Extradition hearing starts for Indonesian businessman in S'pore said to have bribed officials
Extradition hearing starts for Indonesian businessman in S'pore said to have bribed officials
Source: Straits Times
Article Date: 24 Jun 2025
Author: Christine Tan
It is Singapore's first such proceeding under treaty with Indonesia that took effect in 2024.
A court hearing is taking place here that will determine whether an Indonesian businessman in a high-profile corruption case will be extradited to his home country.
The hearing on June 23 regarding Paulus Tannos, also known as Tjhin Thian Po, is Singapore's first such proceeding under its extradition treaty with Indonesia.
Tannos, 70, has been implicated in a major graft scandal involving the Indonesian government's issuing of electronic ID cards – the e-KTP project – allegedly causing state losses of about 2.3 trillion rupiah (S$187 million).
The Indonesian fugitive, who is believed to have been living in Singapore since 2017, faces one charge of corruption under Indonesian law that is punishable with a maximum sentence of life imprisonment.
The crux of the hearing is to determine whether there is enough evidence to support the corruption charge Tannos is facing, so he can be sent back to Indonesia.
In extradition hearings, the state does not have to prove the fugitive's guilt or secure a conviction. It only has to show that there is enough evidence for the fugitive to face trial if his acts had taken place in Singapore.
Delivering the state's opening statement, Deputy Solicitor-General (DSG) Vincent Leow said the state would rely on evidence submitted by the Indonesian authorities.
Tannos was the president and director of technology company PT Sandipala Arthaputra, which was a member of the PNRI Consortium – a grouping of companies that won the e-KTP tender in 2011.
DSG Leow said that under the alleged corruption scheme, the consortium paid 'commitment fees' to officials of the Ministry of Home Affairs of Indonesia (Moha), which was responsible for the e-KTP tender.
Bribes were also allegedly given to members of the House of Representatives of Indonesia, or DPR-RI, who appropriated and allocated the government's budget for the project.
The gratification amounted to 10 per cent of the total project value, split equally among Moha officials and DPR-RI members.
According to the Indonesian authorities, Tannos eventually paid US$530,000 to a Moha officer and approximately US$3.8 million to former Indonesian politician Setya Novanto through the latter's associate.
'The Indonesian authorities' position is that the payment of these 'commitment fees' resulted in the manipulation of the decision-making process regarding the e-KTP project and tender, and that the PNRI Consortium won the tender through unlawful methods,' said DSG Leow.
Chief Special Investigator Alvin Tang of the Corrupt Practices Investigation Bureau (CPIB) – the state's only witness – took the stand to give evidence on how he arrested Tannos and brought him to the State Courts.
Tannos sat in the criminal dock throughout the six-hour hearing. He had been denied bail, was wearing white prison garb, and was handcuffed.
During the hearing, his lawyer Bachoo Mohan Singh argued that there were about 100 pages in the formal extradition request that were added after the stipulated deadline, and should hence be thrown out. Mr Singh said the additional documents, which were supplementary affidavits from the Indonesian authorities, 'appear to be manufactured'.
He questioned why the additional documents were purportedly received by the Singapore authorities in April, but were given to the defence team only almost two months later.
Tannos' other defence lawyer, Mr Suang Wijaya, also objected to the admission of documents prepared by the Indonesian authorities, saying they were not 'duly authenticated'.
For example, the English translation of Tannos' arrest warrant did not have a stamp with official authorisation, said Mr Wijaya.
He added that numerous witness statements in Indonesia were unsigned, and were not sworn by the witness or the interrogator on the day that they were taken. These show the documents breached the conditions of the extradition treaty, and hence are inadmissible in court, argued Mr Wijaya.
The lawyer said that due to such 'multiple and significant irregularities', and the prejudice caused to Tannos by the delayed filing of additional documents, the extradition request should not be allowed.
DSG Leow said his team – comprising State Counsels Sivakumar Ramasamy, Sarah Siaw and Emily Zhao – would be making submissions in response to the defence's arguments.
