Manufacturing in crisis: Saftu and Cosatu warn of job losses amid declining production
The South African Federation of Trade Unions (Saftu) and Congress of South African Trade Unions (Cosatu) are concerned about the loss of jobs as the manufacturing sector continues to decline.
Image: Supplied
The South African Federation of Trade Unions (Saftu) and the Congress of South African Trade Unions (Cosatu) have raised concerns about job losses amidst a decline in the country's manufacturing sector.
This was after Statistics South Africa (Stats SA) released data showing that manufacturing production decreased by 0,8% in March compared to the same period last year.
This marked the fifth consecutive month of decline in industrial activity.
The largest negative contributors were petroleum, chemical, rubber and plastic products and electrical machinery.
On a quarterly basis, production fell by 2,3% in the first quarter of 2025 compared to the fourth quarter of 2024. It also decreased by 2,2% on a monthly basis - March 2025 compared to February 2025.
Saftu attributed the decline to neoliberal policies, insufficient investment and an extractive economic structure. The federation called for policies that prioritise job creation and industrial development.
On the other hand, Cosatu said it was concerned about the loss of jobs.
The union warned that this would be worse as the expanded definition of unemployment, which includes those discouraged from seeking employment, remained unchanged at 41,9%.
Saftu said also this confirms a long-term trend of deindustrialisation.
Since 1994, Saftu said, manufacturing's share of Gross Domestic Product (GDP) has declined from 22% to just over 11% while capacity utilisation has dropped from 82% to 65%.
Video Player is loading.
Play Video
Play
Unmute
Current Time
0:00
/
Duration
-:-
Loaded :
0%
Stream Type LIVE
Seek to live, currently behind live
LIVE
Remaining Time
-
0:00
This is a modal window.
Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window.
Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque
Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps
Reset
restore all settings to the default values Done
Close Modal Dialog
End of dialog window.
Advertisement
Next
Stay
Close ✕
The union pointed to a decline in investment, both public and private, as a key factor in the manufacturing sector's struggles.
The federation added that Gross Fixed Capital Formation was 14,93% of the GDP in 2023, which is down from 20% in the early 2000s. It said the private sector investment was 12,37% of the GDP, while public sector investment was just 2,5%.
Saftu's general secretary, Zwelinzima Vavi, said these figures confirm that both the State and private capital have retreated from investing in the productive economy.
Vavi said if aluminum and steel had been factored in, the deindustrialisation rates would be worse.
'Unless state policy changes, we can anticipate even worse bouts of deindustrialisation, because of the steel industry's crisis. Already the crash of steel output from a peak of nine million tonnes a year to around four million tonnes has required an ongoing bailout of ArcelorMittal foundries that were due to close,' he said, warning that US President Donald Trump's decision to impose tariffs on imports would also worsen the situation.
'Given the extreme animosity to South Africa from Trump and a new group of paleo-conservative imperialist powerbrokers in Washington, due to our government's (correct) labeling of Israel as genocidal and pursuit of affirmative action and land reform, we may anticipate far worse to come. There will likely be no renewal of the Africa Growth and Opportunity Act (AGOA) and intensified punitive tariffs on all exports are certain once the 90-day pause on South Africa's 32% tariff penalty is lifted in July. '
'South Africa cannot overcome its crisis through austerity or corporate appeasement. Both the private and public sectors have withdrawn from investment. The time has come for a bold shift to a developmental state that leads investment, reindustrialises the economy, and places public goods over private profits. Power concedes nothing without a struggle — the working class must mobilise for a new economic future,' said Vavi.
Cosatu called on the government to seek alternate trading partners to counter the impact of US tariffs.
