DCC may thwart plan to demolish 'unique and special' lecture theatres
The Dunedin City Council has included the Archway Lecture Theatre building on a draft list of 146 buildings to be protected under changes to the district plan.
The council's heritage assessment says the building is unique, special and "without comparison" in Dunedin. However, the University of Otago says the building represents the "poorest quality" lecture theatres on campus and demolition had been on the cards for at least 15 years.
The proposed heritage changes will be considered at a hearing beginning on May 19.
In his written evidence, vice-chancellor Grant Robertson asked for the building not to be included on the list, saying the university was considering demolishing the theatres and the neighbouring Gregory Building — possibly replacing them with a formal garden space.
The university wanted to "maximise the value" of neo-gothic buildings on campus by developing the Union St entranceway, he said.
In March, Mr Robertson confirmed he was planning to move a significant proportion of the staff in the Clocktower building — including himself — into the consumer and applied science building.
"A formal garden space connecting the [consumer and applied sciences] building with Union St and the gothic heritage buildings of the Clocktower precinct, for example, offers a substantial enhancement to the university's heritage campus," he said.
"The Archway Lecture Theatres are a barrier to this entranceway."
The 2010 Campus Master Plan suggested removing the building in favour of a new teaching centre. However, following the Covid pandemic and "the changing nature of teaching and learning", the centre was not required.
Rather, the university had an "abundance of building space".
The Archway Lecture Theatre building was built in 1974, designed by notable Dunedin architect Ted McCoy, and won a New Zealand Institute of Architects Southern Architecture Award for Enduring Architecture in 2020.
The council's heritage assessment report proposed the entire external envelope and internal corridor be protected.
"When considered alongside other buildings on the district plan heritage schedule, the Archway Lecture Theatre is without comparison," the report said.
"This building is both unique and special to Dunedin. It also contributes to a nationwide body of Brutalist architecture."
University property and campus development director Tanya Syddall said while opposition did not come lightly, the building represented "the poorest quality" of tiered lecture theatres on campus.
"They are cold and austere, the seating uncomfortable and acoustics poor."
The building would likely be unused in about three years as demand for teaching spaces changed, making maintenance costs "impossible to justify" and demolition inevitable, she said.
Mrs Syddall said in 2010, Mr McCoy was asked about the proposal to demolish the theatres and told Master Plan lead consultant Chris Alcock "words to the effect of 'I'm fine if you want to get rid of them"'.
She said there was no timeline for any proposed demolition and the formal garden was as yet unapproved and subject to change.
The university had supported the inclusion of three of its other buildings — the former Dunedin Hospital Nurses' Home, former Queen Mary Maternity Hospital and the Hercus Building — on the heritage schedule, with some requested amendments.
ruby.shaw@odt.co.nz
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NZ Herald
6 hours ago
- NZ Herald
Borrowers hold off locking in mortgage rates for longer terms, snatching attractive one-year rates
Borrowers were waiting for interest rates to fall, before locking in rates for slightly longer terms. The latest data shows that by June, borrowers had moved towards slightly longer term rates, but were still giving themselves flexibility. Indeed, locking in a two-year rate wasn't a very popular option. Economist Tony Alexander, who does a regular survey of mortgage brokers, believed borrowers snatched one-year rates, because they were the most attractive in June. He believed borrowers didn't feel the need to lock in two, or even three-year rates, because they didn't see interest rates being higher in a year's time when they came to refinance. Rightly or wrongly, they simply chased the most attractive rate. 'It's the kiwi way,' Alexander said, noting that banks in New Zealand compete most aggressively in the shorter-term mortgage rate market. In March and April, two-year rates became quite popular – again, because banks offered attractive rates at these terms. The June data suggests borrowers didn't opt for the stability of a two-year rate on the back of the Reserve Bank in May surprising some observers by suggesting it might slow its Official Cash Rate (OCR) cuts. One of the bank's Monetary Policy Committee members wasn't in favour of cutting the OCR at the time, noting the uncertainty around where the United States would set tariffs and how this would impact inflation. The committee still cut the OCR in May, but kept it at 3.25% when it met in July. It confirmed further cuts were still likely. Like Alexander, Cotality New Zealand chief property economist Kelvin Davidson believed that in June, borrowers might have been more fixated on locking in attractive rates than acting on the slight change of tack in the Reserve Bank's commentary. He believed some may have simply opted for flexibility. Indeed, there was a record amount of bank switching in June, as borrowers chased cash contributions banks offered new customers. Furthermore, by late-June, the sluggishness of the economy may have given some borrowers the impression more rate cuts were surely on the way. 'People are still hedging their bets,' Davidson said. Both he and Alexander noted how in 2020 and 2021, most borrowers didn't take the opportunity to lock in exceptionally low rates for longer terms. They questioned whether the same situation was playing out now, but neither could see interest rates shooting up in the near future as they did after the Covid era of extremely loose monetary policy. While many in the business community, including former Prime Minister Sir John Key, are urging the Reserve Bank to cut interest rates more aggressively to stimulate growth, Alexander wanted to remind people that the Reserve Bank's job was to keep inflation in check, not target the optimal level of growth. Accordingly, he believed it couldn't cut the OCR much more, as this would create too much inflation. Davidson, on the other hand, believed the Reserve Bank would look through near-term inflation risks caused by tariffs and cut the OCR further. The rate will be next reviewed on August 20. The lowest New Zealand economists typically see the OCR going is 2.5%. Because cuts have been well signalled, banks have largely priced them into mortgage rates on offer now. Jenée Tibshraeny is the Herald's Wellington business editor, based in the Parliamentary Press Gallery. She specialises in government and Reserve Bank policymaking, economics and banking.
