
Holt Liberals must choose how to spend $614-million tobacco settlement
It's an unusually good budget problem for a provincial government to have: what to do with an unexpected financial windfall of $614 million.
The Holt government must decide whether to spend that money on programs to help people quit smoking or use it to reduce projected budget deficits.
"When you think of the size of many of the provincial governments' deficits these days — several hundred million dollars — it could be the difference between a deficit and a surplus," says economist Pierre-Marcel Desjardins of the Université de Moncton.
The money will flow from a $32.5 billion settlement in a lawsuit by Canadian provinces and territories against three major tobacco companies over the health-care costs of treating people with smoking-related illnesses.
The settlement was approved by an Ontario judge earlier this year.
Anti-smoking groups, including the Canadian Cancer Society, have called for a "significant" share of the money to be devoted to programs to help people quit smoking and prevent smoking among youth, and to enforcing tobacco restrictions.
"This is a landmark opportunity for New Brunswick to address the leading cause of disease and death in the province," said Rob Cunningham, the society's senior policy analyst.
"It's well-estainslished that sustained, well-funded programs are effective at reducing smoking, and now we have this dramatic problem of youth vaping."
Melanie Langille, the president of NB Lung, said her organization wants a majority of the money to fund quit-smoking programs.
But the Holt Liberals are also projecting a $549 million deficit this year and have been forced to cut spending to keep it from getting even larger.
WATCH | 'A landmark opportunity': No decision on tobacco windfall:
The Holt government's $614-million predicament
26 minutes ago
Duration 2:42
Liberals could use tobacco settlement to reduce deficit or to fund anti-smoking programs.
This year's instalment from the tobacco case, $147 million, would shrink that deficit.
"We are working with our minister of finance and other people on how best to deploy the money that we will collect through this settlement," Health Minister John Dornan said in the legislature on May 14.
"There is no decision yet."
The Opposition Progressive Conservatives have endorsed using a large share of the money on anti-smoking programs.
Health critic Bill Hogan says "all of it" should be devoted to that effort.
"It's a perfect opportunity to fund programs that we don't have to find money to fund," he said.
The settlement amount does not take into account legal fees that must be paid to the law firms who represented the provinces.
According to one court filing, New Brunswick's lawyers will get 3.6 per cent of the total over the two decades or more of the payout.
The specific payment amounts per year may fluctuate depending on a range of factors including the ability of the tobacco companies to pay.
That hasn't stopped two provinces from using this year's money, and estimated amounts in future years, to improve their bottom lines.
Newfoundland and Labrador slapped its entire $520 million total settlement on this year's budget, slashing its deficit by more than half. Quebec has also booked a large part — but not all — of the multi-year total this year.
"You might not want to be cynical, but those two provinces will be facing elections in the next 12 months," Desjardins noted.
He said the most transparent approach would be for provinces to apply each year's instalment to the budget in that year.
New Brunswick announced its lawsuit in 2006 and passed legislation allowing it to file the case in 2008, describing it as a way to hold tobacco companies accountable for promoting a product they knew to be harmful.
"No amount of settlement is going to undo the harms of years and years and years of tobacco use," Langille said.
"But we're hoping that our government will make choices in preventative medicine and supporting those living with tobacco-induced disease right now."
Desjardins said he understands the argument for using the money to fight smoking, but pointed out it is compensation for money already spent on caring for smokers — spending that contributed to budget deficits and provincial debt.
"I don't think there's an obligation to earmark the money for specific programs," he said.
"The money that was spent on health over the past several decades would have either stayed in the pockets of taxpayers or been spent elsewhere. So I think the provinces do have the moral grounds to put the money where they think the priorities are."
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


National Post
33 minutes ago
- National Post
Canadian military personnel to get 20% pay hike: defence minister
Canadian Forces personnel are to receive a 20 per cent salary increase, Defence Minister David McGuinty has confirmed. Article content The move is part of a $9-billion spending increase that will see Canada's defence and security budget climb to an all-time high of $62.7 billion annually by next year. The initiative was announced June 9 by Prime Minister Mark Carney. Article content Carney said the salary increases were well deserved and would contribute to retaining personnel in the ranks as well as attracting new recruits. Article content Article content McGuinty told journalists on June 10 that improvements were also coming in military benefits, housing and health care. 'That's where a lot of the initial investment will be, of course, including a 20-per-cent pay increase,' he said. Article content Article content But when that pay hike will come is still unclear. The Ottawa Citizen asked the Department of National Defence on June 10 for details about the raises and for information on when military personnel would see the extra money on their paycheques. DND did not respond. Article content In addition, there will be increases in training allowances and the introduction of retention bonuses for key military personnel. No further details were provided. Article content At a June 9 technical briefing that followed Carney's spending announcement, government officials noted it was expected that around 1,400 new staff would be hired at DND. More health-care workers will be hired for the Canadian Forces and the civilian workforce will be expanded so military personnel can focus on operations, government officials said at the technical briefing. Under government-imposed rules, the officials who provided the briefing cannot be identified. Article content Article content The Ottawa Citizen asked DND on June 9 for a timeline on when the additional 1,400 staff would be hired. DND did not respond. Article content Article content June Winger, national president of the Union of National Defence Employees, said Wednesday that she had received initial information from DND that more civilian staff would be hired, but no specific details. But Winger noted that the department had faced significant barriers in getting new staff in place because of delays in completing security clearances. Such clearances are taking months and perspective staff, instead of waiting, are instead accepting jobs other than at DND, she said. Article content In January, the Ottawa Citizen reported that military staff were recommending retention bonuses to keep key personnel from leaving the ranks, but there were questions at the time about whether the government would fund such a plan.


CBC
35 minutes ago
- CBC
Family who lost their baby donates a cuddle cot to Timmins hospital to give other families more time to grieve
Social Sharing Sheelah Carbonneau and Justin McCarthy of Timmins had precious few moments with their son Felix. He died two years ago, just hours after he was born. "There's nothing else more important than time," Carbonneau said. "For example, I never dressed him in the clothes that I brought him to bring him home from the hospital. And I think I would have liked to have had him in that outfit." She later found out about a device called a cuddle cot. It's a cooling system for an infant who has died to be placed into and it preserves the infant's body for up to 24 hours so families can have an extra day to say goodbye. "I just thought of it immediately as an opportunity to give families time," said Carbonneau. "Especially after the trauma of childbirth, and then the emotions of welcoming your child and then saying goodbye to your child, there's nothing like having a little bit of time to process and to be able to decide how you want to say goodbye and how you want to honour your baby." Carbonneau reached out to the Timmins and District Hospital Foundation and asked if the hospital was interested in having a cuddle cot, and staff said they would love to have one but it wasn't currently listed as a priority item. She decided to buy one for $3,000 and give it to the hospital. "We're very fortunate to have it," said Alexander Langevin, manager of the maternal child program at Timmins and District Hospital. Langevin said the hospital had been reviewing different processes and options for grieving families in recent years and acknowledged a cuddle cot would be a useful device to have. He confirmed that due to other equipment needs at the hospital, the cuddle cot was not a top priority item, however, they are grateful to have one now. "The cuddle cot really fit the bill for everything we required," said Langevin. "Not hoping to use it, but we understand the reality that it will happen and at least that way we could comfort those families who may experience this in the future."


CTV News
40 minutes ago
- CTV News
Easing exam stress with LDAM
Winnipeg Watch Karen Velthuys of Learning Disabilities Manitoba shares signs of stress and strategies to help students cope and thrive.