Why Hong Kong is not ‘over' but must adapt to a changing world order
In his
latest Bloomberg interview , former Morgan Stanley Asia chairman Stephen Roach said the escalating US-China conflict is providing Hong Kong with 'more of an opportunity than a threat, as I had originally envisioned'.
Advertisement
That was seen as a revision of his controversial remark in February 2024 that '
Hong Kong is over '. Such pessimism was not the first of its kind: recall Fortune magazine's cover story headlined 'The Death of Hong Kong' in June 1995, only to confess that they were wrong in a June 2007 article, 'Oops! Hong Kong is hardly dead'.
Roach argued previously that Hong Kong's demise reflected the confluence of three factors: domestic politics, the China factor, and global developments. He saw China's post-2019 clampdown as removing any remaining semblance of
local political autonomy . Hong Kong was also caught in the US-China crossfire and the spillover of mainland economic slowdown stemming from debt, deflation and demography.
Now, recognising the
local stock market rebound , Roach has emphasised Hong Kong's unique position as China's most important window to international finance such that it is 'experiencing maybe a revival because of its Chinese characteristics, not in spite of it'. But that feature of the city has not changed over time. Only the context might change.
The question is whether the city is suffering a temporary setback or walking down
a gloomy path . China is indeed the deciding factor. Like other pessimists, Roach held bleak assumptions about China's economic future and a linear interpretation of international politics. His latest statement has not clarified his real position.
Advertisement
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
South China Morning Post
30 minutes ago
- South China Morning Post
Civilian group hosts Taiwan tabletop simulation of attack from mainland China
A think tank in Taiwan has started a two-day war game with retired US and Japanese generals to simulate the island's defence in the event of a military attack from the Chinese mainland. The Taipei School of Economics and Political Science Foundation, which organised the tabletop exercise, said the aim was to 'identify the defence issues that Taiwan urgently needs to strengthen and provide recommendations for the government'. Described as the first operational-level military simulation by a civilian institution, the Taiwan Defence TTX event began on Tuesday. Among the invitees were nine retired generals and eight retired lieutenant generals from Taiwan, the US and Japan. They included Michael Mullen, who served as the 17th chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff from 2007 to 2011, and Dennis Blair, former US director of national intelligence, according to a report on Sunday by the Central News Agency. Takei Tomohisa, a former chief of staff of Japan's Maritime Self-Defence Force, and retired air force general Shigeru Iwasaki are also taking part in the exercise, the agency report said. The intention of the exercise is to discuss 'the feasibility of Taiwan's military strategy and operational concepts' in response to Beijing's use of force against Taiwan by 2030, it said. The foundation has not responded to an interview request from the South China Morning Post.
South China Morning Post
an hour ago
- South China Morning Post
Megaquake scare in Japan, Philippines boosts air power: 7 Asia highlights
We have selected seven stories from the SCMP's coverage of Asia over the past week that resonated with our readers and shed light on topical issues. If you would like to see more of our reporting, please consider subscribing A string of moderate earthquakes off the coast of Japan's northern island of Hokkaido has reignited concerns among experts and residents about the risk of a catastrophic seismic event – though scientists stress the tremors do not necessarily signal an impending disaster. Malaysia's Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim is facing a sexual harassment suit filed by his former aide, Muhammed Yusoff Rawther. Photo: AFP A crisis of credibility hangs over Malaysia's Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim as he prepares to face a sexual harassment suit later this month, the latest in a series of controversies that has rocked his administration and cast doubts over his reformist agenda.
South China Morning Post
an hour ago
- South China Morning Post
Hong Kong to offer 71,000 free MTR tickets to mark 28th handover anniversary: John Lee
A total of 71,000 free MTR tickets will be up for grabs on July 1 as part of citywide celebrations to commemorate the 28th anniversary of Hong Kong's return to Chinese rule, the chief executive has said. City leader John Lee Ka-chiu also said on Tuesday he would bring forward his annual policy address by a month to September, in light of the Legislative Council election scheduled for the end of this year. Public consultation is set to kick off on Monday next week. He said the government would host a series of events across 18 districts to celebrate the July 1 anniversary , including flag-raising ceremonies, carnivals, gala shows and sports games. 'The government will also collaborate with the different sectors to launch diversified benefits to allow residents to enjoy the joyous occasion,' Lee added. According to Lee, rail giant the MTR Corporation will offer 71,000 digital tickets on July 1 through lucky draws. Winning residents will redeem a free MTR ticket for designated routes within half a year. Chief Executive John Lee says he will bring forward his annual policy address by a month to September. Photo: Dickson Lee Airport Express would also provide free services to children aged between 3 and 11 that day, while the elderly aged 60 and beyond enjoy half-priced tickets.
