Justice Yadav's Speech At VHP Event: Opposition's Impeachment Motion May Be Rejected, Say Sources
Last Updated:
Of the 55 submitted signatures, eight did not match, three remain unverified, and two were duplicates
The Rajya Sabha Secretariat is likely to reject the impeachment motion against Justice Shekhar Yadav on technical grounds, senior government sources told News18.
Opposition leaders submitted the motion, accusing Justice Yadav of hate speech at a Vishwa Hindu Parishad (VHP) event. However, of the 55 submitted signatures, eight did not match, three remain unverified, and two were duplicates.
Despite repeated requests from the Rajya Sabha Chairman for verification, opposition leaders have not addressed these discrepancies.
The government informed the Supreme Court that the matter falls under Parliament's jurisdiction, as it concerns judicial conduct, not a serious allegation such as corruption.
Sources also told News18 that if those members willing to sign were to resubmit the motion in the prescribed format, the Rajya Sabha Chairman could consider it.
Rules stipulate a minimum of 50 signatures for such a petition. Once correctly submitted, the chairman is obliged to form a three-member committee to examine the charges. This committee would comprise a sitting Supreme Court or High Court judge, a distinguished jurist, and a legal expert.
On December 8 last year, Justice Yadav made remarks targeting the Muslim community at a VHP event in Prayagraj. These comments sparked widespread protests from opposition leaders, who questioned the impartiality of the judicial system.
Parliament is also expected to address an impeachment motion against Justice Verma in the upcoming monsoon session. The government has initiated discussions with opposition leaders to secure support for this matter.
First Published:
June 10, 2025, 12:27 IST
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
18 minutes ago
- Time of India
Kapil Sibal alleges bias in handling of Justices Varma, Yadav cases
New Delhi: Independent MP and senior lawyer Kapil Sibal has alleged "discrimination" in the attitude of Rajya Sabha Chairman Jagdeep Dhankhar for citing information which is "in public domain" to write to the Chief Justice of India, through the RS Secretariat, to halt the (judiciary's) in-house proceedings against Justice Shekhar Kumar Yadav , who is facing charges of hate speech. However, Sibal alleged that the same stance has not been applied by the Chairman in the case of Justice Yashwant Varma , in the 'currency seizure' case. Sibal warned the government of opposition if an attempt is made to impeach Justice Varma on the basis of the 'in-house proceedings' (SC-appointed panel) report, saying such a course will be tantamount to by-passing the proceedings of the Judges Inquiry Act (of conducting an independent panel's inquiry into the charges in impeachment motion) and would thus be in violation of the Constitution besides endangering the independence of the judiciary . by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Mundfalten "bügeln" mit TV-Tipp (Löwen) | bedrop Undo Addressing mediapersons on Tuesday, Sibal wondered why the government was trying to "save" Justice Yadav and asked why the RS Chairman and secretariat have not yet completed the process of verification of the pending impeachment motion signed by 55 Opposition MPs even six months after its submission.
The Hindu
2 hours ago
- The Hindu
From street name to gobbledygook
The street sign says it all – Yahali 3rd Street. There are three of them, all connecting Anna Salai with GN Chetty Road, at Teynampet, very close to Semmozhi Poonga. Only Yahali is not the correct name. Google maps has compounded matters further. You need to search under Yaya Hali Street if you need to find it. The correct name is Yahya Ali Streets – 1, 2 and 3, and they take their names from Justice Yahya Ali of the High Court of Madras. The learned judge is not in public memory. When I spoke to a friend on this, he said that the Internet has no reference to such a judge, and I guess that would mean such a person did not exist. But he did. And when he died as a sitting judge in 1949, the High Court convened to condole his passing. The brilliant barrister and then Public Prosecutor V.L. Ethiraj led the mourners. He dwelt on the 'keen intellect, great learning, profound human understanding and exquisite courtesy we found in that frail figure.' But to get full biographical details we need to turn to the speech of an illustrious contemporary, V.C. Gopalaratnam who spoke on behalf of the Madras Advocates Association. Yahya Ali was born in August 1893 in Nellore, his father serving as Assistant Secretary in the Finance Department of the Nizams of Hyderabad. He graduated in History and Economics from the Presidency College in 1916 and then qualified in Law. He set up practice in Nellore and became Government Pleader and Public Prosecutor. He was a member of the Madras Legislative Council as well. In between