Malatsi's B-BBEE policy sets ‘wrong precedent'
Communications and digital technologies minister Solly Malatsi.
Image: Armand Hough / Independent Newspapers
COMMUNICATIONS and Digital Technologies Minister Solly Malatsi's policy direction to ease broad-based economic empowerment (B-BBEE) regulations in the Information and Communications Technology (ICT) sector faces an uphill battle, with MPs from within and outside the coalition government expressing their strong objections on Tuesday.
Malatsi was hauled before the Communications and Digital Technologies Portfolio Committee to explain his new policy directives aimed at easing Broad-Based Black Economic Empowerment (B-BBEE) requirements for licensing satellite services, including American billionaire Elon Musk's Starlink.
Malatsi reiterated his commitment to the principles of transformation in South Africa, stating that the new policy does not aim to create exceptions for specific companies or individuals.
Malatsi, who highlighted the ongoing efforts to introduce an equity equivalent investment programme in the ICT sector, clarified that his department's work predates recent international developments, specifically referring to last week's visit to Washington by the South African delegation led by President Cyril Ramaphosa.
Malatsi dismissed claims that the timing of the gazette could benefit Starlink, saying: 'This work is not about introducing dispensation for any individual or company.'
The minister sought to reassure the committee that the policy direction allows stakeholders 30 days to submit their views, which will help shape the final product.
'In the end, Icasa may continue to require 30% (B-BBEE ownership), but it must permit commitments envisaged in the ICT sector conditions for valid applications for individual licences,' he stated.
However, dissent erupted within the committee, with members expressing alarm over the implications of the proposed policy.
ANC MP Oscar Mathafa questioned Malatsi's decision to open licensing applications without a clear strategy encompassing the equity equivalent programme, arguing that this move could undermine the transformation agenda that the government was mandated to pursue.
'We request all parties and members of society who are interested in this matter to reject this particular policy direction,' he said emphatically.
The sentiment was echoed by EFF MP Sinawo Thambo, who accused Malatsi of attempting to amend legislation covertly through policy directions designed to align the B-BBEE Act with ICT sector codes.
His colleague Sixolise Gcilishe said the EFF would not hesitate to legally challenge the proposals.
'We will explore all legal mechanisms. We are not to accept our laws being written in Washington. You are setting a wrong precedent by bending backwards when you are bullied. This is about Starlink and Washington,' Gcilishe said.
MK Party MP Colleen Makhubele accused Malatsi of failing to engage transparently with stakeholders and highlighted the need for a thorough regulatory impact assessment before proceeding with the proposed policy changes.
DA MP Tsholofelo Bodlani countered the criticism, urging critics to acknowledge the opportunity for public comment within the 30-day submission period.
'All choose to ignore that little fact,' he remarked, suggesting that some criticisms were politically motivated.
Committee chairperson, Khusela Sangoni-Diko, raised concerns about the legal authority Malatsi held to align the B-BBEE with ICT codes, questioning the potential consequences of removing the 30% B-BBEE requirement.
'Why take away from black people one thing they can make a structural shift in the economy?' she pressed, advocating for industry players' desire for regulatory parity.
In response, Malatsi expressed surprise over the committee's shock regarding the policy proposals, reiterating that the discussions had been ongoing.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Maverick
an hour ago
- Daily Maverick
How Floyd Shivambu caused his own MK party downfall
Floyd Shivambu's refusal to back down on his visit to fugitive pastor Shepherd Bushiri led to his sacking as MK party secretary-general. But he had faced criticism since his arrival from the EFF. Floyd Shivambu's Easter Weekend visit to fugitive pastor Shepherd Bushiri's church in Malawi marked the beginning of the end of his tenure as uMkhonto Wesizwe (MK) party secretary-general, but his refusal to back down on the matter sealed his fate. Shivambu's visit drew backlash, including from Justice Minister Mmamaloko Kubayi, who said it was 'a blatant act of disrespect toward South Africa's legal system' that would 'embolden those who believe they can escape accountability'. The MK party said he undertook the visit in his personal capacity, without the mandate or knowledge of the party. Shivambu could have apologised. Instead, he doubled down. In an interview on SABC last week, he claimed his visit was sanctioned by MK party leader Jacob Zuma. Party spokesperson Nhlamulo Ndhlela suggested he was lying and said the party stood by its criticism. Instead of retracting his comments or apologising, Shivambu went further, telling Newzroom Afrika last week, 'One thing I will never apologise for is when I went to see prophet Shepherd Bushiri.' In the same interview, he said joining the MK party was the best political decision he'd ever taken. Troubled from the start Shivambu's sacking as secretary-general was announced by the party on Tuesday, 3 June, just over nine months after he left his position as deputy president of the EFF, the party he formed with Julius Malema, to join MK. When Shivambu was announced as the latest member of the MK party in Sandton in August 2024, Zuma sang his praises, saying he met him while he was a young man in the ANC Youth League. 