'But at the same time ensure the continuation of AGOA or a similar trade agreement between the USA and SA that increases trade and investment opportunities between both countries,' said spokesperson Zanele Sabela, who added that South Africa also needs to accelerate the role in the African Continental Free Trade Area (ACFTA) to unlock trade with Africa.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
IOL News
a day ago
- IOL News
Employers gain flexibility in choosing EAP demographics for employment equity plans"
The Department of Employment and Labour is forging ahead with the implementation of the Employment Equity Amendment Act. Image: Leon Lestrade/ Independent Newspapers EMPLOYERS will have the option to use the applicable national or regional Economically Active Population (EAP) population as an instrument when developing employment equity (EE) plans. At a recent EE workshop held in Sandton, Department of Employment and Labour deputy director, Masilo Lefika said employers will have this option when developing EE Plans and setting annual numerical targets in their workplaces. He added that when developing EE Plans and setting annual numerical targets in their workplaces in terms of legislation, designated employers must take into account the workforce profile, the relevant five-year sectoral numerical targets, and the applicable EAP. 'The five-year sectoral numerical targets are key milestones towards achieving the equitable representation of the different designated groups within the four upper occupational levels in an employer's workforce in relation to the demographics of the applicable EAP, and for persons with disabilities,' said Lefika. This comes as the Department is forging ahead with legislative amendments to the Employment Equity Act (EEA). These amendments have their origins in 2019, when the Department, in collaboration with the Commission for Employment Equity (CEE), began sector-specific engagements aimed at setting employment equity (EE) targets. The goal was to accelerate transformation in the workplace. These efforts culminated in the Employment Equity Amendment Act No. 4 of 2022, which officially came into effect on January 1, 2025. However the changes have been met with mixed reactions as the DA has taken government to court to challenge the amendments, while others have raised concerns about applying national targets at the expense of regional demographics. According to Lefika, a designated employer will incur "no penalty or any form of disadvantage if there are reasonable grounds to justify its failure to comply with any target". Trade union federation Cosatu welcomed the option for employers to choose which demographics to apply when setting their targets. 'Cosatu engaged with the Department of Employment and Labour extensively on the 2023 amendments to the Employment Equity Act at Nedlac as well as with Parliament. We support these amendments, in particular the provisions recognising regional demographic diversity and enabling employers to utilise them or national demographics depending on their own footprint as an employer. This is critical as the demographics of Limpopo differ widely from those of the Western and Northern Cape and those differ significantly from KwaZulu-Natal. 'Enabling employers to utilise regional demographics is important to ensure local workers enjoy full worker opportunities and also to ensure workplaces represent South Africa's full diversity. This is especially important for provinces like the Western and Northern Cape where coloured workers are the largest demographic group and similarly in provinces like Gauteng and KZN. Employment equity includes all South Africans, of all racial, gender and disability categories,' Cosatu Parliamentary Coordinator, Matthew Parks said. The National Coloured Congress (NCC), which had called to meet with minister Nomakhosazana Meth over the issue, added that without proper consideration of provincial demographics, it risks the further marginalising of Coloured communities. 'The Constitutional Court has ruled you can't implement national demographics, regionally. All the labour department is doing is making it easier for businesses with vested interests to discriminate. As the custodian of employment equity, the labour department should do its job,' NCC leader, Fadiel Adams said. Cape Times National Coloured Congress (NCC) leader Fadiel Adams. Image: Supplied
Daily Maverick
3 days ago
- Daily Maverick
‘Enough is enough' – Saftu threatens mass protests over NMB public fund mismanagement
The South African Federation of Trade Unions in Gqeberha said on Wednesday that it was 'deeply outraged, though not surprised' by the Auditor-General's damning findings on the Nelson Mandela Bay metro. The organisation has threatened mass action as a response to 'incompetence, mismanagement and a total disregard for working-class residents'. The South African Federation of Trade Unions (Saftu) has threatened the Nelson Mandela Bay municipality with mass action to protest against what it has called the current coalition government's 'incompetence, mismanagement and total disregard for working-class residents'. Saftu secretary Mziyanda Mcanda said a meeting had been held with the Speaker of Council, Eugene Johnson, who had promised to address their concerns. But, he added, the latest Auditor-General's report on Nelson Mandela Bay was deeply shocking. 'The report confirms what workers, the unemployed and the poor have long known — that this municipality is being run into the ground by incompetence, mismanagement and a total disregard for working-class communities,' said Mcanda. Grant spending Despite being the only metro to receive the Regional Bulk Infrastructure Grant (RBIG) — a critical intervention aimed at improving bulk water and sanitation infrastructure — the municipality underspent the grant by 41%, according to this report. 'This is criminal negligence in a city facing chronic water insecurity and failing sanitation systems. Communities in KwaZakhele, Motherwell and Chatty continue to suffer water cuts and sewerage overflows, while the money meant to fix these issues lies idle due to so-called implementation challenges,' Mcanda said. 'Even more damning is the fact that 67% of senior management posts are vacant, the highest of any metro in the country. This leadership vacuum reflects a collapsing state — one that is either unwilling or unable to deliver even the most basic services. Workers inside the municipality are overburdened, demoralized and left without leadership or direction, while politically connected elites scramble for tenders and positions,' he added. Motherwell housing project He highlighted the plight of residents who had been promised housing through the Motherwell NU30 housing project, calling it 'another insult to our people'. 'The Auditor-General confirms that houses were approved for handover despite structural defects and no electricity. These are not homes; they are shells. People are being handed keys to hardship, not dignity. This is a systemic crisis. It cannot be reduced to administrative failures; it is the direct result of a capitalist state that serves private profiteers and political elites, not the working class. While public money goes unspent or wasted, our communities suffer hunger, evictions, floods and disease,' he said. Mcanda said the organisation wanted the urgent filling of senior vacancies with competent, accountable and community-oriented personnel. 