Parents call for better mental health care after daughter died in understaffed London hospital
Bonnie Newton was just 20 years old when she took her own life in her room at the Cygnet Hospital in Ealing, west London in July 2019.
She was 100 miles away from her family in Wimborne, Dorset, and had been assured she needed to go to the private hospital for help with her mental health.
But West London coroners court heard of a catalogue of failings, including 'unsafe' staffing levels and a lack of risk assessments vital to Bonnie's safety.
Cygnet Health Care was hit with a £1.53 million fine in 2023 over Bonnie's death, after it pleaded guilty in a Care Quality Commission prosecution for failing to provide safe care and treatment.
Bonnie's family have now spoken publicly for the first time in the wake of the inquest, to call for better mental health care for vulnerable young people.
Bonnie's mother Marie, speaking for herself, Bonnie's father Jon, and her brother Alex, said: 'Our hearts are broken. The pain both mentally and physically is like nothing else. Not only was Bonnie my daughter, she was my best friend. She was my world.
'Although Bonnie had her struggles, alongside her talent for singing and great sense of humour, she continued to be the most kind, polite, caring and wonderful daughter anyone could ever wish for. She will never be forgotten. What Bonnie had to go through shouldn't happen to anyone. She didn't want to feel the way she did, Bonnie was desperate to have a life without sadness.
'Bonnie was reluctant to transfer to Cygnet Ealing but was told she needed to so she could receive the dialectical behavioural therapy she had waited almost half her life for, and ultimately, for her to get better.
'However, she found it challenging and we found communication with the hospital was poor. Any responses we got seemed curt. All we were told was to 'stop worrying and Bonnie was getting better'.
'I'll always believe that if Cygnet, who were entrusted to care for Bonnie, had looked after her properly she would still be with us now.
'We just hope by sharing our story we can improve care for vulnerable young people. I wouldn't wish the pain we face each day on anyone.'
Bonnie, who had been diagnosed with a personality disorder, spent 18 months as an inpatient at a hospital near her home, and was transferred to the New Dawn ward of Cygnet Hospital Ealing on 20 November 2018.
The inquest heard Bonnie became isolated and pre-occupied on 21 July 2019, and she was put on 15-minute observations the following day. Her mother also made a concerned call to the ward after speaking on a video call to Bonnie.
In the early hours of the following morning, Bonnie was found unresponsive in her room by the only mental health nurse on duty in the ward, and she died the following day.
At the time she was found, one of just two healthcare assistants on duty on the ward that night was on a break, and no effort had been made to bring in extra staff as cover.
The inquest was told that staffing levels on the night were 'unsafe' as a minimum of two nurses and two assistants should have been on duty.
Lawyers from Irwin Mitchell, representing Bonnie's family, said she had been involved in a serious incident involving a ligature four months earlier. However her care plans and risk assessments were not updated, and the safety of her room was not scrutinised properly.
When she was found unresponsive in her room, staff tried to use alarms which did not work, and they attempted 'ineffective CPR' with Bonnie lying on her front, the inquest heard.
The jury concluded neglect had contributed to her death, and the 'lack of documentation at Cygnet was insufficient to provide Bonnie with a safe level of care'.
Camilla Burton, an expert human rights lawyer at Irwin Mitchell, said Bonnie's family believe her death was 'entirely preventable', and added: 'Sadly, this isn't an isolated incident. We continue to see too many cases of young people with mental health problems not receiving the level of care they deserve, often miles from home.
'Young people with mental health problems are some of society's most vulnerable. We join Marie and Jon in calling for lessons to be learned from Bonnie's death so other families don't suffer a similar tragedy.'
A Cygnet spokesperson said: 'We continue to extend our deepest condolences to Bonnie's family and loved ones.
'We are always committed to enhancing our practices to ensure the delivery of safe, quality care. At the last inspection, the Care Quality Commission rated Cygnet Hospital Ealing as 'Good' and we continue to work closely with the CQC and other partners to uphold the highest standards of safety and provide compassionate care.
