Can Leeds United and Burnley survive the EPL?
Congratulations to Leeds and Burnley for their promotion back to the EPL and the huge pay check that comes with it.
Both teams have fully deserved their success. Under Daniel Farke, Leeds have been the most exciting Championship team to watch this season. With 89 goals they are by far the league's top scorers (the next closest is Middlesborough with 64 goals).
Advertisement
Conversely - but no less impressively - Burnley (under the management of Scott Parker) have the best defensive record conceding a miserly 15 goals in 44 games (Leeds are 2nd in this metric with 29 goals conceded). There are many ways to skin a cat. Or get promotion to the EPL.
Now comes the harsh reality. In the last two seasons all promoted teams have been relegated. In the 2023/24 season it was Luton, Burnley and Sheffield United. This season Ipswich, Leicester and Southampton are the ones to exemplify the massive gap in class (and money) between the Championship and EPL. In most cases those teams have pressed the panic button and fired their manager – and it's not made an iota of difference.
Daniel Farke and Scott Parker know this. Farke took Norwich up to the EPL in 2018/19. And then took them straight back down. He secured promotion again in the 20/21 campaign, before being fired in September 2021 after overseeing a run of 15 consecutive Premier League losses (a record).
Scott Parker couldn't keep Fulham up when appointed as temporary manager in March 2019. But he did succeed in returning Fulham to the EPL the following season via the play-offs. Only to oversee their relegation again in the 20/21 season after which he was fired. Parker then took over at Bournemouth where he guided them to promotion. The next season he was fired after just four games, three of which they lost with an aggregate score of 0-16.
Advertisement
There are two ways of looking at this. The first is that both were treated harshly and deserved to stay. It's an unrealistic expectation for a promoted club to achieve survival. Clubs that have stuck to their principals and tried to play out from the back have been severely punished for their naivety. Those that have tried to build their success via a defensive mindset risk doing no better – and upsetting the fans along the way with their dour style. It's an impossible job.
The second way of looking at this comes with hindsight. Norwich probably shouldn't have fired Farke; they have struggled since and will finish midtable in the EFL Championship this season. Post-Parker, Fulham and Bournemouth are flying under the guidance of Marco Silva and Andoni Iraola respectively.
Winning promotion from the Championship and keeping a team in the EPL are two very different jobs. The chances are that it ends badly for the promoted teams. History tells us they will probably fire their managers in the middle of next season, neither of whom have succeeded In the EPL. So perhaps the smart play is to say 'Thanks for the promotion; but now you are fired'.
Related: Put Manchester City In The Relegation Zone To Make It Interesting
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Everton midfielder teases supporters as talks over new deal progress
Idrissa Gueye teased Everton supporters with a flurry of social media posts amid his ongoing talks over a new deal. The veteran midfielder is due to enter the final month of his contract on Sunday but the ECHO understands discussions with the 35-year-old to extend his second stint at the Blues are progressing. Advertisement The contract talks follow a season in which he was the backbone of a resilient Everton side, again asserting himself at the heart of the team's midfield. His form after the appointment of David Moyes in January was crucial to the results that pulled the club from a relegation battle. The influence of the Senegal international was particularly valuable given Moyes was forced to take on his opening weeks with an injury-blighted midfield - he arrived with James Garner and Tim Iroegbunam recovering from serious injuries and lost Orel Mangala to knee ligament damage in the hard-fought win at Brighton and Hove Albion, just the third game of his return to Merseyside. READ MORE: Liam Delap update, Idrissa Gueye decision, major contract news - Everton transfer stock take READ MORE: Everton handed major Carlos Alcaraz transfer boost as priority deadline nears Advertisement Gueye's relentless consistency - and the tenacity that saw him make more tackles than anyone else in the Premier League this season - led to supporters voting him the player of the year for the men's team. Gueye was handed the award at Finch Farm and responded by speaking of his pride at the accolade and of his hope Everton get 'what they deserve' and can move on to competing for Europe. There is an increasing expectation the former Paris Saint Germain star will be part of efforts to help Everton progress and he did little to play down that prospect on X, formerly Twitter. Sharing footage of his award win, he posted: 'Thank you everyone, the future looks bright!' Gueye also asked another supporter to 'send me the proof' when he wrote he would name his child after the player, then used two laughing emojis as he shared another fan's request for him to sign a new deal. Advertisement Moyes is keen to rebuild his central midfield this summer with Abdoulaye Doucoure departing the club once his contract expires next month and the Blues boss desperate to add goals from that position.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Why David Moyes wants to strike key Everton deal as club favourite set for exit
