3 controversial bills to change the judiciary have been stopped — others are still proceeding
Bills that proposed changes to judicial retention and judicial elections will no longer be considered. Senate President J. Stuart Adams and Speaker Mike Schultz released a statement on Monday afternoon about the decision.
'Through deliberate debate, thoughtful conversations and in a spirit of collaboration, the Legislature and the Judiciary have found a path forward that will make our government stronger and our state better,' the statement reads.
Legal professionals protest against bills that seek to reshape Utah's judicial branch
The following bills will no longer proceed:
H.B. 512, 'Judicial Retention Changes'
H.B. 451, 'Judicial Election Amendments'
Unnumbered 'Judicial Officer Modifications'
H.B. 512 would have set up the 'Joint Legislative Committee on Judicial Performance.' The bill would have directed the Lt. Governor's office to put 'any retention recommendation from the (committee) for a judge or justice who is listed on the ballot.'
H.B. 451 would have raised the threshold for a judge to be retained. According to the language in the bill, it proposed requiring judges to receive at least 67% of the vote to retain their office.
'Judicial Officer Modifications' would have increased the number of justices.
The following bills/resolutions will still be considered:
S.B. 203, 'Judicial Standing Amendments'
S.B. 204, 'Right to Appeal Amendments'
S.J.R. 9, 'Joint Resolution Amending Rules of Civil Procedure on Injunctions'
S.B. 203 looks to (people different from the plaintiff) and add requirements for when an association can bring a case on behalf of its members. Critics argue this would make it harder for 'everyday Utahns' to challenge laws.
S.B. 204 would allow defendants to appeal an injunction when a trial court rules that a law must be paused or not enacted because it's potentially unconstitutional. Sen. Brady Brammer (R – Pleasant Grove) has previously told ABC4.com this proposal aims to address the 'overuse' of injunctions in lower courts, particularly on laws passed by the legislature and signed by the governor.
S.J.R. 009 would put a 28-day stipulation on parties challenging potentially unconstitutional laws and seeking an injunction. They would need to do so within 28 days from the time the legislature adjourns.
The Judicial Council (the governing body for the Utah Judiciary) said it will remain neutral on S.B. 296, which would allow vacancies in the high court and court of appeals to be filled by appointment of the Governor and confirmation by the Senate.
'The Utah Constitution wisely created three independent branches of government,' Chief Justice Durrant, presiding officer of the Judicial Council, said in a statement. 'At times, there is tension, but that will not prevent the Judiciary and the Legislature from working together to serve the people of Utah.'
Lindsay Aerts contributed to this report.
Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Fox News
26 minutes ago
- Fox News
Swing-state gov slams Trump plan to nix mail-in voting: He ‘can sign whatever the hell he wants'
President Donald Trump took heat from a major swing-state governor and potential 2028 Democratic presidential contender who scoffed Wednesday at the idea of eliminating mail-in balloting by fiat. "Donald Trump can sign whatever the hell executive orders he wants to sign and make a show out of whatever he wants, but he can't change the Constitution with an executive order," Pennsylvania Gov. Josh Shapiro said at a press conference in Harrisburg. "The Constitution gives the authority to set our election rules to the states," Shapiro said. "Let me remind you that it was just about five years ago that a bipartisan majority in the House and in the Senate passed mail-in voting. And [since] that time, millions of people have voted by mail," Shapiro said. He was referring to Act 77 of 2019, which several Republicans supported but later accused Democrats and left-leaning judges of substantially altering post-hoc. Shapiro said Pennsylvania has enjoyed "free and fair" elections – and added that Trump has both won and lost the commonwealth in contests throughout his political career. "For him to try and put more misinformation out there, to stoke more division and fear amongst people who want to exercise their constitutional right to pick the leaders in their communities and in their commonwealth – that is just cynical and wrong." Shapiro said any Trump order will have "no bearing" on Keystone State elections, and that he will support county election officials in all 67 counties in permitting mail-in voting. Former Pennsylvania House Speaker Bryan Cutler, R-Lancaster, lambasted the bipartisan mail-in-vote law Shapiro referenced – accusing Democrats and the popularly-elected Pennsylvania Supreme Court of "diluting" it from its original purpose. "Only one party [worked to] eliminate security safeguards, and delay the timelines for elections," Cutler said in an LNP column, adding the Democrat-controlled high bench "unconstitutionally acted to change the law for receiving and counting ballots [and] allowed for drop boxes … and stripped the security provisions for mail-in ballots." On Monday, Trump foreshadowed changes to the election system, pledging to "lead a movement to get rid of mail-in ballots." Trump wrote on Truth Social he would sign an executive order in that regard to "help bring honesty to the 2026 midterm elections," and said states are "merely agent[s]" for the federal government.