'Whilst this cannot change what has happened, we are not complacent and wish to take this opportunity to once again convey our sincere condolences to all those affected.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
42 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Country park issues warning over toxic levels of algae in lake
Warning signs have been erected at a popular beauty spot after algae levels in a lake became toxic. Testing of the water at Cotgrave Country Park revealed that potentially harmful concentrations of cyanobacteria – known to the general public as blue-green algae – had bloomed earlier this month. Dogs are recommended to be kept on leads and swimming is strictly prohibited at the current time. Regular repeat testing of the site will now be undertaken, but it is unclear how long the algae levels will take to return to normal, or at least drop under the toxic threshold. Signs erected at the sight say: 'Recent sampling of the water in the Dog Pond has indicated that levels of BGA are currently above warning sign levels. Excess BGA can produce toxins which may cause problems if animals drink the water of if accidentally cosnumed by humans. READ MORE: Police cordon set up after street fight in Nottingham city centre READ MORE: Amazon fraudster used refund scam to steal £128,000 then bragged about it online 'Avoid contact and wash your hands if you do come into contact with the water. Do not allow your pets into the siteuntil the current bloom subsides.' Toxic levels of the bacteria are rare and often when algae bloooms it is harmless to pets and humans. However the most recent tests – on July 27 and August 6 – suggested otherwise. The lake has been closed since August 8. It comes in the wake of another country park lake being closed in Nottinghamshire in June, at Colwick. Hot weather can contribute to algae growth. The UK's recent heatwaves have led to blooms all over the country. A Nottinghamshire County Council spokesperson said: 'We routinely test water quality at Cotgrave Country Park during the summer. Samples are taken on a fortnightly basis and sent to a lab for analysis. The most recent sample from Heron Lake within the country park showed elevated levels of blue-green algae, with the advice that there was a risk to public health and that warning signage should be erected at the lake. 'Signage has been installed, and water quality will continue to be monitored. Signage will be maintained until sampling confirms that there is no longer a health risk. Unfortunately, it is not possible to say how long this may be as it is dependent on weather conditions and given the warm and dry conditions it may take some time for levels to return to normal. 'It should be highlighted that as well as posing a potential risk to the public, blue-green algae can also pose a risk to dogs and they should not be allowed to enter or drink from the water.'
Gizmodo
44 minutes ago
- Gizmodo
Man Experiences Joy For the First Time in Decades After Brain Stimulation Treatment
A man who lived with severe, treatment-resistant depression for over 30 years is now in remission, thanks to a new brain stimulation method that targets selective areas of his brain. The man reported experiencing joy for the first time in decades after the treatment. 'He was crying and saying, 'I'm not sad, I'm just happy. I don't know what to do with these emotions',' the study's first author, Ziad Nahas, a psychiatrist and professor at the University of Minnesota, told Gizmodo. Nahas and a team of researchers across several universities developed a personalized method to implant electrodes and precisely send weak electrical signals into brain areas believed to be involved in depression. By fine-tuning this stimulation using the patient's feedback, the treatment has relieved the participant's symptoms for up to two years. Their findings are detailed in a new preprint on PsyArXiv, which has not yet been peer-reviewed. The study's single participant initially contacted the researchers while they were recruiting for a new clinical trial. At the time, he had been living with treatment-resistant depression for three decades, having first been hospitalized at age 13. Since then, he had undergone multiple hospitalizations and tried dozens of treatments alongside intensive psychotherapy. He had also attempted suicide three times. Treatment-resistant depression is a common form of major depressive disorder that does not improve significantly after at least two standard treatment attempts, such as medications or therapy. In such cases, electroconvulsive therapy (ECT)—which stimulates the brain using weak electrical currents—is often considered a next step. While ECT has been used for decades and can be effective for some patients, it fails for others. In this patient's case, brain stimulation had previously failed to alleviate any symptoms. He had undergone two courses of electroconvulsive stimulation therapy. The first was moderately effective, but the second and third brought no relief. The problem is that most ECT studies stimulate specific brain areas based on a standard brain atlas, Damien Fair, a neuroscientist and professor at the University of Minnesota and a study co-author, explained to Gizmodo. That means that researchers don't often know exactly which area they're targeting, since everyone's brain is different. 'It's a one-size-fits-all approach,' said Fair. To address this, the team developed a personalized stimulation method tailored to the participant's brain. First, they used functional MRI (fMRI) to map the borders of his brain networks previously linked to depression. This revealed that the patient's salience network, which processes external stimuli, was about four times larger than in people without depression, potentially contributing to his symptoms, Fair said. Next, the researchers surgically implanted four clusters of electrodes into the brain, over the borders of these brain networks. A few days later, they began sending electrical signals into each of the four networks individually. When they stimulated the default mode network (DMN), a group of regions linked to internal thought processes, the patient began to experience happiness. Nahas immediately called Fair. '[Nahas] said, 'You won't believe it. We stimulated the default network, and [the participant] is breaking down in tears of joy,'' Fair recalled. Stimulating the action-mode network, which is involved in planning, and the salience network both led the man to report a sense of calm. Targeting the frontoparietal network, which is involved in decision-making, resulted in improved focus. Over the next six months, the patient received electrical stimulation in the various brain networks each day for 1 minute, every 5 minutes. The researchers continued to adjust the stimulation settings each month using a statistical method that incorporated the patient's daily feedback. By seven weeks post-surgery, the participant no longer experienced suicidal thoughts. By six months, his symptoms had significantly improved. By nine months, he had entered full remission. That remission has lasted for two years. 'The uniqueness of PACE is combining very precise, individualized targeting of multiple networks and tuning the parameters so the patient can receive the most benefit,' Nahas said. The team has since implanted a second participant and plans to implant a third. Ultimately, they aim to conduct a double-blind clinical trial. Nahas recently received an email from the original participant, who had embarked on a road trip with his family. He was enjoying his trip, he said. 'In psychiatry, we don't have cures,' Nahas said, 'but this is probably the closest we can get.'
CNN
an hour ago
- CNN
Hear TikTok employees raise concerns about app's impact on users
Current and former TikTok employees raise concerns internally about how the app could hurt young users' mental health in a newly unsealed video presented as evidence in a North Carolina lawsuit.
