Should You Buy the 3 Highest-Paying Dividend Stocks in the S&P 500?
But not all are alike -- some are riskier than others.
Be especially careful with ultra-high-yielders.
10 stocks we like better than Dow ›
It's hard to argue with dividend investing. Many assume dividends are mainly for retirees, and it's true that dividend income can be critically important when you're living on a fixed or semi-fixed income. But pre-retirees can benefit greatly from dividends, too -- for example, that income can be used to buy more stock!
So, if you're hunting for dividend payers for your portfolio, you may be tempted to buy into the highest-paying dividend stocks. Think twice before doing so, though. Here's why, including a look at the three highest payers in the S&P 500.
First, here's why dividend-paying stocks deserve your attention:
Dividend-Paying Status
Average Annual Total Return, 1973-2024
Dividend growers and initiators
10.24%
Dividend payers
9.20%
No change in dividend policy
6.75%
Dividend non-payers
4.31%
Dividend shrinkers and eliminators
(0.89%)
Equal-weighted S&P 500 index
7.65%
Data source: Ned Davis Research and Hartford Funds.
Their outperformance isn't that surprising since dividend payers have generally grown enough to have somewhat reliable income that supports a commitment to a dividend. When you start comparing dividend payers, though, here are some things to keep in mind.
Don't focus just on the amount of the dividend -- for example, favoring a $3 annual payout to a $1 one. To really compare apples to apples, you need to look at the dividend yield. Let's say the $3 payout belongs to a $240 stock. Its yield would be 1.25% ($3 divided by $240). If the $1 payout belonged to a $40 stock, its dividend yield would be 2.5% ($1 divided by $40). You would get more dividend income per dollar spent on the second stock.
That said, though, a very high yield is often a sign of trouble because when a stock's price drops, its yield goes up. So, it can be best to seek relatively high yields, but not necessarily the highest yields you can find. Here's a look at the three highest payers in the S&P 500 as of mid-June.
Shares of Dow (NYSE: DOW) recently sported a whopping dividend yield of 9.8%. Not surprisingly, the stock is down -- recently by more than 40% over the past year. Its five-year average annual gain is 1%, too. That's not pretty, but the dividend yield certainly is fetching.
So, why is the stock down? Well, per my colleague Daniel Foelber, it's facing weak customer demand, global competition, and high costs. Yikes. Such problems don't always last, though, and Dow is working to cut its costs and diversify even further, which can spread its risks across multiple kinds of operations. (It's been investing in recycling plastic waste, for example.)
The company hasn't been generating sufficient cash to cover its dividend payout, so unless things change, it may have to shrink the dividend. But even if the payout is cut in half, a roughly 5% dividend yield would still be way above average.
LyondellBasell Industries N.V. (NYSE: LYB) is another chemical company that has seen its fortunes -- and its share price -- fall. Over the past year, it's down about 31%, and its dividend yield was recently 9.2%.
It, too, isn't generating enough in earnings to cover its dividend yield, so a dividend cut is not out of the question. Interestingly, though, the company announced a (modest) dividend increase in May. So management isn't looking very pessimistic. CEO Peter Vanacker said:
LYB continues to reward shareholders with a strong and growing dividend in 2025, which will mark 15 consecutive years of dividend increases....The growth of our dividend reaffirms confidence in our disciplined capital deployment, our value-driven strategy and our capability to navigate the cycle during these challenging times.
Alexandria Real Estate Equities (NYSE: ARE) is a real estate investment trust (REIT) -- a company that owns many real estate properties, charging its tenants rent. REITs are required to pay out at least 90% of their taxable earnings as dividends, and the dividend yield for Alexandria Real Estate Equities was recently a fat 7.5%.
The company specializes in leasing offices to the life sciences industry, and the fact that many people are working from home these days has put pressure on office real estate. Indeed, this REIT's stock has also fallen hard over the past year -- down nearly 34%.
Founded in 1994, Alexandria describes itself as "the pioneer of the life science real estate niche." The company owns, operates, and develops what it calls "collaborative Megacampus ecosystems in AAA life science innovation cluster locations." These are spread out among such places as Boston, San Francisco, Seattle, Maryland, Research Triangle Park, and New York City.
So, take a closer look at any of these high yielders that interest you, but know that there are plenty of other solid dividend payers out there, many with less murky near-term futures.
Before you buy stock in Dow, consider this:
The Motley Fool Stock Advisor analyst team just identified what they believe are the for investors to buy now… and Dow wasn't one of them. The 10 stocks that made the cut could produce monster returns in the coming years.
Consider when Netflix made this list on December 17, 2004... if you invested $1,000 at the time of our recommendation, you'd have $664,089!* Or when Nvidia made this list on April 15, 2005... if you invested $1,000 at the time of our recommendation, you'd have $881,731!*
Now, it's worth noting Stock Advisor's total average return is 994% — a market-crushing outperformance compared to 172% for the S&P 500. Don't miss out on the latest top 10 list, available when you join .
