Donald Trump Vs. Joe Biden: Who Was Better On Inflation?
TOPSHOT - (COMBO) This combination of pictures created on October 22, 2020 shows US President Donald ... More Trump (L) and Democratic Presidential candidate and former US Vice President Joe Biden during the final presidential debate at Belmont University in Nashville, Tennessee, on October 22, 2020. (Photo by Brendan Smialowski and JIM WATSON / AFP) (Photo by BRENDAN SMIALOWSKIJIM WATSON/AFP via Getty Images)
Inflation is not rising prices. Deflation is not falling prices.
The more production expands across a rising number of hands and machines, the lower the price. And vice versa. The Apple iPhone is an effect of production on six different continents around the world. Boeing jets are an effect of millions of different parts around the world. Global cooperation makes both increasingly affordable, not 'monetary policy.'
Which is a reminder yet again that relentlessly falling prices are evidence of increasingly sophisticated and tessellated global production, not deflation. By contrast, evisceration of global cooperation during the coronavirus lockdowns logically resulted in higher prices borne of less sophisticated and less tessellated global production that, contra accepted wisdom, had little to do with inflation.
Inflation is a shrinkage of the unit of measure, in our case, the dollar. But it's not necessarily a decline in the value of the dollar against foreign currencies anymore than deflation is necessarily a rise. Since the dollar floats (as do other foreign currencies), dollar movements upward can at times disguise inflation while a declining dollar can disguise deflation.
It brings us to gold. The reason it has long existed as the definer of money is exactly due to the fact that gold doesn't move, but the currencies in which it's priced do. Gold simply is. It tells the truth. When gold is rising against the dollar, that's a sign of a shrinking dollar. When gold is falling, the dollar is rising.
Since presidents get the dollar they want, gold's movements can be used to assess who has been better on dollar/inflation policy, Donald Trump or Joe Biden. About how it will be done for this write-up, markets are a look ahead. In which case, the dollar price of gold will be looked at from the time each was elected, not when they entered the White House.
In Trump's case, gold closed at $1,273/ounce the day after his election in 2016. On election day in November of 2020, the price of gold had risen to $1,914. Against the objective constant of gold, the dollar lost 50 percent of its value during Trump's first term.
The day after the 2020 presidential election won by Biden, gold closed at 1,904. Biden exited the race for a second term on July 21, 2024. As of Friday, July 19, gold was trading at $2,398. The dollar lost 25 percent against gold during Biden's lone term.
Unknown is what markets knew after Biden's exit. Did they start pricing in a Trump victory right away, and did they start pricing in a Trump victory ahead of Biden's exit. There's no way of knowing for sure, but it's notable that gold rose 13 percent against the dollar between the time that Biden left the race, and Trump's election.
On November 6, 2023, the day Trump's election was made official, gold closed at, 2,721. As of this writing, it's trading at 3,199/ounce, a 17 percent decline in the dollar measured against gold.
There's no partisan statement here. Gold once again is. It just reports, and it signals more substantial dollar weakness under Trump. Meaning Trump was the more inflationary president.
No doubt this won't show up in CPI and other government measures of prices, but prices go up and down for all sorts of reasons, most them having nothing to do with inflation or deflation. So, while Biden will enter the first draft of history as the president who caused inflation, more distant history may well tell a different story, including that it was Trump who presided over the biggest dollar devaluations, and it was a Trump who panicked about the coronavirus. And Trump's panic brought on higher prices during Biden's presidency that had nothing to do with inflation.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
4 minutes ago
Juneteenth celebrations adapt after corporate sponsors pull support
AUSTIN, Texas -- AUSTIN, Texas (AP) — Juneteenth celebrations have been scaled back this year due to funding shortfalls as companies and municipalities across the country reconsider their support for diversity, equity and inclusion initiatives. Canceled federal grants and businesses moving away from so-called brand activism have hit the bottom line of parades and other events heading into Thursday's federal holiday, which celebrates the end of slavery in the United States. The shrinking financial support coincides with many companies severing ties with LGBTQ celebrations for Pride this year and President Donald Trump's efforts to squash DEI programs throughout the federal government. In Denver, for example, more than a dozen companies backed out of supporting the Juneteenth Music Festival, which is one of the city's biggest celebrations of the holiday, according to Norman Harris, executive director of JMF Corporation, which puts on the event. 'There were quite a few sponsors who pulled back their investments or let us know they couldn't or wouldn't be in a position to support this year," said Harris, who has overseen the event for more than a decade. The festival, which takes place in the historically Black Five Points neighborhood, has been scaled back to one day instead of two because of the budget shortfall. It has only been able to stay afloat thanks to donations from individuals and foundations. 'Thankfully, there was a wide range of support that came when we made the announcement that the celebration is in jeopardy,' Harris said. Juneteenth celebrates the day the last enslaved people in Texas were told they were free on June 19, 1865, two years after President Abraham Lincoln's Emancipation Proclamation. The day has been celebrated by Black Americans for generations, including in Harris' family, but became more widely celebrated after becoming a federal holiday in 2021. After the 2020 murder of George Floyd, many companies pursued efforts to make their branding more inclusive, but it has slowed down over the past few years after some received blowback from conservatives and because many companies didn't see it as an important part of their revenue stream, said Dionne Nickerson, a professor in marketing at Emory University. Some companies can no longer afford to support Juneteenth celebrations because they just don't have the money given the economic uncertainty, according to Sonya Grier, a marketing professor at American University. 