B.C. government says more oversight coming for dysfunctional municipalities
"I've come to the conclusion that this type of behaviour just cannot continue to go on … it is our goal to have something in place before the next election," said Minister of Housing and Municipal Affairs Ravi Kahlon, responding to the latest back-and-forth accusations between Kamloops Mayor Reid Hamer-Jackson and the rest of city council.
"The province is going to step in … so that we can ensure that local governments are serving the best interests of their people, and not having these continuously prolonged infighting situations."
Since the 2022 local elections, a number of B.C. municipalities — including Kamloops, Harrison Hot Springs, Lions Bay, Sayward and Sechelt — have seen the mayor opposed by all or a majority of council,
Accusations of inappropriate conduct toward staff, multiple lawsuits, mass departures of senior staff or external investigations have followed, along with code of conduct complaints and escalating legal fees to resolve the personal disputes.
There is no way to recall local politicians in B.C., and there are only a few situations where mayors or councillors can be removed for legal reasons. The province removed the auditor general for municipalities in 2020, and so far has rejected the Union of B.C. Municipalities' requests to appoint a provincial integrity commissioner to resolve disputes.
Kahlon said Kamloops was just one of many municipalities where dysfunction had sparked a change of heart, and implied that the strategy of hands-off dispute resolution could come to an end, though he said any legislation wouldn't take effect until local elections in October 2026.
"It undermines our democracy, undermines people's belief in the work that we do to make their lives better," he said.
"And it's unfortunate, but here we are and we have to take steps."
Endless investigations in Kamloops
Kahlon's comments to CBC News were prompted by the two latest reports into the feud between Hamer-Jackson and the rest of city hall.
A February report to Kahlon from city council, which was made public this week, outlined code of conduct breaches, privacy breaches, investigations and lawsuits that have consumed much of city hall business and cost the city more than $1 million in legal fees.
"This untenable situation has highlighted the limited ability of current legislation to address such scenarios, leaving municipalities with insufficient tools to protect their operations, staff, and taxpayers from the harmful and expensive actions of one rogue elected official," the letter argued.
The second report, which was released last week, concerned Kamloops Coun. Bill Sarai secretly recording a heated argument with Hamer-Jackson in January 2023 and denying being the source of it after it became public.
The investigation by legal firm Young Anderson found Sarai had breached council's code of conduct and his own oath of office. The report recommended council reprimand Sarai, but didn't endorse censuring or lowering his pay, and criticized Hamer-Jackson for not taking part in the investigation.
A council meeting on Tuesday afternoon will consider the report.
"We actually asked Mayor Hamer-Jackson to do very similar things, including a letter of apology, workplace training. He refused to do so … and that's going to be no different from Coun. Sarai," said deputy mayor Mike O'Reilly.
"We are very hopeful that Coun. Sarai will listen to what the will of council is and will provide that letter of apology and take the training needed."
Mayor says it's political deflection
In an interview, Hamer-Jackson denied any issues with his leadership style, called multiple councillors liars, and maintained that he is the victim of a witch hunt.
"The bottom line is they didn't want me to be the mayor, and they don't believe in the democratic process. And like I said, this is just another deflection," he said.
"I got staff ... saying, 'Keep going, Mr. Mayor, keep going.' And the general consensus is they want to get rid of the councillors."
Because of the province's timeline for action, the City of Kamloops will have to resolve its own disputes until next year's local elections, including an ongoing lawsuit by Hamer-Jackson against a fellow councillor, and another by the mayor's former lawyers to get him to pay his legal bills.
But Kahlon made clear what he thought about the fighting and the legal bills.
"I'm hoping that we can resolve these issues, but those are dollars that could have gone to infrastructure. Those are dollars that could have gone to important community services," he said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
National Post
21 minutes ago
- National Post
Federal government's spending review is 'flawed' and too narrow: report
OTTAWA — The federal government's 'comprehensive spending review' is too narrow and won't save enough tax dollars to put Ottawa back on solid footing, a new report will conclude. Article content The report, to be released Thursday by the C.D. Howe Institute, says the Carney government's spending review will only include about one-third of all federal program spending and is expected to save no more than $22 billion by 2028-29. The think tank says that's less than half the $50 billion in savings that are needed to return federal government coffers to 'a fair and prudent path' that would see Ottawa's debt-to-GDP ratio stop climbing. Article content Article content The report, called 'Federal Expenditure Review: Welcome, But Flawed,' says that the problem with focusing only on limited areas of federal spending is that it reduces the scope for improving the quality of spending and ensures that some programs that endure cuts will be superior to some that aren't touched. Article content Article content It's better to review broadly and eliminate programs that aren't working well, the report says, instead of across-the-board cuts that don't assess program success. John Lester, the report's author, said governments often opt for the across-the-board approach because it's easier than evaluating countless programs and can realize tangible results more quickly. Article content 'You need some time to evaluate those programs,' said Lester, a former federal government economist, during an interview. 'It's a big job.' Article content Lester recommends expanding the review to cover the missing two-thirds of program spending, imposing a multi-year cap on operating costs to deliver immediate restraint, and then assessing programs through a value-for-money lens. He also calls for transparent goals and clear communication to build public consensus around the various options. Article content Article content The government's spending review follows years of hefty deficits that have left Ottawa and future generations with mountains of debt. Article content National Post reported last month on an earlier C.D. Howe report that forecasted that the Carney government is poised to post a massive deficit of more than $92 billion during this fiscal year, almost double what was forecast just a few months ago by a non-partisan officer of Parliament. Article content Just four months ago, the Parliamentary Budget Officer projected that the federal deficit would fall to $50.1 billion during this fiscal year, a slight improvement over the $61.9 billion shortfall recorded in 2023-24. The PBO also said at that time that federal deficits would continue to fall in the ensuring years, unless there were new measures to cut revenue or increase spending.
