
Bengali film industry posers for BJP in language controversy
, who criticised Delhi Police on Sunday over a notice issued to Banga Bhawan in the national capital.
Tired of too many ads? go ad free now
The notice sought help to translate the "Bangladeshi language" for an ongoing trial.
Reactions poured in from the likes of Prosenjit Chatterjee, Kaushik Ganguly, Srijit Mukherjee, Rupam Islam, Rahul Arunoday Banerjee, and Parambrata Chattopadhyay.
'Dhumketu' director Kaushik Ganguly said Bengali is his favourite language. "For eight years, I taught the Bengali language. I never knew that there was any 'text' in the 'Bangladeshi' language," said Ganguly, citing that Delhi has plenty of well-versed academics in Bengali and the authorities can easily approach them to get clarity on the language.
"Delhi has numerous universities and many esteemed professors of the Bengali language.
Can't the administration approach them to clarify their understanding of the Bengali language? William Carey learned Bengali passionately to understand the soul of Bengal. If today's administration is unclear about the language, seek help; otherwise, their severe ignorance will repeatedly be exposed in official letters.
Although numerous regional dialects have emerged from the Bengali language, the only 'text' is in Bengali," Ganguly said.
Earlier, 'Padatik' director Srijit Mukherji took to social media to point out: "That's not Bangladeshi language, morons, that's Bangla or Bengali, the same language in which your National Anthem was originally written and one of the 22 official languages of India."
On Monday, actor-director Parambrata Chattopadhyay took to social media to express his views on the subject with a clear disclaimer that it is "not a political post".
Tired of too many ads? go ad free now
The actor-director questioned if the Delhi Police's act is symptomatic of a certain mindset that innately "otherises" all other languages and cultures in the country apart from what's practised and spoken in the mainstream.
He stated, "The method of discerning might attract debates, but I support the principle of not letting foreign nationals seep into Indian territories and becoming voters illegally. But I am also an aware individual who's equally proud of being an Indian and a Bengali! That makes me wonder, is there a separate language called 'Bangladeshi'? Dialects and accents can differ, but it's the same language, our language, my mother language.
.. 'Bangla'! Or 'Bengali'!" Chattopadhyay added that post-Partition, people on both sides of the border in Punjab and Bengal share many commonalities, which is not only historical but also linguistic and cultural. "A large percentage of Pakistanis speak Punjabi, or some even Sindhi or Gujarati! But in India, do we call native Punjabi or Sindhi speakers 'Pakistani language' speaking people? Then how or why does Bangla become only Bangladeshi?"
On the sidelines of an event on Monday, Chatterjee said he would stand beside the CM.
"The Bengali language will be there forever. I will extend my support to the chief minister in her fight against this language terrorism," he said.
On Tuesday, Trinamool Rajya Sabha leader Derek O' Brien extended his thanks for the statements made. "We have noticed the statements made. We thank them for speaking up. This is not just a political issue, but an issue which impacts all of us who love Bengal," he said.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Hindustan Times
24 minutes ago
- Hindustan Times
Gold steady amid Trump's 100% tariff threat on chip imports and trade tensions
Gold held a moderate loss, as traders looked past uncertainty created by US President Donald Trump's latest trade moves, including threatening a 100% tariff on chip imports. Traders also watched for Trump's nomination within days of a temporary Federal Reserve governor who is expected to be more aligned with his agenda to ease monetary policy.(AFP File Photo) Bullion was steady around $3,370 an ounce after a 0.3% decline in the previous session. This came after Trump said he would impose a 100% levy on semiconductor imports in a bid to force companies to move production back to the US. Meanwhile, relations with key trade partners soured, with the US leader doubling the tariff on Indian goods to 50% over the South Asian country's continued purchases of energy from Russia. Japan may also face higher duties than agreed last month on some products, Kyodo reported. Traders also watched for Trump's nomination within days of a temporary Federal Reserve governor who is expected to be more aligned with his agenda to ease monetary policy. Lower rates benefit gold, which doesn't yield interest. The precious metal's recent rally has been driven by rising expectation of rate cuts. Central bank buying and a broad trend of diversifying away from US dollar-denominated assets have also offered support. It's climbed nearly 30% this year, though the bulk of its gains happened in the first four months, as geopolitical and trade tensions rattled the market. Gold was 0.1% higher at $3,373.45 an ounce as of 8:42 a.m. in Singapore. The Bloomberg Dollar Spot Index was steady. Silver, palladium and platinum all rose.

