Cape York man committed to stand trial for murder of Indigenous woman 12 years ago
Warning: This article contains details said in court of threats and violence that some readers may find distressing.
A 23-year-old Kowanyama woman, known for cultural reasons as Ms Bernard, was last seen at a pub in the Cape York town of Coen on February 10, 2013.
Ms Bernard allegedly left the bar with Thomas Maxwell Byrnes, 63, with the intention of going to a quarry where he worked at Archer River, 68 kilometres north of Coen.
Ms Bernard's family reported her missing a few days later, which prompted a search of surrounding bushland, home to several disused mine shafts, but her body has never been found.
Mr Byrnes was charged with Ms Bernard's murder in January last year and has remained in custody since.
He has faced several committal hearings in the Cairns Magistrates Court since May, where several witnesses have been cross-examined.
In one instance, the former manager of the Exchange Hotel in Coen, Dean Lloyd, said Mr Byrnes was a regular patron at the bar.
Mr Lloyd told the court he recalled having a conversation with Mr Byrnes and another customer where they discussed the disappearance of Ms Bernard.
He said it appeared to him that Mr Byrnes was intoxicated.
"He then said, 'I took [Ms Bernard] from the pub and we were meant to go home,' something along those lines, and 'You know what happened next,'" he said.
Mr Lloyd said he "froze" and responded by saying that he did not know what happened next.
He said Mr Byrnes took a while to respond.
"He looked at me and [the other patron] and said, 'Youse f**king say anything, youse'll be put beside her and never found."
A regular visitor to the Coen Exchange Hotel, Jacqueline May Greenhalgh, told another hearing that she spoke with other regulars like Mr Byrnes.
She said words in a conversation with a group of people following Ms Bernard's disappearance were "etched" in her mind.
Ms Greenhalgh said Mr Byrnes made unexpected comments that Ms Bernard's body would not be found by authorities.
In a hearing on Tuesday, Coen resident Neville Shepherd told the court he had a conversation with Mr Byrnes in 2017 or 2018 when he said Ms Bernard had bitten him on the penis.
In the same conversation, Mr Shepherd said Mr Byrnes also said he'd "roughed her up".
Mr Byrnes's lawyer, James Sheridan, questioned Mr Shepherd's recollection of the conversation, noting Mr Shepherd had a hearing impairment.
Mr Sheridan asked Mr Shepherd if Mr Byrnes might have said, "She was a bit rough."
Mr Shepherd said that was possible.
He said Mr Byrnes also told him that Ms Bernard "took off" and he did not ask him what that meant.
Magistrate Scott Luxton committed Mr Byrnes to stand trial in the Cairns Supreme Court at a date to be set.
Mr Byrnes did not enter a plea and remains in custody.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
ABC News
28 minutes ago
- ABC News
Teens charged with murder after stabbing death of Zdravko Bilic on Sunshine Coast
Two teenage boys have been charged with murder following the stabbing death of 57-year-old Zdravko Bilic on Queensland's Sunshine Coast. A 15-year-old boy from West Woombye and a 17-year-old from Beerwah will appear in the Maroochydore Childrens Court this morning.
News.com.au
28 minutes ago
- News.com.au
Two teenagers charged with murder of Zdravko Bilic, 57, at his Sunshine Coast home
Two teenagers have been charged with the murder of a man who was found stabbed to death in front of his Sunshine Coast mansion. Zdravko Bilic, 57, was found unresponsive by a neighbour in the front yard of a home in Napalle St in Warana about 7.35pm on Monday. Police said he sustained two stab wounds to his abdomen. Police now allege there was a disturbance at the Napalle St home, leading to Mr Bilic being stabbed. A 15-year-old West Woombye boy and a 17-year-old Beerwah boy have since been charged with murder. They are set to appear in Maroochydore Childrens Court today.