CTV News
an hour ago
- CTV News
Que. minister Geneviève Guilbault could testify next week before the Gallant Commission
Quebec Transport Minister Genevieve Guilbault is expected to testify before the Gallant Commision into the SAAQclic fiasco. (Jacques Boissinot/The Canadian Press) Quebec Transportation Minister Geneviève Guilbault could testify next week before the Gallant Commission, which is investigating the failed digital transition of the Société de l'assurance automobile du Québec (SAAQ). The information was confirmed on Wednesday by a government source not authorized to speak publicly. The commission of inquiry into the management of the SAAQ's IT modernization, including the SAAQclic platform, will resume its public hearings next Monday after a two-month summer break. The hearings will be held in Montreal over the next three weeks. They will have a political flavour, as former ministers, current ministers, and cabinet staff will be called to testify. In addition to Guilbault, her predecessor, François Bonnardel, now Minister of Public Security, is expected to be heard during this period. Those who held the transport portfolio under Philippe Couillard's Liberal government, Laurent Lessard and André Fortin, are also expected to appear. In the spring, former PQ and Liberal ministers Sylvain Gaudreault and Robert Poëti testified before the commission chaired by Judge Denis Gallant. The commission is scheduled to submit its report by Dec. 15 at the latest. The public hearings are scheduled to continue until early October. Several key players still need to be questioned in connection with what has been dubbed the SAAQclic fiasco. These include the former CEOs of the state-owned corporation, Nathalie Tremblay and Éric Ducharme, who were dismissed by the Legault government at the beginning of the summer. Former vice president of information technology Karl Malenfant, one of those responsible for rolling out the SAAQclic platform, has not yet testified publicly, although he met with the commission behind closed doors last week. It should be noted that the SAAQ's failed digital transition is expected to cost taxpayers at least $1.1 billion, or $500 million more than anticipated, according to calculations by the Auditor General of Quebec. This report by The Canadian Press was first published in French on Aug. 13, 2025.
CBC
an hour ago
- CBC
Manitoba Indigenous groups unite, ink infrastructure and development agreement
Social Sharing Two Indigenous groups in Manitoba have agreed to work together on major infrastructure and development projects. The agreement comes as the federal government looks to fast-track projects across the country. The Southern Chiefs' Organization, which represents 32 Anishinaabe and Dakota First Nations in the province, and the Manitoba Metis Federation have signed a five-year agreement. It outlines their shared commitment to ensure First Nations and Red River Metis voices are included in the approval of any project proposed by the Manitoba government and supported by federal legislation. A new federal law gives Ottawa sweeping powers to speed up permits for what it calls "nation-building projects." The Southern Chiefs' Organization and the Manitoba Metis Federation say they'll work together to pursue Indigenous-led developments in areas including forestry, harvesting and traditional economies. The Manitoba government is also exploring how it would create and operate a proposed Crown-Indigenous corporation. "This agreement sends a message to all governments, partners and industry that First Nations and the Red River Metis are working together to shape a future that is led by Indigenous nations," Grand Chief Jerry Daniels of the Southern Chiefs' Organization said Wednesday. "We are forging a path towards economic independence and sustainability, ensuring the voices of First Nations and Red River Metis are integral to the design, approval and implementation of nation-building projects across this province." Prime Minister Mark Carney has said the legislation is needed to shore up Canada's economy during the trade war with the United States. Ottawa has also promised to build up northern infrastructure, in part, to meet a NATO military alliance spending target for critical infrastructure. It's unknown which projects could be fast-tracked, but the government has pointed to ports, railways and pipelines. Carney recently met with First Nations, Inuit and Metis groups to discuss how best to build projects in partnership with Indigenous Peoples. The Manitoba Metis Federation turned down Carney's invitation to discuss the legislation, after Ottawa invited another Metis group the federation claims has no reason to exist. Other Metis groups and First Nations say communities represented by the Metis Nation of Ontario have no claim to Metis heritage and that Ottawa and Ontario have no right to recognize them. Manitoba Metis Federation president David Chartrand said the legislation must move forward, as Canada deals with ongoing threats from U.S. President Donald Trump. "There's not a doubt it must arrive, because the danger that Trump imposes on all of us is very scary ... this is an economic war, and people should not take it lightly," he said Wednesday.
