'It's not that complicated': LMPD chief responds after woman dragged from car
"So, the question was about the video circulating on social media with the woman that alleged she was pulled from a car," Humphrey said during his bi-weekly press conference on May 15. "It's not an allegation. We pulled her out of the car. And we are aware of it."
That woman is Kearie Watts. After spending Mother's Day at her grandmother's house in the Parklands neighborhood, Watts told The Courier Journal she began to drive home. Phone metadata from a video shot by her passenger shows that Watts was driving on 36th Street between Grand and Hale a little after 3 a.m. on May 12.
At the same time, officers were called to the area following a ShotSpotter notification and multiple calls reporting a person shot.
Watts told The Courier Journal she saw a "bunch of police cars parked with their lights on." She said there was no yellow crime scene tape. She was trying to get to the highway to head back to St. Matthews.
"When the police officer, he approached me, he didn't ask me to leave, he told me to get off his crime scene, and I was interfering," Watts told The Courier Journal. "I didn't know. As we're exchanging words, there are still police pulling up, so at this point, I can't even back out. As we're talking, another police officer was now putting yellow tape out.
"I never would have pulled onto the street because it's common sense that you don't do that if there was yellow crime scene tape."
Watts said the officer also told her to go through an alley instead, but she said she didn't want to drive down a dark alley so late at night.
Veah Kinslow, Watts' passenger, began to take video of the exchange between the officer and Watts. She said the phone metadata, which she provided to The Courier Journal, says she began recording at 3:16 a.m. at 1120 S. 36th Street, which is the same location as the nightclub shooting where police responded "a little past 3 a.m.," per a statement released by the department.
The video begins with Watts in the driver's seat with both hands in her lap, her left hand holding her phone. The driver's side door is open. An unidentified officer reaches his left hand into the car and grabs Watts by her white crop-top shirt and pulls her to the pavement outside her vehicle. His right hand grabs her bicep as he pulls her. Her phone hits the ground, too.
Kinslow begins to scream.
"The car is still in drive," she says.
The officer placed Watts in handcuffs, but she was not arrested or given a court date.
"A standard use of force report investigation will be done, and we'll make sure that everything was done the right way," Humphrey said.
The post to her Facebook page about the incident has been shared more than 950 times.
Watts provided the name of the officer, but The Courier Journal has not been able to confirm it with LMPD.
"What I will say is that when the police tell you to leave, I'd advise you to leave. So you won't get pulled out of your car," Humphrey said. "Now, if that officer did anything wrong in the meantime, we'll take care of that. You can trust we'll take care of that. But when we're dealing with a shooting, the last thing we need is somebody who can't follow simple directions. Like, leave. It's not that complicated."
Stephanie Kuzydym is an enterprise and investigative sports reporter. She can be reached at skuzydym@courier-journal.com. Follow her at @stephkuzy.
