Fauci's pardon illegitimate? Biden's autopen admission gives Trump's MAGA new ammo
Speaking to the New York Times, the Democrat said that he allowed his staff to use his autopen because there were 'so many people' he granted clemency to. While the former president maintained that he personally approved all pardons and commutations at the end of his term, he noted that his staff was directed to use the autopen on clemency warrants since there was a 'whole lot of people'.
'I made every decision', Biden maintained regarding the 25 pardons and commutations where the autopen was used between December 2024 and January 2025.
An autopen is a mechanical device used to replicate someone's signature, and is typically used when there is a large volume of paperwork to be signed.
Speaking of the pardons granted to his family members or other prominent figures like Gen. Mark A. Milley and Dr. Anthony Fauci, Biden said he addressed these personally with his aides. During this time, Biden signed only one pardon by hand – that of his son, Hunter.
Speaking to the publication, Biden said, 'Everybody knows how vindictive he is…', adding that he wanted to shield his family from the legal costs of fighting potential cases.
The NYT reviewed emails handed over to the Trump administration by the Department of Justice, which is probing the autopen usage case. However, not all emails from November 2024 to January 20, 2025, were reviewed.
Nonetheless, the investigation unearthed some key findings.
Biden's staff had a process to ensure that the former president gave his verbal okay to the use of the autopen, which his staff secretary, Stefanie Feldman, used. Aides, present in meetings, where Biden okayed such use, would then draft emails for the accounts. Among those present were former chief of staff Jeffrey D. Zients and White House counsel, Ed Siskel.
The publication explained the process, saying 'At the Jan. 19 meeting, which took place in the Yellow Oval Room of the White House residence, Mr. Biden kept his aides until nearly 10 p.m. to talk through such decisions, according to people familiar with the matter. The emails show that an aide to Mr. Siskel sent a draft summary of Mr. Biden's decisions at that meeting to an assistant to Mr. Zients, copying Mr. Siskel, at 10:03 p.m. The assistant forwarded it to Mr. Reed and Mr. Zients, asking for their approval, and then sent a final version to Ms. Feldman — copying many meeting participants and aides — at 10:28 p.m. Three minutes later, Mr. Zients hit 'reply all' and wrote, 'I approve the use of the autopen for the execution of all of the following pardons.''
The investigation also showed that towards the end of his presidency, when Biden was granting clemency and pardons in large batches, he just signed off on broad criteria and standards for the same, instead of taking them up on a case-by-case basis.
In such cases, communications were run by Biden before being sent out, and in one case, he even requested a small change to a press release, the NYT reported.
Another instance showed that small changes were made, and names were added to the list, but Biden was not notified of each adjustment. Instead, his staff ran the final version through the autopen, with a source telling the NYT that such a procedure was routine.
Trump on Truth Social had earlier criticised Biden and the use of the autopen, saying, 'This is TREASON at the Highest Level! They did it to destroy our Country. The Joe Biden that everybody knew would never allow drug dealers, gang members, and the mentally insane to come into our Country totally unchecked and unvetted. All anyone has to do is look up his record.'
With the latest report from the NYT, some are saying that Fauci's pardon is 'illegitimate' and that it has to be nullified, while Fauci must be locked up. Fauci, who was the COVID-19 response chief, has long been a target of the MAGA base.
Another noted, 'It speaks volumes that the only pardon Biden signed personally was Hunter's. They knew the autopen was legally shaky, so they made sure the one that mattered most was airtight.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
19 minutes ago
- Time of India
Credit scores at risk: US Judge reverses Biden era medical debt rule; millions could be impacted
Representative image A Texas federal judge has reversed a BIden era rule that excluded medical debt from the credit reports, with a potential impact on 15 million Americans. The rule that came into effect this January, did not do away with the debt altogether, rather changed the method how credit scores of individuals would be calculated. It would have removed around $50 billion of medical debt from the credit reports of 15 million people. US district judge Sean Jordan, appointed by President Donald Trump in 2019 during his first term, observed in his ruling that the Fair Credit Reporting Act does not allow the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) to remove medical debt from reports and that it exceeded its authority. The CFPB had introduced new credit reporting rules in January, just before President Joe Biden left office. The independent agency estimated that the changes could generate an additional 22,000 mortgages annually and increase Americans' credit scores by an average of 20 points. Although the judge has blocked the implementation of these changes, he clarified that the CFPB is still allowed to "encourage" lenders to consider other categories of information when assessing creditworthiness. Since taking office for the second time, Trump has moved to eliminate what his department of government efficiency terms "waste, fraud, and abuse" across federal agencies. One of the first to come under scrutiny was the consumer protection agency, which quickly became a target and faced significant layoffs The CFPB had made the changes in January before President Joe Biden left office. The independent agency had calculated that the new credit reporting rules would result in an additional 22,000 mortgages every year and boost Americans' credit scores by an average of 20 points. Although the judge has prevented the advancement of these changes, he noted that the bureau can "encourage" creditors to use other categories of information. Dan Smith, head of the Consumer Data Industry Association, welcomed the decision, calling canceling the reversal of rule a move in the right direction. 'This is the right outcome for protecting the integrity of the system,' Smith wrote in a statement, according to Reuters. The decision comes just a week after Trump signed a massive spending and tax bill that includes sweeping cuts to Medicaid. New work requirements included in the law could strip millions of their coverage.
