Woman who claimed ‘voices' told her to abuse maid has jail term more than doubled to 7 years
Anita Damu, 57, was initially sentenced to two years and seven months' jail in 2018. PHOTO: ST FILE
Woman who claimed 'voices' told her to abuse maid has jail term more than doubled to 7 years
SINGAPORE – A maid abuser who appealed to the High Court to avoid jail time on grounds that she heard voices telling her to hurt the domestic worker, had her prison sentence more than doubled to seven years instead.
Anita Damu, 57, was initially sentenced to two years and seven months' jail in 2018, after a district judge accepted two psychiatric reports that she had abused the victim under the influence of auditory hallucinations.
This explanation has since been rejected by the court.
In increasing her sentence on May 26 , Chief Justice Sundaresh Menon said the sentences imposed by the lower court on each of the charges she faced were manifestly inadequate.
'Among other things, they were infected by the erroneous assumption that the acts of abuse were caused by the auditory hallucinations,' he said.
Anita , who is also known as Shazana Abdullah, had inflicted serious physical and psychological abuse on her 29-year-old Indonesian helper between 2014 and 2015.
The abuse came to light in April 2015 after a Ministry of Manpower officer received information that the maid was being abused by her employer, and visited the flat .
The officer reported the matter to the police after observing that the helper had welts on her face, burn marks on her hands, and scars on her body.
In September 2018, Anita pleaded guilty to five charges: one each for depriving the victim of rest, splashing her with hot water, burning her with an iron, poking her with a metal prong, and hitting her in the face with a slipper.
Four other charges – for slapping the victim, pinching her with pliers on two occasions, and pushing a cup of hot water towards her mouth – were taken into consideration for sentencing.
During a sentencing hearing in October 2018, while her lawyer was arguing for her to be given a fine, she suddenly felt giddy and had to be taken to hospital.
In December that year, she was sentenced to two years and seven months' jail.
She was also ordered to pay $8,000 in compensation to the victim.
Both she and the prosecution appealed against the sentence. The prosecution also appealed for a higher sum of compensation.
She has paid an additional $4,000 in voluntary compensation on top of the ordered sum.
When the appeal was first heard in 2019, Chief Justice Menon ruled that the psychiatric reports alone were not sufficient for the district judge to conclude that the woman was hearing voices when she abused the maid.
The Chief Justice sent the case back to the lower court to determine whether she had suffered from such a condition.
He said the offender should take the stand, as it was incumbent on her to present the best evidence available to support her assertion.
Before she could testify, Anita was diagnosed with schizophrenia. She was assessed to be of unsound mind and unable to understand and follow court proceedings.
Since June 2023, she has been confined at the Institute of Mental Health.
On Aug 5, 2024, she was certified to be of sound mind and capable of standing trial.
She and her family members eventually took the stand to testify before the district judge.
In a judgment dated April 2, the district judge concluded that she did not suffer from auditory hallucinations and that her claim was a 'fabrication'.
The appeal before Chief Justice Menon resumed on May 26.
Deputy Public Prosecutor Timotheus Koh sought a jail term of four years and seven months, standing by the prosecution's submissions in 2019.
He also sought a further $9,588 in compensation.
Chief Justice Menon said the sentence sought by the prosecution was 'manifestly insufficient', looking at the totality of the offending behaviour, the harm to the victim and the cruelty towards the victim.
He said he will explain his sentencing decision in a written judgment at a later date.
He also allowed the prosecution's appeal on the compensation order.
This means Anita has to pay a total of $21,588 to the maid.
Chief Justice Menon noted that while most foreign domestic workers are well-provided for, occasionally, some do not adjust well or have employers who fail to care for them.
'At times, they even fail to accord them the basic dignity due to a fellow human being. Sadly, this is such a case,' he said.
He added that it was a 'matter of regret' that the case has taken this long to be resolved, in large part because of the litigation choices made by the accused.
Selina Lum is senior law correspondent at The Straits Times.