ABC News
an hour ago
- ABC News
Bradley Murdoch's death presents glimmer of hope for finding Peter Falconio's remains
Bradley Murdoch's death presents an opportunity for a late break in Peter Falconio's cold case murder, a leading forensic anthropologist says. It comes as NT Police confirmed they had received tip-offs after last month announcing a $500,000 reward for information on the whereabouts of Mr Falconio's remains. Murdoch died overnight on Wednesday, 24 years after he killed Mr Falconio and kidnapped his partner, Joanne Lees, on a remote stretch of the Northern Territory's Stuart Highway in 2001. The 67-year-old, who had been receiving treatment for throat cancer, had continued to deny his crimes and was destined to die in prison after refusing to reveal the location of Mr Falconio's body. After news of Murdoch's death broke, Central Queensland University criminologist Xanthe Mallett said, "a lot can have changed" in almost a quarter of a century, and "people may now be able to speak that couldn't at the time". "There's always the chance that Bradley Murdoch would have shared some information, and people wouldn't have been able to share that until he's dead, so this may be an opportunity," she said. Dr Mallett said DNA could "remain active for decades" depending on "exactly how they've been left", making it possible to identify Mr Falconio if a new lead were to reveal his final resting place. "If human remains are found in the bush … whomever they are, if they're human remains, it's likely that they will be able to get DNA from them, either from the bones or from the teeth," she said. "So if that person's DNA is on record, as I'm sure Peter's would be, then you could do a match to those remains. "It's finding those remains in the first place that is going to be the key challenge." In a statement acknowledging Murdoch's death, the Northern Territory Police Force said it was "deeply regrettable that Murdoch has died without, as far as we are aware, ever disclosing the location of Peter Falconio's remains". "The Northern Territory Police Force remains committed to resolving this final piece of the investigation," it said. "We continue to appeal to anyone who may have information that could lead us to Peter Falconio's remains to come forward, no matter how small the detail may seem." Last month, NT Police announced a $500,000 reward for information leading to the discovery of Mr Falconio's remains, saying investigators still "hold out hope" of finding his body. "There may be someone out there that he's confided in — whether that's family and friends — we just don't know," Acting Commander Mark Grieve said in June. "It's a good opportunity for us to up the ante in regards to the reward. On Wednesday, an NT Police spokesperson said investigators were yet to verify tips they had received since increasing the reward. "The Northern Territory Police Force can confirm it has received information since the announcement of the reward; however, the information is yet to be verified," he said. In a statement to the ABC, Peter's parents, Luciano and Joan Falconio, said they continued to "hold out hope" their son's final resting place would be found. "We didn't have much faith, but we were hoping Bradley John Murdoch would reveal where Peter was before he died," they said. Upon hearing the news of Murdoch's death, Falconio's parents said their "first feeling was of relief". "It's like a weight that's been lifted," they said. "We are only forced to think about [Murdoch] now that he's died, we don't want to let him ruin our lives more than he already has. "The awful thing is our family's future with Peter was cruelly taken away. "Today, we instead focus on the three children we have left and our grandchildren." The family also expressed their "profound thanks" to the Northern Territory Police "for the support and continuing efforts to investigate our son's murder". During Murdoch's sentencing in 2005, Chief Justice Brian Martin said the killer put Mr Falconio's body into his vehicle before dumping it somewhere between Alice Springs and Broome — a distance spanning almost 1,700 kilometres. Dr Mallett said, unlike some other "no body cases", "the scale of the territory which the police would have to cover" meant recovering any remains would be challenging unless someone came forward. "Next year it'll be the 25th anniversary [so] the likelihood of them finding Peter's remains without significant intelligence — which we were all hoping was going to come from Murdoch — it's going to be very difficult," she said. Initial search efforts in July 2001 involved line and motorbike searches as well as aerial searches 60 kilometres north and south of the location where Mr Falconio was last seen alive. Extensive searches for Mr Falconio were again held in 2005. Dr Mallett said the increased scrutiny on the case after Murdoch's death would be "a really difficult time for Peter's family". "They would have been hoping that Bradley Murdoch would have had a change of heart, knowing that he was terminally ill, and would have shared information to help the police find Peter," she said. "We have to remember Joanne Lees in all of this, too. She lost a partner, she was devastated, and she was vilified as a result of this case. "So this will be a very hard time for people who knew and loved Peter, and I'm just sorry that they didn't get any answers before Bradley Murdoch died."