David Moyes faces one of the toughest challenges of his managerial career with Everton this summer. The club enters this summer with hopes that new ownership will provide stability behind-the-scenes while the move to the Hill Dickinson Stadium should boost the Blues' reputation, revenue and appeal to the new signings Moyes will need to strengthen his squad in line with the ambitions of The Friedkin Group and supporters. Advertisement With that expectation - intensified after his transformative impact on a squad that looked destined for a relegation fight when he took over in January - comes additional pressure though. For Moyes, the test over the coming months is to protect the characteristics that enabled Everton to surge away from trouble and finish with three consecutive wins, while making room for players who will improve what his squad is capable of. READ MORE: Goodison Park shook and Everton had hope - dramatic Bournemouth win in the words of those behind it READ MORE: Liam Delap Manchester United transfer warning sent after Everton talks - 'Not an upgrade' Advertisement Key to his mindset this summer is leadership. Moyes is aware he will need strong characters in the dressing room, not just to set standards but also to impress the responsibility of wearing Royal Blue on new recruits and to help the move from Goodison to the banks of the Mersey - something he is concerned could prove tough. This is one of the reasons he is keen for Seamus Coleman to stay on as a player next season. Moyes is not naive, he is aware the defender will turn 37 this year and that his body has prevented him from sustained availability yet again this season. After starting the Boxing Day draw at Manchester City, Coleman was unavailable for weeks. Twenty minutes into the Goodison farewell against Southampton that he had been protected for, he had to be withdrawn. But manager after manager has spoken of the value of Coleman off the pitch and several, most notably Frank Lampard, have stressed the importance of his influence as a bridge between the stands and the squad. Amid a miserable start to this season it was Coleman's words in the dressing room that prompted the second half comeback against Crystal Palace, Everton's first win of the campaign. Moyes has been impressed with the leadership within the squad he inherited from Sean Dyche. But a complex summer that began with 15 senior players on expiring deals has seen the departure of two of the stars whose impact Moyes was grateful for - Ashley Young and Asmir Begovic. Advertisement For some time it has been clear Coleman will have the chance to extend his stay at Everton for another year, but with the defender having supported former teammate Leighton Baines in the dugout after Dyche's exit and already boasting his coaching qualifications , it was unclear in what capacity he would stay, should he choose to remain. Coleman is one of several players whose future the club is yet to confirm, but Moyes has already made his personal preference clear. 'The plan is to keep him on a playing contract', he said before the win over Southampton. 'But we'll decide when we need to use him and when we won't. It might change, obviously Seamus is getting much further down the road and he's picked up a lot of injuries, so we'll see what fits, but generally he'll be staying next season.' Moyes added: 'We'll need people who understand the characteristics and culture, but we're also going to have to change as well. We have to move forward and we have to find ways of becoming a better side and being a better team. That's part of football. But we don't want to lose good people, we don't want to lose good characters and we want to retain the good things if we can.' Advertisement Jordan Pickford: 'We're going to lose some great servants' With Coleman absent through injury at Newcastle United on Sunday, it was Jordan Pickford who took the armband at the ground where he is subject to the greatest attention. Speaking after another impressive clean sheet, he also alluded to the loss of leaders that will come with the squad overhaul this summer. He told club media : 'We're going to lose some great servants of the club, great leaders in the team, but it's about, like the manager said, the other lads picking it up, picking the pieces and moving on… It's always an honour to captain Everton,' he continued. 'And, you know, when Seamus is not available and Tarks isn't, you've got to step up and it's something I'm really proud of and I know I've always been a leader. Everyone leads in different ways. 'But as well, there wasn't much of a team talk before the game. It was more the gaffer just said to show character. And I think that's what we did.' Advertisement Like Moyes in his post-match press conference , Pickford hopes the momentum gained in recent weeks can be carried through the summer. Players and staff are well aware of the need to start life at the new stadium well. He said: 'There was no pressure on the game, but that's not the level. The level was what we went out and showed today. And as a team performance, it was a great one to finish on. 