The hearing continues till June 25.
Tannos has reportedly been on Indonesia's fugitive list since Oct 19, 2021. He was arrested on Jan 17 by CPIB, and Indonesia put in a formal extradition request on Feb 24.
The extradition treaty between Singapore and Indonesia took effect on March 21, 2024.
It grants extradition for a list of offences, including corruption, money laundering and bribery, and can be retrospectively applied to crimes committed up to 18 years ago.
Christine Tan is a journalist at The Straits Times reporting on crime, justice and social issues in Singapore.
Source: The Straits Times © SPH Media Limited. Permission required for reproduction.
Print
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Times
7 hours ago
- Business Times
Indonesia's sovereign wealth fund Danantara loans US$405 million to flag carrier Garuda
[JAKARTA] Indonesian sovereign wealth fund Danantara will extend a US$405 million loan to Garuda Indonesia to help the distressed flag carrier turn around finances and expand its fleet in the coming years. Garuda chief executive officer Wamildan Tsani Panjaitan said in a briefing on Tuesday (Jun 24) that the shareholder loan would be the first step in a 'comprehensive transformation' of the airline that will include long-term financing based on performance. The move confirms an earlier Bloomberg News report of funding plans. He added that the airline group plans to grow its fleet to 120 aircraft over the next five years. Garuda and its low-cost unit Citilink operated 98 aircraft as at March, down from 103 a year earlier. Garuda will receive about US$111 million of the funding, with the remainder going to Citilink for maintenance of about 15 grounded jets, said Prasetio, the carrier's director of finance and risk management. Danantara chief operating officer Dony Oskaria, speaking at the same briefing, added that global expertise would be brought in to aid Garuda's business plans. State-controlled Garuda booked a net loss in 2024 after two years of profit following a post-pandemic travel boom. In November, the airline appointed Panjaitan as its new leader tasked with fixing its finances and expanding its global network. The Indonesian government transfered its 65 per cent stake in the airline to Danantara earlier this year as part of President Prabowo Subianto's overhaul of the management of state-owned enterprises. BLOOMBERG
Business Times
8 hours ago
- Business Times
MMC Ports to file for biggest Malaysian IPO since 2012: sources
[KUALA LUMPUR] MMC Port Holdings is pressing ahead with its planned listing in Malaysia, according to people familiar with the matter, in what could be the biggest initial public offering in Kuala Lumpur in more than a decade. The port operator, owned by Malaysian tycoon Syed Mokhtar Al-Bukhary, has confidentially filed listing documents with regulators and is awaiting approval to post a draft prospectus, the people said, asking not to be identified because the process is private. MMC Ports could seek to raise about US$2 billion in a share sale as soon as September, the people said. The planned listing could value the company at as much as US$7 billion, some of the people said. Considerations are ongoing and details including size and timing may change, the people said, adding that MMC Ports could also decide against an IPO. Representatives for MMC Ports and parent MMC did not immediately respond to requests seeking comment. Bloomberg News reported in October that MMC Ports was working with financial advisers on an IPO plan. The company runs seven ports along the Straits of Malacca, one of the world's busiest shipping lanes, and is the biggest such operator in Malaysia, according to its website. It also operates three cruise terminals. The potential IPO could be the biggest since plantation group FGV Holdings raised more than RM10 billion (S$3 billion) in 2012, according to data compiled by Bloomberg. BLOOMBERG
Singapore Law Watch
8 hours ago
- Singapore Law Watch
Extradition hearing starts for Indonesian businessman in S'pore said to have bribed officials
