Post Office paid £600m to continue using bug-ridden Horizon IT system
The Post Office has paid more than £600m of public money to continue using the bug-ridden Horizon IT system despite deciding it needed to be replaced more than a decade ago.
It has emerged that the government was warned about potential problems with the original £548m deal the Post Office struck with the Japanese company Fujitsu before it was signed in 1999.
The former prime minister Tony Blair and other senior Labour government figures were aware that, under the terms of the deal, the Post Office would not own the core computer code to Horizon, which would make it difficult to ever shift supplier, according to the BBC.
To date, the Post Office has spent £2.5bn on contracts with Fujitsu, including £600m on extensions since it started looking for new suppliers in 2012, and ultimately attempting to build its own technology, called the New Branch IT system.
The Post Office stopped private prosecutions based on Horizon IT data in 2015, after more than 900 operators were wrongly prosecuted over shortfalls resulting from the faulty system, a practice it has promised not to restart.
The Post Office started the hunt for a new supplier in 2012 and asked IBM to build a replacement system to Horizon in 2015, but that project was abandoned at a cost of £40m in 2016.
A later plan to build a new system running on Amazon's cloud computing system had to be abandoned in 2022.
The embattled business has been developing its own proprietary system, NBIT, which was meant to roll out this year.
However, it has been beset with delays and increasing costs that could run to more than £1bn, raising doubts it will ever be rolled out, with the Post Office and Fujitsu admitting they are likely to still be working together until 2030.
According to the BBC, Blair received an update from the Treasury in May 1999 warning that discussions with a Fujitsu subsidiary, ICL Pathway, over the terms of a deal for Horizon had 'foundered'.
One of the issues related to the implications of not controlling all intellectual property rights, with the Treasury warning that Fujitsu 'would be in a strong position to drive a costly settlement with the Post Office'.
A spokesperson for Blair did not directly address his knowledge of the intellectual property ownership problem but told the BBC he 'took very seriously the issues raised about the Horizon contract' at the time.
Sign up to Business Today
Get set for the working day – we'll point you to all the business news and analysis you need every morning
after newsletter promotion
'The final decision was taken after an investigation by an independent panel recommended it was viable,' the spokesperson said. 'It is now clear that the Horizon product was seriously flawed, leading to tragic and completely unacceptable consequences, and Mr Blair has deep sympathy with all those affected.'
In the same year a document was sent to Gordon Brown, the then chancellor, warning of the issues over code ownership.
A spokesperson for Brown said he 'would not have been shown the memo' from 20 May 1999 and he would have been copied in as a 'formality'.
The spokesperson told the BBC: 'He was not involved in any work related to the purchasing, award or management of the Horizon contract.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
30 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
CHRISTOPHER STEVENS reviews Surviving Syria's Prisons: Bravery of two brothers who exposed the atrocities of Assad's evil regime
Surviving Syria's Prisons (BBC2) What a strange power the television camera exercises over people. Point a lens at them and they will confess to crimes that, in court or under police questioning, they'd deny to their dying breath. Filmed in silhouette, their faces in shadow, torturers and prison guards described the atrocities they routinely inflicted on political detainees, in the This World documentary Surviving Syria 's Prisons. Their testimony was often self-serving. Each one pleaded he had no choice but to mete out brutality and murder. Henchmen took the age-old line that they were 'only obeying orders'. Officers claimed the men below them were an ill-disciplined rabble who could not be restrained. Despite their excuses, all admitted to sadistic abuse and such extremes of violence that, in an international court, they would surely be facing life sentences. Even Syria's deposed dictator, Bashar al-Assad, who was overthrown last December, was not immune to the power of the TV camera. In 2011, he appeared on a U.S. talk show, attempting to justify his reign of terror by claiming the thuggish security services were not under his control. 'They are not my forces. They are military forces that belong to the government,' he said. 'I don't own them. I am president, I don't own the country.' Chinless and goggle-eyed, like a serial killer invented by P.G. Wodehouse, Assad looked desperately pleased with himself to be interviewed by veteran American journalist Barbara Walters. Clearly, he was achieving a long-held ambition to appear on a prestigious U.S. show, and the fact millions of Americans would learn how his regime ruled by mass murder was a price worth paying. The limitless evil exposed to daylight in this film was balanced by the extraordinary bravery of two brothers whose work made the programme possible. Shadi and Hadi Haroun were subjected to years of torment inside Assad's most notorious prison, Saydnaya, as punishment for their role in the Arab Spring protests. They took us into the derelict shell of Saydnaya, 'the human slaughterhouse', where the regime dealt with anyone suspected of opposing Assad's Ba'ath party by word, deed or thought. Executions by hanging were daily events, not on a gallows but with a noose and a chair. Guards frequently beat men to death or even buried them alive. Satellite photos reveal the existence of around 130 mass graves. The Haroun brothers were regularly suspended by their arms from the ceiling pipes, side by side, or with their hands manacled behind their backs and doubled over in what they called the 'ghost method'. How anyone could live through years of that treatment defies comprehension. This was 75 minutes of necessary but relentlessly depressing television. The only relief came from the brothers' devotion to each other. Grey-bearded Hadi told how the worst agony was being forced to listen to his brother's screams. 'I'd always try to be the one who took the beating rather than him,' he said. Truly nightmarish. Small Change of the Night: Bullion robber Charlie (Sam Spruell) had a headache laundering £10million offshore in The Gold (BBC1). These days, as Oliver Bullough's brilliant book Moneyland makes plain, that's petty cash for tax-evading crooks and tech billionaires.
