Ruchir Joshi's Great Eastern Hotel is a Calcutta novel of too muchness but a good experiment
I was fascinated by the huge labyrinthine hotel that had witnessed so many events in Calcutta's history. I was doubly fascinated by its place in Second-World-War Calcutta, where it hosted first a varied cosmopolitan crowd and then became home to high-ranking American officers. However, the book is called Great Eastern Hotel and not The Great Eastern..., this is because as you read you realise that it is the city of Calcutta that becomes the really great eastern 'hotel' during the War, with all sorts of guests, willing or choice-less and desperate, who 'check into' the city for varying durations.
You waited more than 20 years to write your second and your second Calcutta novel.
The book took the time it did due to a variety of reasons, yes.
Great Eastern Hotel sometimes seems to talk too much. This is Nirupama talking about another character,Gopal – 'antisocial, some fringe lumpen, petty criminal type, some sort of assistant pimp, you know, a dalal…' when perhaps just one or two descriptors could have done. And yet in some nearby sentence, you let unoon off without an explanation. Is this by design?
If you think the novel 'talks too much' that's your opinion and you have every right to it. As for the example you've given, when people talk (as opposed to novels talking) they often don't speak in pithily economical sentences. Unoon has been explained as a clay oven earlier.
At one point in the novel, Rabindra Sangeet has been compared to the sound of a cat dying. Bengali novels do not make such observations. And yet you also have an important scene in the backdrop of Tagore's funeral like Mrinal Sen did in his film Baishe Shraban. How does one square with the two – the irreverence and the reverence in the same book?
Lots of Bangla novels are very irreverent about things, including things held in high regard by mainstream Bengali culture. It's possible to be irreverent about someone or something and still love them or it. In this case it's one of my characters who is making that comparison, and yet, yes, he also loves Tagore.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Mint
24 minutes ago
- Mint
‘War 2' review: Laboured sequel fails to capture the silly joy of first film
Metaphors in Hindi films come with brass bands and neon signs. War 2 opens, as Pushpa 2 (2024) and Thug Life (2025) did, with dreams of Japan. A yakuza family is sitting down to dinner when a raggedy wolf walks in, followed by a panicked emissary with news of an approaching army. The army, it turns out, is ol' green eyes, erstwhile RAW agent turned freelance assassin Kabir (Hrithik Roshan). He looks wilder than he did in War (2019), dispatching waves of armed killers with a grim smile until it's just him and the hound left. It's almost like he's become… a lone wolf. After the Japan job, Kabir is hired by Kali, a shadowy crime cartel with a representative each from Russia, China, India, Pakistan, Bangladesh, Myanmar and Sri Lanka. They're bent on some kind of world domination, though all their plans invariably centre on India. Kabir is key, the superspy patriot who now kills his own people, for a price. But writers Sridhar Raghavan and Abbas Tyrewala know that even if Kali believes Kabir has turned, the audience knows better. And so, soon after, it's made clear that Kabir going rogue is part of a mission to destroy the cartel from within. The problem is, only Kabir and former RAW chief Luthra (Ashutosh Rana) know of the plan. The new boss, Kaul (Anil Kapoor), immediately sends a guided missile his way in the shape of special ops soldier Vikram (also headed in his direction, with more mixed feelings, is Luthra's daughter, Kavya, played by Kiara Advani). Vikram (NTR Jr.) is introduced singlehandedly demolishing a ship-full of pirates who've taken a group of Indians hostage. It's a splashy, ludicrous set piece, in keeping with the YRF house style. And yet there's something lacking, that dancer's agility and tongue-in-cheek creativity that made the first War such a delight. NTR Jr. for Tiger Shroff isn't a like-for-like replacement. Their acting evens out: Shroff with a lighter touch, NTR Jr. a marginally stronger dramatic presence. But where the Telugu star is a similar screen fighter to Roshan, Shroff's martial arts skills offered a useful point of contrast in War. Shroff also elevated his co-star: seeing Kabir through Khalid's worshipful eyes made Roshan seem all the more godlike. There's a different dynamic in War 2, that of blood brothers who've fallen out—a very common framing in modern Indian action cinema, and less interesting as a result. The other big replacement is Ayan Mukerji for Sidharth Anand, director of YRF actioners War and Pathaan (2023). Last year's Fighter showed that Anand needs the wit of Tyrewala and Raghavan to avoid coming off like another hawkish government shill Bollywood director. But perhaps YRF needs Anand too. He understands these films in a way Mukerji can't. The edifice remains the same, what's missing is the knack of bearing down on the right moment. There are few scenes in modern Hindi film as giddily effective