NZ Herald
13 hours ago
- NZ Herald
Infrastructure Report: Downer gears up for $111.6b in funded projects
Murray Robertson, Downer New Zealand managing director Robertson says a stable, bipartisan-backed pipeline is seen as critical to investor confidence. It reduces perceived risk and enables better financing terms for public-private partnerships. This is especially important for long-term asset management and maintenance investment. 'We are seeing a shift to design-and-construct projects, rather than construct-only, and this changes the type of workforce we need – such as more engineering and design management personnel. 'We are going through a review of the work expected to come through and making sure we are resourced to a sustainable level based on what we can secure through tender. We have to do this in a measured manner. The key thing is that the industry responds by having the right people to deliver well when the initiatives start flowing. We are seeing a shift to design-and-construct projects, rather than construct-only, and this changes the type of workforce we need – such as more engineering and design management personnel. - Murray Robertson, Downer New Zealand managing director 'We acknowledge that the growth in public-private partnerships will likely see increased involvement from overseas contractors. However, it's important to recognise that delivering these projects successfully will still rely heavily on the capabilities and support of strong local teams like ours – and those of Fulton Hogan, McConnell Dowell, HEB Construction, Higgins, Naylor Love and LT McGuinness. 'By moving away from the boom-bust cycle (for project development), we can retain key talent and skills,' says Robertson. 'We are big with on-the-job training and bringing operational management up to speed with New Zealand regulations and compliance.' Robertson says there's a constant degree of interest from South Africa and the UK in terms of project and design management and onsite supervisors. Interest is also being shown from some of the bigger companies out of Australia and Europe for large public-private partnerships across the country.' In transport infrastructure, the NZ Transport Agency has started procurement of the roads of national significance, each of which presents significant opportunity to the industry, says Robertson. Downer is part of a consortium tendering for the Northern Corridor public-private partnership that involves extending the four-lane highway 26km from Warkworth to Te Hana, including a tunnel section and interchanges. The project is part of the 100km-long Northland Corridor from Puhoi to Whangārei. Three consortia are bidding for the work and the preferred contractor is expected to be confirmed early next year, with detailed design and early construction starting mid-year. For Downer-owned Hawkins, the commercial construction pipeline reflects substantial investment in key sectors, says Robertson. Health NZ released its first long-term infrastructure plan earlier this year, outlining $20b worth of (new and upgrade) projects over 10 years. Health NZ said the plan provided 'a consistent approach to how and when we invest in public health infrastructure across the country based on clinical service planning and equitable healthcare access.' Downer-owned Hawkins has recently completed the new Totara Haumaru building, which includes 150 beds and eight operating theatres, as part of the $600m North Shore hospital upgrade. Robertson says this highly successful project was preceded by a thorough early contractor involvement phase, during which Hawkins collaborated closely with the client to proactively identify risks and ensure that practical construction strategies were well established in advance. He says fair risk allocation is important for any major project to ensure continuity of delivery. Clear, balanced risk-sharing avoids disputes and delays, and early risk clarity helps contractors plan and price accurately. Structured risk registers and delegated authority frameworks ensure accountability and strengthen governance. The transparent risk model fosters collaboration with clients and stakeholders and builds trust. Hawkins is delivering Auckland Airport's $850 million domestic jet terminal, which will connect to the present international terminal, creating a smoother, more spacious experience for travellers. The project is expected to be completed in 2029. Downer is a core member of the Link Alliance, contributing one-third of the management and construction effort for the Auckland City Rail Link (CRL). 'While there is a necessary degree of tension over delivery and cost, the project's quality, safety and productivity are impressive relative to similar large rail builds in Australia and other parts of the world. That comes down to being very clear about risk allocation, and an excellent project team,' says Robertson. 'The alliance is in the final stages of delivering CRL and the public will be impressed when the project is released. The way the project has delivered on social impact and sustainability outcomes is world-class. The innovation and contributions have happened because of understanding and sharing the risks.' Downer has 8000 people - both permanent and contingent workers - operating out of 73 locations in New Zealand, including the Chatham Islands. The transport and infrastructure business is half-and-half maintenance and construction. 'We are located around the country from tip to toe,' says Robertson. 'It's important, particularly for road maintenance, because many of the areas we service are quite remote and we provide reactive as well as routine maintenance.' Downer has 50 staff in the Tasman region but that number more than tripled to 180 to support the recovery work following the recent flooding. 