Daily Mirror
2 hours ago
- Daily Mirror
Donald Trump makes huge World War I blunder in fiery speech as LA riots rage
Donald Trump made a huge blunder about World War I in a fiery speech at Fort Bragg, as the U.S. continues to be rocked by riots over the President's mass deportation order US President Donald Trump delivered a speech at Fort Bragg on Tuesday, as unrest continued in Los Angeles between protesters and ICE officials over his far-reaching deportation order. Fort Bragg, situated near Fayetteville, North Carolina, is home to the military's Special Operations Command, which includes elite units such as the Green Berets and Rangers. During his address, Trump made a significant historical blunder, claiming that many countries had recently commemorated the end of World War I, while the US did not participate in the celebrations, despite asserting "we're the ones who won the war." "Without us," Trump said, "You'd all be speaking German right now." "Maybe a little Japanese thrown in. But we won the war," he added. "We're gonna celebrate on Saturday." However, Trump's claim that citizens would have been speaking Japanese is inaccurate, as Japan was an ally of the US, France, Great Britain, Russia, and Italy against the Axis powers of Germany, Austria-Hungary, Bulgaria, and the Ottoman Empire, reports the Mirror US. It appears the President was actually referencing WW2, which was commemorated recently during VE celebrations. The end of WW1 is traditionally commemorated on "Armistice Day" on November 11 each year. The event at Fort Bragg was also attended by Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth and Army Secretary Dan Driscoll, and included both active service members and their families. The speech comes ahead of the 250th anniversary of the army and coincidentally, Trump's 79th birthday, which will be marked with a parade in Washington, D.C. The city is bracing for a massive turnout at the parade this Saturday, with officials already setting up 18 miles of "anti-scale fencing" and deploying drones, despite the usual no-fly zone rules. City representatives have told The Associated Press they're expecting an "preparing for an enormous turnout." Secret Service's Matt McCool from the Washington Field Office is preparing for "hundreds of thousands" to line the streets, while military sources estimate around 200,000 will join the celebrations. "We have a ton of magnetometers," McCool said. "If a million people show up, then we're going to have some lines." To manage the expected crowds, 175 magnetometers will be in place at security checkpoints throughout the day and for the evening parade. Metropolitan Police Department Chief Pamela Smith has warned of "major impacts to traffic" and advises attendees to consider using the Metro instead of driving. "This is a significant event with a large footprint," she stressed. "We're relying on the public to be an extra set of ears and eyes for us." The event has hit the headlines as a National Special Security Event, with security measures on par with presidential inaugurations or state funerals. This elite status is reserved for high-profile functions drawing sizeable gatherings and the likelihood of significant protests, triggering an increased security collaboration between local officials, the FBI, Capitol Police, and the National Guard, all led by the watchful Secret Service. Officials are also on high alert for possible immigration-related protests, mirroring those in Los Angeles, potentially hitting D. C. 's streets. "We're paying attention, obviously, to what is happening there. We'll be ready," affirmed McCool, underlining the extensive preparations in place to manage any civil unrest.
NBC News
4 hours ago
- NBC News
Trump warns that military parade protesters will face 'very heavy force'
WASHINGTON — President Donald Trump warned Tuesday that anyone who protests at the U.S. military parade here on Saturday will be met with "very heavy force." Trump told reporters in the Oval Office that they're going to be "celebrating big on Saturday," referring to the parade that will wind its way through downtown Washington, D.C. "If there's any protester that wants to come out, they will be met with very big force," Trump said. "I haven't even heard about a protest, but you know, this is people that hate our country, but they will be met with very heavy force." The White House didn't immediately respond to a request for comment. The president also addressed the protests of the administration's immigration raids in Los Angeles."These are paid insurrectionists," he said about the demonstrators. The military parade Saturday will mark the 250th anniversary of the U.S. Army and is expected to feature tanks and hundreds of other military vehicles and aircraft. It's estimated to cost about $45 million, including as much as $16 million to repair D.C. streets afterward, U.S. military officials said last month. Saturday is also Trump's 79th birthday. "We're going to have a fantastic June 14 parade, Flag Day. It's going to be an amazing day. We have tanks, we have planes, we have all sorts of things. And I think it's going to be great. We're going to celebrate our country for a change," Trump said Tuesday. Trump said that other countries celebrate the end of World War II and that the U.S. was the only country that did not. "And we're the one that won the war," said Trump, who added that if it weren't for the U.S., Americans would be speaking German or Japanese. "We won the war, and we're the only country that didn't celebrate it, and we're going to be celebrating big on Saturday," he said. Officials are expecting hundreds of thousands of attendees, Matt McCool, the U.S. Secret Service agent in charge of the Washington field office, said Monday. McCool said they plan to deploy "thousands of agents, officers and specialists from across the country." People attending the parade or a related festival will be required to go through checkpoints with magnetometers. Asked about any changes to security planning in light of the L.A. protests, McCool said, "We plan for those things ahead of time' 'We were paying attention, obviously, to what is happening there, and we'll be ready for that if it were to occur here,' he said, though he added, 'We have no intelligence of that happening here, but if it does, we have the resources to handle it." U.S. Park Police had several protest permits pending on Monday, but officials 'don't have any significant concerns," said McCool, who added that they're tracking 'about nine First Amendment activity demonstrations.' The anti-Trump group No Kings is expecting more than 1,800 rallies nationwide Saturday that organizers said were planned as "a peaceful stand against authoritarian overreach and the gross abuse of power this Administration has shown." With Trump's decision to deploy the National Guard and U.S. Marines to respond to the L.A. demonstrations, the group said in a statement: "This military escalation only confirms what we've known: this government wants to rule by force, not serve the people. From major cities to small towns, we'll rise together and say: we reject political violence. We reject fear as governance. We reject the myth that only some deserve freedom."
