The Disastrous Effects Of Pine Forests On Our Land And On Ratepayers Pockets
The public made it clear they wanted to end the shocking and predictable pollution from slash and waste logs, putting lives and property at risk, and clogging beaches after each significant rainstorm.
'The RMA and councils are failing the public. It's time for a more careful public focused response." says NZ Outdoors and Freedom Party leader and lawyer Sue Grey. "The common law makes individuals strictly responsible for the consequences of activities on their properties. Every lawyer learns about Rylands v Fletcher and strict liability for harm. Why are councils not holding logging companies responsible under these principles? Why are the public being expected to pay time and time again for the clean ups? How can it be in the public interest for private companies to take the benefits of logging but the public to pay the costs?"
The cost to the taxpayer of cleaning some of the beaches in the Gisborne area resulted in a public outcry. As a result we all thought that might have been the end of the problem. The forestry companies promised that they would amend their harvesting practices.
"Of course it was all posture and hollow words to keep the public quiet" says Alan Simmons of the NZ Outdoors and Freedom Party, who published a report after the East Coast floods. "The same can be said for the Government response which again was nothing but platitudes.'
Take one look at the Tasman District after this latest huge rain event and you wonder why anyone ever wasted breath or ink on their promises.
One of regions favourite beaches , Kaiteriteri Beach, has been left in an appalling state, covered in pine forest logs and waste. Sue Grey leader of the Outdoors & Freedom Party and Nelson Resident is angry about the damage done to this beautiful beach and by the lack of respect for the law by the forestry industry and local council.
Sue Grey wants to know "Why forestry companies are not automatically required to pay for the cleanup and also the economic costs to the local business". She said "These costs should not fall on the ratepayer. The community is tired of the continuous excuses, the never ending slippery answers and the hollow promises they will ""voluntarily amend practices"", to avoid further harm and cost to the environment and local communities.'
'A decision by the House of Lords in 1868 developed English tort law establishing the rule of Rylands v Fletcher that everyone is strictly liable for harm caused by non-natural use of their land. It's now approaching 200 years since that rule was developed. Why are we still waiting for it to be applied in New Zealand?' asks Party leader Sue Grey
'If you seek to make the profit from growing the pine trees, then you must pay the costs for the consequences."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Otago Daily Times
an hour ago
- Otago Daily Times
Extension on district plan delivery sought
The Gore District Council wishes to extend the time it has to deliver its annual plan but it is well past the period when it would be forced to stop the whole process by a new government policy. The council is seeking to shift the deadline on delivering the plan to late-January next year from the planned August 29 this year. It is seeking an extension request from Minister for the Environment Penny Simmonds. Plans changes came under the spotlight on Wednesday when Minister Responsible for Resource Management Act (RMA) Reform Chris Bishop said a halt would be made for councils reviewing plans. He said councils were spending too much time on plan processes which would be "largely wasted" under new government RMA reforms. Council operations general manager David Bainbridge-Zafar said the council was in a good position. "The government intends the 'plan stop policy' will be enacted by the end of August. "Once enacted, councils will be required to stop progressing plan changes and plan reviews that are not yet at the hearings stage," he said. "Gore District Council is in a good position in that our proposed district plan is already well past that stage — our last hearing was in April. "Therefore, the minister's comments do not affect our work programme and we still intend to notify decisions on the proposed district plan by January, on the presumption that Ms Simmonds grants our recent extension request." The proposed plan, publicly notified on August 31, 2023, represents the first full-scale review of the district's planning rules since the current operative district plan came into effect in 2006. District plans act as blueprints for how land use, development and environmental protection will be managed in the years ahead. Mr Bainbridge-Zafar said the council needed more time due to a combination of factors that had slowed the decision-making process. There were more than 130 submissions and nearly 7000 individual submission points, more time was needed to deliver decisions which were "well-considered and legally sound", he said. Hearings for the proposed plan only began after a nearly four-month delay caused by submission period extensions and issues summarising submissions. Mr Bainbridge-Zafar said the extra time was essential to complete a thorough and fair review. Another key benefit of the extension is the opportunity to publish the new plan in an "ePlan" format, which will enhance accessibility and usability for residents, developers and planners alike. — APL
NZ Herald
2 hours ago
- NZ Herald
Mayor Mahé Drysdale's call for council review backed by LGNZ