'I have known him from when he was very young. In the Youth League, that is when I picked up that he is a real politician. His politics, I define as scientific politics. He is an honest politician, clear politically, he takes decisions at the right time, for good reasons…' Shivambu was expelled from the ANC under Zuma's leadership. His position within the MK party faced opposition from the start. Within weeks after he joined, he was parachuted into the roles of national organiser and eventually secretary-general. Discontent quickly surfaced in the party's leadership ranks. Among those who opposed his appointment were senior party members who pointed out that just three months earlier, during the May 2024 general elections, he had actively campaigned against the very party he now represented. In September 2024, Shivambu led the party's municipal campaign in Ward 33 in eThekwini, which was his first as a national organiser. It should have been a shoo-in for the MK party in an area where the DA was failing and the ANC was basically dead. The MK party had won over 45% of the vote in the province, but Shivambu's efforts fell flat as the party's vote share dropped significantly in the by-election. The MK party improved in several other by-elections, but it has struggled to maintain the momentum of the 2024 general elections. Shivambu was appointed as secretary-general in November 2024 as the MK party prepared to mark its first anniversary in December. During this period, concerns surfaced over his alleged attempts to centralise financial control of the party, with claims that he sought sole authority over its funds. The MK party's first anniversary celebrations in Durban were far from seamless. Despite securing more than 600,000 votes in eThekwini and more than four million nationally in the May elections, the party struggled to fill the 56,000-seat Moses Mabhida Stadium. To some extent, the blame fell on Shivambu. At the party's anniversary gala dinner, traditional leaders boycotted the function after they had been denied entry to the first-anniversary event at Moses Mabhida Stadium. They were not the only ones who faced difficulties, as hundreds of supporters were unable to attend due to the party's failure to arrange transport. Shivambu apologised to those affected and made a commitment to visit their branches before the end of 2024. Tensions continued to brew. In February 2025, Duduzile Zuma went on a rant on X, making negative remarks and insulting Shivambu with comments that he was 'the worst thing that happened to MK', 'useless', and calling him 'Mafikizolo', which loosely translates to 'newcomer'. Zuma's office instructed her to apologise or face expulsion from the party – she apologised. But the criticism continued. In March, Daily Maverick reported that Mxolisi Mthethwa, the party's Zululand coordinator, had raised concerns about Shivambu's leadership, citing poor decision-making, lack of consultation and abuse of power. This came after he and others accused Shivambu of appointing people of his choice into crucial positions. In the same month, Shivambu was again unpopular for introducing strict controls over access to Zuma. 'All public representatives of the MK party are strictly forbidden from seeking direct meetings with the president before consultation with all the officials of the organisation, ie deputy president, secretary-general, national organiser, national chairperson, deputy national chairperson, and treasurer-general.' Shivambu defended the decision and told members, 'If there is an issue you want to raise before you reach the president, please raise that issue with the internal structures instead of taking a bus from Limpopo and going to KwaDakwa Dunuse [Zuma's Nkandla home].' 'No other option' Following his sacking as secretary-general, Shivambu has been redeployed to Parliament, where he will serve as an ordinary MP, where the party is led by chief whip Colleen Makhubele and party deputy president John Hlophe. On Tuesday, the party's national chairperson, Nkosinathi Nhleko, explained that Shivambu had been demoted because of his Bushiri visit. 'Based on the deliberations by the national officials, it was reaffirmed that the trip was not an officially sanctioned programme of the organisation or the president, which therefore goes against the constitution of the party…' 'Due to the serious nature of this matter and its implications for the party, its image, values and principles, the president and the national officials were left with no other option but to act swiftly in addressing this matter. 'Consequently, as a responsible organisation accountable to its electorate and the broader society, the national officials have come to a decision to redeploy commander Floyd Shivambu as the secretary-general of the party, and redeploy him to the National Assembly.' Speaking at the same media briefing, Shivambu apologised and accepted his demotion. 'I want to confirm that the national officials have taken a decision which I fully accept as a disciplined member of uMkhonto Wesizwe.' Zuma, who, according to the party's constitution, has the prerogative to hire and fire leaders at will, is now applying his mind to who he will appoint as the party's fifth secretary-general in fewer than 18 months. Zuma said it was important to set the record straight, as many complaints had been raised about the party's relationship with Bushiri. 'We thought it was important to clarify what has happened, and why we took this decision, but also respect the people that we say we stand for and therefore take the decision that we took, and I think that closes the matter. There is no problem.' DM
