Children's Health Ireland report referred to gardaí
Children's Health Ireland
(CHI) is to be referred to
gardaí
, the Cabinet committee on health has been told.
The report, which not been published but has been widely reported in some media outlets, has caused shock in Government over the past week.
The revelations come after a series of scandals in CHI, which is due to run the new
national children's hospital
when it opens.
The Cabinet committee on health was told on Wednesday that the Health Service Executive (HSE) has referred the report to the Garda with a view to it being assessed for a possible investigation.
READ MORE
The meeting was attended by Taoiseach
Micheál Martin
, Tánaiste
Simon Harris
, Minister for Health
Jennifer Carroll
MacNeill, Minister for Finance Paschal Donohoe, Minister for Public Expenditure Jack Chambers and Minister for Children Norma Foley.
[
Audit of CHI waiting lists ordered to ensure productivity in public hospitals, Minister for Health says
Opens in new window
]
The
National Treatment Purchase Fund
(NTPF), which buys treatments in the public and private sectors for patients on long waiting lists, has said it will pause funding for CHI while potential irregularities are investigated. Ms Carroll MacNeill has assured parents scheduled surgeries will not be delayed.
Earlier this week, The Irish Times reported further findings, including about reports of a 'toxic' work culture in parts of a CHI hospital, where there were complaints of bullying and victimisation of trainees, and where one consultant had taken proceedings for defamation against another.
The CHI internal report was drawn up in late 2021/early 2022 but was not given to the then minister for health, the HSE or the NTPF.
The report found CHI had a 'broken culture' created by dysfunctional relationships and challenging behaviour.
It said there were also concerns about management of NTPF funding and a lack of oversight of access initiatives that ultimately were not in keeping with a memorandum of understanding between CHI and the NTPF.
[
CHI consultant at centre of review did not fulfil on-call hours for three years due to 'health issues'
Opens in new window
]
The report raised concerns about five special weekend out-patient clinics for 179 children carried out by a consultant. These were funded by the NTPF. The consultant received €35,800 for seeing these patients at the special out-patient clinics that operated over five Saturdays.
The report questioned whether these clinics were needed and suggested the patients could have been treated by other doctors in the public system.
On Tuesday the NTPF suspended payments on a temporary basis pending an investigation into the operation of the waiting list schemes in CHI.
According to the report, which CHI said it cannot publish for legal reasons, the consultant was indefinitely removed from on-call duty for 'health reasons' in 2019, a commitment under his public contract.
CHI hired a locum to fill these hours, spending about €450,000 on the locum between 2019 and when the review took place in 2021.
The report said : 'It needs to be explored how one consultant can undertake a series of NTPF-funded clinics over numerous Saturdays and during these clinics see a much greater number of patients than they are able to see in their routine public clinics, working at a very fast pace with significant throughput – a substantial undertaking of additional work, yet is unfit for any on-call duties for the past three years.'
The NTPF-funded clinics were not sought by or offered to any of the other eight general surgeons in CHI, it said .
In a statement earlier this week, CHI said the NTPF-funded clinics were a waiting-list initiative and were 'over and above the consultant's contractual hours'.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
Mairead McGuinness to drop out of presidential race
Former European Commissioner and MEP Mairead McGuinness is dropping out of the presidential election race for health reasons. In a statement she said: 'I have made the very difficult decision to withdraw my name as the Fine Gael nominee for the Presidential election. 'This decision is not lightly taken and follows a stay in hospital last week. 'My priority now is my health. Given that the election is in a short couple of months, I do not believe that I have the strength to give the campaign my all.' READ MORE 'I am taking this decision on medical advice and while it is extremely difficult, it is the right decision for me and my family.' Ms McGuinness was one of just two official candidates in the race and she led recent opinion polls . Her surprise departure from the race throws the election wide open. The other candidate who has enough confirmed support to secure a place on the ballot paper is Independent TD Catherine Connolly who has the backing of The Social Democrats, Labour and People Before Profit. Fianna Fáil and Sinn Féin are still deliberating on their approach to the presidential election and whether or not they will run candidates. In recent days businessman Gareth Sheridan has announced his intention to run saying he will seek nominations from local authorities . People who wish to enter the race must have nominations from 20 Oireachtas members or four county or city councils. In her statement Ms McGuinness said: 'I appreciate that this will come as a shock and disappointment to party members and colleagues in Fine Gael, but our political family is strong. 'I have spoken with the Tánaiste and Party leader, Simon Harris, and thank him for his support and understanding. 'I also want to thank all of those people who have done so much to support me, now and in the past. 'My focus now is my health and my family, and I ask for privacy in the time ahead.' Mr Harris said: 'Mairead McGuinness has made an incredible contribution to public life in Ireland and in Europe. 'It was our clear view in Fine Gael and the view of many people across Ireland that Mairead would make an excellent President of Ireland. 'Mairead's health will not now allow this. 'This has come as an awful shock to us all. Mairead is a valued member of our Fine Gael family. It is absolutely essential that she now prioritises her health and I know I speak for everyone when I wish her all the very best on that journey. 'In the coming days, Fine Gael, like others, will consider further the presidential election. Our Executive Council will convene to do this. 'But that's for the time ahead, not for today. Today I want to pay tribute to Mairead. I want to thank her for all she has done. I want to wish her and Tom and their family all the best at this time and she knows we are all sending her our very best.'