It comes after Drysdale called for 'tough' amalgamation conversations between Bay of Plenty councils. He said the remit passing showed everyone was aware that change was happening in local government. '[We] want to be proactive around designing the system that will work for our people and work for us as local government.' The remit called for a review of current functions and governance arrangements of councils. Councils weren't as efficient and effective as they could be, he said. The sector needed to look at what services should be delivered nationally, regionally, and locally, then design a system that would best deliver those services, Drysdale said. Having a national IT system for all councils and regional roading networks were some ideas the sector could discuss, he said. Mahé Drysdale said councils could have a national IT system for service like rates. Photo / 123rf When talking about efficiency, people 'jump to amalgamation', Drysdale said, but it was only one of the solutions. 'It may not be the solution that comes out of it. We've got to keep a really open mind.' He said he was not trying to 'ram through amalgamation'. 'The intent of this is getting all the local authorities with LGNZ and central government working together to design a system that works for the country.' New Zealand has 78 councils: 11 regional, 11 city, 50 district, and six unitary authorities (regional and city/district combined). Changes to how councils managed water through Local Water Done Well and Resource Management Act (RMA) reform meant the functions of councils was changing, so councils needed to change their form, Drysdale said. LGNZ was in the 'perfect position' to co-ordinate the remit, but buy-in was needed from central Government and the other councils, he said. Plenty of reviews had been done, but action was needed, Drysdale said. 'Let's make sure we've done this thoroughly and we know what the best system is, but then we've actually got to implement it.' Local Government Minister Simon Watts. Photo / Alex Burton Local Government Minister Simon Watts said opportunities for efficiency included working alongside the sector. The new legislation that would replace the RMA included provisions about the roles, responsibilities, and processes of local government, he said. This included proposals that differed from the status quo, Watts said. 'I am keen to look at how the reorganisation process for local government can be made simpler and expect to receive advice on this.' Local Government New Zealand chief executive Susan Freeman-Greene. Photo / Mark Tantrum LGNZ chief executive Susan Freeman-Greene said local government needed to be proactive and lead the changes required. 'The current sector arrangements are a legacy, and do not always reflect how communities have expanded and how modern services are delivered. 'With key Government legislation changes now under way, it'll require an agile and well-planned response by the sector,' she said in a statement. 'It's also important we retain local decision-making in the work we do and the decisions we make, particularly when it comes to the delivery of infrastructure and services for the community.' The LGNZ national council would consider next steps on the remit in the coming months. After the October election, the organisation would engage with councils in a member-driven process, an LGNZ spokesperson said. Outgoing Bay of Plenty Regional Council chairman Doug Leeder said councils needed to be prepared to question their structure and functions. 'The structure of local government hasn't meaningfully changed since 1989. In that time, our communities, demographics, and challenges have changed dramatically,' he said in a statement. 'We need to be brave enough to question how we deliver services and what functions sit best at which level - national, regional, or local.' The remit had the support of metro councils before it was presented to LGNZ. The metro councils would provide support and resources to work on the programme established, the remit said. - LDR is local body journalism co-funded by RNZ and NZ On Air.
Scoop
4 hours ago
- Scoop
Mixed Reaction As Councils Told To Halt Planning Work
The Government's call to halt planning work has taken North Canterbury council leaders by surprise. Resource Management Act (RMA) Reform Minister Chris Bishop has put a stop to councils working on District and Regional Plans until the new RMA legislation takes effect. ''Rather than let these pricey, pointless planning and policy processes play out, we will be giving councils clarity on where to focus their efforts while they await the new planning system,'' Mr Bishop said at the Local Government NZ conference in Christchurch last week. The shake-up of the RMA is expected to come into effect in 2027. The Waimakariri District Council recently completed its District Plan, and barring any Environment Court appeals, it will become operative next month. But the Hurunui and Kaikōura district councils are just starting out on their District Plan reviews. Waimakariri Mayor Dan Gordon said he welcomed any initiative which streamlines planning processes and reduces the financial and capacity burdens on councils. ''However, it's essential that these changes still allow for meaningful local decision-making. ''Our recently notified District Plan represents a major investment in the future of our district, built on years of dedicated work and community engagement. ''Growth is important, but it must not come at any cost. We need development that is sustainable, well-planned, and aligned with the aspirations of our residents.'' Mr Gordon said local voices must remain central to local planning. Hurunui District Council chief executive Hamish Dobbie said his council welcomed the pause, but he would seek some clarity around potential plan changes. ''We have held off doing it (the District Plan review) on the basis this (new legislation) was coming up and we didn't want to waste the effort.'' The Kaikōura District Council has been working through a review of its District Plan, which was adopted in 2008. Council chief executive Will Doughty said the announcement will stifle the council's attempts to make changes to benefit the community. ''We have just awarded a contract to our consultants to work on the first two or three chapters. ''We always knew reform was under way, but we took an approach to respond to the needs of our community, while being flexible enough to review and respond to any changes.'' Mr Doughty said the council faced criticism that the ''rules are prohibitive'', so it was keen to update the plan. Mr Bishop said money is wasted on planning review processes, which is required under the existing RMA. ''The Government will suspend councils' mandatory RMA requirements to undertake plan and regional policy statement reviews every ten years, and the requirement to implement national planning standards.'' Mr Bishop said there will be some exemptions, including private plan changes and natural hazards planning. It means Cargill Station Ltd will be able to proceed with its private plan change to sub-divide sections in the Ocean Ridge development, south of Kaikōura, but the council may not be able to make any changes. Other council leaders from around the country expressed frustration, following Mr Bishop's address, at not being able to make changes to fix any planning issues, while private developers are still able to submit plan change requests.
