You may not be able to get a Lotto ticket after today
'I do not accept that the sky will fall' says judge
The National Lotteries Commission (NLC) has failed in its bid to change a recent court ruling limiting the temporary licence to operate the lottery to five months.
This means ticket sales may stop before Sunday, 1 June.
The current licence, held by Ithuba Holdings, expires on Saturday. After that, their sister company, Ithuba Lottery, was supposed to take over the licence for a period of twelve months.
But after last week's Gauteng High Court ruling that the issuing of the temporary licence is unconstitutional and can only be issued for five months, Ithuba Lottery said a five-month licence is financially unfeasible and may not continue operating the lottery after Saturday.
And the new licence holder, Sizekhaya Holdings, which is set to take over from Ithuba Lottery for a period of eight years, will need at least nine months to set up its operations.
The NLC therefore applied to change the court order to allow a twelve-month licence. But Judge Omphemetse Mooki ruled against them on Friday.
Will funding stop?
A source at the NLC told GroundUp that the board is in emergency meetings to discuss the way forward.
If lottery ticket sales do stop after Saturday, the National Lottery Distribution Fund does still have about R4.3-billion in reserves to continue issuing grants to good causes.
The NLC's application, which was heard urgently on Thursday at the High Court in Pretoria, was opposed by Wina Njalo, one of the companies that bid on the lottery licence tender.
Wina Njalo argued that the NLC was seeking to relitigate the same issues that had already been heard by the court. If it was found that five months was not enough time, it argued, then the NLC could approach the court at that stage.
It said the application to vary the order was yet another example of how the NLC was seeking to favour the Ithuba companies and they were not entitled to insist on making a profit, given that Ithuba Holdings had already made 'huge profits' by operating the lottery for the last 10 years.
In his ruling, Judge Mooki said the issue was whether it was just and equitable to extend the period that the temporary licence can operate before it is declared invalid and, in doing so, interfere with the discretion exercised by another court.
Such interference was 'very sparingly exercised'.
He said he was not persuaded that the NLC had made out a case.
'There is no substantive support that Ithuba Lottery will suffer a loss of R51-million unless it is granted a temporary licence for 12 months. There was complete silence from Ithuba Lottery. It did not file any affidavits,' the Judge said.
He pointed to the fact that the NLC on 22 May 2025, when it was aware of Judge Potterill's order, had written to Ithuba Lottery requesting it sign a licence to operate for 12 months.
'It was thus inviting the Ithuba Lottery to sign an agreement that would breach the order made on May 21.'
While the NLC had disclosed the response from Ithuba Lottery, it had not disclosed its own letter.
ALSO READ: Big change to Lotto operations: Will tickets be on sale next week?
5 months could be long enough
Judge Mooki said the NLC had also not put up any evidence that Sizekhaya needed more than five months to set up operations.
In fact, as Wina Njalo had pointed out, a condition of the fourth licence was that the successful bidder must be able to operate within five to six months of being awarded the licence.
He said in claiming that its reserves would be significantly depleted should there be no operator after 1 June, the NLC had 'over-egged the pudding'.
'I do not accept that the sky will fall after 1 June should Ithuba Lottery refuse to sign an agreement to conduct lottery operations as determined in (Potterill's) order,' he said.
The request for proposals for the temporary licence was issued when it became apparent that Minister Parks Tau would not meet the strict deadlines to announce the new lottery licence holder, giving it time to take over operations.
He only made the announcement on 28 May, just three days before the expiration of Ithuba's licence. He has yet to provide reasons for the delay.
This article originally appeared on GroundUp and was republished with permission. Read the original article here.