Join ST's WhatsApp Channel and get the latest news and must-reads.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Straits Times
3 hours ago
- Straits Times
Global airline association seeks to address growing problem of in-flight theft
There has been a growing number of theft cases reported on board flights to a number of cities in Asia. PHOTO: ST FILE – The theft of personal belongings on board planes is a growing problem in some parts of the world, and the global trade body for airlines plans to hold discussions on how to deal with this in the coming weeks. Mr Nick Careen, senior vice-president for operations, safety and security at the International Air Transport Association (Iata), said feedback from its members indicate that in-flight theft has become more of an issue on certain routes in the past 12 to 18 months. This is in line with the recovery in international air travel post-pandemic. 'Our security advisory group is planning to meet in the next week or two to discuss what we could potentially do to better manage this – out of China mostly, where it seems to be very organised,' he told the media on June 3. Speaking at Iata's annual general meeting in New Delhi, India, Mr Careen also delved into other aviation safety issues, including turbulence, gaps in accident reporting, and GPS jamming and spoofing near conflict areas. He said: 'We're still the safest mode of transportation... However, we never rest on our laurels in aviation. There are headwinds. There are things that we need to keep an eye on.' On in-flight theft, Mr Careen said he did not want to point fingers, but the concern is the degree of organisation in recent cases. 'How we deal with that, whether it's security on board or cooperation from local governments in terms of the appropriate penalties... those are the types of things that we will see come out of this,' he added. There has been a growing number of theft cases reported on board flights to a number of cities in Asia. In the first 10 months of 2024, Hong Kong recorded 169 such cases, involving HK$4.32 million (S$709,300) worth of valuables – 75 per cent higher than for the same period in 2023. Tokyo's Narita International Airport also reported a recent spike in in-flight thefts. In Singapore, four people were charged over in-flight theft between January 2023 and September 2024, CNA reported in January. Most recently, Chinese national Zhang Kun, 51, pleaded guilty in May to stealing a credit card and more than $200 in cash from a fellow passenger on an overnight Scoot flight from Kuala Lumpur to Singapore in March. Another issue Mr Careen addressed at the Iata meeting was the recent changes made by some airlines to the rules on the use of power banks on flights. This was in the wake of a number of aircraft fires, most notably the blaze in January that destroyed an Air Busan plane in South Korea. In April, Singapore Airlines (SIA) and Scoot banned the use and charging of power banks on their flights, as did carriers in South Korea, Taiwan, Thailand, Malaysia and Hong Kong. In May, Southwest Airlines in the US also tightened its rules on portable battery use. Mr Careen said there is nothing wrong with airlines adjusting their procedures based on their own safety risk assessments. But Iata has not seen a rampant increase in fires on board planes, and he warned against knee-jerk reactions. Airline procedures should ultimately be standardised, Mr Careen added, and any changes should be made via a regulatory review by the International Civil Aviation Organisation, which is discussing the issue. Mr Careen also addressed concerns over turbulence, which he said is the leading cause of accidents on board aircraft. This is one area where Iata is using data to improve safety, he noted. Today, 28 airlines, including SIA and Scoot, exchange real-time turbulence information using Iata's Turbulence Aware platform, sharing reports from more than 2,700 aircraft. This is up from 25 carriers six months ago, and Taiwanese carrier Eva Air on June 2 said that it will be joining the platform as well. Asked if the data-sharing has led to more flights avoiding choppy air, Mr Careen said Iata has not been tracking this. While the association should do so, this would also be hard to measure, he noted. Mr Careen said there has been a rise in turbulence incidents, but this has primarily been due to increased reporting. Referencing SIA's Flight SQ321, which hit severe turbulence in May 2024 that led to a passenger dying of a suspected heart attack, he said such sensational incidents have exacerbated the focus on this topic. It is too early to draw conclusions about the impact of climate change on turbulence incidents, he added. Mr Careen on June 3 also called on governments to improve their accident reporting. 'The standards are clear. Thirty days after, you're required to provide a preliminary report. And 12 months later, you should have the report completed. That does not happen consistently,' he said. Mr Careen said there are still 107 investigations from the period between 2018 and 2023 that remain incomplete, noting that 234 lives were lost in these accidents. Calling this a 'dereliction of duty', Mr Careen added: 'You can't prevent the next (accident) from happening without understanding what happened in the first place.' The politicisation of investigations is an issue, as are labour and technical snags. 'We're willing to accept the good reasons. When we don't get a reason, that's when there's a problem,' he said. According to Iata, there were 1.13 accidents per million flights in 2024 – lower than the five-year average of 1.25. The number of on-board deaths rose sharply to 244 from 72 in 2023, but the fatality risk in 2024 of 0.06 was still lower than the five-year average of 0.1. Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
