Q3: 2.4pc growth
EDITORIAL: Pakistan's economy rose by 2.4 percent during the third quarter of the current fiscal year (July-March 2025) as per the Pakistan Bureau of Statistics.
The credibility of this metric is suspect, given that the projection for the previous two quarters have been revised by the PBS (Pakistan Bureau of Statistics): upgraded to 1.37 percent July-September 2024 against the earlier calculation of 1.34 percent and downgraded to 1.53 percent October-December 2024 against the earlier calculation of 1.73 percent.
The in-house capacity to address important gaps in the statistics as per the first review documents uploaded by the International Monetary Fund on its website this Saturday past is being strengthened and 'efforts to enhance the national accounts continue with the PBS publishing quarter estimates of expenditure side for the first time in December.'
The Fund further referred to a Memorandum of Economic and Financial Policy (read time bound condition) item that stipulates that 'Data collection for three major surveys (Agriculture Census, Labour Force Survey and Household Integrated Economic Survey) is well underway and the Pakistan Bureau of Statistics will publish the final reports (and post the results to the National Summary Data Page portal) by end December 2025, which will provide a better basis to assess recent developments in key areas of the macroeconomic statistics, and for assessing the adequacy of social spending.
Work on a new PPI index has also progressed, including on agreeing modalities with provincial statistics agencies for monthly data collection starting in July 2025. Preparations are also underway to conduct three major surveys in FY26: the Census of Manufacturing Industries, the survey of Small and Household Manufacturing Industries, and the Family Budget Survey, which will incorporate spending on online platforms for the first time.'
Calculation of these statistics and the gradual improvement of the capacity to be more accurate and credible than has been the case so far would, one hopes, be used by the Ministry of Finance to take timely decisions rather than allowing an impending financial crisis to compel the administration to seek IMF support.
Given the fact that we are currently on the twenty-fourth Fund bailout package disturbingly indicates lack of credible data to take timely decisions, a drawback, that many independent economists accuse successive administrations of purposely manipulating, but also the root cause of Pakistan's current indebtedness.
The Fund in its report maintained that 'work on strengthening the Government Financial Statistics is continuing, with the establishment of a GFS team and agreement of a multi-year roadmap for GFS expansion and improvements, including transitioning to GFSM 2014 and incorporating state-owned entities' data.' Or, in other words, there is substantial work involved to strengthen the PBS but more importantly one would hope that the practice of exerting political pressure to manipulate data is abandoned.
It is important to note that the growth of 2.4 percent for the third quarter remains suspect for two reasons. First, the administrative measures to meet the IMF condition of ensuring full-cost recovery of poorly performing utilities has raised input costs across the board, which together with tight monetary policy (11 percent discount rate remains higher than the regional average) accounts for negative large scale manufacturing sector growth.
And the IMF condition to withdraw industrial incentives (export specific or more general) as well as federal and provincial governments no longer engaging in announcing a support price for some major crops is likely to reduce output next fiscal year. The major growth prospect remains the Public Sector Development Programme, which, historically, is mercilessly slashed as and when the authorities fail to meet the budget deficit target.
The growth projection for the current year of 2.6 percent, revised from the earlier estimate of 3.2 percent, by the Fund requires an overambitious growth target in the last quarter, given that the first quarter target is estimated at 1.37 percent, second at 1.53 percent and in the third quarter 2.4 percent.
Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Recorder
18 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Weekly SPI up by 0.02pc
ISLAMABAD: The SPI for the current week ended on June 04, 2025 increased by 0.02 percent. An increase is observed in the prices of tomatoes (16.94 percent), potatoes (11.52 percent), onions (5.21 percent), bananas (1.57 percent), eggs (1.34 percent), sugar (1.24 percent), rice basmati broken (1.02 percent), gur (0.81 percent), masoor (0.65 percent), milk fresh (0.47 percent), maash (0.46 percent), pulse gram (0.44 percent) and petrol (0.41 percent), says Pakistan Bureau of Statistics (PBS). The Year-on-Year trend depicts decrease of 0.02 percent. The major increase is observed in ladies sandal (55.62 percent), eggs (35.36 percent), moong (31.74 percent), powdered milk (23.82 percent), sugar (23.51 percent), beef (17.51 percent), bananas (17.29 percent), pulse gram (15.91 percent), chicken (15.88 percent), LPG (15.31 percent), vegetable ghee 2.5kg (13.56 percent) and vegetable ghee 1kg (12.49 percent), while major decrease is observed in the prices of onions (64.90 percent), electricity charges for q1 (36.54 percent), garlic (27.79 percent), potatoes (23.15 percent), tomatoes (18.10 percent), maash (17.99 percent), tea Lipton (17.93 percent), wheat flour (14.10 percent), chilies powder (5.74 percent), diesel (5.68 percent), rice Irri (5.56 percent), masoor(5.47 percent) and petrol (5.41 percent). During the week, out of 51 items, prices of 18 (35.29 percent) items increased, six (11.77 percent) items decreased and 27 (52.94 percent) items remained stable. The SPI for the consumption group up to Rs17,732, Rs17,732-Rs22,888, Rs22,889-Rs29,517, Rs29,518-Rs44,175 and above Rs44,175 increased by 0.28 percent, 0.18 percent, 0.10 percent, 0.04 percent and 0.05 percent respectively. The items prices of which increased during the period under review include, tomatoes 1kg (18.10 percent), potatoes 1kg (23.15 percent), onions 1kg (64.90 percent, bananas (kela) local 1 dozen (17.29 percent), eggs hen (farm) 1 dozen (1.34 percent), sugar refined 1kg (1.24 percent), rice basmati broken (average quality) 1kg (1.02 percent), gur (average quality) 1kg (0.81 percent), masoor (washed) 1kg (0.65 percent), milk fresh (un-boiled) 1 litre (0.47 percent), maash (washed) 1kg (0.46 percent), pulse gram 1kg (0.44 percent), petrol super per litre (0.41 percent), wheat flour bag 20kg (0.41 percent), moong (washed) 1kg (0.21 percent), shirting (average quality) 1 mtr (0.15 percent), rice IRRI-6/9 (Sindh/Punjab) 1kg (0.13 percent), and mustard oil (average quality)1kg (0.05 percent). Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Express Tribune
19 hours ago
- Express Tribune
GDP growth forecasted at mere 2.44%
Listen to article Pakistan's economy continues to face challenges in achieving meaningful growth, with projections for the fiscal year 2024-25 indicating a slow recovery. According to estimates from the Lahore School of Economics Modelling Lab, GDP growth is expected to reach only 2.44%, reflecting a slight improvement from the 1.7% growth recorded in the previous fiscal year but still remaining below par. These projections broadly align with official figures, including a recent revision by the Pakistan Bureau of Statistics, which lowered its Q3 GDP growth estimate from 2.7% to 2.4%. While international institutions such as the World Bank, International Monetary Fund (IMF), and Asian Development Bank (ADB) have provided slightly higher projections ranging from 2.5% to 2.7%, the overall picture still reflects a sluggish economic recovery. One of the main reasons for the weak growth outlook is the poor performance in key productive sectors, particularly manufacturing and agriculture. Large-Scale Manufacturing (LSM), which should ideally be a driving force for GDP growth, has contracted by 1.9% during the current fiscal year. This continues a trend of stagnation and decline observed over the past two years. In the absence of manufacturing growth, the economy has had to rely heavily on agriculture. However, the agricultural sector has also underperformed, growing at just 0.56%only a quarter of its historical trend rate. The disappointing agricultural growth is largely due to a significant contraction in the production of major crops. Wheat production has dropped by 9%, from 32 million tonnes to 29 million tonnes, while maize has declined by 15%, from 10 million tonnes to 8 million tonnes. Sugarcane production fell by 4%, and rice saw a marginal decrease of 1.4%. Cotton suffered the sharpest fall, contracting by 31%, with output reducing from 10 million to 7 million bales. Analysts argue that this sharp decline cannot be blamed on weather patterns, which have remained consistent. Instead, they attribute the drop to government policy changesmost notably, the removal of long-standing support prices for key crops, a decision that has likely discouraged production. Furthermore, the Pakistan Bureau of Statistics (PBS) measures these crop contractions only in terms of volume, not monetary value. This may result in an underestimation of the actual impact on GDP. For instance, the price of wheat has declined by about Rs1,000 per 40 kg compared to the previous season, reducing the overall value of wheat production by nearly 25%. This translates to significant income losses for farmers and suggests that the real contraction in the agricultural sector could be even worse than officially reported. On the inflation front, the situation has improved compared to previous years, but it still remains a concern. Inflation for FY202425 is projected at 8.37% by the Lahore School's model, higher than the government's upper-end estimate of 7.5% and significantly above the IMF's estimate of 5.1%. The major driver of high inflation in recent years has been the depreciation of the exchange rate, which has now somewhat stabilised due to more effective monetary policies and intervention by the State Bank of Pakistan (SBP). However, energy prices remain a key contributor to inflation. It is estimated that they add around 4% to the inflation rate, primarily due to increased government taxes rather than higher supplier costs. There has been a trade-off between taming inflation and stimulating growth. The current low inflation has come at the cost of stifling agriculture, the only productive sector showing some promise in the absence of manufacturing growth. Experts warn that while bringing inflation down is important, it should not come at the cost of agricultural output, especially when manufacturing is already in decline. Another structural challenge remains the current account deficit, which has long constrained Pakistan's GDP growth. Historical data show that whenever GDP growth exceeds 5%, the current account deficit tends to widen sharply due to increased imports, which are highly sensitive to economic growth. While remittances provide temporary relief, they are not a sustainable solution. With global trade becoming more volatile due to tariff wars and changing regulations, the potential for export-led growth appears to be diminishing. One proposed solution is to focus on investment-led growth by liberalising the import of investment goods. This would allow domestic industries to upgrade their capabilities and drive growth, provided that non-essential consumption imports are controlled to maintain current account balance. Overall, the outlook for Pakistan's economy remains cautious. While inflation is being brought under control, the country has yet to find a solid path to sustainable and inclusive growth. Both manufacturing and agriculture need policy support, and investment strategies must be realigned to address structural weaknesses in the economy, the LSE Modelling Lab added.