NOW READ: SIU is not done with NLC yet, as more corruption allegations emerge
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Maverick
4 hours ago
- Daily Maverick
Nelson Mandela Bay council to decide this week if electricity tariff will rise by 12%
The Nelson Mandela Bay Municipality will vote on the metro's proposed budget, which includes a 12% increase in electricity tariffs — along with rises for other municipal services. The discussion, however, comes as the Electricity and Energy Directorate finds itself in dire financial and governance straits, with funding still not forthcoming for repairs to the high voltage supply line, which provides power to a large part of the city. The Nelson Mandela Bay metro has admitted in its own Integrated Development Plan that it is to present before council this week that electricity outages in the metro are at an all-time high. Yet the budget for the 2025/2026 financial year proposes that consumers pay 12% more for electricity. The plan notes that the Average System Interruption Frequency Index, which measures how often the average customer experiences outages, has reached record levels, primarily due to high-voltage events. These are caused by cable faults, theft and vandalism of fibre cables that trigger unnecessary feeder trips. The document also notes that outages last longer, with forced load reductions worsening reliability indicators. Meanwhile, the metro's Electricity and Energy Directorate is in a financial crisis, operating at a R1.2-billion loss as it struggles to curb illegal connections, vandalism and the collapse of grid infrastructure. One visible example of municipal inaction is the Grogro informal settlement, where illegal electricity connections stretch across Kragga Kamma Road to a substation. These makeshift cables frequently catch fire. In a letter shared with residents, ward councillor Margaret de Andrade wrote, 'My office has engaged in numerous meetings with the relevant departments on this matter, and we have received commitments on several fronts. However, to date, there has been no meaningful feedback or coordinated action. 'As one of your officials previously stated, 'I have forgotten about Grogro'. 'If this sentiment reflects the current level of attention, it is deeply concerning and unacceptable given the gravity of the situation. 'Unrest risk imminent' 'This is no longer just an operational issue — it is a volatile crisis. The community is growing increasingly frustrated due to the lack of visible intervention, and tensions are rising. The risk of unrest, fires and harm to both residents and municipal staff is imminent. 'I strongly urge all departments to urgently coordinate and communicate with one another. We need immediate alignment between Electricity and Energy, Safety and Security, Legal Services, Human Settlements and Disaster Management.' In addition, according to the metro's reports, about 22% of residential electricity meters have been tampered with. In the proposed budget, it is stated: 'As previously reported to Council, it is important to note that the financial position of the Electricity Service is under immense pressure due to the extent of electricity losses, which impact significantly on the financial sustainability of the municipality. This is supported by the fact that the budget for Electricity Bulk Purchases exceeds the total Electricity Service Charges budget. This means that the Electricity Service, which is a Trading Service, is operating at a substantial deficit, requiring support from property rates.' The 12% proposed tariff hike still needs approval by the National Energy Regulator, and if granted, will kick in on 1 July. However, CEO of the Nelson Mandela Bay Business Chamber Denise van Huyssteen said they had not seen the metro's application to Nersa. This is the first year that Nersa will publish all applications on its website; the metro's application also doesn't appear there. Van Huyssteen pointed out that the manufacturing industry was the metro's largest electricity consumer (about 59%) and as a result, organised business in Nelson Mandela Bay would like to have more input on the electricity budget. Van Huyssteen warned that, at the current trajectory, there was a real risk that the municipality might default on its Eskom bulk electricity payments. She noted that if the increase remained capped at 12%, business was unlikely to oppose it. In 2022, the metro led litigation against Nersa, securing a ruling that the general guideline and benchmarking method the regulator had used to determine increases was unconstitutional. The metro argued that the municipality should be required to show Nersa how much it cost to distribute electricity bought from Eskom. Van Huyssteen said programmes such as the geyser control initiative should be reinstated, as it had collapsed. 'We want to add that the municipality needs the urgent support of Eskom to fix its infrastructure,' she said. An additional threat to the metro's electricity security is the temporary repairs to the high-voltage line that collapsed last year. In April, one of the pylons partially collapsed again, damaging the temporary fix. Ward councillors Sean Tappan and Dries van der Westhuyzen said earlier this month that there was now a temporary repair to the temporary repair.
