Ontario bill limiting access to long-term care home inspection reports will protect bad actors: advocate
Social Sharing
The Ontario government is proposing restricting public access to long-term care (LTC) home inspection reports — a move one advocate says will protect bad actors in the sector.
Currently, all LTC home inspection reports are posted online. But under the proposal, contained within a bill tabled last week by Minister of Red Tape Reduction Andrea Khanjin, the reports would be published for three years before being removed from the website.
"It's very clear here that it's to shield the bad reputations of repeated bad actors in long-term care from having their records of non-compliance being made visible," said Dr. Vivian Stamatopoulos, a professor at Ontario Tech University and long-term care advocate, in an interview with CBC Radio's Metro Morning on Tuesday.
Over 30,000 reports are currently available online, dating back over 15 years, including for homes that are no longer operational, according to the Ministry of Long-Term Care.
The ministry will continue maintaining reports outside the three-year time period, and reports will be available "upon request," spokesperson Mark Nesbitt said in an email on Monday.
"By setting a three-year publication period for reports, the government is ensuring the public has access to relevant and accurate information that reflects each long-term care home's current performance," he said.
The time frame is similar to other inspection industry practices, such as for child-care settings, he said.
But Stamatopoulos called the comparison a false equivalency. Children don't live in daycares, and the history of deaths, noncompliance and abuse in Ontario LTC homes demands a full public record, she said.
From March 2020 to April 2022, during the COVID-19 pandemic, 4,335 residents died in Ontario's LTC homes, according to a September 2023 report from the province's ombudsman.
WATCH | 5 years ago, military report detailed abuse, neglect in Ontario's long-term care homes:
Military report puts spotlight on crisis in Ontario's long-term care homes
5 years ago
Duration 3:09
The Canadian Armed Forces released a report in May 2020 detailing disturbing conditions observed by its members in five Ontario LTC homes, including accounts of elder abuse and an accusation that improper care led to the choking death of a resident. The soldiers were called in to help after some of the province's long-term care facilities were overrun by COVID-19 outbreaks.
If the government does implement the three-year time frame for online access to inspection reports, Stamatopoulos says by 2026, "the worst of the worst times in long-term care is just going to be gone."
"And then eventually, it will all be gone."
Move will add more red tape, advocate says
Families, journalists and researchers all rely on the publicly available reports to demonstrate long-standing issues in the sector and support their calls for systemic change, she said.
If the reports are removed, she said it will no longer be possible to do historical analysis and examine trends overtime.
Stamatopoulos said she doubts the government will provide reports upon request in a timely manner. Currently, she said she is waiting for the Ministry of Long-Term Care to get back to her on questions she sent them about inspection reports four months ago.
Requiring additional resources to field individual requests for reports will be inefficient and add more red tape when the data is already publicly available, she said.
"Why would you go out of your way to take these reports down and then have to field these requests on a one-to-one basis if you don't have anything to hide, or if you're not trying to protect bad actors who have long histories of non-compliance?" she said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CTV News
42 minutes ago
- CTV News
Regina Urgent Care Centre to have reduced hours on Saturday
Regina Urgent Care Centre is seen in this file photo. On Saturday, the Regina Urgent Care Centre (UCC) will have reduced hours from 8 a.m. to 4 p.m. According to the Saskatchewan Health Authority (SHA), anyone with a medical emergency while the UCC is not operating, should call 911 or go to the emergency department at the Regina General Hospital or Pasqua Hospital. Those who need non-emergency medical care are advised to call HealthLine 811, visit a walk-in clinic, or connect with their pharmacy, the SHA says. The UCC will return to its regular hours of operation on Sunday, from 8 a.m. to 9:30 p.m.
CTV News
an hour ago
- CTV News
What's the risk of catching measles at airports? Here's what travellers need to know
With the busy summer travel season approaching, some Canadians may be worried about catching measles in public places, such as airports and other indoor settings, amid a resurgence of the highly contagious disease in Canada and around the world. 'We live in an unprecedented time of human mobility at a global level, and we will see inevitable cases of measles imported into Canada,' Dr. Isaac Bogoch, infectious diseases specialist at the Toronto General Hospital, said in a video interview with on Thursday. 'It's happening and it will continue to happen. And while we can't necessarily control what happens outside of our borders, we certainly can have influence of what happens within our borders, and it's our duty to lower barriers to routine childhood immunizations.' Here's what Canadians need to know about the chances of catching it. Measles in Canada and globally Within Canada's borders, the disease has been spreading, with an ongoing outbreak that began in New Brunswick last October affecting a total of 2,088 people as of May 31. This outbreak is the largest in the country since 1998, with related cases in Ontario, Alberta, British Columbia, Manitoba, Northwest Territories, Nova Scotia, Prince Edward Island, Quebec and Saskatchewan. Measles has been 'eliminated' in the country since 1998, which indicates it's no longer found in a large area, according to the Canadian government's latest monitoring report. However, measles cases occur sporadically, typically coming from other affected regions. Cases have climbed to a 27-year peak in Canada, with 2,698 confirmed this year compared to only 17 in 1998. One death was reported in Ontario this year. 'We are in the midst of an outbreak in parts of Canada right now, and there are potential exposures in public places, airports, community centres, restaurants, public places where people may visit,' Bogoch said. 