logo
Northumbria Police participation in Newcastle Pride event ruled unlawful by high court judge

Northumbria Police participation in Newcastle Pride event ruled unlawful by high court judge

ITV News17-07-2025
A police force acted unlawfully by allowing its officers to take part in a Pride event last year, a High Court judge has ruled.
Lindsey Smith, who lodged a complaint against Northumbria Police, describes herself as a 'gender critical' lesbian. She took legal action against the force over its decision to allow officers to participate in the Newcastle Pride in the City event last July, in which she also participated.
Ms Smith argued that officers' participation meant they would have been unable to remain impartial if a dispute between those with similar beliefs and transgender rights supporters, had occurred.
A Northumbria Police spokesperson said the force is committed to "providing each and every person of our wonderful region with an outstanding policing service".
Uniformed officers marched at the event last year with some carrying flags which included Pride colours alongside police insignia, and others wearing uniforms with the word 'police' in the Pride colours.
There was also a static display staffed by uniformed officers, which displayed a Progressive Pride flag, which includes representation of transgender and non-binary people, people of marginalised ethnicities and those living with Aids, the judge said.
A police van with the colours of the transgender Pride flag painted on its sides was also present, the court was told.
Lawyers for Ms Smith told the court that the officers' involvement breached impartiality rules, and that the decision to allow them to take part was unlawful.
Barristers for the force opposed the challenge, claiming the decision, made by Chief Constable Vanessa Jardine, was within her 'discretion'.
In a ruling on Wednesday (17 July), Mr Justice Linden said the decision relating to last year's event was unlawful, but that it was up to the force to decide how it approaches the 2025 event, which is due to take place this weekend.
In his judgment, he said that Ms Smith is opposed to 'gender ideology', which she believes is 'wrong and dangerous' but has been 'embraced' by the organisers of the event, Northern Pride.
While Ms Smith agreed that the event should be policed, she objected to officers 'associating themselves with the views of supporters of gender ideology and transgender activists by actively participating', the judge said.
In a letter to the force before the legal action, Ms Smith said the involvement of officers in the event led her to conclude it was 'biased against gender critical people'.
In response, the force said it considered that the decision to allow officers to participate in the event was a 'lawful exercise' of the 'discretion' of Ms Jardine, who considered that police participation in Pride was 'necessary and justified'.
Ms Jardine also said in her evidence to the court that she believed preventing officers from attending would be contrary to her duties under the Equality Act.
In his ruling, Mr Justice Linden said the participation of officers went against impartiality rules.
He found that those who opposed Northern Pride's view on transgender rights were 'not welcome' at its events, and that uniformed officers' involvement meant they 'demonstrated support for the cause'.
He said: 'It is not hard to imagine circumstances in which the officers in question might be called on to deal with a clash between gender critical people and supporters of gender ideology, and therefore situations where the former had cause for concern as to whether they were being dealt with impartially.'
He added: 'Leaving aside the question whether the activities in question would be likely to interfere with the relevant officers' impartial discharge of their duties, on any view they would be likely to give rise to the impression amongst members of the public that they may do so.'
He concluded that the police displays added to the 'impression' that the force was 'associating itself with a particular viewpoint and, as far as gender critical people were concerned, taking sides'.
In a statement, a Northumbria Police spokesperson said: 'The officers, staff and volunteers of Northumbria Police are dedicated and passionate about providing each and every person of our wonderful region with an outstanding policing service.
'In doing so, we recognise not all communities share the same level of confidence in policing for a variety of reasons. We want to ensure everyone knows that we are absolutely here for them when they need us.
'Part of that is us being visible in those communities and playing an active part in our force area. Throughout the year, we will have an important role to play in a variety of events, including parades and festivals.
'During these events, while our primary aim is to keep people safe, it also provides us with an opportunity to engage with people, including those who may have less confidence in policing.
'It is vitally important they feel supported and we continue to build their trust in us.
'That is why we felt it important to challenge the case which was brought against us and which has implications for wider policing.
'We will work through the ruling to understand the implications, while staying true to our values of fairness, visibility, and support for all.
'Our commitment to providing an outstanding service to all our communities will remain unchanged.'
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Belfast Pride's 2025 'Not Going Back' theme strikes defiant note
Belfast Pride's 2025 'Not Going Back' theme strikes defiant note