See the 10 stocks »
*Stock Advisor returns as of June 9, 2025
Selena Maranjian has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has positions in and recommends Alexandria Real Estate Equities. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.
Should You Buy the 3 Highest-Paying Dividend Stocks in the S&P 500? was originally published by The Motley Fool
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Gizmodo
a minute ago
- Gizmodo
John Deere Hit With Layoffs Amidst Trump's Idiotic Tariffs
Donald Trump's tariff policies are generating billions of dollars for the federal government by sucking it out of American businesses via import duties. Some companies seem to be feeling downstream impacts from the government's unconventional new policies, and it may even be resulting in job losses for the sort of companies that sell to Trump's base. John Deere, the tractor seller, recently announced a raft of layoffs, but right before doing that, it held an unfortunate earnings call during which executives revealed that the company had seen a downturn in profits. Some of that downturn, the call seemed to suggest, could be credited to the climate of uncertainty created by the administration's tariff regime. The Des Moines Register reports: In its earnings report, the company noted that President Donald Trump's tariffs have added to the woes of farm-equipment makers who already were grappling with slow demand. Farmers are opting to rent machinery instead of buying. 'Tariff uncertainty and deflated commodity prices have made farmers increasingly cautious in spending decisions and more hesitant to accept higher machinery prices,' said CFRA Research analyst Jonathan Sakraida. The New Republic reports that, during the company's recent earnings call, Cory Reed, president of John Deere's Worldwide Agriculture and Turf Division, noted that the tariffs were a factor in buying decisions. 'If you have customers that are concerned about what their end markets are going to look like in a tariff environment, they're waiting to see the outcomes of what these trade deals look like,' Reed said. In other words, once again, demographics that Trump claimed he would help (factory workers and farmers) seem to be getting shafted by his policies. The layoffs at John Deere, which were announced on Aug. 18th, will impact 71 workers at its foundry in Iowa and another 167 workers at various locations in Illinois, the Register writes. While the side effects of Trump's tariff regime haven't been quite as apocalyptic as some analysts initially imagined, the economy isn't doing great, and small business owners are clearly feeling the pain from the new economic order. Indeed, recent lawsuits filed by small businesses against the Trump administration have thrown into question the very legal basis of his policies. As we pointed out earlier this month, if the tariffs are deemed illegal in a court of law, it's likely that the government will have to pay back all of that tariff revenue to the businesses it came from. This would be a terrible humiliation for the White House, a logistical nightmare, and a financial disaster for the federal government. Somehow, it's still sorta funny to imagine it happening.


Gizmodo
a minute ago
- Gizmodo
Samsung Galaxy Z Fold7 Gets First Big Discount Weeks After Launch, Likely Targeting Apple's September Reveal
Samsung makes some of the best Android phones out there. Its new Galaxy Z Fold7 is just a little over a month old, and if you've been thinking about trying a foldable, now's a good time. This spectacular device typically retails for a whopping $2,000, but right now, you can grab the 256GB unlocked model for $1,700 on Amazon. That's a 15% discount on easily one of the most advanced models out there. Even better, all color options – including blue, black, and silver – are discounted. See at Amazon The first thing you notice is the screen and how it basically gives you two in one. Closed, it feels like a regular phone with a wide front display. Opened, it offers a big 8-inch screen that lets you access and use up to 3 windows at once. You're essentially getting a tablet-like experience with a device that slides in your pocket. There's even a flex mode to prop the device up for a hands-off viewing experience. Powering it up is a custom Snapdragon 8 Elite chip – that's 38% faster processing, 26% smoother graphics, and 41% quicker AI compared to previous models. 256GB of storage lets you store all your favorite apps, multimedia content, and games easily. Everything runs just as smoothly with the 12GB RAM – perfect for those who prefer multitasking their way through life. Best of all, the battery is powerful enough to get you through a full day. Samsung has always paid attention to camera quality, but with the Fold 7, it is breaking its own records. The smartphone features a 200MP main camera that captures every detail in the most realistic, lifelike manner. Pro-Visual Engine optimizes the images, while Photo Assist lets you be creative with the adjustments yourself. Brightness feels a bit off in your favorite selfie? Tweak it on the larger inner screen with Photo Assist and preview the before-and-after side by side for a better comparison. The smartphone is also durable. Thanks to Armor Aluminum and Gorilla Glass Ceramic 2, Fold7 can handle everyday scratches and bumps well. There's a lot more to like about Galaxy Z Fold7. Samsung has truly outdone itself by incorporating advanced features in a slim, durable build. It's not cheap at the retail price of $2,000, and while we'd still call it a premium purchase even with the discount, $1,700 feels more reasonable. Snag it before the price goes back up. See at Amazon


Fast Company
a minute ago
- Fast Company
Target is struggling. CEO Brian Cornell is stepping down in February
