Armed officer who kicked Manchester Airport 'brawl' brother in the head is 'an uncontrolled bully with a badge', court hears
Police Constable Zachary Marsden had 'defied protocol, ethics, procedure and the law' in the confrontation inn the pay station area of Terminal Two at Manchester airport last July, the jury was told.
The trial at Liverpool Crown Court has heard PC Marsden along with PCs Ellie Cook and Lydia Ward were involved in the fracas with brothers Mohammed Amaaz, 20, and Muhammed Amaad, 26.
The violent clash was sparked when the officers tried to arrest Amaaz for an earlier assault on a man at the Stabucks café inside the terminal, the jury has been told.
CCTV and mobile footage which included PC Marsden kicking Amaaz in the head and stamping on him has been played several times in the four-week trial.
Chloe Gardner, defending Amaad, told the jury in her closing speech the CCTV was without sound and was like 'a jigsaw puzzle' with the prosecution asking the jury 'to guess the final picture'.
Ms Gardner likened the assessment of the CCTV evidence to watching a TV crime drama with the sound turned down.
She said: 'I had Criminal Minds on the TV and I did not have much of a clue about what was going on because the sound was off. I could get the gist but not the full picture.
'CCTV plays a central role here. It can be helpful but it comes with big warning signs because there is no audio and certainly cannot convey what is going on in someone's mind .
'Both sides in this case have played a fair amount of CCTV footage, sometimes at slow speed. We tend to forget how quickly this happened. It was a matter of seconds which has changed the lives of the defendants.'
She said the victim in the Starbucks incident, Abdulkareem Ismaeil, has decided not to take things any further and had not given evidence.
Ms Gardner said: 'The prosecution say "we have the CCTV and that is all the evidence we need". They have given you a jigsaw puzzle and have asked you to guess the final picture. You cannot assess the stature of Mr Ismaeil and whether he was getting wound up, hostile and intimidating.
'The prosecution have not brought Mr Ismaeil here to fill in the gaps by giving evidence.'
She said that it was 'crucial' PC Marsden had 'strode into the pay station' and had grabbed Mr Amaaz without announcing he was a police officer.
Ms Gardner said: 'Imagine if grabbing someone and not saying anything became standard police practice. Police Constable Marsden threw away the rule book long ago. His behaviour was aggressive and uncontrolled.'
She said Amaa had said 'easy, easy, easy, easy, easy ,no , no ,no' in a bid to de escalate the situation.
Ms Gardner continued: 'But these words had zero effect of PC Marsden, who was covered in that red mist. He had no regard for procedure or doing things the right way. He acted how he wanted. His way was the only way.'
'The reality is that PC Marsden, with his firearm and his Taser, was a firearm in himself.'
She said PC Marsden hit the brothers' mother in the face with his Taser during the struggle and had continued to assault Amaad even when he had his hands on his head and when his brother was handcuffed on the ground.
Ms Gardner said the officer had smashed Mr Amaad's face in the ground when he was trying to restrain him and had placed his knee on his neck.
She said: 'PC Marsden could have killed Mr Amaaz with the kick and he could have suffocated Mr Amaad.'
Trial judge Neil Flewitt told the jury they will begin their deliberations on Monday after he has summed up the evidence in the case.
Amaaz denies one charge of assault by beating, two charges of assault causing actual bodily harm and one charge of assault by beating of a police officer acting as an emergency worker.
His elder brother Muhammed Amaad,26, is accused of one charge of assault causing actual bodily harm on PC Marsden.
The brothers from Rochdale, Greater Manchester claim they were acting in self defence.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
13 minutes ago
- The Guardian
Police say ill-fitting uniforms leading to crushed testicles and lumps in breasts
Musculoskeletal damage, crushed testicles and lumps in breasts are just some examples of the harm police officers say they experience because of ill-fitting, uncomfortable and low-quality uniforms. Officers responding to the first national uniform and equipment survey across all 43 forces in England and Wales reported symptoms so severe that some had to have multiple operations. Others told how criminals warned them their uniforms left vital areas of their body exposed and even acted as a 'guide' as to where they could be stabbed. Belinda Goodwin, a former frontline officer who works for the Police Federation, had two operations to remove fistulas from her breasts that she said were caused by ill-fitting body armour. 'We had one model and size of stab vest for both men and women, and we had to wear them eight to 10 hours a day,' she said. 'The pressure for women on our breasts was intense; we were completely flattened. 'Being unable to adjust them for hours on end when you were wearing them in a public-facing role was torture. Driving in them was horrific and dangerous: they rammed up into your chin. 'After my second operation, the consultant told me that they couldn't operate again if the fistulas returned because I'd have no breast left to remove. I realised I had no choice but to leave frontline policing entirely.' Almost 21,000 police officers and staff responded to the Police Federation of England and Wales's (PFEW) survey. The research was conducted in collaboration with the National Police Chiefs' Council and led by Lancaster University Law School. One officer said: 'The current body armour doesn't seem to provide adequate coverage on officer's bodies, with large areas, including armpit areas, exposed compared to other forces' vests that feel a lot more protective. 