‘Damned if you do & damned if you don't – Frustrated Irish mum ‘punished' by strict means test while caring for son, 22
A group of family carers met with politicians near
5
Parents forced to leave work to care for their kids are being denied a carer's allowance
Credit: Mark Stedman
5
Carers are urging the Government to live up to its promise to abolish the means test
Credit: Mark Stedman
5
Family Carers Ireland are urging the Government to increase the means test disregard
Credit: Mark Stedman
People who care for a loved one with additional needs can benefit from a carer's allowance worth €260 a week.
However, carers are ruled out of this payment if there is an income of more than €1,250 per week or €625 for a single person – following changes that kicked in this week.
A separate carer's grant of €2,000 is paid out once a year to help with the cost of caring, but to qualify carers must not work more than 18 and half hours a week in a
Both
Read more in News
Lynsey O'Donovan cares for her son, Jack, 22, who has cerebral palsy and is non-verbal, incontinent, and also suffers from epilepsy.
The mum does not qualify for the carer's allowance because her family income is slightly over the threshold.
She told the Irish Sun: 'I'm not recognised as a carer whatsoever because we're slightly over the means test.
'I had to start work last year. So because I started working and in January I did a few hours over the 18 and a half hours you're allowed without thinking and now I didn't get the support grant either.
Most read in The Irish Sun
'You're damned if you do and damned if you don't.
'I feel punished. I get up to turn Jack at least ten times a night and that's on a good night.
'SO FRUSTRATING'
'It is so frustrating that I get no recognition from the State. Lifting that means test would be massive for us.
'I could stop working or even just cut back my hours because I go to work and I'm coming home and Jack is coming home and it is full on.
'He's peg fed. He needs attention 24/7. He's non verbal and incontinent and epilepsy as well. So it would make a massive difference.'
Dubliner Paul Skelly was forced to leave his job during the
'I HAD TO GIVE UP WORK'
Ciara has cerebral palsy, autism and epilepsy.
Due to Paul's job, he did not qualify for the carer's allowance; meanwhile, other people who could not work due to the Covid-19 restricts were receiving €350 a week through the PUP.
He told the Irish Sun: 'When Covid hit, all her services stopped. Moira was the carer. I was working but when the services stopped I had to give up work at 64 to help care for her.
'But I didn't qualify for the carer's allowance. I went on the dole for nine months and then that was cut.
'THEY DON'T LOOK AT THE COST'
'So you had kids on our road with part time jobs that were getting €350 a week and I was getting €50 because I had to leave my job to help care for my daughter because the services stopped.
'I didn't give up to play golf or swan off. I got a lump sum when I left work and that's all gone to sustaining us.
'When you means test everything, they don't look at the cost of everything like adapting work at home – there's grants but they don't come anywhere near the cost so you just re-mortgage and re-mortgage.'
'You're damned if you do and damned if you don't."
Lynsey O'Donovan
Damien Douglas was a psychiatric nurse and his wife was a nurse before she left work to care for their twin daughters Una and Ailis who both have a rare condition called Wolf-Hirschhorn syndrome.
FAMILY THRIVING
The family were told that Una and Ailis would not live for more than two years but both girls are now 30 and thriving under the care of their mam and dad.
However, as Damien continued to work, the family did not get any carer's allowance until this year.
The weekly disregard for the carer's allowance was raised this week to €1,250 for a couple with Damien and his wife now qualifying for a full payment for the first time despite caring for their daughters for decades.
He said: 'Today is the first day that my wife and I have actually got a full carer's allowance because of the new €1,250 allowance.
'IT WAS ROUGH'
'We're well off insofar as we survived without the full carer's allowance, but both of us had to give up work over the years.
'My wife didn't get a pension at all until two years ago. I had a pension but far reduced than what it would have been if I was able to continue working on until I was 65.
'We still managed. Nobody starved in our house and we never missed a
He added: 'If I was an artist struggling I would get €325 a week which was brought in two years ago. The most a carer can get full time is €260 a week or €280 if you're over 60.
'INEQUALITY THAT DOESN'T RING TRUE'
'There is an inequality in that that doesn't ring true. It devalues what we do. It is not seen as being important.'
