The Office Of ECE's Response To The Green Party's ECE Policy Announcement
Press Release – Office of Early Childhood Education
Although the Greens policy removes the ability for private enterprise to use ECE as a money making endeavour, its not foolproof. The policy still leaves room for community organisations running ECE centres to divert public funding to other …
'The Greens describe their ECE policy as 'bold'. It certainly is. It could even be described as 'whacky', because it's so different to the status quo.
'But that doesn't mean it's crazy. In fact, it deserves consideration and might well have merit.
'Essentially, the Greens are proposing to turn the way the ECE sector is structured and funded on its head.
'The Greens have homed in on two of the most critical problems facing the sector: instability and cost.
'The dominance of the sector by private for-profit providers means that, being businesses, most ECEs could close overnight if they decided to, leaving whānau in the lurch. This is not an issue in the community-based part of the sector.
'Without fee capping, as the Greens are proposing at $10 per day initially, the prices ECE services charge are, and will remain, at their discretion.
'The OECE has spent many years advocating for transparency in ECE services' financial accounts, so parents can see where money is going and assess whether fee hikes are justified. Opening up the books can also help ensure all families can access high quality early childhood education and care, whatever their household income or ability to pay is.
'We also recognise that ECE is a 'public good'.
'Although the Greens' policy removes the ability for private enterprise to use ECE as a money making endeavour, it's not foolproof. The policy still leaves room for community organisations running ECE centres to divert public funding to other purposes of their charity or organisation.
'If an external body is managing the finances of centres, through 'networks' as the Greens have proposed, individual centres won't have control over their own spending.
'Many current providers might also refuse to become not-for-profits, which could lead to a lack of capacity and a lack of available places for tamariki to meet whānau demand.
'There are multiple ways the policy could unravel; whether it's successful will depend on how it's implemented.'
Other comments from the OECE:
In the documentation they've released alongside their policy, the Greens have left some important questions unanswered, such as:
Whether the number of teachers at each not-for-profit centre will be capped according to the existing minimum ratios or whether teacher headcounts, and the corresponding salaries, will be determined per centre using a different metric
How non-teacher led parts of the sector (EG: Playcentre) will be funded. The Greens have confirmed to the OECE that they're committed to funding parent-led services like Playcentre, but how to do this hasn't been costed yet.
How this approach would work for home-based services.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
5 days ago
- RNZ News
Labour buoyed by latest showing in RNZ / Reid Research poll
Labour leader Chris Hipkins is taking heart from the party's showing in the new RNZ/ Reid Research poll. Photo: RNZ / Marika Khabazi It's "encouraging" but there's still 18 months of hard work ahead to regain the Treasury benches, Labour leader Chris Hipkins says. He believes the increases in the party support and for him as preferred prime minister are part of a trend that has shown growing support for the party since the 2023 election. Parliament's left bloc would have enough support to govern, according to the latest RNZ-Reid Research poll . The poll was taken in the seven days following the release of the Budget and in the wake of the $12.8 billion pay equity changes - which RNZ's polling also shows attracting more opposition than support . National with 38 seats loses three seats since the previous poll in March while ACT at eight seats loses four. New Zealand First gains two to have 11 seats in the new poll but it's not enough to save the coalition. It would have a total of 57 seats which is below the threshold to govern. Labour gains two seats from RNZ's last poll and is predicted to have 42, according to these results. The Greens gain two to have 14 and Te Pāti Māori gains one to have seven seats. That's 63 seats compared to the coalition's 57. Hipkins said it was "an encouraging poll result" and it showed people were disappointed with the government and the Budget. "I don't think anybody expected them to be cutting pay equity in order to make