'That is the standard and it's about continuing next season and it's about starting well – not getting the results at Christmas through to May. "It's about sustaining that momentum throughout the season. And when we take hits, it's how we bounce back as a team. And that's what the manager will be driving next season.' Advertisement James Tarkowski earns European recognition Pickford was handed the captaincy not just in the absence of Coleman but also of centre back James Tarkowski as he continues his recovery from hamstring surgery. The talismanic defender - responsible for the sensational stoppage time equaliser in the last Goodison derby this season - may have missed the last month of the campaign but that has not stopped him from joining some impressive company in the Who Scored? team of the year - for the whole of Europe. Based on the average ratings collated by the statistics site, which has almost one million followers on X alone, Tarkowski ended up in a back three of RB Leipzig's Willi Orban and Liverpool's Virgil van Dijk. The 32-year-old's average rating trumped both of those and landed Tarkowski in a star-studded team that included Barcelona's teen prodigy Lamine Yamal as well as Harry Kane and Kylian Mbappe. 'Contract Dave' set to leave Manchester United Former Everton director of football operations David Harrison - fondly known as 'Contract Dave' - is leaving Manchester United amid restructuring behind-the-scenes at the club. Harrison spent 27 years at the Blues, finishing in the role he went to take at Old Trafford back in February 2023. Advertisement He was based at the Carrington Training Centre and took responsibility for football operations for the men's, women's and academy teams. But he is now one of several senior figures set to depart, according to the Training Ground Guru website . Harrison's face became familiar to generations of Blues with him typically being the club official sat next to players in the photographs distributed to announce new signings and contract extensions.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Liam Delap update, Idrissa Gueye decision, major contract news - Everton transfer stock take
Everton start a busy summer with a lot of work to do. The Blues ended the season on a high, with three consecutive wins cementing the club in 13th place and capping off a sensational turnaround from the relegation fight David Moyes inherited in January. Advertisement He wants Everton to be looking up the table, not down it, but that will be no easy feat given the extent of the job at hand. The club finished the campaign with 15 players on expiring deals and Moyes will have to work hard to craft a squad capable of dealing with the threat from below - Manchester United, Tottenham Hotspur and West Ham United will be expected to improve dramatically next season - while playing catch-up to the sides that finished above Everton. The first priority is to finalise which of the many out of contract players will be offered new deals - a process that remains ongoing. Another is to appoint the final members of the club's new-look recruitment team. With Everton desperate to exploit the potential this summer offers, this is the state-of-play. READ MORE: Everton handed major Carlos Alcaraz transfer boost as priority deadline nears READ MORE: Goodison Park shook and Everton had hope - dramatic Bournemouth win in the words of those behind it Advertisement Goalkeepers: A job that has been added to the long 'to-do' list Jordan Pickford captained Everton in their final day win at Newcastle United and was exceptional again. His latest clean sheet left him with 12 for the season, behind only Arsenal's David Raya and Nottingham Forest's Matz Sels. It was some achievement for a player who has done more than any other, on the pitch at least, to protect Everton's Premier League status through recent dark years. While Pickford offers Everton an international-quality option in a key position, there is work to do behind him. Opportunities for Joao Virginia and Asmir Begovic have been limited but Virginia proved a capable back-up in cup competitions while Moyes repeatedly spoke of the leadership qualities of Begovic. That both are set to leave, with the club having opted not to trigger its extension for Virginia, comes as a surprise given how important stability in the goalkeeping department has been to keeping Pickford on top form. It adds another job to the lengthy 'to-do' list as Moyes will need to bring in at least one more option behind Pickford. Advertisement Harry Tyrer played 38 games in League One for Blackpool this season, a stint that followed success in the National League with Chesterfield the previous year. He would be the most senior back-up at Everton should Billy Crellin, who spent this year on loan at Accrington Stanley, not be offered a new deal. Even becoming third-choice would represent a significant step up for both, so Everton enter this summer looking for a back-up goalkeeper who has had some exposure to top-level first team football. Centre backs: A problem David Moyes was desperate to avoid Preparations for the summer began some time ago and Moyes quickly knew his starting point. The Blues boss has long-seen the foundation of his new-look Blues being the axis of Pickford, James Tarkowski and Jarrad Branthwaite. Advertisement Banking on both has become more fraught than he would have hoped. Tarkowski ended the season with a hamstring injury that poses a headache for Moyes. The 32-year-old is key to his plans but his game is built around his strength and durability. The