Federal government's spending review is 'flawed' and too narrow: report
Article content
The report, to be released Thursday by the C.D. Howe Institute, says the Carney government's spending review will only include about one-third of all federal program spending and is expected to save no more than $22 billion by 2028-29. The think tank says that's less than half the $50 billion in savings that are needed to return federal government coffers to 'a fair and prudent path' that would see Ottawa's debt-to-GDP ratio stop climbing.
Article content
Article content
The report, called 'Federal Expenditure Review: Welcome, But Flawed,' says that the problem with focusing only on limited areas of federal spending is that it reduces the scope for improving the quality of spending and ensures that some programs that endure cuts will be superior to some that aren't touched.
Article content
Article content
It's better to review broadly and eliminate programs that aren't working well, the report says, instead of across-the-board cuts that don't assess program success. John Lester, the report's author, said governments often opt for the across-the-board approach because it's easier than evaluating countless programs and can realize tangible results more quickly.
Article content
'You need some time to evaluate those programs,' said Lester, a former federal government economist, during an interview. 'It's a big job.'
Article content
Lester recommends expanding the review to cover the missing two-thirds of program spending, imposing a multi-year cap on operating costs to deliver immediate restraint, and then assessing programs through a value-for-money lens. He also calls for transparent goals and clear communication to build public consensus around the various options.
Article content
Article content
The government's spending review follows years of hefty deficits that have left Ottawa and future generations with mountains of debt.
Article content
National Post reported last month on an earlier C.D. Howe report that forecasted that the Carney government is poised to post a massive deficit of more than $92 billion during this fiscal year, almost double what was forecast just a few months ago by a non-partisan officer of Parliament.
Article content
Just four months ago, the Parliamentary Budget Officer projected that the federal deficit would fall to $50.1 billion during this fiscal year, a slight improvement over the $61.9 billion shortfall recorded in 2023-24. The PBO also said at that time that federal deficits would continue to fall in the ensuring years, unless there were new measures to cut revenue or increase spending.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
National Post
14 minutes ago
- National Post
Ultrarich building luxury underground bunkers
Just think of it as doomsday prepping gone chic. In the past few years, the ultrarich have been quietly getting their homes ready for the next big disaster by building luxury underground bunkers. Article content Witness Meta CEO Mark Zuckerberg, who's reportedly building a $300-million compound in Hawaii — complete with a 5,000-square-foot bunker that has its own energy, water and food infrastructure. Or Microsoft co-founder Bill Gates, who reportedly who has bunkers under several of his homes. Or Kim Kardashian and Shaquille O'Neal, who are also said to have explored the idea. Article content Article content 'What were once rudimentary shelters have become bespoke sanctuaries,' Naomi Corbi of SAFE, a firm specializing in secure residential design, told Robb Report. 'Today's clients want features that mirror their lifestyles — often with highly individual touches.' Article content So yes. While the rest of us are living out a Planet of the Apes dystopia above ground — or fighting off zombies, pandemics and nuclear threats — they'll be cosetted and carefree. Article content Corbi said clients have requested amenities such as a regulation-grade putting green, a climate-controlled art gallery, private theatres and hydroponic gardens. Other features could include gyms, pools, saunas, staff quarters and, really, anything that could make survival amid societal breakdown that much more cushy. Article content But if you think you can just track down one of these opulent oases and demand to be let in, think again. In a March 2024 article on the CBC News website, a rep for the Swiss-based company Oppidum, which specializes in fortified underground residences, said privacy is key in the industry. Article content 'One of the tenets of shelter design is you don't want anyone to know about it,' explained Tom Grmela, the company's head of communications. He added: 'Rarely do I ever actually meet the billionaire client. And even when you do, they always have aliases.' Article content Douglass Rushkoff, who interviewed billionaire disaster preppers for his book Survival of the Richest, said many of them were keen to keep strangers out of their sanctuaries. Article content 'These people are no more driven by fear as they are by desire,' he told BBC Science Focus. 'The idea of being isolated in a space station or underground bunker is a good thing for a lot of these types.' Article content Ultimately, though, that idea could backfire. Another option for surviving The Big One involves not keeping others out but bringing them in. As in, having one big bunker for many people, like in the video game and TV show Fallout. Article content The company Vivos specializes in these types of complexes, which can house up to 800 people and are less expensive than owning an individual bunker.
