
Why is Wimbledon blaming human error for a mistake by its new electronic line-calling system?
(You can now subscribe to our
(You can now subscribe to our Economic Times WhatsApp channel
The All England Club, somewhat ironically, is blaming " human error " for a glaring mistake by the electronic system that replaced human line judges this year at Wimbledon The CEO of the club, Sally Bolton , said Monday that the ball-tracking technology was "inadvertently deactivated" by someone for three points at Centre Court during Anastasia Pavlyuchenkova's three-set victory over Sonay Kartal a day earlier in the fourth round. On one point, a shot by Kartal clearly landed past the baseline but wasn't called out by the automated setup - called Hawk-Eye - because it had been shut off.Bolton declined to say who made the mistake or how, exactly, it occurred or whether that person would face any consequences or be re-trained. She did note that there were other people at fault: the chair umpire, Nico Helwerth, and two who should have let him know the system was temporarily down - the review official and the Hawk-Eye official."We didn't need to put line judges back on the court again," Bolton said. "We needed the system to be active."Is Wimbledon using AI for line calls this year? Not really. But like most big tennis tournaments nowadays - the French Open is one notable exception - Wimbledon has replaced its line judges with cameras that are supposed to follow the balls on every shot to determine whether they land in or out.There are those, particularly in the British media, who keep referring to this as part of the ever-increasing creep of AI into day-to-day life, but Bolton objected to the use of that term in this case."The point I would want to emphasize - and perhaps contrary to some of the reporting we've seen - is it's not an artificial intelligence system. And it is electronic in the sense that the camera-tracking technology is set up to call the lines automatically, but it requires a human element to ensure that the system is functional," Bolton said. "So it is not AI. There are some humans involved. And in this instance, it was a human error."What happened on the missed call at Wimbledon? Russia's Pavlyuchenkova was one point from winning a game for a 5-4 lead in the first set against Britain's Kartal on Sunday when a shot by Kartal landed long. But there was no ruling from Hawk-Eye.After a delay, Helwerth decided the point should be replayed, which Pavlyuchenkova thought showed bias toward an opponent competing in her home country. With Hawk-Eye back up and running after a delay, Kartal won that game, but Pavlyuchenkova took that set and the match.The All England Club looked into what happened and found that the line-calling system actually was off for three points before anyone noticed.The system itself worked "optimally," Bolton said repeatedly."In this instance, sadly," she said, "it was the human part of the operation that made a mistake."Why was the Hawk-Eye system accidentally turned off during a match? Bolton said the system is shut down between matches - "and the humans are the people that need to do the activating and deactivating" - and someone accidentally did so during Pavlyuchenkova vs. Kartal.Asked why, Bolton responded: "Well, I don't know. It was a mistake, obviously. ... I wasn't sat there, so I don't know what happened."She said Helwerth could have made a ruling himself on the controversial non-call, the way he did on the prior pair of points, but instead just decided to pause the match."I'm assuming," Bolton said, "he felt he had not seen it properly."Pavlyuchenkova said after the match the official told her he thought the ball was out.What do players think about the use of technology at Wimbledon? Players are divided on whether there even should be electronic rulings during matches - unless it is fool-proof - or whether there should be a return to Wimbledon's old way of doing things.Since 2007 through last year, there was a combination of the human touch and technology: There were line judges on court to make calls, but players were allowed to challenge and ask for a video replay of a point if they thought there was a mistake."It's such a big match, big event," Pavlyuchenkova said. "Since we have already automatic line-calling and so much invested into this, we should probably look into something else to have better decisions."
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Time of India
24 minutes ago
- Time of India
Wimbledon 2025 final: Jannik Sinner defeats Carlos Alcaraz in four sets, full stats breakdown
Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads Detailed Wimbledon 2025 Men's final statistics Wimbledon 2025 final: points, games, and serve performance Statistic Jannik Sinner Carlos Alcaraz Aces 8 15 Double faults 2 7 First serve per cent 62 per cent 53 per cent Win per cent on 1st Serve 75 per cent 75 per cent Win per cent on 2nd Serve 63 per cent 58 per cent Break points converted 4/9 2/6 Tiebreaks won 0 0 Receiving points won 44 36 Total points won 125 113 Games won 22 18 Max games won in a row 3 4 Max points won in a row 6 5 Service points won 81 77 Service games won 18 16 Jannik Sinner defeated Carlos Alcaraz in four sets to win the Wimbledon 2025 men's singles final at Centre Court, 4-6, 6-4, 6-4, 6-4. Despite losing the first set, Sinner came back strongly to capture his first Wimbledon victory was built on consistent serving, fewer double faults, and superior conversion on break points. While Alcaraz led in aces with 15 compared to Sinner's 8, he also committed more double faults, registering 7 to Sinner's 2. Both players won 75 per cent of their first-serve points, but Sinner's 63 per cent success on second serve edged Alcaraz's 58 per read: Wimbledon 2025 prize money: how much champions, finalists, and other competitors earn On break points, Sinner was more efficient, converting 4 of his 9 opportunities, while Alcaraz converted just 2 of 6. Neither player won a tiebreak. In total points won, Sinner led narrowly with 125 to Alcaraz's total games won, Sinner secured 22 while Alcaraz finished with 18. Although Alcaraz managed a streak of four consecutive games, Sinner's maximum was three in a row. When it came to points won consecutively, Sinner again led narrowly with a six-point streak compared to Alcaraz's service performance, Sinner won 81 service points to Alcaraz's 77 and captured 18 service games compared to Alcaraz's 16. These metrics reflected Sinner's marginal but meaningful edge in maintaining control during his service games throughout the points won also favored Sinner, who won 44 points on Alcaraz's serve, while Alcaraz secured 36 receiving points. These differences contributed to Sinner's greater consistency across the final three sets after dropping the Sinner's triumph at Wimbledon 2025 marks his first Grand Slam title at the All England Club. His superior consistency across service games, break points, and return points secured victory over Carlos Alcaraz, who was bidding for his third consecutive Wimbledon title.