IOL News
12 hours ago
- IOL News
How deal was struck to save National Lottery from shutdown
Sizekhaya Holdings is led by a consortium that includes KwaZulu-Natal business figures such as Moses Tembe, former Chairperson of the KZN Growth Coalition, and Sandile Zungu, owner of AmaZulu football club. Image: Sihle Mlambo/IOL In tense, last minute discussions at the weekend, Trade, Industry, and Competition Minister Parks Tau intervened to prevent a shutdown of the popular National Lottery. Tau's intervention came after a high-stakes meeting on Saturday with the National Lottery Commission (NLC) and Ithuba, the current lottery operator. The situation arose after a Gauteng High Court ruled that Ithuba's operating license could only be extended for five months, until the new operator, Sizekhaya Holdings takes over. However the NLC had argued that a 12-month temporary license was necessary to ensure a smooth transition, but the court disagreed. However, in a surprise move, Tau announced that he had granted a 12-month temporary license to Ithuba Holdings, allowing them to continue operating the National Lottery from June 1 until the end of May next year - when Sizekhaya Holdings takes over as the operator. According to sources close to Tau, the minister promised Ithuba that they would not lose any revenue and would instead make a profit, although the details of how this would be achieved are not clear. Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Advertisement Next Stay Close ✕ Ad Loading "It was an intense meeting, and the minister knew what impact it would have on the country's economy given the scale of the tender and people relying on playing the lotto week in and week out," a source said. Ithuba had argued in court that if they accepted a five-month extension, they would incur a loss of R51 million. Ithuba has agreed to continue operating the National Lottery, ensuring that all games, draws, and prize payouts will proceed normally. The company has reassured the public that they will maintain their commitment to integrity, transparency, and the benefit of South Africans. "As a proudly 100% black-owned South African operator, Ithuba remains steadfast in its commitment to operate the National Lottery with integrity, transparency, and for the benefit of South Africans," the company stated on Saturday. While this agreement provides short-term relief, the long-term future of the National Lottery remains uncertain. Sizekhaya Holdings, the preferred bidder, is set to take over the lottery in June 2026, but questions remain about the transparency of the licensing process and the impact of further legal challenges. Announcing the preferred bidder Tau said he had received a report from the NLC regarding the satisfactory conclusion of negotiations with the preferred bidder for the Fourth National Lottery and Sports Pools Licence. 'I am pleased to announce that I have awarded Sizekhaya Holdings (RF) (Pty) Ltd ('Sizekhaya') the licence in terms of section 13 of the Lotteries Act 57 of 1997. As I indicated previously, I intended to announce the successful bidder on 28 May 2025 provided that the licence agreement negotiations with the preferred bidder were successfully concluded. I wish to thank the parties to the negotiations for completing their work in time. 'It is most unfortunate that this matter has already become the subject of litigation and a judgment of the High Court. I am seeking legal advice with a view to appealing against the judgment's findings and orders, and I reserve all my rights concerning this judgment. 'With due respect to the Honourable High Court, my announcement is the result of my undertaking made to the bidders and the Court before the hearing of the ends a long and difficult process of evaluating eight applications for the fourth licence. I appreciate that this has been an enormous and complex endeavour,' Tau said. On Sunday, Sizekhaya Holdings chairperson Moses Tembe, expressed his gratitude for being awarded the fourth lottery licence by the National Lottery "We welcome that the honourable Minister of Trade, Industry and Competition, Parks Tau appreciated the power of our vision. When the National Lottery was first mooted after the ushering in of our democracy, the most compelling argument for its existence was income it could generate to help the poorest and most vulnerable of South Africans," said Tembe. Tembe is a co-owner with Sandile Zungu, the owner of Amazulu Football. Ithuba had previously expressed disappointment at the decision to award the license to Sizekhaya Holdings, stating that they had invested significantly in developing the lottery infrastructure and had made significant contributions to good causes. "As a fully South African-owned and black-empowered operator, Ithuba Lottery has invested significantly in developing the first African central lottery system, owned and developed for Africa by South Africans," the company stated.