CTV News
14 minutes ago
- CTV News
Parents protest as Parry Sound students face classes in construction sites
Parents and students gathered outside Parry Sound District High School on Friday, voicing frustration over the Near North District School Board's handling of school construction delays. With both the existing high school and the new JK-12 site under construction, families say they lack clear answers about safety and logistics for the upcoming school year. 'Today we're just trying to hype up the awareness of the Near North District School Board's plan. We're questioning their contingency plan,' said Shane Reynolds with the group 'Parents for Parry Sound.' 'We're standing in front of the existing high school, which is a third broken down right now with demolition. We have questions that are still outstanding.' Parry Sound - Parents Protest Parents and students gathered outside on August 15, 2025, to voice frustration over the Near North District School Board's handling of school construction delays. With both the existing high school and the new JK-12 site under construction, families say they lack clear answers about safety and logistics for the upcoming school year. (Madison Marier/CTV News Northern Ontario) Amy Black, another parent with the group, echoed concerns over transparency. 'We band together when push comes to shove, and we are not taking a very vague media release as a satisfactory answer,' she said. 'We want proof that the school is safe. We want proof that the well-being of the children is the priority. So far, we have yet to see that.' Board releases contingency plan Late Friday, the board published an eight-page contingency plan on its website and social media, addressing safety and operational adjustments. The document confirms that fire alarms, PA systems and security cameras remain functional at Parry Sound High School, despite partial demolition. A conference room will serve as a temporary library, while a classroom will host bagged lunches in place of a cafeteria. Parry Sound school construction site Parry Sound High School sits as a construction site as demolition had started on the building before it became clear a the new school's construction would not be completed for the start of the 2025-26 school year. (Madison Marier/CTV News Northern Ontario) In a media release, the board acknowledged the 'delay and resulting confusion' but emphasized that student safety and learning continuity are 'paramount.' The plan, developed with input from the Ministry of Education and community partners, remains 'fluid,' with updates to be shared via email and a dedicated webpage. Uncertain timelines and logistics The $58.5 million school project, funded by the province in June 2023, has no confirmed completion date. The board stated it is working with contractors to finalize timelines but warned that exterior work may continue into 2026. Parry Sound - New school rendering An undated computer graphic rendering of what the new Parry Sound JK-12 school will look like when consturction is completed. (Supplied/Near North District School Board) Temporary measures include redistributing some students to McDougall and Nobel Public Schools, which the board says have 'sufficient capacity.' Transportation details are expected by Aug. 25, and remote learning has been ruled out as an option at this time. Calls for transparency persist Parents continue to push for in-person updates, but the board has not committed to a town hall, stating it will rely on digital communications. Reynolds and others argue more direct engagement is needed. 'We want our questions answered,' Black said. 'Right now, it feels like we're being kept in the dark.' Parry Sound - Parents Protest Parents gathered outside on August 15, 2025, to voice frustration over the Near North District School Board's handling of school construction delays. With both the existing high school and the new JK-12 site under construction, families say they lack clear answers about safety and logistics for the upcoming school year. (Madison Marier/CTV News Northern Ontario) The Near North District School Board urges families to monitor its website for further adjustments as the school year approaches and check its new FAQ page to address common questions.
CTV News
43 minutes ago
- CTV News
Some grocery stores could stop selling alcohol ahead of new Ontario recycling program rules
A person carries in empty cans to The Beer Store in Ottawa on Aug. 16, 2025. (Kimberley Johnson/CTV News Ottawa) Some grocery stores could soon stop selling alcohol in response to a looming rule. Stores that sell liquor will be required to start accepting empty liquor bottles and cans through the Ontario Deposit Return Program starting Jan. 1, 2026, but the Retail Council of Canada is warning that some members say they aren't equipped to do that. In a statement to CTV News Ottawa, Michael Zabaneh, vice-president of sustainability with the council, says the current compensation model, which gives retailers two cents for every container, isn't enough to offset costs. 'Given the cost and operational complexities of managing alcohol returns, some retailers are reassessing whether it remains viable to continue selling alcohol at all under current or proposed deposit-return conditions,' he writes. He says the plan poses health and safety risks and is costly. Some stores also don't have the space and staff to accept beer and wine bottles. 'While retailers support improving collection and recycling rates, this must be done through well-funded and scalable alternatives,' reads the statement. Returning a few dozen beer bottles to The Beer Store on Saturday morning, Peter Finnie says he often sees firsthand how much workers handle. 'I can't think of any stores that would be set up to do what these people do,' he said. He brings cans multiple times a week to raise money for the charity he works with, the Bytown Association for Rescued Kanines – or B.A.R.K. He says the job does not look easy for those inside. 'You have people who professionally collect bottles, and they'll show up and maybe have a couple of thousand beer cans and hundreds and hundreds of wine bottles,' he said. 'Now, if they showed up at some other place, it would jam them up pretty quickly and then you got the awful smell.' In a statement to CP24 this week, the Ontario Ministry of Finance says more than 400 grocery stores and convenience stores are already participating in the recycling program with more expected to join in the coming months. The Beer Store has an agreement with the provincial government to keep at least 300 locations open until the end of 2025. It will be allowed to close an unlimited number of stores starting in the new year when the new recycling rules take effect. Those like Martha Fenton say they hope it remains easy to bring back empty bottles and cans. 'If it does close, then I don't know what I would do,' she said. 'Might have to go in my recycle bin if grocery stores or corner stores don't offer that option.'