the Budget balance so I think people are expressing some dissatisfaction with that. "We've still got 18 months to go and we know in the Labour party we're going to have to work hard in that time," he told Morning Report. All of the polls were showing that Labour was rebuilding support since the last general election and it was making good progress. Hipkins was pressed on the lack of Labour policies released so far, however, he countered that the party had outlined its priorities - jobs, health and homes - and detailed policies would be released closer to the election. "We'll get a tax policy out this year. There'll be some other policies as well ... A lot of that does have to wait until you know what you're in a position to deliver on. A lot can change in 18 months." No fiscal plan could be released when the government still had another Budget to deliver prior to the 2026 Budget, he said. Hipkins said he had not changed his opinion that it was "highly unikely" Labour would work with NZ First post-election although he was not completely ruling it out. NZ First's "persecution of minorities" and "backward views on climate change" made them an unappealing coalition partner. Hipkins believed some of the ideas around tax in the Greens' alternative Budget could be looked at. However, "the scale of change the Greens are proposing to do in a rapid period of time would make that very challenging". As for Te Pāti Māori, Hipkins said closer to the election Labour would set out those parties it believed it could operate with and those it would struggle to work with. When it comes to preferred Prime Minister, Christopher Luxon's lost support since the last RNZ / Reid Research poll, down 3.1 percent. He's on 18.8 percent, below Hipkins who's up 2.3 points from March, and on 23.2 percent support. NZ First leader Winston Peters at 8.9 percent (up 1 point) recorded his highest result since 2017. Chlöe Swarbrick in fourth was at 6.9 percent (up 0.8) - a personal best and just ahead of ACT's David Seymour on 6.4 percent (down 0.4). Earlier, Luxon was dismissive of the poll results. "Look, I mean, I don't recognise the numbers. There's lots of different polls and frankly I'm just not going to comment or focus on the polls. Frankly what we're focused on is we were elected in '23 and people get to decide again in 2026. "We've done a good job, and that's why we've got to focus on the economy, law and order, and health and education." He said New Zealanders had "responded really positively" to the government's Budget, and saw the economy turning a corner. Seymour said the numbers would continue to "bounce around" but it was still a tough time for New Zealanders - and the numbers were not a reflection on the Budget. It was possible the pay equity changes were changing some voters' minds, he said, "but I also think doing what is right is what is politically popular in the long term, and even if I'm wrong about that, good policy is worth it anyway". "The fact that ACT is close to where it was on election night 18 months into a government with 18 months to go is a good foundation. We have to prove ourselves on election night, and we've got lots of time to do that." Peters refused to comment on whether his coalition partners were suffering from the handling of the pay equity changes. The next 18 months leading up to the election would show the "critical need for stability", he said, and having ruled out working with Hipkins he was "comfortable and confident in our prospects" because the Greens and Te Pāti Māori in government would be "a nightmare". Greens co-leader Chlöe Swarbrick Photo: RNZ Swarbrick said New Zealanders wanted a sense of hope. "Things are feeling pretty bloody bleak. You know, we've got 191 New Zealanders leaving every single day, three quarters of them between the ages of 18 to 45, it's not a recipe for a flourishing country. "We had dozens and dozens of folks turn out to talk to us about our Green budget and the sense of hope that they feel that they need - the kind of building blocks that we can have for a fairer society." Te Pāti Māori's co-leader Rawiri Waititi said the poll numbers showed the party's policies and rhetoric around the government's actions were appealing to new supporters. "The kind of anti-Māori, anti-wāhine, anti-woman, anti-worker, anti-climate, anti-rainbow, anti-woke type agenda that this government is pushing at the moment also is not appealing to the people who are trying to find a place to put their political support and trying to support those who fiercely advocate for them." Explore the full results with RNZ's interactive charts .