as the camera panning to John Abraham smirking in the pool in Pathaan. War 2 offers similar opportunities, none of which are sold with the same verve. Mukerji has practically the same team that did War: Tyrewala-Raghavan writing, Aditya Chopra producing, cinematographer Benjamin Jasper, editor Aarif Sheikh, score by Sanchit and Ankit Balhara. But he can't make their work sing—even the catchy 'Janaab-e-Aali' number struggles to seem like anything other than a reheat of 'Jai Jai Shiv Shankar'. War 2 has every kind of set piece you'd expect from a Spyverse film, on top of trains and up belltowers and in ice caves, wielding samurai swords and brass knuckles and grenades. Even with a three-hour runtime, you won't lack for quantity, though quality varies (the sequence where they're hanging off a plane but somehow landing precision kicks is too stupid even for YRF). After Brahmastra, it was always going to be a gamble to hire Mukerji for a big action film. Perhaps the studio figured it wouldn't matter, that the expert and very large group of stunt and fight coordinators (including regulars Se-yeong Oh, Sunil Rodrigues and Craig Macrae) would handle things fine. But it's never the same: there are filmmakers who direct action persuasively and those who can't, and fans can tell the difference. If Mukerji seems cautious, so does Yash Raj. This is the sixth Spyverse film, and the second with Kabir. We can assume there'll be a Pathaan sequel at some point. But in case the studio decides to pull the plug on Salman Khan's Tiger—and it should—they might find themselves short of leads, even with the female-led Alpha in the works. This might be why War 2 closes very few character arcs and introduces a new central figure in Kaul. It's risk-averse universe management, but it denies the film the sense of completeness that War and Pathaan had. There's an awful end-credits montage that flies in the face of the emotional tenor in the film's second half. You've got to know when to walk away, know when to run…
Hindustan Times
27 minutes ago
- Hindustan Times
Wayne Rooney hits back at Tom Brady's ‘work ethic' comment, questions Birmingham City owner's awareness: ‘Not the NFL'
Former England and Manchester United legend Wayne Rooney has fired back after finding himself at the wrong end of some fiery comments directed his way by American NFL great Tom Brady, who recently took over as owner of Birmingham City FC, the club at which Rooney was acting as coach two seasons ago. Wayne Rooney and Tom Brady have shared a few sharp words following a release of an Amazon Prime docuseries on Birmingham City FC. Speaking on his podcast The Wayne Rooney Show, the English star explained how Brady's questioning of his work ethic and demeanor while in charge of Birmingham stung and felt 'unfair'. "I think it was a very unfair comment. When I went into Birmingham, they were in a mess really,' explained Rooney, who has had a tough history in terms of his managerial career after trying to make the switch from his playing days. 'Hence the fact that, the players weren't really the players who could take the club forward.' 'Don't think he really understood football…' Rooney's tenure at Birmingham in the 23/24 season coincided with Brady's onboarding as part-owner and chairperson, a season which was covered in Amazon Prime docuseries 'Brady & The Blues: Birmingham City'. However, it was an unhappy year for the team, as they were relegated from the EFL Championship and into the third division of English football. In the docuseries, Brady and his business manager Ben Rawitz had commented on Rooney, questioning his work ethic and describing him as 'lackadaisical'. However, for a player considered to be one of the most determined and committed to come through the England systems in its long history, the comments didn't go down well for Rooney. "We knew that and Tom [came in] the day before a game, where the day is a little bit light anyway, and I don't think he really understood football that well at the time, maybe he does now…' explained the 39-year-old. 'Football is not NFL…' Rooney also explained that the disconnect stemmed from how the NFL lifestyle sees players go at 110% throughout the season, which isn't a realistic option in the much longer, more taxing world of football. "But what he does understand is, he's a hard worker, we know that, so that's why I'm really disappointed with the comment. Because football is not NFL - NFL works for 3 months a year, players do need rest as well, so I think he was very unfair the way he's come out and portrayed that,' said Rooney. Rooney would be the first to admit that his coaching experience has been disastrous, first being relegated with Derby County following a massive points deduction, before overseeing much of Birmingham's relegation season, and then joining Plymouth Argyle only to part ways halfway through the season with the Pilgrims in last place. Nevertheless, despite not having cracked it at any level as a manager, Rooney remains one of England's finest players in history, both in terms of talent and his dedication to the sport, explaining why the Birmingham owner's comments chafed in such a manner.
