5 signs you're living a 'B+ life'—and what it says about you: Harvard-trained career expert
If it's the former, you may be living what, in my research and teaching, I've come to call a "B+ life," which is certainly better than a stick in the eye, but can also be more damaging in the long run.
Because when things are "OK" and "good enough," we rarely make the effort to make the changes to find something better. For instance, an A+ life, filled with authenticity and fulfillment.
By the way, and to be clear, the "grader" in all this life-rating is not society. It's not your family or your boss. It's you.
Hear me out. As a business academic who studies career trajectories, I completely understand that just surviving in this complex economy can sometimes feel like a victory. I also know that life's many challenges, like the death of a loved one or a struggle with mental illness, can make achieving a "perfect" life unattainable.
But after working with thousands of early and mid-career professionals, as a professor, researcher, and mentor, I know that for many, settling for B+ is not an imperative — but a habit. We get used to living in a suit that's a size too big or too small, to use an image that for many, feels uncomfortably accurate.
We tell ourselves, "The dreams I once had were stupid; no one gets what they want."
Before I list the more concrete signs you're living a B+ life yourself, a bit of context and background.
I'm a professor and researcher who studies career trajectories. The culmination of my work is a scientifically-validated methodology taught at NYU Stern School of Business in a class called "Becoming You: Crafting the Authentic Life You Want and Need." On campus and in numerous workshops for the public and within organizations, the Becoming You methodology, and its various components, has been used by more than 10,000 people around the world.
My method is based on the premise that our purpose in life lies at the intersection of our deeply held values, cognitive and emotional aptitudes, and economically viable interests. Aptitudes and interests are usually self-evident, but unfortunately, very few people actually know their values in specific detail. This information has to be excavated, for lack of a better word, with values testing.
But once it is, we can move away from living by default to living by design. There is no easy hack to it, but the end result is the roadmap from B+ to beyond.
To assess whether you are living a B+ life, consider these five signs:
Despite hitting external milestones — whether at work or in your personal life — your energy is low and you often feel numb, disengaged, or secretly exhausted. This misalignment can show up in what my values testing instrument, The Values Bridge, calls the "Authenticity Gapthe measure of how muchour outer life doesn't match your inner truth.
You talk about what matters to you (self-determination, creative self-expression, service, community), but your calendar and choices don't reflect those priorities.
If you're fully honest with yourself, you would have to admit you are curating your image or chasing validation. Dan Harris, an expert on self-awareness and host of the acclaimed 10% Happier podcast, might frame this as a lack of "mindful presence"; you're so caught in striving that you've lost the ability to just .
Conflict, resentment, or emotional distance can show up when you're suppressing needs, boundaries, or truths about yourself. My research clearly demonstrates that not living authentically has a strong tendency to distort how we connect with others.
You daydream about quitting, running away, or starting over. This is less about reinvention and more about fleeing a life that feels misfitted to who you actually are.
As I said, for some people a B+ life is more than they ever imagined given their life circumstances. It can indeed be "good enough."
But for others, more fulfillment and authenticity is a yearning that slowly builds, and along the way, causes increasing discomfort, sometimes ending in the kind of disruption that has us starting again, by our own volition or not.
