MLB Pete Rose decision is 'dark day for baseball' and Hall of Fame

The Herald Scotland

14-05-2025

Who knew that once you're dead, all could be forgiven too?
Pete Rose, who gambled on baseball as manager of the Cincinnati Reds and lied about it for 15 years before dying September 2024 at the age of 83, had his Hall of Fame chances resurrected by commissioner Rob Manfred.
Manfred announced, on the eve of Pete Rose Day in Cincinnati, that he is lifting Rose's permanent ban from baseball, and for the first time will be eligible to be elected into the Hall of Fame.
Manfred, while ruling that the permanent ineligibility of players ends upon their death, also cleared everyone from the 1919 Black Sox scandal, who deliberately fixed games during the World Series.
"It's a serious dark day for baseball," Marcus Giamatti, the 63-year-old son of late former commissioner Bart Giamatti, who permanently suspended Rose in 1989, told USA TODAY Sports. "For my dad, it was all about defending the integrity of baseball. Now, without integrity, I believe the game of baseball, as we know it, will cease to exist. How, without integrity, will the fans ever entrust the purity of the game. ...
"The basic principle that the game is built on, fair play, and that integrity is going to be compromised. And the fans are losers. I don't know how a fan could go and watch a game knowing that what they're seeing may not be real and fair anymore. That's a really scary thought."
If Rose, who produced a record 4,256 career hits, winds up in Cooperstown, Giamatti says, what stops Shoeless Joe and anyone else from the Black Sox? Barry Bonds and Roger Clemens, come on in. Alex Rodriguez, let's forget about your year-long drug suspension. The 2017 Houston Astros? You had immunity anyway.
"If you let him in, the floodgates are now open," Giamatti says. "Sure, why not let all those guys in, too? He hasn't done anything, you know, to reconfigure his life. He was never seriously remorseful or rehabilitated himself by going to gambler's anonymous or any of that stuff. He did none of that.
"He could have possibly opened the door for a second chance, but it's moot because he didn't do any of that stuff. So, it's not even a point to discuss."
Rose's reinstatement, of course doesn't automatically put him into the Hall of Fame. He still must be elected, even though Donald Trump, who met with Manfred on April 16, believes that it will be fait accompli, saying on X: "Baseball, which is dying all over the place, should get off its fat, lazy ass, and elect Pete Rose, even though far too late, into the Baseball Hall of Fame!''
Rose, who was never on the official BBWAA ballot, can now be nominated by the Hall of Fame's Historical Overview Committee and placed on the 2027 Classic Baseball Era committee ballot. He would need at least 12 votes by the 16-member committee - made up of four former players, four executives, four writers, and four historians - to be elected and inducted in the summer of 2028.
WHAT'S NEXT? Pete Rose's MLB ban ends. Does that mean he's bound for the Hall of Fame?
"I'd love to be on that committee," said a former All-Star outfielder whose career overlapped with Rose. "I would vote 'no' in a heartbeat and try to convince everyone to do the same. He embarrassed the game. He was a Hall of Famer on the field, but he ruined the integrity of the game off the field."
Said a former GM who also is a candidate to be on the committee: "This guy was jeopardizing players' careers to win bets as a manager. He could care less about their health. And now you're going to validate someone like this, someone who's also accused of statutory rape.
"You let Pete get away with this, you're opening yourself up to the biggest gambling scandal in baseball history. It makes Rule 21 (prohibiting players, umpires, and other league officials from betting on any baseball game) a complete joke."
Manfred, after rejecting Rose's bid to be reinstated while he was alive, became the first commissioner since the suspension to even seriously consider lifting the lifetime ban.
Giamatti was the one who suspended Rose. Fay Vincent, who succeeded Giamatti after his sudden death, remained strongly opposed against Rose's ban ever being lifted before he died in February. Bud Selig, who replaced Vincent and was commissioner from 1992-2015, also has continued to voice his strong opposition against Rose's reinstatement.
"While it is my preference not to disturb decisions made by prior Commissioners," Manfred said, "Mr. Rose was not placed on the permanently ineligible list by Commissioner action but rather as the result of a 1989 settlement of potential litigation with the Commissioner's Office. My decision today is consistent with Commissioner Giamatti's expectations of that agreement."
Manfred argues that the lifetime ban was severe enough punishment and denies being persuaded by Trump to lift the ban, saying that Rose's family visited him in December when he informed them he would reevaluate it.
Besides, MLB says, they're not putting Rose into the Hall of Fame.
"Commissioner Giamatti's comments were completely reasonable given that, at the time, the Hall of Fame did not have a rule barring people on the permanently ineligible list from Hall of Fame consideration," Manfred said. "In fact, Shoeless Joe Jackson was afforded the opportunity to be voted upon in 1936 and again in 1946."
That now falls on the museum, which announced in 1991 that no player permanently banned from baseball is eligible, taking the vote away from the baseball writers.
"It's like there's no rules," Giamatti says. "It's like once you die, you can be reinstated and they'll let you back in. There won't be any asterisk or anything.
"You're supposed to consider character, sportsmanship and integrity. He doesn't check any of those boxes."
Besides Rose's admission to gambling on baseball, he was accused by an unidentified woman in a defamation lawsuit - filed by Rose against former federal prosecutor John Dowd - that he had a sexual relationship with her before she was 16 years old. Rose, married with two children at the time, acknowledged the relationship in court documents made public in 2017, but said she was 16 years old, which was the age of consent.
Giamatti, an actor, musician, writer and professor at Temple University in Philadelphia, is particularly galled that no one from MLB bothered to talk to him or his younger brother, Paul Giamatti, the award-winning actor. They don't personally know Rose, but they do know the stress, heartache, and the ensuing death threats, with their father dying of a sudden heart attack at the age of just 51, just eight days after Rose's permanent suspension.
"What's frustrating is that nobody has talked to me or my family about it,'' Giamatti said. "I understand that Rose's daughter [Fawn] talked to them, and had every right to. But nobody has reached out to me or my brother to say, "What would be your side of the argument? What are your feelings about this now?'
"I don't think they want to talk to me and hear what I have to say, or what we went through as a family with the tremendous amount of pressure, the death threats that the FBI still has, and all of the backlash my dad faced.
"It was really an ugly, ugly time.
"Now, it's going to be an ugly time for the game, with everything that my father fought to uphold in peril."
Follow Nightengale on X: @Bnightengale
The USA TODAY app gets you to the heart of the news -- fast. Download for award-winning coverage, crosswords, audio storytelling, the eNewspaper and more.