RNZ News
5 days ago
- RNZ News
Left bloc would have enough support to turf coalition government out of power
The preferred prime minister and leadership ratings are bad news for the government, with the exception of Winston Peters who has seen his highest result since 2017. Photo: RNZ After the Budget and pay equity changes the left bloc would have the support to turf the coalition out of power, the latest RNZ-Reid Research poll shows. The preferred prime minister and leadership ratings are also bad news for the government , with the exception of Winston Peters who has seen his highest result since 2017 - and ratings of the government's general performance have also continued to slide. With Labour, the Greens and Te Pāti Māori all gaining compared to the previous poll taken in March, they would have a majority with 63 seats between them, compared to the coalition's 57 - again, New Zealand First was the only coalition party to see a boost. The poll was taken in the seven days following the release of the Budget and in the wake of the $12.8 billion pay equity changes - which RNZ's polling also shows attracting more opposition than support . National continued a downward trend from the March survey, dropping 2.2 percentage points to 30.7 percent of the party vote - and overtaken by Labour, which gained 0.9 percentage points to 33.2 percent. The Greens' 1.6 percent increase brings them back to their election-night result of 11.6 percent, while Te Pāti Māori's 0.5 percentage point boost lifts them clear of the 5 percent threshold and - presuming they held all Māori seats - nets them a list MP. ACT dropped 2.8 points to 6.6 percent - the largest shift in party polling - while New Zealand First gained 1.9 points to 9.1 percent, upending the trend facing their coalition partners. Undecided or non-voters made up 6.5 percent of those polled - up from 6.1 in the previous poll . For parties outside Parliament, TOP (The Opportunities Party) gained 0.4 points to 2.2 percent, New Conservatives fell 0.3 points to 0.8, and all others combined were at 0.3 points, a 0.1 point increase on the last survey. More New Zealanders polled say the country is going in the wrong direction (46.6 percent) than in the right direction (37.8 percent), giving a net negative result of -8.8, a substantial decrease on March's 2.9 result. Little surprise then to see National leader Christopher Luxon's net favourability ratings drop further into the negative, from -3.9 percent in March to -9.8 percent, with significantly more respondents (45.5 percent) saying he performed poorly or very poorly, than said he performed well or very well (35.7 percent). That compared to Labour's Chris Hipkins on net 5.1 percent rating (34 percent negative, 39.1 percent positive) - though Hipkins also saw a steeper fall of 7.1 percentage points. The survey shows New Zealanders' preferred prime minister as Labour's Chris Hipkins (23.2 percent, up 2.3), taking the lead over National's Christopher Luxon (18.8 percent, down 3.1). NZ First leader Winston Peters at 8.9 percent (up 1 point) recorded his highest result since 2017. Chlöe Swarbrick in fourth was at 6.9 percent (up 0.8) - a personal best and just ahead of ACT's David Seymour on 6.4 percent (down 0.4). The next highest ratings were former PM Jacinda Ardern (3.7 percent, up 0.1), Te Pāti Māori MP Hana-Rawhiti Maipi-Clarke (1.7 percent, up 0.5), Finance Minister Nicola Willis (1.1, up 0.3) and Education/Immigration Minister Erica Stanford making her first appearance at 1 percent. Luxon simply rejected the poll results. "Look, I mean, I don't recognise the numbers. There's lots of different polls and frankly I'm just not going to comment or focus on the polls. Frankly what we're focused on is we were elected in '23 and people get to decide again in 2026. "We've done a good job, and that's why we've got to focus on the economy, law and order, and health and education." He said New Zealanders had "responded really positively" to the government's Budget, and saw the economy turning a corner. "There's a sense of optimism that, you know, we actually have had to manage some very difficult things economically to get our books back in order. But we're doing that job, and it's all about growth, growth, growth." Christopher Luxon (L) with David Seymour last week, after the ACT leader was sworn in as deputy prime minister. Photo: NZME/Dean Purcell Seymour said the numbers would continue to "bounce around" but it was still a tough time for New Zealanders - and the numbers were not a reflection on the Budget. "Different voters will have different reasons for their choices ... so long as people are voting for the economy, it's going to be tough for parties that are tied closely to economic management," he said. It was possible the pay equity changes were changing some voters' minds, he said, "but I also think doing what is right is what is politically popular in the long term, and even if I'm wrong about that, good policy is worth it anyway". "The fact that ACT is close to where it was on election night 18 months into a government with 18 months to go is a good foundation. We have to prove ourselves on election night, and we've got lots of time to do that." Peters refused to comment on whether his coalition partners were suffering from the handling of the