Daily Maverick
an hour ago
- Daily Maverick
South African GDP grows by a paltry 0.1% in Q1, but agriculture shines
One thing that is as certain as the changing seasons is that as the year progresses, forecasts for South African economic growth in 2025 – which are mostly around 1.2% – will be downgraded, which in turn will blow out of the water many of the revenue and debt projections in Budget 3.0. South Africa's sluggish economy barely grew in the first quarter (Q1) of this year, expanding a pathetic 0.1% from Q4 of 2024, according to data released on Tuesday by Statistics South Africa (Stats SA). This 'growth' – at a pace that a snail could slither past – would have been a contraction of 0.3% were it not for a stellar performance by the agricultural sector, which grew its production by a hefty 15.8% in the first three months of the year. Following gross domestic product (GDP) growth of just 0.4% in Q4 of 2024 – revised down from an initial estimate of 0.6% – the data underscores the woeful state of South Africa's economy, which simply cannot seem to expand at a rate that exceeds population growth and creates jobs. Against this backdrop, it's no surprise that South Africa's unemployment rate rose one percentage point in Q1 to 32.9%. Worryingly, only four of the 10 industries on the production side of the economy posted growth, led by agriculture, a sector that is also extremely volatile. Agriculture biggest growth driver South Africa's descent into deindustrialisation was writ large in the data, with the manufacturing and mining sectors the biggest drags on the read, declining 2.0% and 4.1% respectively. Consumer spending perked up – helped by lower interest rates, slowing inflation and early pension drawdowns under the two-pot reforms – but it hardly shot the lights out. 'Consumer activity was stronger, with trade, catering & accommodation expanding by 0.5%. Retail trade, motor trade, accommodation and food & beverages contributed positively,' Stats SA said. Changes in GDP contributions Gross fixed capital expenditure – a key measure of investment – maintained its downward trajectory, falling 1.7%. And without investment growth, the economy will remain stuck in a rut. 'Consumer demand likely received a small boost from lower rates, higher disposable incomes given still-low inflation and pension reform. But none of this is sufficient to offset the soft outlook still painted by dismal investment. From this data alone, there is no clear indication that it might be reasonable to expect more robust growth going forward,' said Razia Khan, Chief Economist Africa at Standard Chartered Bank in London. Indeed, the outlook for Q2 is already troubling. What this means South Africa cannot attract investment, create jobs and reduce poverty without significantly faster rates of economic growth. Many of the country's crippling social ills, including rampant crime, are at least partly a reflection of this woeful pace of growth. This deprives the government of revenue, forcing it to borrow more, raising its debt-servicing costs – leaving it with less to spend on things such as education, welfare and health – in a vicious cycle that shows no sign of ending soon. The Absa Purchasing Managers' Index (PMI) fell 1.6 points in May to 43.1 – pointedly, its lowest level since the Covid-19 pandemic. This marked the seventh consecutive month that the PMI was in contractionary territory below the neutral 50 mark and bodes ill for the sector's performance this quarter. The return of the rolling power cuts, popularly known as 'load shedding', after a 310-day pause in Q1 did not help matters, but the economy has been trapped in slow-growth mode for years. There are a range of reasons for this depressing state of affairs, which continues to fuel the terrible trifecta of poverty, unemployment and inequality. Policy uncertainty continues to deter investment, along with mounting concerns about reliable water supplies and a crumbling road, rail and port network. Transnet is showing promising signs of a management turnaround, but it still has a mountain to climb. A high tax burden with little to show for it hardly inspires confidence. Sky-high levels of violent crime and the security costs that go with that are constraints to growth, while South Africa's failing public schools add up to a chronic skills shortage. And amid these domestic challenges and many more, the outlook for the global economy has been souring, not least because of US President Donald Trump's bewildering tariff 'policies' that top the ANC and the GNU in the League of Uncertainty. One thing that is as certain as the changing seasons is that as the year progresses, forecasts for South African economic growth in 2025 – which are mostly around 1.2% – will be further downgraded, which in turn will blow out of the water many of the revenue and debt projections in Budget 3.0.