'No more cadre deployment for corruption,' he added. They are also demanding the institution of a forensic investigation into the RBIG underspending and NU30 housing project, 'with consequences for those responsible'. He said they also wanted an emergency summit of affected communities, labour and civil society 'to chart a democratic, people-centred turnaround strategy for the metro'. Saftu's concerns were also echoed in a letter by faith leaders in the metro which was sent to President Cyril Ramaphosa in May. 'Enough is enough. We will not allow this municipality to continue failing our people. If these demands are not urgently addressed, Saftu Gqeberha will mobilise for mass action,' Mcanda added. DA says budget is morally indefensible Meanwhile, the Democratic Alliance (DA) said the proposed 2025/26 Nelson Mandela Bay budget was unrealistic and morally indefensible, as it passes the buck to ratepayers to 'fund the mismanagement of our inept ANC-led municipality'. In a pre-budget press conference held on Wednesday, Odendaal said the metro was haemorrhaging millions of rands due to its inability to spend grant funding. The budget will be discussed in a council meeting on Thursday. 'Over the last two financial years, the ANC-led administration's dysfunction has lost a staggering R900-million in grant funding meant to build roads, and water and electricity infrastructure. 'This inability to spend is a crisis and, as of April this year, the municipality had only spent 38% (R752-million) of its R1.934-billion capital expenditure budget. 'Against the backdrop of this continued mismanagement, the tariff increases in the budget are morally indefensible. Imagine losing money and then asking ratepayers to balance the books,' Odendaal added. He further said that the budget as presented to council was only funded because it assumes a 76% collection rate while the average collection rate for the 2024/2025 financial year is 72.15%. 'Ward-based budgets are also a major concern as very little budget has been made available for certain wards. The DA believes every community has the right to a fair allocation of resources,' he said. Executive Mayor of Nelson Mandela Bay Municipality, Cllr Babalwa Lobishe, held a mayoral member committee meeting on Wednesday to address the findings of the Auditor-General, and stressed the critical importance of enhanced planning and accountability within all departments. She promised last week that she would address the vast underspending of Treasury grants at the city council meeting on Thursday. 'By Monday, a consultative report must be ready for virtual discussion to guide Wednesday's submission. With only three months left until the Auditor-General's review, we cannot afford to be caught off guard,' she said. Departments have also been directed to review current contracts, identify possible risks and define clear actions to avoid repeated deviations or contract extensions. 'Changing our culture doesn't take time; it takes consistency. If we focus on efficient, daily execution, our teams will adapt and we will start seeing real progress,' she concluded. DM
The Citizen
3 days ago
- The Citizen
Cosatu says debate on B-BBEE is needed for beneciaries' benefit
Cosatu calls for reform of B-BBEE to ensure real empowerment for workers and disadvantaged communities, not just political elites and business insiders. The debate about the broad-based black economic empowerment (B-BBEE) is needed on how to ensure it benefits the beneficiaries. This is according to union federation Cosatu spokesperson Matthew Parks, who was reacting to the ongoing debate on whether the B-BBEE policy is aimed at being biased against whites. Inequality persists 'While we support the B-BBEE Act, we believe a debate is needed on how to make sure it reaches its intended beneficiaries, in particular historically disadvantaged individuals and communities,' he said. 'We support the objectives of B-BBEE. These are necessary given three and a half centuries of systematic discrimination and disempowerment under colonial and apartheid rule. South Africa is 31 years into democracy but remains the world's most unequal society.' Parks said the policy was a necessity to help historically disadvantaged persons and communities to enter the economy, not only as wage earners but also as owners of businesses. He said Cosatu cannot remain satisfied with progress when the colour of one's skin still largely determines one's economic status. ALSO READ: Minister extends date for comments on R100 billion transformation fund 'Ticking time bomb' He added the majority of shares on the Johannesburg Stock Exchange are owned by whites, similarly with regards to ownership patterns of businesses. 'This is a ticking time bomb that we must address. It's not racism against whites and, in fact, white women and white South Africans with disabilities are included. White South Africans and investors are not excluded,' he said. 'All the policy seeks to do is to boost the economic empowerment of those still disadvantaged. It has helped to begin the journey of building a nonracial society. While some progress has been made in building a black middle class and black industrialists, it is not enough given the inequalities still so prevalent.' Parks said more must be done to ensure 'it benefits workers and not just the elite and worker ownership and employee shareholder ownership programmes should be ramped up'. He added more must be done to ensure investors honour their B-BBEE shareholders and equity equivalents. Equity equivalents offer alternative for foreign investors When asked if Cosatu supports the equity equivalents, Parks agreed and said that has been one of two options under the B-BBEE Act for many years. He said they provide a useful option for international investors who are not able to do the B-BBEE shareholders' option. ALSO READ: DA transformation policies stance dents its image and may lose it votes, says expert 'Equity equivalent option allows investors to support local manufacturers, create jobs, skill workers or invest in local communities,' he said. 'These have benefited many local businesses, workers and communities. They have been successful in many sectors, including clothing and motor manufacturing. Many companies have utilised this option before.' Malatsi's draft policy Communications and Digital Technologies Minister Solly Malatsi was recently criticised for unveiling a draft policy direction in the Government Gazette 'proposing an alternative to the B-BBEE ownership requirements for the ICT [Information and Communication Technology] sector'. 'The new model would allow companies to meet empowerment obligations through equity equivalent programmes rather than direct ownership transfers,' one critic said. The proposed amendment to the Act could facilitate the entry of investors such as Elon Musk's Starlink into South Africa's telecommunications market and contribute to the empowerment of the previously disadvantaged people without having done a direct transfer of ownership. Malatsi's critics said he was trying to pave a way for Starlink to do business in SA. Musk has previously criticised the B-BBEE policy, saying it was racist. NOW READ: Proposed Starlink deal 'wrong in principle and practice'