pay equity changes. The next 18 months leading up to the election would show the "critical need for stability", he said, and having ruled out working with Chris Hipkins he was "comfortable and confident in our prospects" because the Greens and Te Pāti Māori in government would be "a nightmare". New Zealand First leader Winston Peters and finance minister Nicola Willis. Photo: RNZ / Samuel Rillstone The 80-year-old Peters said economies internationally were in trouble as a result of "unprecedented times for the last, say, 80 years", and the party was looking at New Zealand's fundamentals: asset values, and the need to increase wages and decrease business tax. "We're out there to ensure over the next few months that we can show enough improvement in the economy from what we're doing to make the prospects of an improved tomorrow possible." Hipkins was also not counting his electoral chickens, but was happy to point out the effect of the Budget, saying New Zealanders were "disillusioned" with the government overall. "New Zealanders can increasingly see that this government is taking the country backwards," he said. "I don't think anyone expected the government to cancel pay equity as a way of balancing its books. Nicola Willis and Christopher Luxon told New Zealanders before the election that they knew their numbers, that everything all added up. It's clear that their numbers didn't add up." He said he did not pay much attention to small shifts from the minor parties or his personal ratings in the polls. "It's nice to be popular, but I'm really focused on making sure I win as many votes as possible for Labour at the next election." Labour leader Chris Hipkins. Photo: RNZ / Samuel Rillstone Swarbrick said New Zealanders wanted a sense of hope. "Things are feeling pretty bloody bleak. You know, we've got 191 New Zealanders leaving every single day, three quarters of them between the ages of 18 to 45, it's not a recipe for a flourishing country. "We had dozens and dozens of folks turn out to talk to us about our Green budget and the sense of hope that they feel that they need - the kind of building blocks that we can have for a fairer society." She said polls did not mean the writing was on the wall, but she was hearing from people that they were exhausted and fatigued - something she suggested was a deliberate strategy from the coalition. Te Pāti Māori's co-leader Rawiri Waititi said the poll numbers showed the party's policies and rhetoric around the government's actions were appealing to new supporters. "The kind of anti-Māori, anti-wāhine, anti-woman, anti-worker, anti-climate, anti-rainbow, anti-woke type agenda that this government is pushing at the moment also is not appealing to the people who are trying to find a place to put their political support and trying to support those who fiercely advocate for them." He said their internal polling showed even higher support for the party and its style of politics - but the decreased support for ACT and increase for NZ First was a zero-sum game. "You've got a hard-right type voter ... I think they think that National is a little bit weak, which I agree [with] because they're allowing ACT to kind of run the show ... they will use Te Pāti Māori as their political football to kick us in the guts the hardest to garner the support of their voters, but at the end of the day the enemy for ACT is New Zealand First, and the enemy for New Zealand First is ACT." Explore the full results with RNZ's interactive charts . This poll of 1008 people was conducted by Reid Research, using quota sampling and weighting to ensure representative cross section by age, gender and geography. The poll was conducted through online interviews between 23-30 May 2025 and has a maximum margin of error of +/- 3.1 percent at a 95 percent confidence level. The report is availabe here . Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Scoop
5 days ago
- Scoop
Luxon Must End Climate Denial Speculation
The Greens welcome the open letter from world-leading climate scientists to the Prime Minister, urging his Government to abandon any plan to water down climate targets. 'Christopher Luxon must end any further speculation that his Government is on the climate denial bandwagon. After wasting a year playing around with the mythical 'no additional warming' idea, international alarm bells are ringing,' says Green Party co-leader and Climate Change spokesperson, Chlöe Swarbrick. 'The Climate Change Commission is clear that any entertainment of 'no additional warming' from agricultural gasses would mean households and businesses across the rest of the economy carrying a far higher burden. 'International experts are rightfully calling out this accounting trick. It's about fixing numbers on a page while the real world burns. 'While the Government doesn't tend to show any care for people and the planet, perhaps they would understand that pushing ahead with this agenda poses huge risks for our international exports, climate and trade agreements. 'The Greens have shown how we can reduce real-world emissions five times faster than the Government's 'plan,' while reducing the cost of living and improving our quality of life. 'New Zealanders deserve so much better than this Government's low ambitions for our country,' says Chlöe Swarbrick.
