Drew Harris ‘deeply concerned' over ‘erroneous' Garda strip-search claims made in Dáil
The Garda Commissioner has written to the Ceann Comhairle describing claims made in the
Dáil
about the treatment of women protesters by
gardaí
as 'wholly inaccurate'.
Last month, People Before Profit-Solidarity TDs
Richard Boyd Barrett
,
Paul Murphy
and Ruth Coppinger
told the Dáil
that members of the Mothers Against Genocide group were arrested and strip-searched, and that one of the protesters was subjected to a cavity search.
The group had held an overnight protest outside Leinster House to remember the mothers and children killed in
Gaza
on Mother's Day.
Members of Mothers Against Genocide were among 14 people
arrested following the vigil
.
READ MORE
In a letter to Ceann Comhairle
Verona Murphy
, Garda Commissioner
Drew Harris
has said the remarks made by the three People Before Profit-Solidarity TDs are 'erroneous' and he expressed his 'deep concern' at the statements.
He said he 'initiated a comprehensive review of the allegations'.
Garda Commissioner Drew Harris: 'Such unfounded allegations made by public representatives under Dáil privilege and repeated in media coverage cannot remain unchallenged.' Photograph: Sam Boal/Collins Photos
Mr Harris wrote: 'I can confirm the Garda members involved in conducting the searches acted at all times professionally, lawfully, and in accordance with established procedures and legislative provision.'
He said he has verified that gardaí treated those in custody 'with respect at all times' and ensured the safety of all within the Garda station.
Mr Harris said the protests and subsequent arrests were recorded on Garda body-worn cameras and that there are also visual and audio recordings available from the Garda stations' custody areas.
'These recordings show nothing that would substantiate any allegations of wrongdoing,' he said.
'There are no recording devices in cells when prisoners are being searched for obvious requirements for dignity and privacy.'
Mr Harris said an allegation of mistreatment of any person detained in the custody of An Garda Síochána is taken 'extremely seriously'.
'As a direct consequence of these wholly inaccurate statements and the widespread coverage of them in the media, I am deeply concerned about the damage that may be caused to public confidence and trust in policing,' he said.
'Such unfounded allegations made by public representatives under Dáil privilege and repeated in media coverage cannot remain unchallenged.'
He asked that copies of his letter be circulated to TDs 'to dispel any doubts as to the accuracy of the statements made by deputies Boyd Barrett, Murphy and Coppinger, but moreover, to reiterate the very serious harm they cause to public confidence in An Garda Síochána and the professional reputation of members of the service'.
People Before Profit TD Mr Murphy reacted to the letter, claiming a line in it contradicts remarks made by Minister for Justice
Jim O'Callaghan
and 'vindicates our claims'.
Mr Murphy highlighted how Mr Harris's letter states 'there are no recording devices in cells when prisoners are being searched'.
The TD added that the Minister made comments at a Garda association conference last month 'claiming our statements had been shown to be false' but 'did not disclose this crucial information'.
[
Government facing crisis filling Garda Commissioner job amid 'entrenched' dispute
Opens in new window
]
Mr Murphy said the Minister 'gave the clear impression that footage had 'revealed' that our claims on strip and cavity searches were false'.
'On the contrary, this letter from the Garda Commissioner vindicates our claims and proves that the Minister misled the public,' he said.
The Irish Times report on the AGSI conference last month quotes Mr O'Callaghan as saying: 'I asked that bodycam footage and any recordings be examined, particularly recordings from Garda stations.
'Having conducted his inquiries, the commissioner reported back to me last week in writing, stating that his inquiries revealed the allegations made by some members of Dáil Éireann were false.'
A spokeswoman for Mr O'Callaghan said the Minister 'stands over his statement'.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Suggestions for solving the housing crisis
Sir, – Building on Pat Leahy's excellent observation that the Government's response to the housing crisis is barely at the mildly urgent level ( 'Housing emergency? Ireland is not even acting at the level of mildly urgent' , June 2nd), may I suggest a suitable response that addresses the supply side issues currently faced? 1) All Ministers, civil servants, planners, and local authority heads involved in the planning process and the delivery of critical infrastructure such as water and electricity – as well as TDs, Senators and local councillors who make representations on behalf of objectors in their constituency, members of the judiciary who make planning decisions, serial objectors and owners of derelict properties – to be made homeless and put on the housing waiting list. 2) Keep the above on the waiting list until the housing crisis is marked as 'solved'. Perhaps this might focus minds accordingly. All without the need to offer someone ¤450,000 per annum. – Yours, etc, READ MORE RORY J WHELAN, Drogheda, Co Meath.