This article originally appeared on Louisville Courier Journal: LMPD chief Paul Humphrey talks about woman dragged from car
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Post
3 hours ago
- New York Post
Moment $167.3M Powerball winner is tackled, tased after attacking Florida deputy
Newly released video captured the moment the winner of a $167.3 million Powerball jackpot got tackled and tased by Florida police after kicking a deputy in the head. Bodycam footage from the April 29 brawl caught James Farthing, 50, booting a Pinellas County Sheriff's deputy in the head when police arrived at the TradeWinds Resort, in St. Pete Beach, after he allegedly punched a hotel guest in the face, WFLA reported. The deputy was holding another person to the ground when Farthing ran up and kicked him, with resort security rushing in to pin the suspect against the wall and help the deputy. 4 James Farthing, 50, was arrested on April 29 after he kicked a Pinellas County Sheriff's deputy in the head. Pinellas County Sheriffs Office 4 Officers tased and tackled Farthing after he tried to make a run for it inside the TradeWinds Resort, in St. Pete Beach, Florida. Pinellas County Sheriffs Office 'I just got kicked,' the dumbfounded deputy could be heard radioing as the security guards yelled at Farthing to stand down. The officer quickly picked up his taser from the ground and confronted Farthing, ordering him to put his hands up. 'Put your hands behind your back right f—king now. Put your hands behind your back and get the f—king wall,' the deputy repeated, shoving Farthing to the wall. The suspect quickly slipped behind a column and tried to run away, with the deputy firing his taser as another officer tackled Farthing to the ground. 4 Farthing was revealed to be a career criminal with a long rap sheet before winning the lottery. PCSO 'I'm sorry man, please,' Farthing could be heard saying as the officers handcuffed him. 'Save your f—king sorries for later,' the deputy fired back. The law enforcement officer had 'swelling and redness' on the right side of his face under his eye, according to the affidavit first reported on by the Smoking Gun. 4 Days before his arrest, Farthing celebrated winning Kentucky's largest lottery jackpot. Kentucky Lottery Farthing hit Kentucky's largest lottery jackpot just day before the encounter, opting to split the winnings with his mother as an early Mother's Day gift. Following his arrest at the TradeWinds Resort, it was revealed that Farthing was a career criminal who had has racked up convictions across nine counties in Kentucky for a litany of offenses — including choking a girlfriend, bribing officers while in prison and selling cocaine to an undercover cop, according to the Smoking Gun. Along with Farthing, police also arrested his girlfriend, Jacqueline Fightmaster, 42, for alleged involvement in the brawl. Farthing was charged with resisting an officer without violence, battery on a law enforcement officer, battery, and parole violation.
New York Post
2 days ago
- New York Post
Kin of tragic tot tossed into East River suing NYPD for $60M, claim cops told mom, ‘So what?'
The grieving mother of a 2-year-old boy tossed to his death in the East River is suing the city and the NYPD for $60 million, accusing them of failing to try to save him when told he'd been taken by his dad. Cierra Carroll, 17, claims in a new complaint that police misclassified her call when she reported little Montrell Williams missing in May — with someone even hanging up the phone after asking, 'So what?' 'Montrell Williams should be here today if it wasn't for the NYPD being neglectful in finding him,' family spokesman Rev. Kevin McCall said at a press conference outside the NYPD 40th Precinct stationhouse on Friday, according to the Daily News. 4 Montrell Williams, 2, was killed when he was tossed off a Bronx overpass on May 11, allegedly by his father. 'No amount of money will bring him back,' McCall said. 'However, the NYPD has to be held responsible.' Carroll said she called police on May 11 after Montrell's father, 20-year-old Arius Williams, failed to return him — but cops blew her off when she called 911, she claims. 'They told me not to follow him and to go to the police to file a complaint,' Carroll told the Daily Mail. 'I told the police that he had a warrant, they said, 'So what?'' That official then 'hung up the phone,' according to Carroll's own mom, Octavia Roane. McCall first accused the NYPD of negligence in the case in June alongside Roane, Montrell's grandmother, claiming police misclassified the 911 call as a simple custody dispute. 4 Octavia Roane, the grandmother of tragic tot Montrell Williams, at a press conference in June abou tthe boy's death. James Messerschmidt 4 Arius Williams, 20, is charged with murder for allegedly throwing his 2-year-old son into the East River on May 11. Kevin C Downs forThe New York Post Arius Williams is now charged with killing his tiny son one day earlier by allegedly tossing him off a Bronx overpass and into the East River during a custodial visit with the toddler. Carroll waited for her boy to be returned outside a McDonald's on Mother's Day. The tragic tot's body was later recovered from the waters off Ferry Point Park in Queens. Although police weren't notified that Montrell was missing until a day after he was killed, the family said it took until May 28 for a warrant to be issued ordering the dad to produce the boy. The brute even taunted Carroll when she questioned him about their son. 4 Montrell Williams, 2, was supposed to go to McDonald's wit his mom on Mother's Day. DCPI 'Shut the f–k up,' he allegedly snapped at her. 'I threw that n—a into the river!' Now, Montrell's family said the NYPD bears some blame. 'NYPD officers misclassified the call as a custody dispute, failed to initiate a missing child investigation, failed to issue an Amber Alert, and took no immediate steps to locate or safeguard Montrell,' the lawsuit said, according to the Daily News.
