Google loses appeal in suit filed by 'Fortnite' maker Epic Games as app store verdict upheld
The San Francisco-based 9th US Circuit Court of Appeals rejected claims from Google that the trial judge made legal errors in the antitrust case that unfairly benefited 'Fortnite' maker Epic Games, which filed the lawsuit in 2020.
Epic accused Google of monopolizing how consumers access apps on Android devices and pay for transactions within apps.
Advertisement
'Fortnite' maker Epic Games accused Google of monopolizing how consumers access apps on Android devices and pay for transactions within apps.
AFP via Getty Images
The Cary, North Carolina-based company convinced a San Francisco jury in 2023 that Google illegally stifled competition.
US District Judge James Donato in San Francisco ordered Google in October to restore competition by allowing users to download rival app stores within its Play store and by making Play's app catalog available to those competitors, among other reforms.
Donato's order was on hold pending the outcome of the 9th Circuit appeal.
Advertisement
The court's decision can be appealed to the US Supreme Court.
Google told the appeals court that the tech company's Play store competes with Apple's App Store, and that Donato unfairly barred Google from making that point to contest Epic's antitrust claims.
The tech giant also argued that a jury should never have heard Epic's lawsuit because it sought to enjoin Google's conduct — a request normally decided by a judge — and not collect damages.
Advertisement
Epic has defended the verdict and court injunction, telling the 9th Circuit judges that the Android app market has been 'suffering under anti-competitive behavior for the better part of a decade.'
Google told the appeals court that the tech company's Play store competes with Apple's App Store, and that the judge unfairly barred Google from making that point to contest Epic's antitrust claims.
SOPA Images/LightRocket via Getty Images
In the trial court and in the appeal, Epic disputed arguments by Google that changes to its app business ordered by the court would harm user privacy and security.
Microsoft filed a brief backing Epic, as did the Justice Department and Federal Trade Commission.
Advertisement
Epic separately is battling Apple over a US judge's order requiring the iPhone maker to give developers greater freedom to steer consumers to make purchases outside its App Store.
Apple has appealed a ruling that said it violated a prior injunction in a lawsuit that Epic filed in 2020.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Post
2 minutes ago
- New York Post
Berkshire takes $3.8 billion Kraft Heinz writedown, profit falls
Warren Buffett's Berkshire Hathaway said on Saturday it took a $3.76 billion writedown on its stake in Kraft Heinz during the second quarter, an acknowledgment the decade-old investment hasn't worked out. Berkshire also reported a 4% decline in quarterly operating profit as insurance underwriting premiums fell. The writedown and lower gains from common stocks caused a 59% drop in overall net income. Buffett's conglomerate signaled it remains cautious about market valuations, amid uncertainty about tariffs and growth in the broader economy. 6 Berkshire reported a near-record $344.1 billion cash stake for the second quarter. REUTERS It reported a near-record $344.1 billion cash stake, and sold more stocks than it bought for an 11th straight quarter. As of mid-July, Berkshire hadn't repurchased any of its own stock since May 2024. Buffett, 94, has led Omaha, Nebraska-based Berkshire since 1965, though he plans to step down at year-end. 'Investors are getting antsy and want to seek activity, and nothing is happening,' said Kyle Sanders, an analyst at Edward Jones. 'Buffett definitely views the market as overvalued, and will sit back and wait for something to come to him.' 6 Berkshire CEO Warren Buffett said he will leave the post at the end of this year. AP Uncertainty about trade policies, including tariffs, has become a headwind as delayed orders and shipments led to declining revenue at most of Berkshire's consumer businesses. Jazwares, which makes the popular Squishmallows plush toys, saw revenue fall 38.5% in the year's first half. Analysts viewed overall results as lackluster. 'Berkshire and the economy are at an inflection point,' said Cathy Seifert, a CFRA Research analyst. 'I don't think the market will embrace the combination of mediocre results, a lack of stock buybacks, and Berkshire's recent share underperformance amid a management transition.' Seifert and Sanders rate Berkshire 'hold.' Second-quarter operating income fell to $11.16 billion, or about $7,760 per Class A share, from $11.6 billion a year earlier. Results included $877 million of currency losses as the U.S. dollar weakened. Net income, including gains and losses on stocks such as Apple and American Express, fell to $12.37 billion from $30.35 billion. Revenue fell 1% to $92.52 billion. Buffett views unrealized investment gains and losses, including on stocks Berkshire has no plans to sell, as often meaningless to understanding his company. 6 Kraft Heinz said last month it would consider strategic alternatives, including a breakup. Getty Images The $3.76 billion after-tax writedown for Berkshire's 27.4% Kraft Heinz stake, equal to $5 billion before taxes, followed the struggling food company's announcement it would consider strategic alternatives, which could include a breakup. Berkshire had carried Kraft Heinz on its books at above-market value but said economic and other uncertainties, and its longer-term plans to remain an investor, made the gap 'other-than-temporary.' The writedown is Berkshire's second for Kraft Heinz, following a $3 billion writedown in 2019. Buffett acknowledged at the time that Berkshire overpaid in the 2015 merger of Kraft Foods and H.J. Heinz, one of his biggest investment missteps. Kraft Heinz has suffered as more shoppers favor healthier and private-label alternatives. Its approximately 200 brands include Oscar Mayer, Kool-Aid, Velveeta and Jell-O. 6 Kraft Heinz's plant in Montreal. JHVEPhoto – Berkshire also carries another big investment, its 28.1% stake in Occidental Petroleum at $5.3 billion above fair value, but reported no need for a writedown. Shares of Berkshire have fallen more than 12%, and lagged the S&P 500 by about 22 percentage points, since Buffett announced on May 3 he would step down as chief executive at year end. Vice Chairman Greg Abel, 63,will succeed him, though Buffett will remain chairman. Analysts said the premium embedded in Berkshire's stock price because of the presence of Buffett, arguably the world's most well-known investor, has eroded, while growth may slow in the insurance sector, a major Berkshire profit center. 