Daily Maverick
an hour ago
- Daily Maverick
Jaden Hendrikse's cheeky wink reminds us that rugby needs characters, not robots
Rugby's struggle for global superstars is evident, as seen in the contrasting reactions to Jaden Hendrikse's sly wink and Northampton's Henry Pollock's flamboyant celebrations. Rugby needs larger-than-life personalities to grow the game. 'Winkgate' stole the headlines after Saturday's United Rugby Championship (URC) quarterfinal clash between the Sharks and Munster, which the South African side won 6-4 by place-kicking shootout after the sides were tied 24-24 after 100 minutes of rugby. It didn't take too much to divert the attention from a match that, outside of the first place-kicking shootout in URC history, offered very little in terms of extended quality entertainment while the referee's clock was running in regular time and the 20 minutes of extra time. But a cheeky wink by one of the kickers in the place-kicking shootout, Jaden Hendrikse, aimed at Munster flyhalf Jack Crowley spurred a few days of social media outbursts from rugby fans globally, calling the act 'unsportmanlike' and 'against the values of the game', along with plenty more unsavoury comments directed towards the Sharks scrumhalf. It even drew a reaction from Springbok coach Rassie Erasmus on X. The social media fallout was largely excessive for an event so frivolous, but it was not uncharacteristic for rugby as a sport, whose loudest voices can evidently be self-righteous of the behaviour of its athletes. Rugby has so few global superstars – unlike soccer, tennis or even basketball – and it does itself no favours by attempting to suppress the personalities of its players on the field. Superstars Northampton Saints backrow Henry Pollock also attracted headlines in recent weeks for his eccentric try celebrations throughout his side's sublime run to the final of the Champions Cup. His celebration – by holding two fingers to his neck, as if to check his pulse – in the Champions Cup semifinal against Leinster drew the most attention. Especially from opponents. Several players from the tournament winning team, the Bordeaux-Bègles, including French flyhalf Matthieu Jalibert and Bègles head coach Yannick Bru, posed for pictures in the same fashion after the final – mocking Pollock's celebration after defeating his side. Pollock doesn't fit into the traditional mould of English rugby players. He is full of flair and exudes confidence, which some may argue as arrogance, on and off the field. But he's a personality that rugby so desperately needs and shouldn't try to suppress, akin to the attempts to stifle Hendrikse. Although, as someone seemingly carrying the torch for rugby players who are a little bit different, being on the receiving end of banter from opponents is to be expected. However, to be slammed by critics for antics – completely within the laws of the game – does nothing to grow the game. Instead, it marginalises players who are a bit different, when it could be used to leverage new fans to the game. Rugby has very few superstars — which are needed to draw new eyes to the sport. French star Antoine Dupont is one of them. US women's Sevens star Ilona Maher is another, for different reasons. Dupont, one of the best players in the world and already a French icon, starred at the Olympic Games for the French Sevens team last year in their gold-medal run. He ensured the limelight was shone even brighter on a sport often considered a little brother to the 15s version. While Maher has more followers than 5 million followers on Instagram — more than any other rugby player in the world — she uses the platform to showcase her personality and the behind-the-scenes action of what being a professional rugby player is like. Maher had a short stint with the Bristol Bears in the United Kingdom at the start of the year and her debut match set a new attendance record for the Bears. Stars bring fans to stadiums and new eyes to the game that desperately needs it. Growing the game Rugby has a massive following in South Africa, with the national team currently enjoying its most successful period in history aiding that. But across the globe, the sport is largely niche with other sports such as soccer and cricket dwarfing rugby in every metric. World Rugby launched several attempts to grow the game and amends its laws almost annually in an attempt to make the game more entertaining to increase its supporter base. But evidently what generates fans, especially new ones, are heroes and interesting characters — such as Dupont, Maher and Pollock. Hendrikse has neither displayed the same larger-than-life personality as the latter two in his five-year professional rugby career to date nor is he quite the superstar that Dupont is, but on Saturday he was cheeky. Although his impudence generally does not extend any further than that of any other scrumhalf. Munster scrumhalf Conor Murray, for example, shook Bradley Davids's hand to 'wish him well' before he took the kick to win the match for the Sharks — not too dissimilar from the gamesmanship that takes place in soccer before a penalty is taken. It's the way sport works. Teams find the tiniest opportunity to find a mental edge, especially in a match where the margins between victory and defeat were evidently so small. These actions should be embraced, it adds an additional layer to the game and simultaneously deepens rivalries — both elements that are positive to growing the game. Although, as with shifting away from the customs of any activity in society, the forebearers often bear the brunt of criticism while paving the way for the next generation. DM