'On numerous occasions, offenders have commented on how exposed our kit leaves us, and state that our kit acts as a target of where to be stabbed.' More than 60% of men and 85% of women reported a physical health condition that they believed was caused by or made worse through wearing uniform. The most commonly worn garments were the most problematic: 61% complained about body armour; 69% flagged cargo trousers. The survey also found inconsistent uniform quality across forces, with access to high-performance kit depending more on local budgets than operational need: negative experiences ranged from 29% in North Yorkshire to 75% in nearby South Yorkshire. One officer said: 'Cargo trousers are too restrictive when struggling with suspects. On foot patrol or foot chases, [they] do not allow for flexibility to climb, jump or fight as you should.' Another said: 'The standard fit of the patrol/cargo trousers is not fit for purpose. They are extremely tight around the groin/thigh area and often cause rubbing and soreness.' But for another officer, the trousers were too loose: 'The cargo trousers are completely unsuitable for frontline policing – they are baggy and dangerous.' The survey also found uniforms did not enable officers to carry all their equipment. 'The utility vest does not offer enough room to add all items that the force requires us to carry,' said one officer. Another said: 'The utility vest causes horrific back pain as the amount of equipment, and weight of that equipment, is too much to all be placed on the front.' When officers reported the problems, however, the survey found that their complaints were often trivialised and dismissed: almost 40% of officers had made a complaint but only 8% received replacement uniform. One force's female members cbought their own rather than use their department's trousers because the crotch was too short. 'Concerns were raised and women's health issues were not given appropriate consideration by the men deciding what we should wear. It was viewed as more of a fashion issue, and anxiety about body image and the medical issues, such as thrush, were ignored,' she said. The PFEW is calling on the Home Office to create coordinated procurement standards for uniforms with a higher minimum national standard. Melissa Russhard, the National Police Chiefs' Council lead for uniform, said: 'This survey will help give us the mandate to push forward with our moves towards setting national standardisation for uniform requirements and end the postcode lottery that exists.' A spokesperson for the Home Office said: 'We refer to individual police forces, given decisions on uniform are a matter for them.'
Daily Mail
13 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Charlotte Crosby shares fresh details of terrifying break-in at her £1.4million mansion and admits she called her mum for help rather than the police
Charlotte Crosby has recalled fresh details of her terror after an attempted break-in at her £1.4million mansion. The Geordie Shore star, 35, was left terrified when she and fiancé Jake Anker were subjected to an attempted armed burglary at their Sunderland pad in November. Charlotte was heavily pregnant with their second child Pixie Cecilia, now seven months, at the time, while they were also home with their another daughter Alba, two. Speaking on Luke Hamnett's brand new podcast Live Laugh Luke, Charlotte recalled the terrifying incident and admitted she had no idea what to do. She recalled never having felt fear like it and first called her mother Letitia for help rather than 999, because she had never called the police before in her life. 'There's not much to talk about we got broken into and I was pregnant, Jake and Alba were there and it all happened very fast,' she recalled. 'We were downstairs and we heard all these footsteps and we heard these sounds and there was footsteps upstairs and I've never had fear like it and I didn't know what to do. 'Jake went upstairs to get them out and I didn't know what to do. I've never rang the police and instead I rang my mum and I told her to ring the police. 'Jake chased them out, they didn't have time to rob anything. We were already looking at houses to move because our house was too big.' The incident was caught on their baby monitor and Jake chased the masked individuals out while she stood at the bottom of the stairs holding their daughter Alba. Following the ordeal, Charlotte put their house up for sale and insisted she won't be revealing the location of her new pad after shelling out on extra security measures. She recently told The Sun: 'I won't share my house anywhere online again. 'We have very intense security now and it's very expensive. It's everything you can imagine for very close protection we have - but no bodyguard!' Charlotte also discussed the ordeal on her Paramount+ reality series Geordie Stories: Charlotte's New Baby, saying she had not yet had any update from the police. 'The worst thing that could ever happen to us happened and it was all captured on Alba's baby monitor,' she recalled on the show earlier this year. 'I was at the bottom of the stars with Alba and Jake literally chased them out of the house. I cannot believe how brave he was. 'Not knowing what was going to happen was the scariest, scariest moment of my life. We're scared to be in our own home.' Charlotte was eight months pregnant at the time and welcomed her daughter Pixie just weeks after later on January 31. The couple moved into the house together in 2021 and then renovated the sprawling property, which was said to be worth in excess of £1million.
BBC News
13 minutes ago
- BBC News
Police investigate attempted rape in Reading town centre
Police are investigating after a woman in her 20s was subjected to a sexual assault and attempted rape in Reading town centre. The victim was approached by an unknown man in Merchant's Place between 03:00 BST and 03:45 on offender was described as being Asian or Russian, about 5ft 7in (1.7m) tall, with lots of facial hair and long, straight black Valley Police, which is appealing for witnesses, said the woman was being supported by specially trained officers. Det Insp Stuart Streeter said: "We understand this sexual assault and attempted rape will cause concern but we are carrying out a thorough investigation."He added that there would be extra police officers in the town centre this weekend. You can follow BBC Berkshire on Facebook, X (Twitter), or Instagram.
