Why Hong Kong is not ‘over' but must adapt to a changing world order
latest Bloomberg interview , former Morgan Stanley Asia chairman Stephen Roach said the escalating US-China conflict is providing Hong Kong with 'more of an opportunity than a threat, as I had originally envisioned'.
Advertisement
That was seen as a revision of his controversial remark in February 2024 that '
Hong Kong is over '. Such pessimism was not the first of its kind: recall Fortune magazine's cover story headlined 'The Death of Hong Kong' in June 1995, only to confess that they were wrong in a June 2007 article, 'Oops! Hong Kong is hardly dead'.
Roach argued previously that Hong Kong's demise reflected the confluence of three factors: domestic politics, the China factor, and global developments. He saw China's post-2019 clampdown as removing any remaining semblance of
local political autonomy . Hong Kong was also caught in the US-China crossfire and the spillover of mainland economic slowdown stemming from debt, deflation and demography.
Now, recognising the
local stock market rebound , Roach has emphasised Hong Kong's unique position as China's most important window to international finance such that it is 'experiencing maybe a revival because of its Chinese characteristics, not in spite of it'. But that feature of the city has not changed over time. Only the context might change.
The question is whether the city is suffering a temporary setback or walking down
a gloomy path . China is indeed the deciding factor. Like other pessimists, Roach held bleak assumptions about China's economic future and a linear interpretation of international politics. His latest statement has not clarified his real position.
Advertisement
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
South China Morning Post
3 hours ago
- South China Morning Post
With no US trade deal, China continues Brazil pivot for soybean supply
China slashed its soybean imports from the United States while increasing shipments from Brazil in July, a move that further reorients its supply from the world's top producer even as American farmers press Washington to negotiate for larger purchases of the crop in a hypothetical trade agreement. Last month, China imported 420,873 tonnes of soybeans from the US, down 11.47 per cent from a year earlier, according to a Wednesday data release by the General Administration of Customs in Beijing. The figures indicate China is continuing a gradual pivot towards Brazil to satisfy its vast demand for soybeans, as trade tensions with Washington persist and multiple rounds of talks have failed to produce the sort of wide-ranging deal that would include an increase in shipments of the sought-after legume. Imports from Brazil jumped 13.92 per cent year on year to 10.39 million tonnes in July, in stark contrast to the decline in US shipments. Overall, China's soybean imports rose 18.39 per cent year on year to 11.67 million tonnes in July, with Brazil accounting for nearly 90 per cent of its supply. The US' share stood at just under 4 per cent. In the first seven months of the year, China imported 61.03 million tonnes of soybeans, up 4.63 per cent from the year prior, with nearly 70 per cent sourced from Brazil and just over a quarter from the US. One of the US' most important agricultural exports, soybeans have been a point of leverage at a fraught time for bilateral relations. China relies heavily on imports for its supply, primarily used as animal feed and cooking oil.
South China Morning Post
5 hours ago
- South China Morning Post
Trump tariffs spark India-China reset, Chinese city's biotech dream: SCMP daily highlights
Catch up on some of SCMP's biggest China stories of the day. If you would like to see more of our reporting, please consider subscribing The world's two most-populous countries made significant progress on the diplomatic front recently, and those championing such moves may have Washington to thank. South China's Guangdong province has announced its ambition to join the country's race to expand its commercial space sector, promising financial and policy support for companies wanting to build low-orbit satellite constellation systems and promote their application in futuristic industries including space mining and space tourism. Ilustration: Brian Wang Could a city best known for its classical gardens and ancient canals emerge as China's answer to Boston – the global epicentre of biotechnology innovation?
South China Morning Post
5 hours ago
- South China Morning Post
Philippines assures China of restraint after ship clashes – will tensions ease?
Maritime tensions between the Philippines and China have entered what analysts describe as a risky and potentially volatile phase after an accidental collision between two Chinese vessels near Scarborough Shoal, one of the most contested features in the South China Sea The rare mishap involving the vessels from the Chinese coastguard and navy during a high-speed chase of a Philippine coastguard ship has raised the risk of Beijing adopting a more aggressive posture as it seeks to save face, potentially leading to further tensions in the disputed waters, according to analysts. Chester Cabalza, founding president of the International Development and Security Cooperation think tank in Manila, said the Chinese coastguard and navy could 'launch a thousand assets from the sea, cyber, air, and ground to redeem its military image in the region' because of the 'embarrassing collision'. Nonetheless, officials in Manila reaffirmed the Philippines' intention to exercise restraint while defending its sovereignty in response to the incident on August 11 and other subsequent maritime activities involving Chinese vessels. 'We will not be intimidated. And we will continue to have our presence felt to protect and defend sovereignty in our jurisdiction,' said Undersecretary Alexander Lopez, spokesman for the National Maritime Council, the government's coordinating and policymaking body on maritime concerns, during a press briefing on Monday. Borrowing a line from President Ferdinand Marcos Jnr , Lopez said: 'Now, we do not intensify operations, we just respond.'