he became Chairman of Nellore Municipality, his election being testimony to the regard he enjoyed from all residents of the town. It was a place notorious for communal tension and being a Hindu majority, it was considered impossible for a Muslim to win the ballot. In 1926, Yahya Ali became District Judge, being posted in that capacity to various parts of Madras Presidency. His specialisation in matters concerning finance led to his being appointed by the then Imperial Government in 1942 as the Chairman of the Appellate Income Tax Tribunal where he equipped himself 'with a thorough and exhaustive knowledge of Income Tax Law and Procedure.' In 1945 he became a judge of the High Court of Madras. It is interesting to note that he sat in judgement till the last day of his life, taking ill on April 21, 1949, and passing away the next day. While these details are from Gopalaratnam's speech during the condolence meet, we learn some more from what the then Chief Justice had to say. Yahya Ali he noted, was a connoisseur of Telugu poetry and 'he was a deeply cultured person- culture with the best ingredients of what I may call Moghul culture – urbanity, catholicity and instinctive love of all that was beautiful.' What was his link to Teynampet? He was at the time of his death Mutawalli (trustee or guardian) of the Teynampet Mosque in which his family had taken a deep interest. It was also in the precincts of this mosque that Yahya Ali was buried. And eventually a locality was named after him. And from there, the name has morphed phonetically as it were, to what it is now with street names changing accordingly. I wish the Corporation would be more careful with street signs. We have suffered enough mutilation with truncation of many names to initials, morphing of others, and of course, name changes at the drop of a hat.
Indian Express
2 hours ago
- Indian Express
BJP at Shaheen Bagh: Muslim girls should aim for the Army
In a move aimed at expanding its outreach into the Muslim-dominated areas of the national capital, the BJP's Minority Morcha held a 'minority chaupal' in Shaheen Bagh on Tuesday. The main purpose of this chaupal was to encourage young Muslim girls to consider careers in the Indian Army, it said. Colonel Sofiya Qureshi, an Indian Army officer who garnered attention during Operation Sindoor, was repeatedly cited as a role model throughout the event. This was the BJP's first such chaupal in the Capital under a broader national campaign celebrating the first-year anniversary of the Prime Minister Narendra Modi-led government's third term in office. The event was held in a modest hotel room in the heart of the neighbourhood that rose to national prominence during the 2020 anti-CAA protests. 'Our daughter should become strong, she should be educated, she should be independent…,' said Jamal Siddiqui, National President of the BJP Minority Morcha and chief guest at the event. 'If anyone tries to harass, scare, or intimidate her, she should be able to give a befitting reply. We have to take our daughters out of their homes and into society. They should also go to the border… and show the strength of Indian women.' 'To teach Pakistan a lesson, the leadership of (explaining) air strikes on terrorist bases was handed over to two daughters, Colonel Sophia and Wing Commander Vyomika Singh, and the world has been introduced to the courage, valour and bravery of Indian women,' he added. The chaupal featured a small but engaged gathering of two women and 20 party workers, and sought to familiarise attendees with the Agniveer recruitment scheme and other opportunities in the Armed Forces. Organisers also distributed copies of the Constitution and announced a one-stop camp for registrations under the Ayushman Bharat Yojana. 'This is not just about Army recruitment,' said Ashu Chaudhary, Delhi State Executive Member of the Minority Morcha and the event's coordinator. 'It's about rights, awareness, and helping women from our community imagine a future where they are leaders.' Attendees were also handed 'data books' — kits detailing key government schemes across sectors such as education, employment, and health — with instructions to imitate similar minority chaupals in their localities and to share the data with other members of the Muslim community. The BJP's choice of Shaheen Bagh for the pilot chaupal carries political weight. Once the epicentre of the months-long protests, led largely by Muslim women against the Citizenship (Amendment) Act, the neighbourhood had become a symbol of resistance — and now, as the BJP frames it, potential transformation. 'We all are sons of India. We all are citizens of India. These 11 years of the Modi government have brought light where there was darkness,' Siddiqui declared. Launching a scathing attack against the BJP's political rivals, he added, 'The Congress and AAP created that darkness. Now, it is our duty to spread awareness, take the government's message and schemes to the people.'