Straits Times
14 hours ago
- Straits Times
In-flight theft a growing problem that global airline association seeks to address
There has been a growing number of theft cases reported on board flights to a number of cities in Asia. PHOTO: ST FILE – The theft of personal belongings on board planes is a growing problem in some parts of the world, and the global trade body for airlines plans to hold discussions on how to deal with this in the coming weeks. Mr Nick Careen, senior vice-president for operations, safety and security at the International Air Transport Association (Iata), said feedback from its members indicate that in-flight theft has become more of an issue on certain routes in the past 12 to 18 months. This is in line with the recovery in international air travel post-pandemic. 'Our security advisory group are planning to meet in the next week or two to discuss what we could potentially do to better manage this – out of China mostly, where it seems to be very organised,' he told reporters on June 3. Speaking at Iata's annual general meeting in New Delhi, Mr Careen also delved into other aviation safety issues, including turbulence, gaps in accident reporting, and GPS jamming and spoofing near conflict areas. He said: 'We're still the safest mode of transportation... However, we never rest on our laurels in aviation. There are headwinds. There are things that we need to keep an eye on.' On in-flight theft, Mr Careen said he did not want to point fingers, but the concern is the degree of organisation in recent cases. 'How we deal with that, whether it's security on board or cooperation from local governments in terms of the appropriate penalties... those are the types of things that we will see come out of this,' he added. There has been a growing number of theft cases reported on board flights to a number of cities in Asia. In the first 10 months of 2024, Hong Kong recorded 169 such cases involving HK$4.32 million (S$708,775) worth of valuables – 75 per cent higher than the same period in 2023. Tokyo's Narita International Airport also reported a recent spike in in-flight thefts. In Singapore, four people were charged for in-flight theft between January 2023 and September 2024, CNA reported in January. Most recently, Chinese national Zhang Kun, 51, pleaded guilty in May to stealing a credit card and more than $200 in cash from a fellow passenger on an overnight Scoot flight from Kuala Lumpur to Singapore in March. Another issue Mr Careen addressed at the Iata meeting was the recent changes made by some airlines to the rules on the use of power banks on flights. This was in the wake of a number of aircraft fires, most notably the blaze in January that destroyed an Air Busan plane in South Korea. In April, Singapore Airlines (SIA) and Scoot banned the use and charging of power banks on their flights, as have carriers in South Korea, Taiwan, Thailand, Malaysia and Hong Kong. In May, Southwest Airlines in the US also tightened its rules on portable battery use. Mr Careen said there is nothing wrong with airlines adjusting their procedures based on their own safety risk assessments. But Iata has not seen a rampant increase of fires on board planes, and he warned against making knee-jerk reactions. Airline procedures should be ultimately be standardised, he added, and any changes should be made via a regulatory review by the International Civil Aviation Organisation, which is in discussion about the issue. Mr Careen also addressed concerns over turbulence, which he said is the leading cause of accidents on board aircraft. This is one area where Iata is using data to improve safety, he added. Today, 28 airlines, including SIA and Scoot, exchange real-time turbulence information using Iata's Turbulence Aware platform, sharing reports from more than 2,700 aircraft. This is up from 25 carriers six months ago, and Taiwanese carrier Eva Air said on June 2 that it will be joining the platform too. Asked if the data-sharing has led to more flights avoiding choppy air, Mr Careen said Iata has not been tracking this. While it should do so, this would also be hard to measure, he noted. Mr Careen said there has been a rise in turbulence incidents, but this has primarily been due to increased reporting. Referencing SIA's Flight SQ321, which hit severe turbulence in May 2024 that led to a passenger dying of a suspected heart attack, he said such sensational incidents have exacerbated the focus on this topic. It is also too early to draw conclusions about the impact of climate change on turbulence incidents, he added. Mr Careen on June 3 also called on governments to improve their accident reporting. 'The standards are clear. Thirty days after, you're required to provide a preliminary report. And 12 months later, you should have the report completed. That does not happen consistently,' he added. Mr Careen said there are still 107 investigations from the period between 2018 and 2023 that remain incomplete, noting that 234 lives were lost in these accidents. Calling this a 'dereliction of duty', Mr Careen added: 'You can't prevent the next (accident) from happening without understanding what will happen in the first place.' The politicisation of investigations is an issue, as are labour and technical snags. 'We're willing to accept the good reasons. When we don't get a reason, that's when there's a problem,' he said. According to Iata, there were 1.13 accidents per million flights in 2024 – lower than the five-year average of 1.25. The number of on-board deaths rose sharply to 244 from 72 in 2023, but the fatality risk in 2024 of 0.06 was still lower than the five-year average of 0.10. Join ST's WhatsApp Channel and get the latest news and must-reads.