BBC News

time3 hours ago

  • BBC News

Belfast Pride's 2025 'Not Going Back' theme strikes defiant note

Belfast Pride is striking a defiant note as it holds its annual parade in the city on 2025 theme is "Not Going Back", which organisers said was chosen because they believe "LGBTQIA+ rights are under attack, here and across the world".Stormont's four executive parties, Sinn Féin, DUP, Alliance and UUP, have been told by Pride organisers they are not welcome at the parade because they supported a ban on puberty blockers for parade starts at Custom House Square at 13:00 BST and will make its way through the city centre before finishing in Victoria Street. Thousands of marchers and spectators are expected to watch and take part in the parade, which is part of a wider programme of wider Pride festival has been running since 19 July and finishes on festival's co-chairpersons, Neil Millar-McDonagh and Lynn Millar, said said the "Not Going Back" theme sent a clear message."As we celebrate how far we've come, we stand firm in our commitment to keep moving forward - towards love, equality and justice for everyone in our LGBTQIA+ community," they said. Political controversy First Minister Michelle O'Neill said she was sad her party was permitted to march in Belfast Pride over the puberty blockers Sinn Féin deputy leader said she would still celebrate Pride "in my own way".Stormont's Agriculture Minister Andrew Muir, who is gay, has said he will be taking part in Belfast Pride in a "personal capacity".The majority of Pride parades across Northern Ireland have taken a similar decision and asked the executive parties not to attend. Lynn Millar said that the rights of the transgender community were "under threat" as a result of the to the BBC's Good Morning Ulster programme, she defended the decision to exclude executive parties from taking part in the parade."We're acting on what our trans community wanted us to do," Ms Millar said."Pride has always been a protest. It started out as riots - we're not going back to that."We celebrate Pride as well, but there will always be a political element when it comes to human rights and I'm not going to apologise for that."

Munroe Bergdorf 'hopeful for Corbyn's new party' as she calls out Labour for no 'backbone'
Munroe Bergdorf 'hopeful for Corbyn's new party' as she calls out Labour for no 'backbone'

Daily Mirror

time4 hours ago

  • Daily Mirror

Munroe Bergdorf 'hopeful for Corbyn's new party' as she calls out Labour for no 'backbone'

Munroe Bergdorf has "never been more hopeful" following the announcement of Jeremy Corbyn and Zara Sultana's independent party, but calls on Labour MPs to do better for the trans community Model and trans activist Munroe Bergdoft expressed her disappointment at the Labour party's treatment of trans people in the UK. ‌ At the London Trans+ Pride launch event, she told a panel of activists that the Labour party have "shown who they are and have cemented who they are in history." She later added that she has "a lot to shout at this government, but reasoning with them is fruitless." ‌ In preparation for London Trans+ Pride, set to take place on July 26, Bergdorf joined a panel consisting of London Trans+ Pride founding member Lewis G Burton, BAFTA-winning writer and activist Sukey Venables-Fisher and Trans Kids Deserve Better members, Merlin and Cliff. Instilling hope into trans people nationwide, she said: "Just like other civil rights movements before us, things will come to fruition for our movement and for our lives." ‌ Bergdorf stated she has "never felt so hopeful" after seeing the announcement of Jeremy Corbyn and Zara Sultana's independent party. Earlier this month, Sultana quit Labour and voiced her frustration with the party, saying "Labour has completely failed to improve people's lives." The 31-year-old wrote in a statement posted to X: "Today, after 14 years, I'm resigning from the Labour Party. Jeremy Corbyn and I will co-lead the founding of a new party, with other Independent MPs, campaigners and activists across the country." ‌ Bergdorf admitted that she had considered leaving the UK, but now wants to "stay and fight and see growth and support [Corbyn and Sultana's party]." Corbyn confirmed that "real change is coming" and praised Sultana for helping to build "a real alternative." Whilst the new independent party establishes itself, Bergdorf urged the current Labour government to take action for the transgender community. "To everything single MP in the Labour party on the left; it's time for backbone, it's time to actually do something instead of just talking. Join us, come to trans pride. It's time to show urgency." For more stories like this subscribe to our weekly newsletter, The Weekly Gulp, for a curated roundup of trending stories, poignant interviews, and viral lifestyle picks from The Mirror's Audience U35 team delivered straight to your inbox. ‌ Bergdorf and the panellists acknowledged that it's been a tough year for trans people, following the UK Supreme Court ruling. In April 2024, the court ruled in favour of so-called 'gender critical' volunteer organisation For Women Scotland in their appeal against the Scottish Government's usage of the term 'woman'. Lord Hodge, Lady Rose and Lady Simler gave a joint judgment, with which the other Justices agreed, passing down an unanimous verdict that the term 'woman' used in the Equality Act 2010 refers to biological sex. ‌ Trans charity Gendered Intelligence told the Mirror at the time that they were disappointed at the ruling, and said the judgement is "likely to empower those who want to exclude trans people, but we trust that this remains a small minority." At the London Trans+ Pride panel, Bergdorf called for meaningful trans allyship, stating that "directing traffic, money, support and awareness to services that support us is paramount... If people are going to be allies they need to make it worth it." Help us improve our content by completing the survey below. We'd love to hear from you!

