Concerns KiwiSaver Is Being Used As ‘Piggy Bank' To Solve Financial Woes
A growing number of New Zealanders are making hardship withdrawals from their retirement savings.
, Money Correspondent
KiwiSaver is in danger of being considered a 'piggy bank' to solve all of New Zealanders' financial woes, one provider says, and too many people are tapping into their savings on hardship grounds.
Founder of Kōura KiwiSaver scheme Rupert Carlyon was wary of calls for settings to be changed to allow people to use their money to buy farms.
He said KiwiSaver was already being called on to solve the country's housing and infrastructure crises.
Carlyon said changing the rules to allow more withdrawals sent the wrong message to people, who should be using KiwiSaver for their retirement.
Instead, they were tapping into KiwiSaver in growing numbers.
In April, 4220 people withdrew savings for financial hardship reasons, up from 3700 in April 2024. They withdrew a combined $37.6 million.
'It encourages more and more people to think about it like a piggybank. It's scary what's happening in that space,' he said.
He said he saw people making repeated hardship withdrawals, depleting their balance.
'People come back multiple times with the same claims… it's hard to figure out what's real and what's not.'
He said it would now not be possible to close the 'hardship loophole' because people expected it to be available and any change could dent confidence in the scheme.
But he said it should be tightened up so there was a limit on the number of withdrawals that could be made within a certain timeframe.
'The other part is it's very resource intensive. We spend on average up to six hours per financial hardship claim… It's hard on staff because they often have to say no when they want to say yes.'
A spokesperson for Public Trust, one of the KiwiSaver supervisors, said people were not required to repay hardship withdrawals if it was found they were not necessary.
'Their future self might not thank them for dipping into their retirement savings. We see situations of real and urgent need… there are strict rules and checks in place to help ensure withdrawals are only approved for genuine financial hardship, and applicants need to sign a legal declaration confirming their situation.
'If someone doesn't use funds as intended, it could affect their ability to make another hardship withdrawal in the future.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Otago Daily Times
25 minutes ago
- Otago Daily Times
600 rental homes planned in Queenstown development
Six hundred build-to-rent units are on the way for Queenstown in a $500 million Simplicity Living development. The company owned by KiwiSaver and investment funds is managed by Simplicity NZ Ltd. It has already built 210 homes across Auckland, with another 889 under construction. It has just acquired a 6.1ha site on Ladies Mile, north of the Stalker Rd roundabout, for its first development outside the City of Sails, with an aspiration to build 2000 homes in the resort. Simplicity NZ managing director Sam Stubbs said they were working closely with the Queenstown Lakes District Council on the infrastructure required to enable construction to start. Once that was in place, and they had the necessary consents, "we're ready to go". Based on the Auckland developments, the first tenants could be living there within 13 months of the start. "We've always had our eye down here, because we thought that the economics of Queenstown makes sense because it's growing, the rents are good, and there's this massive need for housing people who live here," he said. The Queenstown development will likely comprise three-storey walk-up apartments, in one-, two- and three-bed configurations, noting there was a huge gap in the market for one- and two-bedders. Two live-in managers will also be employed. The units will primarily be built using concrete, brick and local schist, with an expected lifespan of over 150 years. "The idea for us on this one ... is to do a lot of green space, a lot of carparks, a lot of outdoor storage, because it's got to be Queenstown-specific," Mr Stubbs said. While initially the homes will be for long-term rent, they may consider selling some to retirees or first-home buyers. He also believed they would be able to build them "slightly cheaper" than in Auckland and while he could not put a figure on the rental cost, he noted Simplicity Living's rents were usually 5%-10% below market value. Regardless, Queenstown rents would justify the development cost. Queenstown Lakes Community Housing Trust chief executive Julie Scott said the proposed development "interconnects" with the work the trust was doing. The trust had 1480 eligible households on its waiting list, "and we know that we can't ... house them all tomorrow, or even in the next few years". Before work can start, though, infrastructure to the site needs to be sorted. Mr Stubbs said Simplicity wanted to help with that, too, but noted the council was getting all of the Ladies Mile landowners together to have a look at what was required — "we've never had that happen before". Queenstown Mayor Glyn Lewers said the "$60 million question" was who would pay for it. "We're quite happy for [the developer] to put the infrastructure in, and then we'll offset the development contributions at the other end when it comes to creating title. "Our debt limits and our capacity to do that front-loading of infrastructure, especially within growth nodes in this district, has become quite tight. "We'll put in where we can, and where we need to, but the way we're structured financially at the moment, we're looking for partnerships to actually provide this great social benefit." However, council was committed to working it out because the outcome was "so beneficial" to the area. Mr Lewers said he had been having "quite intense" conversations with NZ Transport Agency Waka Kotahi about potential solutions for traffic implications. "The regional deal construct certainly helps that conversation."
