Men being over-treated for prostate cancer, says charity
NICE recommends that monitoring, using blood tests and scans, should be offered to the lowest risk cases, where nine in 10 will have no signs of cancer spreading within five years.But research has suggested this could be extended to the next lowest risk group where eight in 10 men will have no signs of cancer spreading.
Evidence gathered by Prostate Cancer UK suggests many hospitals have started offering monitoring to this wider group of patients, but a quarter have not.According to the charity's analysis:in some hospitals in England, 24% of patients who could be monitored, instead undergo treatmentacross the UK, an average of 8% of men who could be monitored are treated instead, amounting to 5,000 a yearSome of this could be down to patient choice – men are generally given the option of treatment even if they are at low-risk.But the charity said if the NHS was more active in offering monitoring it could help strengthen the case for prostate cancer screening, which has gained traction since the diagnosis of Olympic cyclist Sir Chris Hoy.One argument against screening is that the prostate specific antigen (PSA) blood test, used to spot potential signs of the cancer, is unreliable and leads to unnecessary treatment.Amy Rylance of Prostate Cancer UK, said: "To reduce the harm caused by prostate cancer and build the foundations for a screening programme, we need to both save lives and prevent unnecessary treatment."One patient who opted for monitoring was Michael Lewis, 63, from the West Midlands.He was diagnosed with prostate cancer in 2020 and, as it was judged low-risk, he opted for monitoring. Four years later tests suggested the cancer was worsening so he had his prostate removed. He said delaying treatment was so valuable."I was able to continue my everyday life with no side effects."NICE said the organisation was reviewing the prostate cancer guidelines and looking to update them."We are committed to ensuring our guidelines continue to reflect the best available evidence and give patients the best possible outcomes," said a spokesman.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
24 minutes ago
- The Independent
Parents who advised daughter against chemotherapy warned over inquest behaviour
The parents of a Cambridge graduate who refused chemotherapy after being diagnosed with cancer have both been warned about their behaviour in court during an inquest into her death. Paloma Shemirani, 23, collapsed on July 19 last year and was taken to Royal Sussex County Hospital where she died five days later. She had earlier declined treatment for non-Hodgkin lymphoma. Her mother, Kay 'Kate' Shemirani, a prominent online conspiracy theorist and her father, Dr Faramarz Shemirani, who is 'sympathetic' to his ex-wife's views, believe medical professionals are to blame for their daughter's death. Coroner Catherine Wood, presiding over the inquest at Kent and Medway Coroner's Court in Maidstone, left the court due to the behaviour of Miss Shemirani's parents on Tuesday afternoon. The inquest, which was originally scheduled to conclude on Wednesday, had been extended as the evidence and questioning of witnesses had taken longer than anticipated. On Tuesday, Mrs Shemirani, who was struck off as a nurse in 2021 after spreading harmful misinformation about Covid-19, was cross-examined by Dr Shemirani. Questioning broke down when Dr Shemirani, who is understood to have a PhD in computational fluid dynamics, tried to ask his ex-wife's opinion of medical evidence which she would then try to answer, despite warnings from the coroner. 'Mrs Shemirani, I've told you not to speak, I'll find you in contempt if you keep on speaking now,' the coroner said. 'Confine (yourself) to asking questions of this witness as a witness of fact,' she told Dr Shemirani. As Dr Shemirani argued back through his video-link, the coroner said: 'Dr Shemirani, challenge me by judicial review later' before trying to move on. 'Of course I will, of course I will,' he replied. Later, Dr Shemirani once again tried to ask questions which had already been ruled irrelevant by the coroner. 'I'm going to rise for a few minutes because I'm finding it incredibly difficult to keep you on track,' said Ms Wood. Dr Shemirani continued to speak until the coroner shouted 'Dr Shemirani, listen'. 'Your behaviour has been bordering on contemptuous to the court – when I make a ruling on something you cannot come back,' she added. Mrs Shemirani also accused osteopath Nick Gosset of lying under oath earlier in the inquest. Mr Gosset treated Miss Shemirani the day she collapsed and said she had appeared to be in the 'last stages of a very difficult disease'. He told the court that when he inspected her, he could feel lumps in her right shoulder going all the way up into her neck, which he identified as lymphoid mass and that he 'had never seen anything like it' in 43 years of practice. Mr Gosset told the court: 'It was obvious to me that I was not the right person to be helping her, normally you see a patient like that, you would refer her (to a GP). 'Any referral was refused – when I suggested that the proper avenue of approach was through a normal, medical channel she dismissed it. On Tuesday, Paloma's mother said 'his statement under oath is completely opposed with the truth' and has argued her daughter was healthy the day she collapsed. The inquest continues on Wednesday.