Heartache for Bayesian yacht victim Mike Lynch's family – estate faces bankruptcy after court demands it hand over £700M
Heartache for Bayesian yacht victim Mike Lynch's family – estate faces bankruptcy after court demands it hand over £700M

The Sun

time13 hours ago

  • The Sun

Heartache for Bayesian yacht victim Mike Lynch's family – estate faces bankruptcy after court demands it hand over £700M

IT was a tragedy that claimed the lives of a ­billionaire father and his daughter, drowned in a storm at sea. British tech entrepreneur Mike Lynch was out celebrating his acquittal from US fraud charges when his £38million yacht ­ Bayesian was knocked sideways by a sudden 80mph gust and started taking in water. 6 6 6 As the boat sank rapidly, his wife Angela Bacares was pulled to safety by a crew member — but Lynch, their 18-year-old daughter Hannah and five others on board never made it out. Now, as the one-year anniversary approaches next month, 58-year-old businesswoman Angela is facing a financial battle. There is the potential of court action by the families of the victims who died on the yacht — and earlier this week, the UK's High Court ruled that her husband's estate owes US tech giant Hewlett-Packard more than £700million relating to fraud claims. The case was brought six years ago by HP after they acquired his company Autonomy in 2011. The firm claimed Lynch and the former chief financial officer had fraudulently inflated its value. While Lynch was facing court action in America, HP was already chasing him through the civil courts in Britain — leading to this week's damages ruling. The High Court ruled that HP had paid a lot more than it would have done 'had Autonomy's true financial ­position been correctly presented' during the sale. If his estate — which goes to Angela and her remaining daughter Esme, 22 — ends up having to pay, it will almost certainly be bankrupted, ­leaving no inheritance for the family. It is believed Lynch shielded his wife's ­personal fortune from the messy court cases. She owned millions of pounds worth of shares held in her name in other family firms. I found doomed Bayesian I saw still haunts me And she made more than £15million from the sale of her shares when Autonomy was taken over. One pal told us: 'Mike wasn't ­perfect but he wasn't a ­criminal in any way, shape or form. He had asked various Cabinet ministers and Prime Ministers, including Rishi Sunak and Boris Johnson, to help him. 'Rishi and Johnson were more interested in making post- Brexit trade deals than making any trouble on Mike's behalf. 'Rishi and Johnson were more interested in making post-Brexit trade deals than making any trouble on Mike's behalf. 'These cases hung over him for years and he ended up under house arrest in San Francisco unable to leave for months, facing charges that he was ­ultimately cleared of. 'He helped a lot of people make a lot of money but they assumed he was guilty as charged and then ran a ­million miles. 'He was abandoned by his peer group and by his government then, when he won his US case, everyone wanted to be his friend again. 'The irony is he had gone out on the Bayesian to celebrate the US court outcome. "It's been one tragedy after another for his family.' The latest damages ruling had been delayed until this week because of the ­circumstances surrounding the yachting ­disaster on August 19 last year. The judge expressed his 'sorrow at the devastating turn of events' at sea and offered ­'sympathy and deepest condolences'. 