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
US vetoes UN resolution demanding immediate Gaza ceasefire
The United States vetoed a United Nations (UN) Security Council resolution demanding an immediate and unconditional ceasefire in the Gaza Strip , the release of all hostages and the resumption of full-scale humanitarian aid deliveries to the enclave on Wednesday. Ten non-permanent members of the 15-seat council had put forth the resolution for a vote. It was the first time since president Donald Trump took office that the council had considered a ceasefire resolution on the Israel -Hamas war in Gaza. The US was the only member to vote against the measure; the other 14 members of the council, including Russia, voted in favour, highlighting Washington's isolation on the global stage over its policy of unconditional support of Israel. 'We believe this text reflects the consensus shared by all council members that the war in Gaza has to come to an immediate halt, all hostages must be immediately and unconditionally released, and civilians in Gaza must not starve and must have full and unimpeded access to aid,' said a joint statement from the 10 non-permanent members, which was read by Slovenia's ambassador to the UN, Samuel Zbogar, at the council meeting before the vote. READ MORE [ Gaza aid group halts distribution due to civilian safety concerns after dozens killed seeking aid Opens in new window ] To be adopted, Security Council resolution must receive nine votes in favour and no vetoes from the five permanent members: Britain, China, France, Russia and the United States. Since the war broke out after the October 7th, 2023, Hamas-led attack on Israel, the US has vetoed four council resolutions calling for a ceasefire and has abstained from one, allowing it to pass, last June. Dorothy Camille Shea, the interim US representative at the UN, repeated Washington's message that Israel had the right to defend itself. She blamed Hamas for the suffering of Palestinians, saying the war would end if the group surrendered. 'Any product that undermines our close ally Israel's security is a non-starter,' Ms Shea said, explaining the 'no' vote. Diplomats at the UN have watched in fury and frustration as the humanitarian situation in Gaza has deteriorated to levels where children are starving. Since March, Israel had enforced a ban on all aid delivery into the territory, facing global backlash and accusations that its army was committing war crimes by weaponising food and essential aid. Israel justified blocking aid deliveries by claiming that Hamas hijacks them and has denied international assessments that Palestinians are on the brink of famine. [ Liam Cunningham says Government is 'siding with warmongers' as he endorses Irish neutrality campaign Opens in new window ] Council members have also been frustrated at the United States for blocking the body from acting in a deadly war that has killed more than 56,000 Palestinians, many of them women and children, said Gaza officials, whose numbers do not distinguish between combatants and civilians. Unicef said this week that 50,000 children had been killed or injured in Gaza since the war began. The council members say, publicly and privately, that the United States is standing in the way of the will of the majority of the member states at the UN 'Today, the elected members of the council have stood with clarity, with conviction, with courage – they are the proud bearer of moral legitimacy,' said Algeria's ambassador to the UN, Amar Bendjama, the only Arab representative in the council. He said the resolution was not 'the voice of the few, but the collective will of the entire world '. Israel's ambassador to the UN, Danny Danon, told reporters before the council meeting Wednesday that the resolution 'doesn't advance humanitarian relief – it undermines it.' He said , 'It ignores a working system in favour of political agendas.' A new US-Israeli backed effort to control and distribute limited aid in Gaza through the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation was suspended Wednesday, after a week of chaos and deadly violence. Gaza officials said that on June 1st, Israeli soldiers shot and killed more than 20 Palestinians standing in line to receive aid. The Israeli military said its troops had fired warning shots toward 'suspects' who approached them. On Tuesday, at least 27 people were killed as Palestinians walked toward a new food distribution site in southern Gaza, Gaza health officials said. Israel said its forces had fired near 'a few' people who had strayed from the route to the site and did not respond to warning shots. The UN has called for an independent investigation into the killings and has denounced this aid-distribution effort, saying that it violates international laws protecting the unhindered flow of aid and access for aid agencies in conflict zones. 'The world is watching, day after day, horrifying scenes of Palestinians being shot, wounded or killed in Gaza while simply trying to eat,' the UN's top humanitarian chief, Tom Fletcher, said on Wednesday. 'We must be allowed to do our jobs. We have the teams, the plan, the supplies and the experience.' The Trump administration has been trying without success to mediate a temporary ceasefire between Israel and Hamas. This week, Hamas – which has said it is willing to free the Israeli and foreign captives in Gaza as part of a broader deal – rejected the American plan, demanding guarantees for a permanent end to the war. – This article originally appeared in The New York Times . 2025 The New York Times Company
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
Two bunches of flowers lie outside Fairgreen Shopping Centre following ‘terrible' fatal shooting
The marks of a concentrated number of shots can be seen in the 'o' of the Tesco sign at Fairgreen Shopping Centre in Co Carlow. Outside the premises, two bunches of flowers have been laid close to where gunman Evan Fitzgerald died on Sunday evening. The busy centre was the scene of chaos and fear, when at 6.15pm, as shoppers filled their trolleys for the week ahead, the 22-year-old, from Kiltegan, Co Wicklow, entered carrying a shotgun. He discharged shots into the air a number of times, causing shoppers to flea. Outside the building, he fatally wounded himself after being challenged by gardaí. No one else was shot during the incident. On Wednesday, Geraldine Nolan (64), who regularly shops at the Tesco, sat in a coffee shop in the centre with her five-month-old grandson on her lap. READ MORE [ Carlow gunman Evan Fitzgerald had bail conditions relaxed prior to trial date Opens in new window ] She was 'shocked' by the 'terrible' events that occurred here days earlier, she says. She is mindful of the effect witnessing the shooting will have on people working in the centre at the time and glad workers and customers were not seriously injured. Her thoughts too are with the deceased, she said, : 'It's hard on his family too.' Her daughter Vanessa (33) is also coming to terms with the shock what occurred in their locality. 'You don't expect something like that to happen in a small town. It's not something that's normalised,' she says. John Brophy, manager of the centre, says uncertainty pervaded in the aftermath of the shooting and it was 'very hard to know what was going on'. However, gardaí, fire services and bomb squad were 'exemplary in the way they conducted themselves over the couple of days', he says. At the time of the incident, Tesco was the only shop still open in the centre, he says. [ Carlow gunman Evan Fitzgerald (22) had 'a fascination with firearms' Opens in new window ] He is mindful that security staff, Tesco employees and customers witnessed the shooting. The deceased young man and his family are also in his thoughts, and he is keen that they are 'respected', he says. Counselling is being provided to the Tesco employees and the centre's security staff. In Carlow town's Primary Care Centre, the Health Service (HSE) has implemented a counselling service for the public to avail of in the aftermath of the event. A HSE representative said the service has been 'busy'.