Target CEO Brian Cornell, who helped reenergize the company but has struggled to turn around weak sales in a more competitive retail landscape since the COVID pandemic, plans to step down Feb. 1. Minneapolis-based Target Corp. said Wednesday that Chief Operating Officer Michael Fiddelke, a 20-year company veteran, will succeed Cornell. Cornell will transition to be executive chair of the board. Cornell, 66, took the helm at Target in August 2014. In September 2022, the board extended his contract for three more years and eliminated a policy requiring its chief executives to retire at age 65. Cornell said the appointment followed several years of board vetting of both internal and external candidates. Fiddelke has overhauled Target's supply network and expanded the company's stores and digital services while cutting costs. 'Mike was the right candidate to lead our business back to growth,' Cornell told reporters. 'As I arrived at Target, I consistently relied on Michael's strategic insights and sound judgment when making decisions. Michael has developed a deeper knowledge of our business than anyone I know.' Fiddelke told reporters he's stepping into the role with 'urgency' to reclaim the company's merchandising authority. 'When we're leading with swagger in our merchandising authority, when we have swagger in our marketing, and we're setting the trend for retail, those are some of the moments I think that Target has been at its highest in my 20 years,' he said. In May, Target announced that Fiddelke would lead a new office focused on faster decision-making to help accelerate sales growth. The change in leadership was announced Wednesday at the same time that Target reported another quarter of sluggish results. The company's stock was down more than 8% in pre-market trading. Target reported a 21% drop in net income in the quarter ended Aug. 2. Sales were down slightly and the company reported a 1.9% dip in comparable sales — those from established physical stores and online channels. Target has seen flat or declining comparable sales in eight out of the past 10 quarters including the latest period. Target, which has about 1,980 U.S. stores, has been the focus of consumer boycotts since late January, when it joined rival Walmart and a number of other prominent American brands in scaling back corporate diversity, equity and inclusion initiatives. Target's sales also have languished as customers defect to Walmart and off-price department store chains like TJ Maxx in search of lower prices. But many analysts think Target is stumbling because consumers no longer consider it the place to go for affordable but stylish products, a niche that long ago earned the retailer the jokingly posh nickname 'Tarzhay.' In fact, out of 35 merchandise categories that Target tracks, it gained or maintaining market share in only 14 during the latest quarter, Fiddelke told reporters Tuesday. Meanwhile, Walmart gained market share among households with incomes over $100,000 as U.S. inflation caused consumer prices to rise rapidly. Lower-income shoppers have driven customer growth at Target, suggesting it may have lost appeal with wealthier customers, according to market research firm Consumer Edge. 'It's probably not the best sign, especially because higher-income consumers continue to hold up a little bit better' during times of economic uncertainty, said Consumer Edge Head of Insights Michael Gunther. In March, members of Target's executive team told investors they planned to regain the chain's reputation for selling stylish goods at budget prices by expanding Target's lineup of store label brands and shortening the time it took to get new items from the idea stage to store shelves. The moves would help the company stay close to trends, executives said. 'In a world where we operate today, our guests are looking for Tarzhay,' Cornell told investors. 'Consumers coined that term decades ago to define how we elevate the everything everyday to something special, how we had unexpected fun in the shopping that would be otherwise routine.' Before joining Target, Cornell spent more than 30 years in leadership positions at retail and consumer-product companies, including as chief marketing officer at Safeway Inc. and CEO at Michaels, Walmart's Sam's Club and PepsiCo America Foods. He came to Target when the company was facing a different set of challenges. Cornell replaced former CEO Gregg Steinhafel, who stepped down nearly five months after Target disclosed a huge data breach in which hackers stole millions of customers' credit- and debit-card records. The theft badly damaged the chain's reputation and profits. Cornell reenergized sales by having his team rev up Target's store brands. It now has 40 private label brands in its portfolio. And even before the pandemic, Cornell spearheaded the company's mission to transform its stores into delivery hubs to cut down on costs and speed up deliveries. Target's 2017 acquisition of Shipt helped bolster the discounter's same-day, store-based fulfillment services. Cornell also focused on making its stores better tailored to the local community. The coronavirus pandemic delivered outsized sales for Target as well as its peers as people stayed home and bought pajamas, furnishings and kitchen items. And it continued to see a surge in sales as shoppers emerged from their homes and went to stores. But the spending sprees eventually subsided. As inflation started to spike, Target reported a 52% drop in profits during its 2022 first quarter compared with a year earlier. Purchases of big TVs and appliances that Americans loaded up on during the pandemic faded, leaving the retailer with excess inventory that had to be sold off. In July 2023, as shoppers feeling pinched by inflation curtailed their spending, Target said its comparable sales declined for the first time in six years. Moreover, Target started losing its edge as an authority on style by focusing too much on home furnishings basics, and not enough trendy items, Fiddelke said. A customer backlash over the annual line of LGBTQ+ Pride merchandise Target stores carried that year further cut into sales. Although Walmart retreated from its diversity initiatives first, Target has been the focus of more concerted consumer boycotts. Organizers have said they viewed Target's action as a greater betrayal because the company previously had held itself out as a champion of inclusion.