'It's a whole confluence of issues,' Grier said. Many state and local governments hold or help fund celebrations, but some decided not to this year. The governor's office in West Virginia stated that the state won't be hosting any Juneteenth events this year for the first time since 2017 due to a budget deficit. Republican Gov. Patrick Morrisey last month signed a bill to end all diversity programs. 'Due to the continued fiscal challenges facing West Virginia, state government will not be sponsoring any formal activities,' deputy press secretary Drew Galang said in an email. City Council members in Scottsdale, Arizona, dissolved their DEI office in February, which led to the cancellation of the city's annual Juneteenth festival. Event organizers in Colorado Springs, Colorado, had to move locations due to fewer sponsors and cuts in city funding, said Jennifer Smith, a planner for the Southern Colorado Juneteenth Festival. Around five companies sponsored the event this year, compared to dozens in years prior, Smith said. 'They have said their budgets have been cut because of DEI,' and that they can no longer afford it, she said. Some groups have also mentioned safety concerns. Planners in Bend, Oregon, cited 'an increasingly volatile political climate' in a statement about why they canceled this year's celebration. Many local organizations have also had their budgets slashed after the National Endowment for the Arts pulled funding for numerous grants in May. The Cooper Family Foundation throws one of the largest Juneteenth celebrations in San Diego each year. It was one of dozens of groups told by the NEA in May that its $25,000 grant was being rescinded. The email said the event no longer aligned with the agency's priorities, said Maliya Jones, who works for the foundation. The grant money went toward paying for arts and dance performers. The event will still take place this year, but members of the Cooper family will have to divide up covering the costs, said Marla Cooper, who leads the foundation. 'That's $25,000 we have to figure out how we're going to pay for," Cooper said. 'We will always have Juneteenth. And we will work it out,' she said.
CNN
11 minutes ago
- CNN
Trump orders ICE officers to expand deportation efforts in Democratic cities
President Donald Trump called for Immigration and Customs Enforcement to expand deportation efforts in Democratic cities and 'do all in their power' to achieve mass deportations in a social media post Sunday. 'ICE Officers are herewith ordered, by notice of this TRUTH, to do all in their power to achieve the very important goal of delivering the single largest Mass Deportation Program in History,' the president posted on Truth Social as he traveled on Air Force One to Canada for the G7 summit. The president's post comes as CNN has reported that ICE has been racing to meet White House arrest quotas and on the heels of Trump acknowledging that his immigration policies have impacted farm workers and those in the hospitality industry. The White House has enlisted components across the federal government to achieve its goal of 3,000 immigration-related arrests per day. But while the Trump administration has publicly touted its enforcement efforts, officials have privately faced criticism for failing to meet that quota, according to multiple sources familiar with the discussions. The president also directed ICE to 'expand efforts' in 'the Democrat Power Center' while claiming without evidence that his political opponents are using 'Illegal Aliens' to 'cheat in Elections, and grow the Welfare State.' 'We must expand efforts to detain and deport Illegal Aliens in America's largest Cities, such as Los Angeles, Chicago, and New York, where Millions upon Millions of Illegal Aliens reside,' Trump said. The administration's immigration crackdown sparked protests in Los Angeles earlier this month, which prompted the president to mobilize both National Guard troops and Marines to deal with demonstrations over federal raids in the city. Protests have expanded across the country, culminating in hundreds of thousands of anti-Trump protesters taking to the streets in 'No Kings' protests nationwide over the weekend. Since Trump took office, ICE, which had previously been operating with a set of guidelines focused on public safety and national security threats, has had to pivot as the key agency at the core of the president's campaign promise to carry out mass deportations. Recent arrests have taken place during routine immigration checks, and at immigration court and worksites. Immigration-enforcement operations have created a chilling effect on some industries heavily reliant on immigrant workforces, including farms and hotels, and as ICE races to fulfill Trump's goal to increase deportations. The president appeared to acknowledge Thursday that his immigration policies are straining those sectors. 'Our great Farmers and people in the Hotel and Leisure business have been stating that our very aggressive policy on immigration is taking very good, long time workers away from them, with those jobs being almost impossible to replace,' Trump said on Truth Social. 'We must protect our Farmers, but get the CRIMINALS OUT OF THE USA. Changes are coming!' CNN's Priscilla Alvarez and Michael Williams contributed to this post.
Bloomberg
26 minutes ago
- Bloomberg
US Allies and Adversaries Are Dodging Trump's Tariff Threats
Donald Trump has a clear, uncomplicated notion of how things should work. He tells everyone what to do, and they do it. In this world, law firms stop representing his accusers. Universities cede him control of admissions and curriculum. Europe and China swallow his tariffs. Corporations move their factories to the US. Ukraine surrenders to Russia. Denmark hands him Greenland. Panama hands him the canal. To the president's daily fury, the world outside his head isn't always cooperating. Harvard University has forcefully fought back against his attempt to take charge of the school. After some major law firms buckled under his threats, others are now resisting. Trump has whipsawed between escalation and retreat on tariffs when other nations have refused to go along. Russian President Vladimir Putin has ignored his demands to end the bloodshed in Ukraine, and for months Chinese President Xi Jinping all but gave him the silent treatment. Fired federal workers, immigrants targeted for deportation without due process and others who've sued to challenge his actions are winning support from courts, including some presided over by Trump-appointed judges.