The Hill
32 minutes ago
- The Hill
Senate Democrat predicts ‘day of reckoning' for private prison employees
Sen. Jon Ossoff (D-Ga.) on Wednesday said private prison employees would have to answer to their treatment of inmates amid the Trump administration's crackdown on illegal immigration and as more detention facilities may pop up around the U.S. 'There, at some point, is going to be a reckoning for all of this,' Ossoff told MSNBC during an appearance on 'The Weeknight.' 'These folks who are working at these private prison companies, who are on Kristi Noem's staff right now, they are at some point going to have to testify under oath about what is happening in the facilities that they're currently running,' he added. Democrats have slammed Republicans for rejecting their attempts to conduct oversight at facilities where U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) hold detained migrants awaiting deportation. Some state lawmakers were also denied entry to 'Alligator Alcatraz' last month, the detention center in the Florida Everglades. They have also been critical of President Trump's robust immigration agenda, with turmoil rising after lawmakers joined with protestors outside of an ICE center in New York earlier this year and anti-ICE protests sprung up in Southern California and beyond in opposition to an uptick in deportation raids after the administration sent National Guard soldiers to Los Angeles to quell demonstrations. Families of those detained and human rights groups have said their loved ones are suffering from abuse while in ICE custody, such as a lack of clean water and electricity. 'We're talking about pregnant women. We're talking about children,' Ossoff told MSNBC's Alicia Menendez. 'We're talking about people who have no business being in one of these horrible detention centers.' 'And, you know, I believe that the American people have rejected this draconian and inhumane approach to interior enforcement,' the lawmaker continued. 'But in terms of my Republican colleagues, no spine is yet visible in the Senate.' The Georgia Democrat also noted that the treatment is 'indefensible' citing what he said is over 500 credible reports of abuses. House and Senate Democrats joined forces to send a Wednesday letter to Department of Homeland Security (DHS) Secretary Kristi Noem hoping to address the alleged injustices. 'Brushing aside concerns from human rights watchdogs, environmentalist groups, and Tribal nations, [DHS] has greenlit the construction of this expansive detention facility that may violate detained individuals' human rights, jeopardize public and environmental health and violate federal law,' Democrats wrote in a letter to Noem inquiring about operations at 'Alligator Alcatraz.' It's unclear if they've received a response.
Yahoo
40 minutes ago
- Yahoo
'Maine's Mamdani': Maine GOP chief issues warning about new challenger looking to oust Susan Collins
The latest addition to the pool of Democrats seeking to challenge Sen. Susan Collins, R-Maine, is doubling down on Zohran Mamdani-style socialism, says the chief of Maine's Republican Party. Democrat Graham Platner launched his campaign highlighting his history as an Army and Marine veteran as well as an oyster farmer, but state GOP chief Jason Savage told Fox News Digital that rural accolades aren't policy positions. He pointed to Platner's hiring of a top Mamdani advisor, Morris Katz, to produce his campaign launch video. In that video, Platner rails against the "oligarchy" and endorses universal healthcare. His website features messaging that claims the U.S. has a "billionaire economy," and that – if elected – Platner would view it as a key part of his job "to dismantle" it. "Graham Platner is Maine's Mamdani," Savage told Fox News Digital in an interview. "He brought in the Mamdani team to support his campaign. He's out doing a lot of work with socialist groups.… He's a Bernie bro." Senate Democrats Are Feverishly Recruiting Top Candidates To Win Back Majority In 2026 Midterms "What we're seeing here is the exporting of the Mamdani ideology to the state of Maine because they think that they can gain ground in a small state where things aren't as expensive," he added. Read On The Fox News App Trump Ally Mike Collins Launch Key Battleground State Bid To Flip Democrat-held Senate Seat "You can look through Graham Platner's donor history, and you can see that he donated to Harris for President, Bernie Sanders, Ilhan Omar," he continued, arguing that far-left candidates are a major threat to the Democratic Party. Platner's campaign did not immediately respond to a request for comment from Fox News Digital. "If commonsense Democrats, and then the leadership like [Sen.] Chuck Schumer don't do something and say that isn't the future of our party, then they're gonna run in a bunch of these races. and we're gonna beat them," he said. Savage argued that the Democratic Party's embracing of the far left is a "double-edged sword." He said Democratic candidates can't succeed without the "extreme wing" of the party, and now "they've created a monster that they don't have the ability to control." "In the long run, it's going to be catastrophic for them. I mean, Graham Platner advocates for allowing men to be in girls' and women's sports," Savage said. "He advocates for all sorts of policies that are very, very unpopular, and the Democrats can't say anything to stop that." The Democratic challenger list against Collins is growing, and reports say those already in office are trying to tap Janet Mills, the state's 77-year-old Democratic governor, for the seat. Republicans currently control the majority of the Senate by a 53-47 margin. Democrats would need to flip four seats in the 2026 midterm elections to take the majority. A spokesperson for Collins told Fox News Digital that Platner is "just another progressive entering the race." Fox News' Pilar Arias contributed to this report Original article source: 'Maine's Mamdani': Maine GOP chief issues warning about new challenger looking to oust Susan Collins
