacity, most chrome exports now reach ports by road, raising costs, damaging roads and the environment.