Otago Daily Times
39 minutes ago
- Otago Daily Times
Job losses 'inevitable' in cruise industry slump
By Felix Walton of RNZ The cruise sector hopes crisis talks at this year's industry conference will help chart a course through rocky financial waters. The theme of this year's NZ Cruise Association Conference - 'This is Not a Drill' - speaks for itself. Passenger numbers have fallen year on year, down 20 percent last summer and projected to fall another 20 percent this year, but NZCA chief executive Jacqui Lloyd maintains an optimistic outlook. "It is a little [like] crisis talks, but there is also a lot of positivity," she told RNZ, between panel discussions from the conference in Napier. "[We're talking about] how we all need to work together, and make sure that the messaging is going out around central and local government on how important cruise is for regional economies, particularly our tourism and hospitality operators." Lloyd expected 660 port calls and about 215,000 cruise passengers to visit New Zealand shores in the 2025/26 season. "That's down from 1120 port calls in 2023/24 and around 330,000 passengers." She said the industry could do little to adapt, rather policy change was needed to keep it from sinking. "We'd rather not adapt, to be honest. We'd like to instead make sure that we get some return in that business, and a key part of it has been around working with government on regulatory changes, transparency on increased costs, and also biosecurity risks." Lloyd said New Zealand was particularly harsh on biofouling - the build-up of algae and other microorganisms on a ship's hull. "[There's a] risk of being turned away, because we don't have a safety net in New Zealand to allow any kind of cleaning, if ships do have any issues, and cruise lines have to go off the 12-mile limit, and wait for a calm day for a diver to go down and clean the ship. "Meanwhile, passengers are on board, wondering why they're not at the destination that they had planned, so that's a real strong risk from a brand reputation and cost reputation." Lloyd said representatives from Ports of Auckland had also spoken at the conference about their plans to facilitate in-water cleaning for visiting ships. "Ports of Auckland has been speaking today about the trials they're doing for in-water cleaning, which has been positive, and they are working with MPI on how they might be able to do that going forward," she explained "That's safe cleaning, not only for the ship, but also New Zealand's environment. We don't want to let any nasties into our waters and cause concerns with our aquaculture industry." Meanwhile, the volatility of New Zealand's tourism policies were problematic for operators that often planned cruises years in advance. "Passengers will book their cruises two years in advance and we've had cases recently where government agencies have increased costs by $11, $12, $20 per passenger, with only a very short two- to three-month window," she said. These challenges were causing a decline in New Zealand's global reputation as a cruise destination. "[It was] interesting talking to Princess Cruises today, who spoke at conference, and talked about the fact that the searches for New Zealand and Australia for Princess are down quite considerably on what they have been previously," Lloyd said. "We will need to do a lot of work, as a nation, to promote passengers to come back to our shores." She said job losses would be inevitable. "There will be [job losses], and that will predominantly be through hospitality and tourism providers, drivers for coaches, likely within ports for teams that usually will look after cruise vessels. "There are 10,000 jobs created by [the cruise industry] in the 2023/24 season and we do have concerns that we'll see a reduction for this season coming." Viv Beck, the chief executive of central Auckland's business association Heart of the City, said cruises were an essential source of visitors. "[Cruises] are really important and particularly at a time where spending is down, and we've had severe impacts with construction and Covid-19, and all of the above," she said. "This is one of the means of getting people in here and they arrive right on our doorstep at the bottom of Queen Street. "A reduction in numbers is definitely going to be missed."