Business Recorder
2 days ago
- Business Recorder
Budget consultation with IMF
EDITORIAL: Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif while speaking to a group of journalists in Peshawar stated that ongoing negotiations on the budget 2025-26 with the International Monetary Fund (IMF) under the ongoing 7 billion-dollar Extended Fund Facility (EFF) programme have been successful. He did not elaborate, thereby prompting several analysts to define success as the Fund agreeing to the government proposals on at least three major components of the budget where there was reported disagreement. First, reducing the tax on the salaried people, which was raised in the current year's budget, accounts for no feel-good factor in spite of the consumer price index plummeting to 0.3 percent in April, though there was an upward revision last month to 3.5 percent. The Fund's first review documents stipulate that EFF tax target was surpassed to reach 10.7 percent of GDP instead of the budgeted 10.6 percent of GDP, which can be sourced to the decline in GDP to 2.6 as opposed to the projected 3.2 percent. However, next fiscal year the Fund projects direct tax collections at 5 percent of GDP, against 3.8 percent this year, which would necessitate considerable widening of withholding taxes levied in the sales tax mode, an indirect tax whose incidence on the poor is greater than on the rich, which account for nearly 70 to 75 percent of all direct tax collections. This, in turn, may again be a challenge to the feel-good factor by the salaried people, especially as inflation is projected to rise between 5 to 7 percent next year. Second, discussions between the Pakistani authorities and the Fund have reportedly centered on the need to end the traditional fiscal incentives to specific industries and to desist from procuring farm products, particularly wheat after announcing a support price. In this context, it is relevant to note that the Ministry of Industries is proposing fiscal and monetary incentives in order to fuel the wheels of industry, given that the large-scale manufacturing sector has been registering negative growth for the past three to four years. Additionally, wheat prices have plummeted this year due to provincial governments being barred from procuring wheat as per EFF condition and it is feared that next year's crop would not be able to meet domestic demand as farmers shift to growing more profitable crops. Subsidies therefore may be more than the budgeted target next year to forestall public discontent at higher wheat prices. Reports also indicate that the Fund has agreed not to insist on doubling the federal excise duty on fertilizers — from 5 to 10 percent but again this would imply that taxes would have to be generated from another source, which historically has implied widening the net of indirect taxes. And finally, the Fund in its uploaded documents envisaged a decline in current expenditure as a percentage of GDP from 18.9 percent of GDP this year to 17.8 percent next year. Given the projected growth rate next fiscal year of 3.6 percent, one percent higher than this year, the Fund envisages current expenditure to decline from 14 percent of GDP this year to 12.7 percent next year — a decline that would nonetheless consist of a rise in total terms — from this year's projection of 16.15 trillion rupees to 16.86 trillion rupees next year. This implies in actual terms the government has reduced current expenditure from what was budgeted for this year by one trillion rupees or an exact match to the shortfall in FBR revenue collection for the first eleven months. It is unclear whether the Fund's projections will be reflected in the budget due next week. Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif, supported by the Fund and his economic team leaders, reiterated that economic stability has been achieved. This is supported by data relating to foreign exchange reserves held by the State Bank of Pakistan (11.5 billion dollars on 23 May though rollovers by friendly countries are of 16 billion dollars), the trade deficit remains sustainable even though it has risen to 21.3 billion dollars July-April 2025 against 19.6 billion dollars in the comparable period the year before (but remains lower than the average of previous years), and the rupee-dollar parity continues to fluctuate within a narrow range with the fund urging the SBP towards 'a more flexible exchange rate should be an integral part of Pakistan's policy framework facilitating a smooth adjustment of the economy in the face of external and domestic shocks.' To conclude, the time for complacency is not at hand and as the Fund states the 'gains are still fragile and policy and reform efforts need to be sustained to strengthen public finances, rebuild external buffers. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
