Could Giants Host Kicking Competition in 2025?
Could Giants Host Kicking Competition in 2025? originally appeared on Athlon Sports.
For a team that finished with the NFC's worst record in 2024, there aren't a ton of training camp battles for fans to monitor this summer. Rookie defensive tackle Darius Alexander will look to start from the jump, and there might be some noise at interior offensive line, but the New York Giants' lineup can comfortably be penciled in months before Week 1.
Advertisement
Perhaps New York will see a competition emerge on special teams. Veteran Graham Gano dealt with injuries in an unsteady 2024 campaign, and as he enters his age-38 season, his job security appears to be less stable than in years past.
In the other corner is second-year kicker Jude McAtamney, an Irish-born, Rutgers-bred Giant who spent much of the season on the practice squad. New York is hoping to develop him into Gano's eventual replacement, and it's possible he accelerates that timeline with a strong summer.
According to Pro Football Rumors, a kicking competition could shake up the Giants' plans on special teams.
'At the moment, it looks like the job is Gano's for the taking in New York, but McAtamney continues to lurk in the background and seems to be doing enough to remain in contention,' Ely Allen wrote. 'If McAtamney can impress this summer, the combination of Gano's cap impact and his recent struggles with injury may open the door a little wider for McAtamney to kick his way through.'
Advertisement
In his one-game cameo, McAtamney hit his field goal and extra point attempt.
The Giants stand to benefit from cutting Gano, too, saving $4.4 million in cap space with a $1.25 million dead cap charge (per Over the Cap).
On June 5, special teams coordinator Michael Ghobrial spoke about the potential for a competition to break out on special teams.
'Absolutely. I think if you're on this roster, no matter what position you play, you're competing,' Michael Ghobrial said, via team transcript. 'You're competing to win the job. I think everybody will have a fair chance winning whatever job it is, whether it be the kicker position or any other position.
Advertisement
'But I would say that Jude has shown a lot of promise even from last year kicking in a game. You obviously see the leg talent, you see the leg strength, all those things that amount to being a good kicker in this league.'
New York has kept McAtamney around for a reason, even if it's just risk-free insurance. Whether it's Week 1, a late-season contest, or sometime in 2026, the Giants are preparing for McAtamney to contribute. It's on Gano to stave him off for as long as possible.
Related: Giants Schedule Release: Game-By-Game Predictions
Related: Giants Schedule Reveals Potential Dart Debuts
This story was originally reported by Athlon Sports on Jun 15, 2025, where it first appeared.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
4 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Terry McLaurin Trade Proposal Would Redefine Offseason
Terry McLaurin Trade Proposal Would Redefine Offseason originally appeared on Athlon Sports. The Washington Commanders have done a good job of appreciating the gift they've been given in quarterback Jayden Daniels. General manager Adam Peters has met the moment by adding tackle Laremy Tunsil and receiver Deebo Samuel, among others, to a team that was a win away from the Super Bowl in 2024. Advertisement However, as receiver Terry McLaurin's contract negotiations continue to stall, some have grown worried about his potential departure. Speculation, subsequently, has run rampant, sending McLaurin to several contenders. One such proposal from Bleacher Report sent McLaurin and a third-round pick to the Los Angeles Chargers for receiver Quentin Johnston, a second-round pick, and a fourth-round pick in the 2026 NFL Draft. Simply put, a McLaurin trade would redefine the Commanders' offseason. 'McLaurin would walk into L.A. as Herbert's top perimeter target and would instantly elevate the passing game,' Kristopher Knox wrote. 'For a team looking to leapfrog the Kansas City Chiefs in the AFC West and make a deep postseason push, that would be huge. Advertisement 'And like the Cardinals ($40.9 million), the Chargers should have the cap space ($27.9 million) needed to work out a long-term extension with McLaurin.' The crux of this speculation revolves around an extension McLaurin is yet to sign. With five consecutive 1,000-yard seasons to his name, McLaurin has earned the right to be paid like a top receiver. Anything less from Washington's part would feel like malpractice. McLaurin has endured some of the darkest seasons in franchise history and came out on the other side, thriving with a franchise quarterback. The Commanders' cap is healthy enough to hand out an extension, and he plays an integral role on the boundary in this offense. Samuel was an aggressive addition that deserves to be praised, but nobody is suggesting he's without risk. Is Washington truly willing to enter the year with Samuel as its leading receiver? Advertisement 'Los Angeles could send Johnston to Washington in the deal,' Knox wrote. 'While the TCU product hasn't played up to his draft status yet (1,142 yards in two seasons), he has intriguing upside, is only 23 years old and is starting to adapt to the NFL game. … 'With up to three years left on Johnston's rookie contract—including the fifth-year option—he could be valuable enough for Washington to justify a Day-2 pick swap instead of an outright second-rounder.' Johnston took a step forward in 2024. Still, he's yet to fulfill his promise and wouldn't be getting some significant jump under center that other receivers could pin their hopes on. The Commanders would instantly have the worst receiving corps in the division, and possibly the worst among all Super Bowl contenders. Doing so for the right to move up on Day 2 (while still giving up draft capital) would set Washington back to square one. It would take away a superstar quarterback's best weapon for a marginal increase in draft capital and stunt an offseason's worth of progress. Advertisement Getting an extension signed should be Washington's top priority. If the trade offers aren't wildly favorable, it would be more worthwhile to let McLaurin compete for a Super Bowl and deal with the consequences later. m Related: Trade Speculation as McLaurin Extension Talks Stall Related: Commanders Star Laremy Tunsil Oozes Excitement About Teammates This story was originally reported by Athlon Sports on Jun 16, 2025, where it first appeared.