'I didn't give up to play golf or swan off. I got a lump sum when I left work and that's all gone to sustaining us."
Paul Skelly
A briefing for politicians heard from carers who raised a range of issues from waiting lists for therapies, lack of respite services, complications in transferring to adult services and problems accessing appropriate changing facilities.
Family Carers Ireland are urging the Government to increase the means test disregard to €1,500 per couple and €750 for a single person in the upcoming budget on the pathway to abolishing the test altogether.
The carers group is also urging the Coalition to increase funding for respite services to give carers help in day services or overnight services.
5
Lynsey O'Donovan doesn't qualify because her income is slightly over the threshold
Credit: Sam Boal/Collins
5
The carers group is also urging the Coalition to increase funding for respite services
Credit: Sam Boal/Collins
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Irish Sun
19 hours ago
- The Irish Sun
‘Damned if you do & damned if you don't – Frustrated Irish mum ‘punished' by strict means test while caring for son, 22
PARENTS who have been forced to leave work to care for their children are being denied a carer's allowance due to a strict means test, with one mum claiming: 'I feel like I'm being punished.' A group of family carers met with politicians near 5 Parents forced to leave work to care for their kids are being denied a carer's allowance Credit: Mark Stedman 5 Carers are urging the Government to live up to its promise to abolish the means test Credit: Mark Stedman 5 Family Carers Ireland are urging the Government to increase the means test disregard Credit: Mark Stedman People who care for a loved one with additional needs can benefit from a carer's allowance worth €260 a week. However, carers are ruled out of this payment if there is an income of more than €1,250 per week or €625 for a single person – following changes that kicked in this week. A separate carer's grant of €2,000 is paid out once a year to help with the cost of caring, but to qualify carers must not work more than 18 and half hours a week in a Both Read more in News Lynsey O'Donovan cares for her son, Jack, 22, who has cerebral palsy and is non-verbal, incontinent, and also suffers from epilepsy. The mum does not qualify for the carer's allowance because her family income is slightly over the threshold. She told the Irish Sun: 'I'm not recognised as a carer whatsoever because we're slightly over the means test. 'I had to start work last year. So because I started working and in January I did a few hours over the 18 and a half hours you're allowed without thinking and now I didn't get the support grant either. Most read in The Irish Sun 'You're damned if you do and damned if you don't. 'I feel punished. I get up to turn Jack at least ten times a night and that's on a good night. 'SO FRUSTRATING' 'It is so frustrating that I get no recognition from the State. Lifting that means test would be massive for us. 'I could stop working or even just cut back my hours because I go to work and I'm coming home and Jack is coming home and it is full on. 'He's peg fed. He needs attention 24/7. He's non verbal and incontinent and epilepsy as well. So it would make a massive difference.' Dubliner Paul Skelly was forced to leave his job during the 'I HAD TO GIVE UP WORK' Ciara has cerebral palsy, autism and epilepsy. Due to Paul's job, he did not qualify for the carer's allowance; meanwhile, other people who could not work due to the Covid-19 restricts were receiving €350 a week through the PUP. He told the Irish Sun: 'When Covid hit, all her services stopped. Moira was the carer. I was working but when the services stopped I had to give up work at 64 to help care for her. 'But I didn't qualify for the carer's allowance. I went on the dole for nine months and then that was cut. 'THEY DON'T LOOK AT THE COST' 'So you had kids on our road with part time jobs that were getting €350 a week and I was getting €50 because I had to leave my job to help care for my daughter because the services stopped. 'I didn't give up to play golf or swan off. I got a lump sum when I left work and that's all gone to sustaining us. 'When you means test everything, they don't look at the cost of everything like adapting work at home – there's grants but they don't come anywhere near the cost so you just re-mortgage and re-mortgage.' 'You're damned if you do and damned if you don't." Lynsey O'Donovan Damien Douglas was a psychiatric nurse and his wife was a nurse before she left work to care for their twin daughters Una and Ailis who both have a rare condition called Wolf-Hirschhorn syndrome. FAMILY THRIVING The family were told that Una and Ailis would not live for more than two years but both girls are now 30 and thriving under the care of their mam and dad. However, as Damien continued to work, the family did not get any carer's allowance until this year. The weekly disregard for the carer's allowance was raised this week to €1,250 for a couple with Damien and his wife now qualifying for a full payment for the first time despite caring for their daughters for decades. He said: 'Today is the first day that my wife and I have actually got a full carer's allowance because of the new €1,250 allowance. 