'We deployed people from across the South Island – the team has been working long hours and we have had to carefully manage fatigue.' Downer maintains more than 50,000km of urban and rural roads in New Zealand Australia. It has also stretched to the Pacific Islands, recently constructing airfields in Niue Solomon Islands and Nauru. Other completed projects include the Court Theatre performing arts venue in Christchurch, the award-winning Auckland University Hiwa Recreation centre, the Burnham Health and Rehabilitation Centre for the New Zealand Defence Force, and stage two of the Wakefield private hospital in Wellington. Hawkins is presently delivering the Manaaki Hohonu building at Waitakere Hospital – a modern, two-storey facility housing intensive care and inpatient wards and designed to support contemporary models of care and future clinical expansion. Other current projects include a paediatric facility at the Tira Ora Child Health Centre in Whangārei, and the Kenepuru Science Centre for PHF Science in Porirua. Robertson says aligning investment decisions with community wellbeing and long-term regional development reinforces confidence. Downer has developed a New Zealand Infrastructure Resilience Index – a strategic tool designed to measure and strengthen infrastructure resilience across regions. Created in collaboration with NZIER, the index helps identify vulnerabilities in the system and guides where investment should be prioritised to ensure infrastructure continues to function with minimal disruption during future shocks. Robertson agrees there's plenty going on. The infrastructure pipeline is growing with more than 8000 initiatives listed nationally. 'A level of confidence is building in the industry, and we want to see this flowing through to major projects that are not held up for any reason, whether it's consenting or designing. 'The Government is intent on making New Zealand open to foreign direct investment, and substantiate special purpose vehicles for public-private partnerships. The first significant one is the Northern Corridor. 'New Zealand is an attractive place to do business and to live. We can deliver superb engineering and training capabilities. And a lot of people who might have gone away are now coming back, and this gives clients the confidence that contractors can deliver.' Robertson says even though the overall sentiment in the infrastructure industry is positive, it is measured. 'Confidence is at its highest when funding is confirmed, political alignment is strong and delivery capability is mature.' Downer is an advertising sponsor of the Herald's Infrastructure report.
NZ Herald
14 hours ago
- NZ Herald
On The Up: Whangārei trust wants to offer supermarket alternative, cheaper butter
Taimahi Trust also has a long-term aim of making everything in the store available online, so customers can place orders whenever it suits them, and receive them through delivery or click-and-collect. Delivery areas cover greater Whangārei including Hikurangi, Te Kamo, Maunu and Onerahi, with plans to deliver to hubs as demand grows. Chairwoman and chief executive Rachel Hill is even looking at expanding the store's range, so it will eventually sell some cheeses and butter. With the price of butter being a hot topic at the moment, she hopes to be able to sell it for cheaper than supermarkets, while still making a small margin. 'Even though we're a charity we still want to be business-like and we also want to be cheaper than other places. It helps people with their budget and people who might be food insecure.' But Hill is conscious of working on one step at a time. Taimahi Trust operations administrator Troy Robertson, back left, and admin trainee Anton Herbert have found their calling with the trust. Photo / Denise Piper The trust previously delivered vege boxes but had to retrench this during the post-Covid downturn, before branching out again thanks to grants from the likes of the Ministry of Social Development. Resilience and fortitude are part of the story of the trust, which began as a coffee cart in 2017. Hill and Alison Faithful started the enterprise for their sons, who both have Down syndrome, and were struggling to find training and work opportunities - like many with intellectual disabilities. It has now developed into a groundbreaking training model for young people with intellectual or learning disabilities, creating a community for them, Hill said. Trainee Jordan Jennings carefully cuts ginger in Taimahi Trust's commercial kitchen, where a wide range of goodies are made. Photo / Denise Piper Taimahi Trust currently has 12 staff and 20 trainees, who often surpass what is expected of them, she said. Some have moved into supervisory roles, while others have gained paid work or further training, Hill said. 'They come here quite helpless because people have done things for them all the time - we turn it around,' she said. Hill's son Nathan is still a trainee and she, like many parents of the trainees, has noticed large changes due to the trust's holistic approach. Trainees Sweetie Loeak and Te Wairere Tepania work happily in Taimahi Trust's greenhouses. Strategic development manager James Ibell-Roberts said every time someone comes into the store or buys a product, it helps empower and upskill the trainees. 'For us, the more people coming into the store and engaging with our trainees is breaking down the social barriers or isolation that our trainees experience.' Taimahi Trust works with social enterprise Foodtogether to get affordable fresh produce, he said. 'We're about making affordable and nutritious kai - many of it grown by our trainees - making it accessible either at people's door or in store.' The store is also less overwhelming for customers who might struggle with sensory overload in a supermarket, Ibell-Roberts said. Further long-term plans include providing accommodation for trainees from wider Northland and branching out with different microenterprises. The Taimahi Fresh+ store is available at 19 Bank St or for online orders. Denise Piper is a news reporter for the Northern Advocate, focusing on health and business. She has more than 20 years in journalism and is passionate about covering stories that make a difference.