The antidote is understanding your values in their specific detail, and just as importantly, acknowledging whether you are living them as much as your heart and soul desire. Only then can we break out of our comfort zone, to something that can be even better.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CNBC
11-08-2025
- CNBC
Success comes down to just 3 things: Companies ‘will be in a cage match over you,' says CEO
In the end, success comes down to three things. If you think the first one is luck, sorry! That would be a platitude. Okay, fine, of course luck matters. It matters in the big-big things, like where and when you're born, your health, your class, your race. But it also helps with the small stuff, like when the person sitting next to you in Row 45 on the Tampa-Chicago flight loves your product and places the order that saves you from bankruptcy. But luck is random by definition. As a business academic who studies career trajectories, I've found long-term success is, aside from luck, a function of PIE. It refers to the quality of your: Let me explain. Good news, I'm not going to tell you to network. I hate networking. It's mercenary and phony, and it doesn't work. Instead, invest your time and energy making friends with all sorts of people, and lots of them, at work and out, with no expectation of anything in return. They may be able to help you someday, or maybe not, but if and when they do, their help will have more impact than any networking contact. My dear friend, Hollis, is the publisher of my latest book, "Becoming You." Would she have acquired my manuscript if she hadn't liked it? No, of course not, and our friendship would have been just fine. But you've also never seen an easier, faster book deal brokered. The lawyers had nothing to do. Poor them! Friends, real ones, are what make business go. And the better friends you have, the better it will go for you You don't need a lot of ideas. But I've never met a successful person who didn't have a few really good ones over the long arc of their career. What is a "good" idea? Well, for one thing, it's original. I'm thinking of Jeff Bezos when it dawned on him that he didn't need to sell just books online. He could sell anything. Luckily for the rest of us, an original idea doesn't have to blow up the economy. It can be as small as replacing a bureaucratic process with a clean, simple one. Or a marketing activation that bumps sales 3% or a design tweak that makes an industrial product 5% more efficient. I know a car salesman who, in his first year on the job, doubled his location's sales by bringing a new question to his teammates. When a customer throws a lowball price at you, he said, instead of negotiating off the bat, ask, "Can you help me understand how you came up with that number?" He runs the place now. This is the most underrated success-driver of the PIE triad — which is ridiculous, because any manager in the world will tell you they'd kill for a team member who gets you-know-what done. In my class at NYU, every MBA student must go through 360 Feedback, an evaluation tool that gathers input from former and current coworkers, bosses, and employees, and aggregates it into a report. Sarah, a student, reviewed her 360 results in class and immediately booked double office hours. When we met up, she was in tears. "Professor Welch, I need you to teach me how to be a leader," she said, "because my 360 Feedback results are horrifying." Dear Reader, it was a WTF moment for me, since my reaction to her results had been, "Nice!" The issue was that Sarah's 360 results had shown her to be kind of low on leadership traits. But every single piece of feedback suggested that Sarah was SEAL Team Six when it came to getting projects over the finish line. Her execution was perfect, precise, and invisible. As a leader myself, it made me feel faint with ardor. I needed to make sure. Did Sarah to be a leader? There was a long pause, then: "Honestly? No!" Strategy bored her, she told me. Vision statements made her gag. Just tell me what needs to be done and get out of my way. "Why don't you just aim to have a career as a COO?" I asked. "Every CEO in the world will be in a cage match over you." "But we're supposed to become leaders," she protested. "That's why we go to business school." Ah, but no, I reminded her. You are in business school — you are in life — to become you. My Becoming You methodology helps you answer: "What should I do with my life?" The PIE theory drives much of the information Becoming You digs to unearth: how you relate to people, how your brain works, and how you show up in the world. It's literally set up to set you up to succeed, based on how I believe success actually happens.
CNBC
28-07-2025
- CNBC
'What should I do with my life?': A Harvard-trained career expert tells us exactly how to answer
You are you, right? Seems straightforward. But are you the you you want to be? The one living the life and pursuing the career you should be? Suzy Welch knows from experience that many people aren't. Not yet. She's spent over 15 years developing and testing a methodology to help people discover their "authentic purpose," based on: Welch calls it "Becoming You." Through her course at NYU Stern School of Business, workshops, and private sessions, she's seen thousands of people learn about themselves in hopes of answering the question: "What should I do with my life?" CNBC Make It put "Becoming You: The Proven Method for Crafting Your Authentic Life and Career" on our first book club shortlist because, as Welch writes, "most of us struggle with this our whole lives." If you haven't had a chance to read, or could use a quick recap before Wednesday's discussion in our private LinkedIn group, here are a few key takeaways: Welch divides her book into three parts accordingly: Your values are "your authentic wants, needs, and desires. Your deeply held beliefs about how your life — and life in general — should be," Welch writes. Welch spent years, as part of her PhD research and beyond, "identifying, testing, validating, and codifying" what she considers the 15 "core human values." They include, for example: The Values Bridge