injury required surgery and, while that is thought to have gone well, there was an expectation the recovery could eat into Tarkowski's pre-season. The hope is the centre back returns as the player Everton have relied so heavily on since his arrival three years ago. Until he makes his comeback there will be lingering fears over whether his first serious injury in years will have any long-term consequences. Moyes enters the summer aware there may be interest in Tarkowski's partner Branthwaite and keen to stave it off. The 22-year-old is central to his plans and holding onto him would represent a significant statement of intent heading into the new stadium. Chelsea are one of several potential suitors rumoured to be looking at the England starlet and, should they show greater respect than Manchester United did last year, could test Everton's resolve should they be willing to approach the club's valuation of the player. Last year that was north of £60m and that will be the case again given the new-found financial stability provided by owners The Friedkin Group. Advertisement While Everton will be reluctant to sell Branthwaite, club chiefs are expected to be pragmatic with sensible offers for key players this summer, particularly given the additional leeway any sale could have on the club's Profit and Sustainability calculations - before and after the June 30 fiscal deadline. The good news for Moyes is that, disappointing as it was to lose Tarkowski for the final month of the season, it allowed him to test Jake O'Brien in his favoured position. No player benefitted more through Moyes' appointment than O'Brien, who was signed amid fanfare in the summer but sidelined by Sean Dyche. O'Brien proved a capable option on the right of the defence and was impressive at Newcastle in the middle. The success of the towering centre back means that, should Tarkowski suffer a setback in his rehabilitation, or Everton receive an offer for Branthwaite that is too good to turn down, Moyes already has a solution. His problem is if Branthwaite is sold and Tarkowski is unable to undergo a strong pre-season. It is concerns around that which have led Moyes to think so carefully about the future of Michael Keane. Keane is out of contract and for most of this season had been expected to depart. There has been interest from Italy and the USA at various points this year, while he was set to be a target of Sheffield United had they won promotion from the Championship. Advertisement Moyes rates Keane's professionalism highly and with the potential for uncertainty ahead of him is considering whether he could be retained beyond the summer. Keane was excellent in the away win at Fulham, in which he scored, and at Newcastle on the final day. For Keane, Moyes represents a known quantity and, should he leave, the Blues boss would need to add a fourth-choice centre back to his list for this summer. Mason Holgate, who has spent the past two seasons on loan, is expected to depart this summer. Full-backs: A new chance to solve an old problem The right back position has been problematic for Everton for several years. It was accepted this was an area that needed strengthening last summer but, with money tight, the club gambled on being able to muddle through with veterans Seamus Coleman and Ashley Young, injury-plagued Nathan Patterson and, should it come to it, James Garner. At first, that plan looked problematic. Patterson and Coleman started the season injured and when Young was sent off on the first day of the campaign, Dyche turned to Holgate for the final minutes of the hammering by Brighton and Hove Albion. It was a decision that went down so badly, Under-21s youngster Roman Dixon started the next game at Tottenham Hotspur. Advertisement Young is leaving the club but Patterson will remain under contract and Moyes wants Coleman to extend his stay. He accepts Coleman's body is likely to prevent him from having an impact on the pitch - the 36-year-old was protected for the Goodison farewell against Southampton but lasted just 20 minutes. But he wants the leadership of the club captain in the dressing room during a summer of major transition. That opens the door for Patterson to finally nail down the right back slot. To do so, he will have to overcome serious competition though, with Everton entering the market open to finding a new first choice option. The Scotland international has had good spells on Merseyside but injuries have repeatedly halted his momentum and recent months have suggested Moyes has question marks over the former Rangers player. The Blues boss played O'Brien out of position ahead of the 23-year-old for months and was then frustrated with both Patterson and Vitalii Mykolenko in the build-up to the Ipswich Town equaliser at Goodison. He opted to start Young ahead of Patterson at Newcastle. Work is also expected at left back, an area Moyes accepted needed strengthening when he was appointed in January. Mykolenko's attacking threat has grown under Moyes and he provided the assist for Carlos Alcaraz's winner at St James' Park - adding to the one he picked up at Brentford when he crossed for O'Brien to score. But with Young having departed it is accepted Mykolenko needs competition and cover, so Everton's search this summer will include options on both sides of the defence. Advertisement Central Midfield: Moving away from a reliance on Idrissa Gueye Idrissa Gueye was the most impressive performer