San Francisco Chronicle
6 days ago
- San Francisco Chronicle
A Piedmont wealth manager left his wife and a dying man at scene of hit-and-run. Now he wants his license back
A Piedmont wealth manager convicted of a deadly hit-and-run is fighting to get his driver's license reinstated. Attorneys for Timothy Hamano say the 68-year-old man has already served a mandatory three-year period without his driving privileges, and should be allowed to resume a normal life. But their request drew fervent resistance from family members of Gregory Turnage, the man Hamano struck and killed on Mother's Day in 2021. It's the latest chapter in an unusually complicated case that's produced two starkly different narratives. Hamano's lawyers say their client's life was upended by a tragic accident that he regrets every day. Turnage's bereaved relatives, by contrast, see Hamano as an avatar of wealth and power, maneuvering through a justice system where money buys better outcomes. Losing his ability to drive was the only 'real punishment' Hamano ever received, wrote Turnage's partner, Angie Brey, in a searing July letter to the Alameda County court. 'If you take a life with your car, I don't think you should get your license back,' Brey told the Chronicle. 'That's where I stand.' The crash occurred on May 9, 2021, when police said Hamano plowed his white Lexus into a parked SUV on leafy Park Boulevard in Oakland. He struck Turnage, who was walking on the sidewalk, with a force strong enough to throw the 41-year-old man over the hood of the Lexus and then back onto the pavement. As Turnage lay bleeding, witnesses said, Hamano opened his door and walked around the crumpled front bumper, looking down at the gravely injured man. He then fled on foot, leaving Turnage behind, as well as his wife, who sat in the front passenger seat of the Lexus behind a deployed airbag. Hamano turned himself in the next day after Oakland police issued a warrant for his arrest. Although restaurant receipts obtained by police indicate that he had been drinking prior to the crash, prosecutors lacked sufficient evidence to charge him with driving while intoxicated. Last year Hamano pled no contest to felony vehicular manslaughter and fleeing the scene of an accident, receiving a sentence of six years' home detention with an ankle monitor. Under California law, defendants typically serve half the time to which they are sentenced, so Hamano spent three years confined to his house in Piedmont. The conditions of his $125,000 bail barred him from driving or drinking alcohol, but owing to a clerical error, court staff failed to report his conviction to the Department of Motor Vehicles. The error was first reported by Cal Matters. Out of the hundreds of mandatory DMV notifications that Alameda County court has sent since 2019, Hamano's was one of two that slipped, according to court spokesperson Paul Rosynsky. When court officials learned of the mistake, Rosynsky said, they 'immediately rectified the situation,' creating a new quandary. By then Hamano had successfully re-applied for his license, only to have the DMV revoke it on May 28. His attorney, Colin Cooper, subsequently filed a motion for the court to 'set aside' the DMV's order. In a recent interview, Cooper emphasized that this penalty seemed to come out of nowhere: The case has long been resolved, he noted, and months have passed since Hamano settled a wrongful death lawsuit filed on behalf of Turnage and Brey's son, Miles. 'If someone commits this crime (of vehicular manslaughter) and admits to it, then part of the punishment, by statute, is that you can't drive for three years,' Cooper said. 'I think that's appropriate. And I think that occurred here. We abided by the tenor of the law.' But Brey maintains that Hamano poses a threat to public safety, and contends that he shouldn't be allowed behind the wheel. In her letter to the court, she cited a subsequent collision in Oakland that Hamano reported to his insurance carrier in May. Cooper said his client was hit by another car and the other driver was at fault.