Yahoo
9 minutes ago
- Yahoo
‘Haven't Been Relevant Since Matt Leinart': Former Oregon Star Rips USC
'Haven't Been Relevant Since Matt Leinart': Former Oregon Star Rips USC originally appeared on Athlon Sports. It's safe to say Kenjon Barner doesn't view Lincoln Riley and the USC Trojans very fondly. The former Oregon Ducks running back, who spent eight seasons in the NFL as a journeyman, sounded off on his former Pac-12 rival recently. Advertisement 'This fan base is starting to remind me of the Dallas Cowboys fan base, right? Just annoying,' Barner said Saturday on "Ducks of a Feather." 'All you're doing is running your mouth. Your bark is louder than your bite. … Listen, you've got the No. 1 recruiting class coming in. That's cool. You've still got to be able to win football games, which you guys have not been able to do for a very long time.' At the Los Angeles Memorial Coliseum in 2012, Barner had the best performance of his college career. In a 62-51 win over USC, he rushed for 321 yards and five touchdowns on 38 gives. Lane Kiffin and the Trojans entered that same campaign ranked No. 1 in the nation, but finished the go-round with a 7-6 mark. The season before, Barner punched it in twice against USC in a 123-yard losing effort at home. USC coach Lincoln Riley© Gary A. Vasquez-Imagn Images 'You guys have been front-runners,' Barner said. 'You guys have been the school that comes in talking. You know, you've got the look. You're out in front. But when you get on that field? Trash. Tragedy. Tragedy strikes USC. … Listen, there's nothing been nice about y'all. Advertisement 'You guys haven't been relevant since Matt Leinart and Reggie Bush, LenDale White.' The Trojans went 34-5 in the three seasons after Leinart and Bush headed to the NFL, winning the Rose Bowl to cap each year. Head coach Pete Carroll left after one more season, and since then, USC has had just five double-digit-win efforts, including only one since 2018. Related: Urban Meyer Sends Blunt Message to Lincoln Riley This story was originally reported by Athlon Sports on Jun 17, 2025, where it first appeared.
Yahoo
15 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Ducks Fly Together: Kayvon Praises Giants' Chemistry
Ducks Fly Together: Kayvon Praises Giants' Chemistry originally appeared on Athlon Sports. The New York Giants failed to live up to its presumed pass-rush synergy in 2024, dealing with injuries and struggles on the back end to create an underwhelming unit. Blame defensive coordinator Shane Bowen, the offense putting them behind the eight ball, or a talent level that didn't quite meet the hype, but New York was worse than the sum of its parts a season ago. Advertisement General manager Joe Schoen ensured that wouldn't be the case in 2025. In free agency, he immediately injected athleticism and ball skills into a unit that desperately needed it, signing corner Paulson Adebo and safety Jevon Holland. In the NFL Draft, New York found the class' best edge rusher, Abdul Carter, and promising defensive tackle Darius Alexander. This defense is filled to the brim with talent, but less tangible factors could make a similar impact. Giants edge rusher Kayvon Thibodeaux rekindles his Oregon connection with Holland and spoke about the team's chemistry at minicamp. 'Man, I love him having safety Jevón,' Thibodeaux said. 'I played with Jevón back in college and he's always been a field general. Paulson's great. He's been doing his thing. He's a leader. But I think just having that, those extra pieces definitely does add to the nucleus of the defense.' Advertisement Holland hasn't racked up accolades just yet, but he's widely viewed as a Pro Bowl-level talent. He had a lackluster season in terms of ball production in 2024, but there's reason to believe he can find the football, especially in a defense that's going to get after the quarterback. Across his first four seasons, Holland has generated five interceptions, five forced fumbles, and 25 passes defended. 'Yeah, he got a nose for the ball ever since college, he's been getting that ball out whether it's interceptions or punch outs and things like that,' Thibodeaux said. 'But he's definitely, he makes his teammates better and he knows everything that's going on, so I think that's definitely going to help some of the younger guys step up and then also help the defense as a whole.' Holland signed a three-year, $45.3 million deal, rather similar to Adebo's three-year, $54 million contract. The two, with similar skill sets and Pac-12 pedigree, will hope to change the fortunes of New York's defense. 'I think it's kind of interesting how Joe went and got a Stanford guy for (linebacker) Bobby (Okereke), an Oregon guy for me, and we got a couple Oregon guys on the team, but bringing in guys that know each other that can play well together, that can do what needs to get done.' Advertisement Related: Edge Rusher Rankings Set High Bar for Giants Related: Giants Ready To Get Creative With Abdul Carter This story was originally reported by Athlon Sports on Jun 18, 2025, where it first appeared.