'STILL GRIEVING' He even said that he 'admired' Lynch, despite ruling against him. Insiders have told The Sun that the family want to appeal the High Court decision. Our source said: 'It's not just about money, it's about restoring Mike's ­reputation. "The family are considering their next move but we all know that appealing these sorts of decisions is lengthy and costly. "They are also still grieving their loss.' Lynch created software company Autonomy, which processed people's information and data, in 1996. He sold it to Hewlett-Packard for £8.6billion in 2011. The businessman reportedly netted around £500million from the deal before going on to set up tech ­investment firm Invoke ­Capital. Just a year after the mega-bucks deal, HP wrote down Autonomy's value by £6.5billion and brought a £4billion lawsuit against Lynch and ex-finance officer Sushovan Hussain. The allegations that they inflated the value of the company were ­investigated by the UK Serious Fraud Office too, who found 'insufficient evidence' of wrongdoing — but some aspects of the case were then handed over to US authorities. In 2018, Lynch and Autonomy's ­former vice-president of finance Stephen Chamberlain were charged with fraud in the US and accused of making false and misleading ­statements about their company. But both were acquitted following a sensational three-month trial in San Francisco, where Lynch had been extradited to in 2023. If Lynch had been found guilty, he would have faced up to 25 years in prison. 6 He told reporters last year that given his poor health, he would have almost certainly died in jail. The pair were still celebrating their win when Chamberlain, 52, died after being hit by a car while out ­running near his home in Cambridgeshire. Two days later, the Bayesian sank off the coast of Sicily, claiming the lives of Lynch, Hannah, the vessel's cook Recaldo Thomas, high-profile US lawyer Chris Morvillo, his wife Neda and British banking couple Jonathan and Judy Bloomer. As part of a criminal investigation by Italian authorities, the yacht was raised from the sea bed last month. That inquiry may not conclude until 2027, bringing more heartache for the Lynch family. James Healy-Pratt, a US lawyer representing the family of chef Recaldo, said they would push for compensation from Angela, the crew and yacht management ­company Camper & Nicholsons. As one of the country's most ­successful entrepreneurs, Lynch had a life of luxury, enjoying exotic holidays and a £6milliion country mansion in Suffolk, which boasts 2,500 acres. The close family are said to have loved spending time at home, breeding rare livestock, including Suffolk sheep and Gloucestershire Old Spot pigs, which roamed free in the estate's woodland. But the businessman came from humble beginnings. Born to Irish parents — a ­firefighter father and nurse mother — Lynch won a scholarship to a private school in Essex. Mike worked hard but was very much a family man and wanted to make life as normal for his ­children as it could be, given the extreme wealth Andrew Kanter He went on to gain a PhD in mathematical computing from ­ Cambridge University. A friend said: 'He really was a genius. "He was just a brilliant mathematician and his life transformed as he built companies. 'He was a very early advocate of artificial intelligence — the very field in which we need expertise in this country.' Long-time friend Andrew Kanter, who was a pallbearer at Lynch's funeral, said: 'He was never ­happier than when someone asked to see the pigs on his estate. 'Mike worked hard but was very much a family man and wanted to make life as normal for his ­children as it could be, given the extreme wealth. 'He never let his legal issues get in the way and did everything to make sure his kids grew up untroubled by whatever the world lay at his feet.' 'I truly believe that Mike would have looked at the UK ruling as a good day. "Although the numbers are crazy, even the judge has found that Hewlett-Packard had overstated its claim. 'Mike would have continued to fight this. "He always argued that a law that allows America to extradite British ­citizens and not have a return agreement was really flawed. 'It's been the case for 15 years and he was going to have that fight too. 'The legal issues weighed heavily on him but he never let it affect his ­family. 'I never saw him sitting around self-pitying. He wanted to clear his name. 'The loss of Mike is an ­incalculable loss for technology. 'He was utterly devoted to its growth in Britain.' 6 6

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store