Time of India
36 minutes ago
- Time of India
‘He didn't understand football': Wayne Rooney hits back after Tom Brady questions his work ethic
Wayne Rooney and Tom Brady (Images via Getty Images) When Tom Brady bought into Birmingham City, no one expected the NFL legend to become the star of a football (yes, soccer ) feud. But here we are. In Amazon Prime's new docuseries Built in Birmingham: Brady & the Blues , the seven-time Super Bowl champ doesn't just sip the tea, he pours the whole pot on Wayne Rooney 's short-lived managerial stint. His main gripe? Rooney's work ethic. And Rooney? Let's just say he fired back with a perfectly curved shot, claiming Brady 'didn't really understand football. ' Now, fans are throwing jerseys and tweets in the air, picking sides like it's a derby day. Tom Brady's blunt critique of Wayne Rooney's time at Birmingham City Tom Brady became a minority owner of Birmingham City in August 2023, right before the club brought in Manchester United legend Wayne Rooney as manager in October. Hopes were high, but the honeymoon barely lasted, Rooney's 83-day run saw just two wins in 15 games, and the club was eventually relegated. In the docuseries, Brady didn't hold back: 'I'm a little worried about our head coach's work ethic. I mean, I don't know, I don't have great instincts on that.' Tom Brady blasts Wayne Rooney 😳 He also called the squad from Rooney's tenure 'lazy and entitled,' and admitted that replacing the coach wasn't enough to stop the slide. For Brady, leadership energy and day-to-day drive are non-negotiables, and he clearly felt something was missing. Wayne Rooney claps back with a football reality check Wayne Rooney wasn't about to let that go unanswered. Speaking to BBC in an interview, Rooney said: 'Tom came in once, which was the day before a game, which is a little bit lighter anyway, and I don't think he really understood football that well at the time. Maybe he does now, Rooney called Brady's comments 'very unfair,' pointing out that Brady reportedly visited the training ground only once and on a light day. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Your Finger Shape Says a Lot About Your Personality, Read Now Tips and Tricks Undo He also stressed the major difference between NFL's 17-game season and the year-round grind of football, hinting that Brady might not fully appreciate the demands of the sport on players and staff. Fans are already picking their fighter Social media is doing what social media does, turning this into a full-on sporting civil war. NFL fans are nodding along with Brady, praising his 'championship mindset.' UK football fans, on the other hand, are rallying behind Rooney, insisting the American legend doesn't get 'proper football.' Memes, sarcastic tweets, and even mock match posters are making the rounds. Whether you're wearing a Brady jersey or a Rooney scarf, one thing's clear, Birmingham City just landed in the global spotlight for all the wrong (or right, depending on how much you love drama) reasons. And with the docuseries still fresh, the debate isn't slowing down. Football, meet American football, now fight. Also read - 'I've never seen her talk to men': Fans react to Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce's uncomfortable podcast vibes Catch Rani Rampal's inspiring story on Game On, Episode 4. Watch Here!