Irish Times
6 hours ago
- Irish Times
Data watchdog opens ‘inquiry' into CHI Tallaght over safety of children's records
The Data Protection Commission has opened an 'inquiry' into Children's Health Ireland (CHI) Tallaght relating to the physical safety and security of children's health records. Last month The Irish Times reported that the watchdog had conducted an unannounced inspection of a shared office for nonconsultant hospital doctors on the first floor of the hospital on July 16th. It is understood the door to the shared office, containing hundreds of patient charts, was propped open – making it accessible to people walking by. When closed properly, the door is locked with a keypad. In a statement on Thursday, the watchdog said it became aware there were 'potential issues' at the site from a number of different sources, including protected disclosures and a breach notification submitted to it by CHI. READ MORE 'This formal inquiry will examine CHI's compliance with their GDPR obligations, in particular relating to the security of personal data and the processes that CHI have in place for managing physical records at CHI (Tallaght),' the statement said. On the day after the unannounced inspection, Dr Turlough Bolger, a consultant in emergency medicine, sent an email to staff at the hospital highlighting concerns expressed by the commission. 'The report will be received in the coming weeks but they expressed concern regarding the number of charts in the room yesterday (about 320 charts) and the amount of loose pages with patient details,' his email states. 'I expect that the recommendations will be wide-ranging and damaging to CHI at Tallaght.' Dr Bolger said he appreciated the 'hard work' made by staff to reduce the number of outstanding discharge charts in recent weeks, which had seen a 'significant reduction' from 900 to 600 charts. 'I have said repeatedly that there needs to be a sustainable approach to this issue. Ultimately, as the accountable officer in CHI at Tallaght, I am responsible for the overall situation regarding medical records.' Dr Bolger said, as the accountable officer, he 'cannot rely on blitzes to clear backlogs as routine'. In order to clear the current backlog, Dr Bolger said he had requested that four nonconsultant hospital doctors be allocated to discharges daily. He added that there needed to be 'an emphasis on the use of the confidential shredding bin for most of the loose pages'. A spokeswoman for CHI said 'immediate measures' were taken after the unannounced inspection to reduce potential risks, 'including reinforcing physical safeguards and engaging directly with staff'. 'Additional actions will follow, as appropriate, in line with our internal procedures and any recommendations issued by the DPC as part of its broader oversight,' she said. The spokeswoman added that CHI was transitioning to a 'fully digital health records system and, once complete, this will significantly reduce reliance on paper charts'.
Irish Times
6 hours ago
- Irish Times
DPC opens ‘inquiry' into CHI over safety of children's records at Tallaght hospital
The Data Protection Commission (DPC) has opened an 'inquiry' into Children's Health Ireland (CHI) relating to the physical safety and security of children's health records at its Tallaght hospital. Last month, The Irish Times reported the watchdog conducted an unannounced inspection of a shared office for non-consultant hospital doctors (NCHDs) on the first floor of the hospital on July 16th. It is understood the door to the shared office, containing hundreds of patient charts, was propped open – making it accessible to people walking by. When closed properly, the door is locked with a keypad. In a statement on Thursday, the DPC said it became aware there were 'potential issues' at the site from a number of different sources, includingprotected disclosures and a breach notification submitted to the DPC by CHI. READ MORE 'This formal inquiry will examine CHI's compliance with their GDPR obligations, in particular relating to the security of personal data and the processes that CHI have in place for managing physical records at CHI (Tallaght),' the statement said. On the day after the unannounced inspection, Dr Turlough Bolger, a consultant in emergency medicine, sent an email to staff at the hospital highlighting concerns expressed by the commission. 'The report will be received in the coming weeks but they expressed concern regarding the number of charts in the room yesterday (approx 320 charts) and the amount of loose pages with patient details,' his email states. 'I expect that the recommendations will be wide-ranging and damaging to CHI at Tallaght.' Dr Bolger said he appreciates the 'hard work' made by staff to reduce the number of outstanding discharge charts in recent weeks, which has seen a 'significant reduction' from 900 to 600 charts. 'I have said repeatedly that there needs to be a sustainable approach to this issue. Ultimately, as the accountable officer in CHI at Tallaght, I am responsible for the overall situation regarding medical records.' Dr Bolger said as the accountable officer, he 'cannot rely on blitzes to clear backlogs as routine'. In order to clear the current backlog, Dr Bolger said he had requested that four NCHDs be allocated to discharges daily. He added that there was a need for 'an emphasis on the use of the confidential shredding bin for most of the loose pages'. A spokeswoman for CHI said 'immediate measures' were taken after the unannounced inspection to reduce potential risks, 'including reinforcing physical safeguards and engaging directly with staff'. 'Additional actions will follow, as appropriate, in line with our internal procedures and any recommendations issued by the DPC as part of its broader oversight,' she said. The spokeswoman added that CHI is transitioning to a 'fully digital health records system and, once complete, this will significantly reduce reliance on paper charts'.