Times
an hour ago
- Times
NHS landlord Assura backs takeover by PHP in boost for London
Two large NHS landlords are to merge after shareholders voted to pursue a tie-up rather than selling to KKR, the American private equity group, for £1.7 billion. Assura shareholders had until Tuesday to decide whether to take the cash offer tabled by KKR and Stonepeak Partners, its bidding partner, or merge with Primary Health Properties (PHP) instead. Both sides needed a simple majority to claim victory. Defying expectations of a closer vote, 62.9 per cent backed the PHP merger. KKR and Stonepeak got less than 17 per cent. Andrew Saunders, a real estate industry analyst at Peel Hunt, said it was 'not only a victory for [PHP] but also one for critical UK infrastructure, the UK stock market, the delivery of healthcare in the British Isles and society at large in our view'.
BBC News
an hour ago
- BBC News
Dudley's Russells Hall Hospital uses AI to help stroke patients
Stroke patients at a hospital are receiving a faster diagnosis with the help of artificial intelligence (AI) Hall Hospital in Dudley introduced RapidAI into its stroke unit in May 2024, with the technology speeding up the triage process for patients by providing instant access to diagnostic minister Stephen Kinnock visited the hospital on Tuesday, where he saw the "potentially life-saving improvement" in of the latest patients to benefit is Patrick Potter from Stourbridge, who had a stroke on Thursday and suffered a bleed on the brain. Mr Potter's scan was sent straight to his consultant's mobile phone, resulting in quicker diagnosis and treatment - and with a stroke, doctors say every minute 62-year-old said the technology was "absolutely brilliant"."I don't know to what extent or what damage it would have done to my brain," he said."Initially I was terrified because I've never had anything happen like that before, but within a few days [I was told] it looks like it'll be able to recover and you'll be okay." While visiting the hospital on Tuesday, Kinnock said: "Within seconds of the scan taking place, the consultants are able to see exactly what the issue is in terms of what has caused the stroke."That speed of information is then shared through an app with all the relevant consultants, the quicker they get the diagnosis, the quicker they can decide what treatment is required."He added: "This use of AI can slash the time between someone showing symptoms of stroke to getting treatment by up to an hour – a potentially life-saving improvement. When it comes to strokes, every second counts." Diagnosis within an hour The technology speeds up the triage process by providing instant access to diagnostic imaging, accompanied by preliminary reports for clinicians to quickly verify and act upon – significantly improving response times and technology also flags suspected strokes in patients that may not show traditional clinical signs, such as speech problems or a droopy face or means patients can receive potentially life-saving treatments its implementation at Dudley Group NHS Foundation Trust in May 2024, the technology has meant patients were able to be diagnosed within 40-60 minutes, which is up to 1 hour faster than diagnoses without AI. The government is planning to roll out the use of AI across the country as part of the NHS's shift from analogue to digital systems, a 10-year plan called the Plan for Change. Kinnock said: "Artificial intelligence and digital tech are central to our 10 year health plan, helping patients be seen faster to improve outcomes so they can get home sooner." Follow BBC Birmingham on BBC Sounds, Facebook, X and Instagram.