Extradition hearing starts for Indonesian businessman in S'pore said to have bribed officials Source: Straits Times Article Date: 24 Jun 2025 Author: Christine Tan It is Singapore's first such proceeding under treaty with Indonesia that took effect in 2024. A court hearing is taking place here that will determine whether an Indonesian businessman in a high-profile corruption case will be extradited to his home country. The hearing on June 23 regarding Paulus Tannos, also known as Tjhin Thian Po, is Singapore's first such proceeding under its extradition treaty with Indonesia. Tannos, 70, has been implicated in a major graft scandal involving the Indonesian government's issuing of electronic ID cards – the e-KTP project – allegedly causing state losses of about 2.3 trillion rupiah (S$187 million). The Indonesian fugitive, who is believed to have been living in Singapore since 2017, faces one charge of corruption under Indonesian law that is punishable with a maximum sentence of life imprisonment. The crux of the hearing is to determine whether there is enough evidence to support the corruption charge Tannos is facing, so he can be sent back to Indonesia. In extradition hearings, the state does not have to prove the fugitive's guilt or secure a conviction. It only has to show that there is enough evidence for the fugitive to face trial if his acts had taken place in Singapore. Delivering the state's opening statement, Deputy Solicitor-General (DSG) Vincent Leow said the state would rely on evidence submitted by the Indonesian authorities. Tannos was the president and director of technology company PT Sandipala Arthaputra, which was a member of the PNRI Consortium – a grouping of companies that won the e-KTP tender in 2011. DSG Leow said that under the alleged corruption scheme, the consortium paid 'commitment fees' to officials of the Ministry of Home Affairs of Indonesia (Moha), which was responsible for the e-KTP tender. Bribes were also allegedly given to members of the House of Representatives of Indonesia, or DPR-RI, who appropriated and allocated the government's budget for the project. The gratification amounted to 10 per cent of the total project value, split equally among Moha officials and DPR-RI members. According to the Indonesian authorities, Tannos eventually paid US$530,000 to a Moha officer and approximately US$3.8 million to former Indonesian politician Setya Novanto through the latter's associate. 'The Indonesian authorities' position is that the payment of these 'commitment fees' resulted in the manipulation of the decision-making process regarding the e-KTP project and tender, and that the PNRI Consortium won the tender through unlawful methods,' said DSG Leow. Chief Special Investigator Alvin Tang of the Corrupt Practices Investigation Bureau (CPIB) – the state's only witness – took the stand to give evidence on how he arrested Tannos and brought him to the State Courts. Tannos sat in the criminal dock throughout the six-hour hearing. He had been denied bail, was wearing white prison garb, and was handcuffed. During the hearing, his lawyer Bachoo Mohan Singh argued that there were about 100 pages in the formal extradition request that were added after the stipulated deadline, and should hence be thrown out. Mr Singh said the additional documents, which were supplementary affidavits from the Indonesian authorities, 'appear to be manufactured'. He questioned why the additional documents were purportedly received by the Singapore authorities in April, but were given to the defence team only almost two months later. Tannos' other defence lawyer, Mr Suang Wijaya, also objected to the admission of documents prepared by the Indonesian authorities, saying they were not 'duly authenticated'. For example, the English translation of Tannos' arrest warrant did not have a stamp with official authorisation, said Mr Wijaya. He added that numerous witness statements in Indonesia were unsigned, and were not sworn by the witness or the interrogator on the day that they were taken. These show the documents breached the conditions of the extradition treaty, and hence are inadmissible in court, argued Mr Wijaya. The lawyer said that due to such 'multiple and significant irregularities', and the prejudice caused to Tannos by the delayed filing of additional documents, the extradition request should not be allowed. DSG Leow said his team – comprising State Counsels Sivakumar Ramasamy, Sarah Siaw and Emily Zhao – would be making submissions in response to the defence's arguments. The hearing continues till June 25. Tannos has reportedly been on Indonesia's fugitive list since Oct 19, 2021. He was arrested on Jan 17 by CPIB, and Indonesia put in a formal extradition request on Feb 24. The extradition treaty between Singapore and Indonesia took effect on March 21, 2024. It grants extradition for a list of offences, including corruption, money laundering and bribery, and can be retrospectively applied to crimes committed up to 18 years ago. Christine Tan is a journalist at The Straits Times reporting on crime, justice and social issues in Singapore. Source: The Straits Times © SPH Media Limited. Permission required for reproduction. Print
