
HC upholds PhD for scholar pursuing part-time tabla diploma
The court further ruled that the scholar is entitled to receive his degree without refunding a university scholarship.
"We have carefully perused the PhD ordinance as well as the University Research Scholarship (URS) ordinance... It has been correctly held that such part-time evening courses (tabla course) do not interfere with PhD studies," a division bench comprising Justice Lisa Gill and Justice Sudeepti Sharma held in its order released on Monday.
The bench further noted that the university failed to point out any illegality, infirmity, or irregularity in the impugned order passed by the single bench.
The ruling came as the court dismissed MDU's appeal against a Feb 11 order. That order had granted relief to Pradeep Deswal, who had sought directions for the university to award him his PhD degree.
The primary contention in the case revolved around MDU vice-chancellor's decision to grant Deswal his PhD only upon the refund of Rs 4,95,833, the full amount of the University Research Scholarship he had received.
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
This Could Be the Best Time to Trade Gold in 5 Years
IC Markets
Learn More
Undo
The university's counsel argued that while MDU had no objection to granting the degree, Deswal needed to repay the scholarship due to his enrolment as an advocate and his pursuit of the tabla course during his PhD studies.
The university maintained that Deswal failed to disclose his enrolment as a lawyer and the tabla course, and the vice-chancellor's refund requirement was "fair and balanced".
After examining the matter, the division bench observed that it was the specific case of the petitioner (Deswal) that as he was active in politics apart from regular studies, a complaint was filed against him due to extraneous considerations.
Though he enrolled with the Bar Council in 2011, he filed his first power of attorney in a court of law in 2020, having concentrated solely on his studies prior to that. The division bench noted that Deswal's averment regarding his delayed legal practice was not specifically refuted by the university.
The court observed, "Counsel for appellants was unable to point out any bar, which may be applicable upon the writ petitioner to pursue his PhD while being enrolled as an advocate."
Regarding the tabla diploma, the bench reiterated that Deswal undertook the course on a part-time basis in the same university, specifically in evening classes. "It has been correctly held by the learned single bench that such would not interfere with the studies of the writ petitioner in so far as his pursuit in the doctorate in laws was concerned. Thus, in our considered opinion, the order dated February 11 has been correctly passed, and the writ petitioner is indeed entitled to a degree in doctorate in the programme of laws without insistence upon refund of the scholarship amount," the high court ordered.
MSID:: 122813620 413 |
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


India.com
28 minutes ago
- India.com
Masterstroke by Mukesh Ambani: Jio launches monthly plans under Rs…, 2GB daily data, Jio TV and more
Masterstroke by Mukesh Ambani: Jio launches monthly plans under Rs…, 2GB daily data, Jio TV and more Jio Cheapest 28 Days Plans: Private telecom service providers like Airtel, Jio, and Vodafone Idea have increased prices of their tariff plans. Now, it has become very difficult for the users, especially school and college goers, to find the right recharge plan on a low budget every month. However, Jio still provides several budget plans for its users, that too under Rs 300 only. These plans are beneficial for users who want unlimited data and free calling without spending more money, and also want to keep their secondary SIM active. Let's know about such best Jio prepaid recharge plans, which are priced at less than Rs 300. Jio Cheapest 28 Days Plans: Rs 198 Plan This plan is beneficial for those users whose data usage is pretty high. The Rs 198 plan offers 2GB data per day with a validity of 14 days. It means the user will get a total of 28GB of high-speed data for 14 days. Users will also get unlimited calling and 100 daily SMS which they can send to any number. Access to Jio TV, Cinema and Cloud apps is also available for free. Jio Cheapest 28-Day Plans: Rs 199 Plan In Rs 199 plan, users will get a validity of 18 days and 1.5 GB of high-speed data daily. It means the user will get a total of 27 GB of high-speed data for 18 days. The plan also offers unlimited calling and 100 SMS daily. Not only that, but the facility of Jio TV, Cinema, and Cloud is also provided with this plan. Jio Cheapest 28-Day Plans: Rs 209 Plan The Rs 209 plan offers 1GB of high-speed data daily for 22 days, totalling 22GB. It also includes unlimited calling to all networks and 100 SMS per day. Users also get access to Jio TV, Jio Cinema, and Jio Cloud with this plan. Jio Cheapest 28-Day Plans: Rs 239 Plan This plan offers 1.5 GB of data per day with unlimited calling on all networks. Users will also get 100 free SMS daily. The plan's validity is 22 days. The Rs 239 plan is for those users who need a little more data. Jio Cheapest 28-Day Plans: Rs 249 Plan The users will get 1 GB of high-speed data for 28 days with unlimited voice calling. Like other plans, users will also get 100 SMS daily with Rs 249 plan. This plan is best for those users whose data requirements is less. Jio Cheapest 28-Day Plans: Rs 299 Plan This 28-day plan provides 1.5GB of data each day, which means a total of 42GB high-speed data for 28 days. Similar to other plans, Rs 299 plan also includes unlimited calling, 100 SMS daily, and access to all Jio applications.


Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Telangana HC seeks fresh affidavit from heritage director on construction near Golconda fort
Hyderabad: The high court has directed the director of heritage, Telangana, who also serves as the competent authority under the National Monuments Authority (NMA), to file a fresh affidavit regarding the issuance of permission to a builder for construction on a 14-acre plot in Qila Mohammed Nagar, adjacent to the outer wall of the protected Golconda fort. A division bench comprising Chief Justice Aparesh Kumar Singh and Justice P Sam Koshy issued the direction while hearing an appeal filed by a businessman challenging a March 2025 order passed by a single judge of the high court. The single judge had earlier directed the director of heritage to grant permission to the builder in accordance with the NMA's directives. During the hearing on Wednesday, Chief Justice Singh said: "The competent authority, is it a post office service or do they have some role in implementing the orders? There should be some application of mind." The Chief Justice further remarked that they do not have any issue with authorities implementing the orders, as long as they are in accordance with the law. You Can Also Check: Hyderabad AQI | Weather in Hyderabad | Bank Holidays in Hyderabad | Public Holidays in Hyderabad The bench observed that the director of heritage had earlier opposed the builder's request in a counter-affidavit filed on June 21, 2021, but failed to file any subsequent updates clarifying whether those objections were addressed or if the builder had complied with necessary conditions. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like No annual fees for life UnionBank Credit Card Apply Now Undo Meanwhile, the counsel for the appellant informed the court that the no-objection certificate granted to the builder by the NMA in April 2019 is currently under challenge in a public interest litigation pending before the high court. Taking note of these submissions and referring to relevant provisions of the Ancient Monuments and Archaeological Sites and Remains Act, the bench directed the competent authority to submit a clear affidavit confirming whether the builder fulfilled all requisite conditions. The matter has been posted for further hearing in two weeks.


Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
20K houses on city outskirtsto get piped cooking gas
Chennai: Around 20,000 houses along Old Mahabalipuram Road (OMR), Grand Southern Trunk (GST) Road, and the city's southern outskirts will receive piped natural gas (PNG) within the next 18 months, said M Thirukumaran N T, regional head (Kanchipuram) of THINK Gas, which holds licences for Kanchipuram. The company currently has 5,500 active domestic connections, nearly 60% of them concentrated in Sholinganallur, Thiruporur, Thalambur, and Thaiyur along OMR. "We have created adequate infrastructure across OMR, parts of GST Road beyond Tambaram, and southern suburbs. Expansion work is ongoing," he said, adding that pipeline networks have been looped with multiple supply sources to ensure uninterrupted service even if one line is disrupted. While infrastructure is in place, the company is facing challenges in driving demand. You Can Also Check: Chennai AQI | Weather in Chennai | Bank Holidays in Chennai | Public Holidays in Chennai "In many shared living spaces, especially bachelor accommodations, residents don't seek gas connections as they depend on food apps or office canteens. We have identified potential high-rises like Hiranandani (Siruseri) where work could begin soon," he said. The process of getting a PNG connection has been simplified. Pipelines with valves are already laid along main roads and can be extended to individual homes. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Villa Prices in Dubai Might Be Lower Than You Think! Villa for sale in Dubai | Search Ads Learn More Undo For high-rises, gas risers up to 28 metres are provided. "Our technical team connects to the stove, retrofitting burners from 90 nm (LPG) to 110 nm (PNG) within 10-15 minutes. From registration to installation, it takes one day. The cost is around 7,000 with multiple payment options," Thirukumaran said. Operational costs for PNG are now 4-5% cheaper than LPG cylinders, down from a previous 15% advantage after LPG prices were reduced by 300. "Give us a level-playing field. If you get, say, 100 subsidy or 300 subsidy in a month, then I should not be punished for using PNG. Give me a 300 subsidy through a direct transfer without routing through any of the entities. We are asking the govt to either promote LPG or natural gas. You cannot promote both," said Chiradeep Datta, director & chief operating officer, THINK Gas. Pipeline expansion is hampered by strict work-hour limits, allowing activity only between 11pm and 5am, with effective hours reduced to five due to setup and clearance. Approvals are slow, taking two months from highways and another month from traffic police, while 45-day permits lapse during processing. Gas firms have asked TIDCO to implement single-window clearances to cut timelines to five-seven working days.