New Paper
15 hours ago
- New Paper
Eldercare services provider fined after client in wheelchair rolled off van platform and later died
Two employees of an eldercare services provider were helping clients board its van when one of the senior citizens fell off the vehicle's wheelchair lift platform and his head struck the ground. Mr Hassan Mohamed Karchi Arsan Osman, 76, was unconscious when he was taken to the National University Hospital, and he died of a head injury at 9.35pm on Feb 3, 2021. On June 3, Active Global Respite Care was fined $7,000 after it was convicted of an offence under the Workplace Safety and Health (Risk Management) Regulations. Court documents stated that the company had failed to implement safety control measures and safe work procedures governing the use of the wheelchair lift at the rear of the van. Two people, who were working for Active Global Respite Care when the incident took place, were each fined $10,000 in December 2023. Myanmar national Moe Thadar, then 49, was a health care assistant at the time while Singaporean Kwa Kim Seng, then 67, was employed as a van driver. They had failed to ensure that the brakes of Mr Hassan's wheelchair were engaged, causing his death. For the current case, Ministry of Manpower prosecutor Kimberly Boo told the court that Active Global Respite Care owned two vans used for transporting elderly clients between their homes and a senior care centre located at Block 31A, Ghim Moh Link. A health care assistant would be present in each van to assist with the transportation of such elderly clients. Each van was installed with a wheelchair lift at its rear. This lift allowed wheelchair users to be loaded onto the vehicle through a platform that could be raised. At around 4.40pm on Feb 3, 2021, Moe Thadar and Kwa were at work, helping the company's elderly clients board one of the vans at the senior care centre's pickup point. Ms Boo said: "When Moe wheeled (Mr Hassan) from the pickup point onto the wheelchair lift platform, she failed to engage the brakes of (his) wheelchair. "As Moe was walking away, she told Kwa 'uncle, hold', in order to inform him that (Mr Hassan) was ready to be lifted. Kwa proceeded to raise the wheelchair lift platform while chatting with a colleague." As the platform was reaching the top of the lift, in line with the van, Kwa did not wait for a health care assistant inside the van to grab hold of the wheelchair. Kwa released his grip off Mr Hassan's wheelchair, which then rolled backwards and off the platform. Mr Hassan's head struck the ground when he fell. He was pronounced dead later that day. Ms Boo told the court that prior to the incident, Active Global Respite Care had no documented risk assessment on the transportation of their clients using a van with a wheelchair lift. She added that on the day of the incident, multiple control measures to minimise safety risks to Mr Hassan were also not implemented. These included ensuring that wheelchair brakes were engaged before activating the wheelchair lift. Defence lawyers Gloria James-Civetta and Noelle Teoh, who represented Active Global Respite Care, on June 3 pleaded for their client to be given a fine of not more than $5,000. The pair from Gloria James-Civetta & Co added: "The incident was an isolated and unprecedented occurrence that tragically resulted in the passing of the late Mr Hassan. "Prior to the incident on Feb 3, 2021, Active Global had operated in Singapore for several years without any record of similar serious incidents or accidents. It is also noted that the late Mr Hassan had successfully completed nearly 500 rides with Active Global over the course of his engagement, without issue." The lawyers stated in court documents that since the incident, their client has taken immediate and proactive measures to address any gaps in its safety protocols. This includes updating its standard operating procedure in June 2021 to further enhance the clients' safety during transportation. The company has also deployed additional manpower to act as traffic marshals at the drop-off and pick-up points of its centres, the court heard.