'But if people are immune to this infection, preferably through vaccination but also through recovery from infection, the risk is negligible.' Many parts of the world are experiencing a growing number of measles cases. For instance, data from the European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control show the number of measles cases in the European Union and European Economic Area have risen since 2013. In the United States, more than 1,100 measles cases were reported this year, and the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention recently updated its travel notice to warn people that they can get the disease from many travel settings such as airports, train stations, crowded events and tourist attractions, CNN reported on June 5. Even with the outbreak in Canada, the country's travel health notice says the risk is at the lowest level. The level 1 advisory encourages travellers to practise health precautions, including avoiding insect bites, properly washing their hands and having updated vaccinations. It said vaccination is the best way to protect yourself and others from the disease. 'My main concern is that there may be people who are non-immune who can receive a free, widely available vaccine that has decades of safety data and decades of effectiveness data associated with it and that it's a preventable disease,' Bogoch said. How do you get measles? The virus is spread through coughing, sneezing or breathing the same air as an infected person. It can remain contagious in the air or on infected surfaces for up to two hours, according to the World Health Organization. Who is most at risk? Most people are immune to measles, but the virus will circulate more in certain cases, with those who are unvaccinated and not immune to it mainly getting infected, Bogoch said. He noted that pockets of Canada may have under-vaccinated communities. He listed an example of many cases in Ontario occurring in a largely unvaccinated Mennonite Christian community in the southwestern part of the province. 'It sadly spreads like wildfire, and that's exactly what we're seeing happening right now,' Bogoch said. People who get infected with the virus are typically those under age 20, he added. 'It's primarily, almost exclusively … people who have not received two doses of vaccine,' Bogoch said. 'You can significantly lower risk of infection by receiving a routine childhood immunization. Two doses of a measles vaccine is extraordinarily effective in preventing measles infections.' Where are people more likely to get measles? While people can contract measles at airports, train stations and other crowded public areas, Bogoch said there isn't one primary place of infection. 'Measles is transmitted primarily in indoor settings through the air,' he said. 'It's a virus that is able to stay suspended in the air for a prolonged period of time, and the infectious dose is tiny. 'So if someone is non-immune and is exposed to the virus in an indoor setting, there's a very high likelihood that that person will get infected with measles.' With the disease mostly transmitted in indoor settings, the risks aren't necessarily higher during the peak summer travel season. 'It can be transmitted at any time of year,' Bogoch said. 'For example, in the winter months, there might be more people crowding in indoor settings because it's cold outside.' Symptoms and treatment Symptoms can show up as a fever, cough, runny nose and watery eyes before a rash with red and blotchy spots appears. There isn't any specific antiviral treatment for measles. People can be treated with medications to help relieve symptoms. Most people recover, but severe cases may require hospitalization. Bogoch said the vast majority of those born before 1970 were already infected with measles since the virus was common back then, so they generally won't have to worry about getting it and have 'lifelong protection.' Most who have received two doses of the measles-mumps-rubella (MMR) vaccine, which is routinely given to children, have a 'very, very small' risk of infection, Bogoch added. Advice for travellers If you're travelling anywhere outside Canada where the measles risk may be higher, Bogoch recommends getting health advice before leaving the country. 'There's measles, but of course, there's a lot of other things that you can be mindful of and take precautions to ensure you have a healthy, safe and happy trip,' he said.
CTV News
an hour ago
- CTV News
Changes coming to Waterloo Region's approach to drug strategy
Changes are coming to how the Region of Waterloo handles its approach to illicit drugs. The Waterloo Region Integrated Drug Strategy (WRIDS) has focused on substance abuse harm reduction for more than a decade, but now their funding stream from the region is drying up. 'Public health has funded, for many years, resources to the WRIDS in the form of funding to support an administrative role that would support the steering committee and the actions of the working groups,' said Rhonda Nicholls, director of strategy, performance and partnerships for Region of Waterloo Public Health. Now, that funding will no longer be available at the end of this year. 'After that, public health staff and other system partners will continue all the impactful work that has really started to take shape over the last number of years,' Nicholls said. She explained the funding that supported WRIDS will instead be directed to other community organizations also focused on tackling substance abuse issues. In light of the funding decision, a steering committee has decided to sunset WRIDS. 'This was not an easy decision, but given much of the work within the Four Pillars of our drug strategy is happening at various tables and initiatives, the Steering Committee felt that everyone's resources were best utilized in supporting this existing work,' a release from WRIDS explained on May 26. WRIDS lists its four pillars as prevention, treatment, harm reduction and enforcement. 'We know that the drug poisoning crisis continues to claim lives across our community, and we need to continue to work collaboratively to coordinate programs and strategies, share and advocate for resources, and put an end to this crisis,' the release said. A call for support Advocates say more work is needed at a provincial level to really get a grip on the ongoing issues. 'We have a public health policy, but the public health policy really isn't working,' said Brice Balmer, former chair of the Waterloo Region Crime Prevention Task Force, which developed WRIDS. 'It comes out of the province now instead of out of the region. It's really not working at the systemic [level] that needs to go on with everybody working together.' Balmer said it will take effort on all fronts to effectively address the pervasive problems. 'The work of the [Waterloo Region] Integrated Drug Strategy has actually minimized over the last six, seven, eight years. Even after we got the whole strategy together, everybody worked on it. But then it turned out to be maybe six or seven people that were working on the strategy, rather than bringing a whole group of people together to really look at how addiction impacted many agencies.' He said the best way forward, is to work together.