'IT WAS ROUGH' 'We're well off insofar as we survived without the full carer's allowance, but both of us had to give up work over the years. 'My wife didn't get a pension at all until two years ago. I had a pension but far reduced than what it would have been if I was able to continue working on until I was 65. 'We still managed. Nobody starved in our house and we never missed a He added: 'If I was an artist struggling I would get €325 a week which was brought in two years ago. The most a carer can get full time is €260 a week or €280 if you're over 60. 'INEQUALITY THAT DOESN'T RING TRUE' 'There is an inequality in that that doesn't ring true. It devalues what we do. It is not seen as being important.' 'I didn't give up to play golf or swan off. I got a lump sum when I left work and that's all gone to sustaining us." Paul Skelly A briefing for politicians heard from carers who raised a range of issues from waiting lists for therapies, lack of respite services, complications in transferring to adult services and problems accessing appropriate changing facilities. Family Carers Ireland are urging the Government to increase the means test disregard to €1,500 per couple and €750 for a single person in the upcoming budget on the pathway to abolishing the test altogether. The carers group is also urging the Coalition to increase funding for respite services to give carers help in day services or overnight services. 5 Lynsey O'Donovan doesn't qualify because her income is slightly over the threshold Credit: Sam Boal/Collins 5 The carers group is also urging the Coalition to increase funding for respite services Credit: Sam Boal/Collins
Irish Independent
a day ago
- Irish Independent
Fr Amos is leaving Kerry and will ‘miss going to Croke Park' the most
Kerry and Tralee have become a second home to Fr Amos since arriving at the dioceses in August 2019 along with Fr Vitalis Barasa. Fr Amos has already been approached about changing his green and gold jersey for a Cork one, but the sense is he is in no rush. It's the little acts of kindness that Fr Amos experienced from parishioners, many miles from his native Kitale in Kenya, that will make certain of Tralee holding a place in his heart long after he crosses the county bounds. Appointed to St Brendan's parish in August 2020, Fr Amos insists Tralee folk made him feel like 'one of their own' – which is the most definitive way Tralee people can give credibility to one's character. Fr Amos was only in Kerry seven months when the COVID pandemic struck. This delayed his interaction with parishioners for over a year. At one point he knew the names, voices and personalities of his parishioners, but not their faces. This was due to compulsory mask wearing. 'It was a difficult start during that time. By then, I was working at St John's after which I moved to St Brendan's Parish. I've had a really good time here,' Fr Amos said. 'I will remember the good people of Tralee, especially at St Brendan's. Fr Padraig (Walsh) has been very supportive to me. I feel very comfortable at St Brendan's and I won't forget the staff at the parish. The entire community of St Brendan's Parish have made me feel welcome and one of their own. I feel a big loss leaving them,' he added. Fr Amos understands his vocation requires him to find pastures new and a new flock. Sad as this is, he is viewing it as a new chapter in his life. 'All credit goes to the people of Tralee for the support they have given me,' he said. 'I must say, it has been a big change in my life. I've adapted to the weather, although at times I still struggle. The language was a struggle a little bit at the start. I'm not perfect now but at least I've experienced a big improvement. When it comes to food, I eat most of the food now. Generally, I feel like I'm more at home,' he added. It didn't take Fr Amos long to discover the place reserved for football in Kerry life. A keen follower of the green and gold and Austin Stacks GAA Club, he was a regular at games in Tralee and enjoyed journeying to Croke Park. 'One of the things I was telling Fr Padraig that I will really miss is going to Croke Park to see Kerry. I don't mean that I'll not be gong to Croke Park now. But being in Castletownbere might be a little bit challenging compared to when I am in Tralee. For sure, that is one thing I will really miss,' he said. 'But I will be attending football games within the county (Cork). If I find the opportunity, I will go to Croke Park. Some people have advised me that I need to have a red jersey now,' he laughs. Lastly, Fr Amos explained that when he first heard the news he was leaving Tralee it brought both sadness and joy. 'Sad because I'm leaving a place where I have settled; a place where I've created friends; a place that was kind of my comfort zone,' he said. 'But also a happy feeling because this is the nature of the ministry. It's also an opportunity to work in a different part of the dioceses and meet different people. It's an opportunity for me to learn and to grow. I will always remember Tralee and I will always come back,' Fr Amos said.