Indian Express
22 minutes ago
- Indian Express
US citizen who helped Russia from inside Ukraine granted Russian passport by Putin
Daniel Martindale, a US citizen who helped the Kremlin target Ukrainian troops and was then spirited out of eastern Ukraine by Russian special forces, has received a Russian passport in Moscow. Russian state television broadcast a report on Tuesday showing Martindale, with a trim beard and dressed in a suit and tie, smiling as he received his new documents. 'I, Daniel Richard Martindale, voluntarily and consciously accepting the citizenship of the Russian Federation, swear to observe the Constitution,' he said in good Russian. 'The belief that Russia is not just my home, but also my family – I am extremely glad that this is not only in my heart, but also by law,' Martindale told television cameras, holding up the Russian passport. State media said Martindale had been granted the passport by order of President Vladimir Putin. Reuters was unable to reach Martindale. A spokesperson for the US State Department declined to comment. A self-described Christian missionary, Martindale is one of many foreigners who have supported Russia during its war against Ukraine. But few foreigners are known to have provided key logistical support to Russia from inside Ukraine. Martindale grew to love Russia when he lived there in 2018, studying the language and teaching English in the Pacific port city of Vladivostok. Now in his early 30s, Martindale was living in Poland in the months before Russia launched its full-scale invasion of Ukraine in February 2022. He had a sense that Russia would invade Ukraine, he later told InfoDefense, a pro-Russian media project, and wanted to be there when it happened. Martindale hopped on a bicycle and rode from Poland across the Ukrainian border that February. He was in the western Ukrainian city of Lviv when Russia launched its attack. 'It was actually kind of exciting,' he told InfoDefense in May. 'I understood that the adventure I had been looking forward to was not going to be cancelled.' Over the next two years, Martindale made his way to eastern Ukraine, where he lived in a Ukrainian-held village near the front line in the Donetsk region. He planted carrots, sweet potatoes, and corn in his yard, and celebrated birthdays and holidays with villagers, he later told the Wall Street Journal. Secretly, Martindale was passing along information to pro-Russian troops, including details on Ukrainian military positions and other intelligence. On Tuesday, Denis Pushilin, the Moscow-installed leader of the Russian-controlled part of Donetsk region, praised Martindale, saying some of the information he had shared formed the basis for Russian planning to seize Kurakhove, a town near the key Ukrainian logistics hub of Pokrovsk. After two years of working as an informant for Russia, Martindale was spirited out of Ukraine by Russian forces as they took control of the village where he lived. At a press conference in Moscow last November, Martindale told reporters he had established contact with pro-Russian forces via Telegram. 'For the last two years, I have done everything to save the lives of Russian soldiers and ensure some kind of future for Russians in Ukraine. I would like to continue doing this,' he said. On Tuesday, Pushilin expressed gratitude to Martindale for his role in Russia's successes on the battlefield. The American 'has long since proven with his loyalty and actions that he is one of us,' Pushilin said.' For us, this (the Russian passport) is a sign of respect and a sign of gratitude for what Daniel has done.'
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Why US man Daniel Martindale was granted Russian citizenship in the middle of Ukraine war
An American citizen who assisted the Kremlin in targeting Ukrainian troops amid the conflict with Kyiv has received a Russian passport in Moscow. The man was identified as Daniel Richard Martindale. He was assisting Russian forces during the special military operation in Ukraine. Later, he was spirited out of eastern Ukraine by Russian special forces. Russian state television broadcast a report on Tuesday showing Martindale, with a trim beard and dressed in a suit and tie, smiling as he received his new documents, as reported by news agency Reuters. Authorities in the Moscow-controlled Donetsk claimed that he had played a 'key role' in helping Russian forces seize the village of Bohoiavlenka near the occupied city of Vuhledar in October 2023, according to The Moscow Times. The pro-Kremlin head of Donetsk, Denis Pushilin, said President Vladimir Putin had signed a decree granting him citizenship. 'I, Daniel Richard Martindale, voluntarily and consciously accepting the citizenship of the Russian Federation, swear to observe the constitution,' Martindale said. Martindale, who originally hails from, told reporters in 2024 that he had done 'everything to save the lives of Russian soldiers' and requested Russian citizenship during a press conference in Moscow, The Moscow Times reported. Live Events Pushilin claimed Martindale provided intelligence that helped Russian forces capture the Ukrainian city of Kurakhove. He also stated that Martindale had to be rescued due to threats to his safety. 'When it became clear that Daniel's continued presence in that area was life-threatening, our special services conducted a highly complex rescue,' he wrote on Telegram, according to The Moscow Times. 'Dream come true': Martindale Martindale said that he dreamed of obtaining Russian citizenship as far back as ten years ago and is now very happy that his dream has come true. 'This dream entered my heart ten years ago, long before the current conflict—a conviction that Russia is not only my home but also my family.' He said that in Russia, he wants to start a family and raise children as a true citizen. He also noted that his parents dream of living in Russia as well. According to Russian state media, Martindale's family supports his decision to remain in the region and plans to visit him. What drew Martindale towards Russia Martindale grew up on farms in upstate New York and Indiana, the child of missionaries who later moved to rural China, according to a Wall Street Journal report. A brief trip over the border into Russia's Far East during the family's time in China sparked Martindale's interest in Russia. In 2018, Martindale, now in his early 30s, moved to Vladivostok, a Russian port city on the Pacific, where he studied Russian and taught English before being deported a year later for violating labor laws, the Journal said. He moved to southern Poland but was keen to return to Russia, the journal said. In 2022, Martindale entered Ukraine just days before President Vladimir Putin ordered thousands of troops into Ukraine.