RNZ News
an hour ago
- RNZ News
Cruise industry brainstorms over falling foreign visitor numbers
The volatility of New Zealand's tourism policies are problematic for operators. Photo: NZ Herald/Paul Taylor The cruise sector hopes crisis talks at this year's industry conference will help chart a course through rocky financial waters. The theme of this year's NZ Cruise Association Conference - 'This is Not a Drill' - speaks for itself. Passenger numbers have fallen year on year , down 20 percent last summer and projected to fall another 20 percent this year, but NZCA chief executive Jacqui Lloyd maintains an optimistic outlook. "It is a little [like] crisis talks, but there is also a lot of positivity," she told RNZ, between panel discussions from the conference in Napier. "[We're talking about] how we all need to work together, and make sure that the messaging is going out around central and local government on how important cruise is for regional economies, particularly our tourism and hospitality operators." Lloyd expected 660 port calls and about 215,000 cruise passengers to visit New Zealand shores in the 2025/26 season. "That's down from 1120 port calls in 2023/24 and around 330,000 passengers." She said the industry could do little to adapt, rather policy change was needed to keep it from sinking. "We'd rather not adapt, to be honest. We'd like to instead make sure that we get some return in that business, and a key part of it has been around working with government on regulatory changes, transparency on increased costs, and also biosecurity risks." Lloyd said New Zealand was particularly harsh on biofouling - the build-up of algae and other microorganisms on a ship's hull. "[There's a] risk of being turned away, because we don't have a safety net in New Zealand to allow any kind of cleaning, if ships do have any issues, and cruise lines have to go off the 12-mile limit, and wait for a calm day for a diver to go down and clean the ship. "Meanwhile, passengers are on board, wondering why they're not at the destination that they had planned, so that's a real strong risk from a brand reputation and cost reputation." Lloyd said representatives from Ports of Auckland had also spoken at the conference about their plans to facilitate in-water cleaning for visiting ships. "Ports of Auckland has been speaking today about the trials they're doing for in-water cleaning, which has been positive, and they are working with MPI on how they might be able to do that going forward," she explained "That's safe cleaning, not only for the ship, but also New Zealand's environment. We don't want to let any nasties into our waters and cause concerns with our aquaculture industry." Meanwhile, the volatility of New Zealand's tourism policies were problematic for operators that often planned cruises years in advance. "Passengers will book their cruises two years in advance and we've had cases recently where government agencies have increased costs by $11, $12, $20 per passenger, with only a very short two to three-month window," she said. These challenges were causing a decline in New Zealand's global reputation as a cruise destination. "[It was] interesting talking to Princess Cruises today, who spoke at conference, and talked about the fact that the searches for New Zealand and Australia for Princess are down quite considerably on what they have been previously," Lloyd said. "We will need to do a lot of work, as a nation, to promote passengers to come back to our shores." She said job losses would be inevitable. "There will be [job losses], and that will predominantly be through hospitality and tourism providers, drivers for coaches, likely within ports for teams that usually will look after cruise vessels. "There are 10,000 jobs created by [the cruise industry] in the 2023/24 season and we do have concerns that we'll see a reduction for this season coming." Viv Beck, the chief executive of central Auckland's business association Heart of the City, said cruises were an essential source of visitors. "[Cruises] are really important and particularly at a time where spending is down, and we've had severe impacts with construction and Covid-19, and all of the above," she said. "This is one of the means of getting people in here and they arrive right on our doorstep at the bottom of Queen Street. "A reduction in numbers is definitely going to be missed." Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