The Hindu
24 minutes ago
- The Hindu
Sinner beats Alcaraz to win Wimbledon men's title
Jannik Sinner defeated Carlos Alcaraz 4-6 6-4 6-4 6-4 in a high-octane final to claim his maiden Wimbledon trophy and fourth Grand Slam crown on Sunday, avenging his loss to the Spaniard in last month's epic French Open final. The hard-fought win over the two-times defending champion on the famous lawns of London ensured that Sinner became the first Italian to secure a Wimbledon singles title. The 23-year-old Sinner drew first blood in the first Wimbledon men's final contested by a pair born in the 2000s, breaking for a 3-2 lead, but Alcaraz clawed back before hitting a spectacular return at full stretch to wrap up the opening set and he celebrated by cupping his ear and soaking up the cheers. Sinner was gifted a break in the opening game of next set and he let out a rare yell of 'Let's go' after winning a point en route to holding in a tight game before surging ahead 3-1 after a brief interruption when a champagne cork flew from the stands and landed on Centre Court. The top seed shrugged off the distraction and hit a running crosscourt winner to take the second set, before tightening his grip on the contest by unleashing a superb volley at the net to break for 5-4 and then holding in the next game to seal the third set with minimum fuss. With shadows drifting across the main showcourt that had basked in bright sunshine, Sinner wheeled away to a 3-1 lead in the fourth set as Alcaraz began to display the smallest signs of dejection, and the monk-like world number one held firm from there to complete a famous victory. There was to be no Roland Garros-like resurrection for Alcaraz, who fought back from three match-points down in the Paris finale just 35 days ago, as the Spaniard's bid to claim three successive All England Club titles was extinguished.


India Today
33 minutes ago
- India Today
Jannik Sinner wins maiden Wimbledon title, denies Carlos Alcaraz three-peat
World No. 1 Jannik Sinner cracked the Carlos Alcaraz code to clinch his maiden Wimbledon title. On Sunday, July 13, in front of a packed Centre Court, Sinner needed three hours and four minutes to defeat Alcaraz 4-6, 6-4, 6-4, aiming to become only the fifth man to win the grass-court major three years in a row, made a brilliant start but soon lost his rhythm. advertisementSince returning from his absence at the Madrid Open, Alcaraz had gone on a 24-match winning streak - claiming titles at the Italian Open, French Open, and the Queen's Club (HSBC) Championships - before suffering his first defeat at Wimbledon. The victory marked a turning point for Sinner, who ended a five-match losing streak against Alcaraz and handed the Spaniard his first Grand Slam final defeat in six 2025 men's singles final HighlightsHe also narrowed their ATP head-to-head record to 5–8 and exacted revenge for his heartbreaking loss in the French Open final, where Alcaraz had stormed back from two sets down and saved multiple championship puts Sinner under pressureSinner made a strong start, going 3-2 up with an early break, pressuring Alcaraz's serve. But the Spaniard hit back swiftly, breaking back and dominating the rest of the set. He wrapped it up in just 44 minutes, capitalising on Sinner's 13 unforced errors while firing 11 winners of his his back against the wall, Sinner showed resilience, grabbing an early break to go 1-0 up in the second set. This time, he didn't let the advantage slip after putting Alcaraz under even threatened a double break, but Alcaraz managed to hold. Still, the Spaniard couldn't retrieve the break he desperately needed, and Sinner went on to level the match. Alcaraz's four double faults until then only deepened his Sinner is a Wimbledon championThe world No.1 defeats Carlos Alcaraz 4-6, 6-4, 6-4, 6-4 to win the 2025 Gentlemen's Singles Trophy #Wimbledon Wimbledon (@Wimbledon) July 13, 2025Sinner topples Alcaraz on Centre CourtBoth players battled hard at the start of the third set before Alcaraz held Sinner to love in the fourth game. Just when it seemed the set was headed for a tie-breaker, Sinner broke serve to go 5-4 up. Serving at 5-4, 40-15, he earned two set points and converted the first to take the third made 12 unforced errors in the set - seven more than Alcaraz - but offset them with 15 winners and seven aces. Heading into the fourth set, Alcaraz found himself in familiar territory: he had come back from two sets down to beat Sinner in the French Open final, and now needed two in a row at SW19 to do it however, continued to rise to the occasion. He earned an early break to go 2-1 up and quickly extended his lead to 3-1. At 3-4, 40-15, Alcaraz had two golden opportunities to break back, but failed to convert either - perhaps missing his last real chance at a comeback. In the end, Sinner finished it off clinically, leaving Alcaraz heartbroken.- Ends