Time of India
24 minutes ago
- Time of India
Big U.S.-India Escalation: Trump Threatens SANCTIONS After 50% Tariffs Over Russia Oil
Brazil's Big BRICS Snub At Trump Over Tariff War, Nikki Haley Warns US Not To Burn Bridge With India In a stunning diplomatic twist, Brazilian President Lula da Silva has refused to call US President Donald Trump amidst a growing trade war. While Trump imposed a crushing 50% tariff on Brazilian imports and threatened similar action on India, Lula declared that he would instead reach out to Indian PM Narendra Modi and Chinese President Xi Jinping. Lula called the tariff day "the most regrettable" in Brazil-US ties and hinted at coordinated BRICS retaliation. India, too, faces tariff threats from Trump over Russian oil purchases. Meanwhile, Nikki Haley warned Trump against alienating India while soft-pedaling on China. As Trump dismisses BRICS as "fading fast," the bloc's symbolic banknote launch and anti-dollar stance suggest a global realignment, with India at its center. The global trade game is shifting, and New Delhi is no longer a silent player.#lula #donaldtrump #trumptariffs #brics #bricsbanknote #modi #xijinping #putin #nikkihaley #indianews #brazilnews #globaltradewar #usindia #usbrasil #russianoil #chinaus #wto #geopolitics #modigovernment #usforeignpolicy #trendingnow #india #breakingnews #trending #bharat #toi #toibharat #indianews 6.1K views | 20 hours ago


India.com
24 minutes ago
- India.com
Rs 2580000000000: US's treasury overflowing with billions in tax revenue! Here's how Trump administration plans to use money..., Americans to get...
Escalating his tariff offensive against India, US President Donald Trump on Wednesday slapped an additional 25 per cent duty–doubling it to 50 per cent–on Indian goods over New Delhi's continued imports of Russian oil. The move that is likely to hit sectors such as textiles, marine and leather exports hard was slammed by India as 'unfair, unjustified, and unreasonable'. How much has the US government collected so far this year? The Treasury Department reported that in the last month, the US government collected almost $30 billion in tariff revenue in July, a 242% increase from July of last year, reported CNN. The government has earned $100 billion in revenue from tariffs since April, when the president instituted a 10% tariff on nearly all goods and many other even higher tariffs. This is three times more than was collected in the previous year in the same four months. So the question arises: what will the Trump administration do with all this money? As reported by CNN, Trump has offered two possible options for the tariff revenue: Either to reduce the government's multi-trillion-dollar debt or to send 'tariff rebate checks' back to the American people. 'The purpose of what I'm doing is primarily to pay down debt, which will happen in very large quantity,' Trump was quoted as saying by CNN. 'But I think there's also a possibility that we're taking in so much money that we may very well make a dividend to the people of America,' he added. How will tariff revenues affect the federal budget deficit? According to CNN reports, neither of those plans has come to fruition – at least not at this time. So, many Americans may feel that the billions of dollars coming in from tariffs, mostly paid upfront by U.S.-based businesses importing foreign goods, are sitting idle. There is a lot more going on behind the scenes. The government collects revenue from various sources, such as taxes and tariffs. The revenue is all sent into the general fund, which is managed by the Treasury Department. The Treasury calls this general fund 'America's checkbook.' The Treasury Department then spends that money on the government's obligations, including payments such as Social Security. When the money raised by the government does not equal the expenses it has, resulting in a budget deficit, it needs to borrow money to cover the expenses it cannot pay with tax revenue. The national debt is now exceeding $36 trillion, and the debt is increasing. Many economists are concerned about the increasing debt and think it could be impacting economic growth. This is because the government, like an individual, is also required to pay interest on the money borrowed. The more it borrows, the larger its interest obligations grow—adding another monetary impediment that forces money away from critical public investments, like upgrading roadways and infrastructure. While the tariff revenue isn't enough to plug the $1.4 trillion budget deficit the government is facing this fiscal year, it has helped close the gap somewhat. Therefore, the government is borrowing a bit less than it would in the absence of these tariff collections. If Congress agrees to Trump's proposal to use tariffs to send 'rebate checks' to Americans—an idea supported by a bill introduced last week by Republican senator Josh Hawley—it would probably create a budget hole, Ernie Tedeschi, director of economics for the Budget Lab at Yale, and a former economist in the Biden White House said, reported CNN.