Irish Independent
a day ago
- Irish Independent
Map initiative calls for protection of Ireland's endangered seabirds
But despite laws being passed 46 years ago to safeguard them, the places they feed, roam and spend most of their time are largely unprotected. Birdwatch Ireland now wants the Government to make up for lost time and officially designate key locations around and off the coast as protected areas. The charity has identified 73 strips of coastline and stretches of sea it said meet the criteria for Important Bird and Biodiversity Areas (IBAs) and is calling on the Government to recognise them as a first step towards formal protections. Oonagh Duggan, of Birdwatch Ireland, said such protections were long overdue. 'The European Union Birds Directive dates back to 1979, so that's how long we're waiting,' she said. 'Article four of the directive says sites should be designated for all phases of a bird's life cycle. On land we have some legally created Special Protected Areas [SPAs] for breeding birds but we don't designate out to sea, which is where they feed, winter and generally hang out the rest of the time.' Birdwatch Ireland is proposing that 49 coastal IBAs be created for vital breeding sites and established colonies of birds, with a further 24 marine IBAs out at sea. Marine IBAs are areas where birds have regular feeding grounds and where they exhibit 'rafting' behaviour – gathering in floating groups to socialise and preen under the safety of numbers. IBAs would support 24 species of seabird of all shapes and sizes, from the compact puffin to the hefty gannet, from the little tern to the great skua, from the well-known herring gull to less familiar manx shearwater. The others are black guillemot, common guillemot, Arctic tern, roseate tern, sandwich tern, common tern, kittiwake, shag, cormorant, European storm petrel, Leach's storm petrel, northern fulmar, razorbill, Mediterranean gull, black-headed gull, great black-backed gull, lesser black-backed gull and common gull. All but the great black-backed gull have an unfavourable conservation status, which means their populations are under threat. Pressures include loss of food sources from overfishing, entanglement in fishing nets, predation of nests and chicks by rats and other invasive species and marine pollution, including plastics. They are also suffering from the spread of avian flu, human interference with breeding sites and increasing extreme weather events caused by climate change. Future threats are also identified – including intensification of development at sea when offshore wind projects are built. Birdwatch Ireland is calling on the Government to accept the IBAs and designate all of them as formal SPAs. The organisation is also asking that existing SPAs be reviewed and updated using the new IBA data. It also said management plans must be developed for all IBAs/SPAs with 'clearly defined and quantifiable science-based conservation objectives' and 'conservation measures necessary to achieve these objectives'. It said accompanying 'avian sensitivity maps' should be drawn up to guide activities at sea, in particular the location of offshore renewable projects. While they are not a legal designation, thousands of IBAs are already recognised in many countries and used to inform policymakers in the process of formally declaring protected areas. The EU accepts their validity, as does the European Court of Justice. Global conservation organisation BirdLife International has devised the criteria for declaring an IBA, setting out the research that must be carried out to ensure they are scientifically robust. A detailed report being published today by Birdwatch Ireland was compiled with help from experts at the National Parks and Wildlife Service, University College Cork, University College Dublin, the Royal Society for the Protection of Birds, and universities and research institutes in England, Scotland and Norway. Extensive surveys were carried out and tracking data collated to piece together the most up-to-date picture of the places our seabirds depend on for survival. The public will be able to check out the areas and birds for themselves when Birdwatch Ireland launches an interactive map on its website today. It stressed the initiative is not just critical for Ireland's wildlife but for global biodiversity, as some of the sites host some of the most significant colonies of species in the world. The initiative comes as concern grows over the fate of Government promises to designate 30pc of Ireland's seas as marine protected areas (MPAs). Just 10pc is designated so far and practical protections have not been put in place. Legislation to formally create MPAs has been delayed and Environment Minister Darragh O'Brien indicated this week that he may change tack.