during the second half of the season and his influence belied his age. He is out of contract but he is one of the players whose future is being actively discussed and the 35-year-old showed few signs of dropping off as he continued to operate relentlessly in the middle. With the departure of Abdoulaye Doucoure, a player whose importance was undeniable across recent seasons, the loss of Gueye would leave a gaping hole in a midfield Moyes already wanted to improve. Should the Senegal international remain, there will still be efforts to create the midfield of the future around him given his age. James Garner will be around to support that transition. He became integral to Moyes in the final weeks of the season but enters the final year of his contract in July and so his future, potentially a new contract, will require thought. Advertisement This is an area Moyes believed Everton needed to strengthen in January - even before loanee Orel Mangala's season ended with ligament damage at Brighton - but was unable to find a way to do so. At the time he looked at Chelsea's Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall and Sean Longstaff and he retains an interest in both going into the summer. There is no expectation from Everton that Dewsbury-Hall will be available but Longstaff is surplus to requirements at Newcastle and is on the Blues' radar as Moyes assesses his options. Teen starlet Harrison Armstrong will be considered when pre-season begins with Moyes having travelled to watch the midfielder during his impressive loan spell in the Championship with Derby County while Tim Iroegbunam, who ended the season with a groin injury, will be another option. Moyes was keen to add goals to his midfield even before Doucoure's departure was signed off so will begin the summer searching for players who can produce in front of goal. He maintains admiration for Tomas Soucek, a favourite of his at West Ham United, but claims Everton have made enquiries for the Czech international have been dismissed at Finch Farm. A reunion with James Ward-Prowse has not been explored despite Moyes' frustration at the quality of set pieces since his return. Securing Alcaraz then further upgrading Everton's attacking midfield Another of Moyes' frustrations since January has been the lack of goals from the roles supporting his striker. The failure to provide a consistent thread of goals and assists has led to the returns of Jesper Lindstrom and Jack Harrison to their parent clubs, for now at least and was the reason Moyes opted against a move for Lyon winger Ernest Nuameh upon his arrival. Advertisement The departures of Lindstrom and Harrison mean Everton start the summer with no recognised senior right wingers. Dwight McNeil, Garner and Iliman Ndiaye have been used there but this is clearly a priority area for Moyes. Outgoing director of football Kevin Thelwell hoped to find a long-term solution last summer but his pursuits of Leeds United's Wilfried Gnonto, Newcastle's Yankuba Minteh and Jaden Philogene, then of Hull City, were unsuccessful. This is an area Everton want to address and it is not lost on anyone at the club that, with the search for a right back also underway, a new-look right side may need time to gel over pre-season. Ndiaye was one of the most impressive players of Everton's season and became a fan favourite following his move from Marseille, while McNeil is also a proven Premier League option on the left whose quality from set pieces adds to his value. Everton hope to make Carlos Alcaraz, who spent the second half of the season on loan from Flamengo, the club's first permanent signing of the summer and are confident a deal will be done by the end of May. There is also interest in Liverpool's Ben Doak, who has spent this season on loan with Middlesbrough. Advertisement Can Everton woo Liam Delap? Finally, Moyes has made no secret of his desire to tempt Liam Delap into a move to Everton. The striker, who scored 12 times in the league for relegated Ipswich Town, has held talks with the Blues as part of his exploration of the clubs keen to secure his signature - a long list that includes Manchester United and Chelsea. Everton can offer Delap the opportunity to be their leading forward and the star the new squad is built around as it moves to the state-of-the-art new stadium. It is expected Delap will make his decision in the coming days, with his release clause standing at £30m. What Everton do in the transfer market will largely depend on Delap's call. Dominic Calvert-Lewin has struggled with injuries but there is an acceptance his quality would be expensive to replace should he be able to stay fit. Meanwhile, Beto's goals proved crucial to pulling Everton to safety and the striker finished the season in solid form. A serious bid for the Guinea-Bissau forward would likely be contemplated but not if it was to strengthen a Premier League rival such as Leeds, who are reportedly interested in him. The forward line is one that remains fluid, therefore, and will likely depend on the knock-on effect of moves elsewhere in the market. Advertisement Youssef Chermiti adds a fourth option and he is likely to be assessed in pre-season, with his short term future potentially on loan. He has shown promise in glimpses but injuries have limited his exposure to first team football. Neal Maupay's loan move to Marseille included an obligation to make the move permanent, so he will not return.