IOL News
13 hours ago
- IOL News
Transnet secures R51 billion bailout to enhance South Africa's rail and port infrastructure
Analysis by the maritime sector has been mostly positive to the news that Transnet would be receiving a R51 billion bailout for Transnet announced by the Minister of Transport last week. Image: File IT IS HOPED that the R51 billion bailout for Transnet, announced by the Minister of Transport last week, will help revitalise the country's rail and port facilities and secure South Africa's reputation as the gateway into Africa. While it is yet to be established how exactly the entity would get to use the much needed financial assistance, but indications are that it will be directed mainly towards Transnet's debt and infrastructure upgrades. Experts in the maritime sector have been largely upbeat about the Minister of Transport's announcement. Transnet, in a statement, said that it welcomed the minister's R51 billion government guarantee facility to support Transnet's sustainability and long-term growth. 'The facility will enable Transnet to refinance maturing debt and ensure the organisation's continued access to adequate resources and facilities to be able to continue its operations as well as fund the capital investment programme for the foreseeable future.' Dave Watts, a maritime consultant, said that the communication from Transnet does not make clear how much of the R51 billion guarantee will be used to roll over or refinance current debt and how much will be used for increased borrowing. 'Clearly the state guarantees are critical in enabling the organisation to continue as a going concern and provide ongoing services to the SA Logistics sector and broader economy.' Watts added that refinancing maturing debt was not paying debt off; however, it was essential that there was sufficient working capital to enable ongoing operations and capital investments. Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Advertisement Next Stay Close ✕ Ad loading 'Investment in infrastructure and equipment will, in the long run, enable volume and revenue growth, providing the ability to reduce the corporation's substantial debt burden. It is critical for the entire economy that there are sufficient funds to enable Transnet not only to continue operations but to sustain and expand on its current capital expenditure programme.' Malcolm Hartwell, Norton Rose Fulbright director and master mariner, said that Transnet will use the bailout in part to refinance maturing debt, which was reported to be in the region of R120 billion earlier this year. 'It is also going to be used to pursue public sector participation (PSP) transactions being implemented in the port and rail networks. Transnet's capital debt, which has grown significantly over the last decade, is one of the obstacles Transnet faces in its attempt to revitalise the rail and port facilities. Much of its income is being used to service that debt and a bloated wage bill, which has not been helped by its recent agreement with the majority unions on wage increases or its ongoing dispute with United National Transport Union (UNTU) regarding wage increases." Hartwell added that the effect of this is that Transnet has not been in a position to invest at all in maintenance of existing infrastructure or building new infrastructure. 'In part, this has driven Transnet's recent enthusiasm to embrace PSPs, which have seen the signing of a number of agreements for terminal operations in Durban and Richards Bay and its invitation to the private sector to invest in rail operating agreements. The guarantee, which hopefully is closely protected by criteria to ensure that the money is properly invested in infrastructure rather than in wages, has to be welcomed by everybody involved in the logistics network. Hartwell said that Transnet's virtual monopoly over much of South Africa's logistics infrastructure means that its operational efficiency and cost models affect South Africa's entire import and export industry, which is the backbone of South Africa's economy. 'It is trite economic theory that investment in infrastructure creates the most significant return on investment, and it is to be hoped that this guarantee helps Transnet accelerate its privatisation programme. While details of the maturing debt have not been released, if a portion of this guarantee is to help refinance that debt, this must free up capital for investment in maintenance and thereby attract more interest from the private sector in PSPs involving the port and rail networks.' Hartwell added that the guarantee will allow Transnet to continue to operate, and it is to be hoped that this will not be seen by Transnet and its employees as an opportunity to consider carrying on business as usual. 'Given all of the well-publicised recent initiatives, however, it seems likely that the guarantee will help Transnet revitalise the rail and port facilities to enable South Africa to continue to be the gateway into Africa.' A maritime consultant who did not want to be named said that a large portion of the Government bail-out will unfortunately have to be utilised for the purposes of reducing the debt with International Funders secured in EUROS and not all for the acquisition of new equipment. 'This will also unfortunately result in a less than optimum impact of the bail-out on improved operations. For maximum impact on operations, the Government should have a qualifier to the bail-out of the nature that it should largely be used for the acquisition of new equipment.' BUSINESS REPORT Addition reporting: DAILY NEWS