assessment Welch created "reflects the distance between your current life and the one you should be living, and would if you could," she writes. "The hard part is what to do next: figuring out how to build that bridge to the future." You might think you already know what you're good at, but "identifying your aptitudes almost always does take work," Welch writes. First, she explains, it's important to understand that aptitudes aren't skills or competencies, which we acquire and practice through education or training. "Aptitudes those things. They're the inborn faculties that make us good or better at certain skills, competencies, and areas of expertise." Welch identifies eight cognitive aptitudes, all of which fall on a spectrum. They include, for example: She also highlights four personality traits she believes are particularly important in the process of "Becoming You," including "wonderment," which is all about curiosity and currency, as in being current about what's going on in your job function, industry, and more. Knowing your values and aptitudes isn't enough. Welch often sees her students struggle. "What kind of work calls them emotionally and engages them intellectually, they wonder, and is it tenable as a life and lifestyle they desire?" So the third part of the process is about figuring out their interests and the corresponding opportunities — "the jobs, companies, and industries that make up the world of work today" and "the economic trends on the horizon." If you think of values, aptitudes, and economically viable interests as intersecting circles, that spot at the center where all three overlap is your purpose, or what Welch calls your "Area of Transcendence." Finding it is the ultimate goal of the "Becoming You" methodology. "One of the hardest things to know in life is ourselves," Welch writes. But the methodology is "deeply personal," and "for Becoming You to work, it cannot be performative," she writes. "The process requires radical honesty with yourself." This is one of the reasons she uses so many assessments, exercises, and challenges in the "Becoming You" process, many of which she includes as appendices in the book. They're meant to help you go beyond the superficial answers. "It can be fearsome, humbling, and occasionally embarrassing to admit who we are. But we truly do need to know so that we can set out on the journey toward who it is we must become." Welch, who writes that she hates platitudes, might nevertheless agree with these two: People change. Things change. Becoming You "is not intended as a prescription, a one and done," she writes. It "is meant to be a forever thing, a way of thinking and sorting things out that you return to at every crossroads, time and again." Want to talk about it? Request to join our LinkedIn group, and come talk with us and Welch on Wednesday, July 30, at 10 a.m. ET, at our next CNBC Make It Book Club discussion. In the meantime, you can also read Welch's recent articles, including on signs you're living a "B+ life" and the No. 1 question you should ask in a job interview that "cuts through the BS." Any questions for the author? Email them to us in advance at askmakeit@ using the subject line "Question for Suzy Welch." Hoping to get ahead on the next book? Our August pick is "Rich AF: The Money Mindset That Will Change Your Life" by Vivian Tu. Have suggestions for future picks? Send them to us at askmakeit@ using the subject line "Make It book club suggestion."
CNBC
14-07-2025
- CNBC
July's book club pick, Suzy Welch's 'Becoming You,' helps you answer: 'What should I do with my life?'
It's a simple question without an easy answer: "What should I do with my life?" "Most of us struggle with this our whole lives," writes Suzy Welch in the introduction to her recent book, "Becoming You: The Proven Method for Crafting Your Authentic Life and Career." Her goal — as it is in the similarly named course she teaches at NYU Stern School of Business — is to help people answer this "pesky" question. CNBC Make It tends to draw an audience of young professionals who want to be smarter, more successful, and happier with their work, money, and lives. That's why we, with input from our community, chose "Becoming You" as our July book club pick. "It's about self-discovery and career development," says Welch, who will be joining us to discuss the book and answer your questions at the end of this month. The book "presents you with a methodology where you excavate your values, your deeply held beliefs. [You] identify your aptitudes, what you're really really good at. And you narrow in on what kind of work calls you emotionally and intellectually," she says. "You put it together and you pretty much land at your purpose. That's what 'Becoming You' is all about." Welch, a graduate of Harvard University and Harvard Business School, has spent over 15 years developing the Becoming You methodology, and more than 10,000 people have used it. Watching so many people grapple with that eternal question, "What should I do with my life?" she's found that "discovering your purpose is a journey. Hard, messy, joyful, exhausting, exhilarating, bumpy, scary, life-giving, and — did I mention — ," she writes. But it's worth the work, because "what a relief it can be to finally figure out the answer! And then, over time, to actually do the thing you're meant to do!" she writes. "It's about you waking up, opening your eyes, and thinking, " Ready to dive in? Start reading, request to join our LinkedIn group, and come chat with us and Welch on Wednesday, July 30, at 10 a.m. ET, at our next CNBC Make It Book Club discussion. In the meantime, you can also read Welch's recent articles, including on signs you're living a "B+ life" and the No. 1 question you should ask in a job interview that "cuts through the BS." Any questions for the author? Email them to us in advance at askmakeit@ using the subject line "Question for Suzy Welch." Hoping to get ahead on the next book? Our August pick is "Rich AF: The Money Mindset That Will Change Your Life" by Vivian Tu. Have suggestions for future picks? Send them to us at askmakeit@ using the subject line "Make It book club suggestion."