6 Berkshire shares have fallen more than 12% since CEO Warren Buffett announced his departure on May 3. AP The lack of new investments has also been a drag. Analysts believe Berkshire's BNSF unit could buy CSX to create another transcontinental railroad, after Union Pacific agreed last week to acquire Norfolk Southern. Buffett transformed Berkshire over six decades from a troubled and since-closed textile company into a $1.02 trillion conglomerate. Berkshire owns several insurers and reinsurers, electric utility and renewable energy businesses, several chemical and industrial companies, and familiar consumer brands such as Dairy Queen, Fruit of the Loom and See's Candies. Berkshire said the 12% quarterly decline in insurance underwriting profit stemmed primarily from reinsurance businesses and some smaller insurance businesses. 6 Warren Buffett has led Berkshire since 1965. AFP via Getty Images Geico, its best-known insurance business, saw pre-tax underwriting profit rise 2%, as a 5% increase in premiums offset a smaller rise in accident losses. The car insurer has been ceding market share to State Farm and Progressive, while focusing on improving underwriting quality and technology and cutting jobs. Analysts said higher tariffs could be a headwind for Geico if the cost of auto parts rose, potentially increasing losses from accident claims. BNSF is also cutting expenses. Lower fuel costs helped boost quarterly profit 19% gain, though revenue and cargo volumes barely changed. The energy business, Berkshire Hathaway Energy, posted a 7% profit increase. Berkshire said it is evaluating the impact of the One Big Beautiful Bill Act, signed last month by President Trump, on the 'economics and viability' of its renewable energy, storage and technology-neutral projects.
Forbes
3 minutes ago
- Forbes
Google Just Cut The Price Of The Pixel 9a To Its Lowest-Ever, But Not For Long
Google released its latest smartphone, the Pixel 9a, in April 2025. It was already the most affordable smartphone in the range, but Google has just announced a new price, $100 off, but only for the next two weeks. The Pixel 9a went on sale for $499 for the model with 128GB storage. It comes in four colors, peony, which is a blazing-bright pink color, iris (a sort of purple), plus two quieter shades, porcelain and obsidian (off-white and black). It came with an evolved design: the raised camera bar of the Pixel 9 series has been replaced by a pair of lenses that barely protrude at all. It has Google's Gemini AI baked in, a battery that the company claims lasts all day and seven years of updates. 13-megaixel front-facing camera. There's a 13-megapixel front-facing camera and two rear cameras, one with 48 megapixel resolution, and an ultra wide with a 13-megapixel sensor. At $499, it is priced at $300 less than the regular Pixel 9 (which costs $799) and $100 less than the Pixel 8 Pro from 2023. But right now, it's cheaper still, with the Pixel 9a with 128GB storage available with $100 off, dropping the price to $399. This price is available direct from Google from its store in the U.S. This offer is only available for two weeks, that is, until Aug. 17, 2025 at 11.59 Pacific. You could choose the model with more storage, 256GB, which has also dropped in price and is available for as long as the offer runs for $499 instead of $599. Again, Google has all four colors available at this storage level, too. This reduced price, which represents 20% off the 128GB model and 17% off the 256GB version, is also available from Amazon, which has all four colors for the smaller storage capacity, and obsidian and iris for the larger-capacity model.
Miami Herald
an hour ago
- Miami Herald
Apple CEO drops bombshell about its future
Apple is notoriously tight-to-the-vest when it comes to making announcements, preferring to keep loyal fans and die-hard investors in the dark until the timing is right. The company's 'one more thing' mentality, reflected by founder Steve Jobs's surprising product reveals at Apple keynote conferences, appears shared by current CEO Tim Cook. In contrast to other big tech leaders, including Elon Musk, Cook often lets Apple's products do the talking. As a result, investors often look closely at Cook's comments during conference calls, looking for clues to what he may have planned for the company next. During Apple's second-quarter earnings conference call, Cook may have dropped his guard a little when he offered an interesting response about Apple's massive cash stockpile and artificial intelligence ambitions. Apple reported a solid June quarter that outpaced analysts' expectations. Revenue was a whopping $94 billion, up 10% year over year, and almost $5 billion better than Wall Street expected. Net income was over $23 billion, resulting in earnings per share, or EPS, of $1.57, up 12% from one year ago, and 14 cents ahead of estimates. Related: Veteran analyst spots unexpected star in Apple's earnings report The company's massive profit lifted its cash hoard to about $36 billion from roughly $30 billion last year, giving it plenty of financial firepower to invest in its products and software. And that's precisely what investors want to see happen. While competitors like Google have gone all in on artificial intelligence, developing the AI chatbot Gemini, Apple's AI strategy has been criticized as too little, too late. The company's arguably slow development of AI solutions relative to peers has left many investors wondering if Tim Cook's number-crunching mindset sets Apple on a course of missing out on the most significant opportunity since the dawn of the Internet. However, during Apple's earnings conference call, Cook acknowledged that he'd consider accelerating Apple's AI efforts by using its massive cash war chest. When Citi analyst Atif Malik asked about the prospects of "big M&A," Cook responded bluntly. "We've acquired around seven companies this year," said Cook on the call. "We're very open to M&A that accelerates our road map… We are not stuck on a certain size company." Cook said he didn't have anything to announce currently, but his willingness to consider a big deal could mean that reports of interest in Perplexity, a major AI player, may have merit. Cook aims to accelerate Apple's development timeline, ostensibly via internal research and development and smaller bolt-on deals. However, if he really wanted to, he could do a deal to acquire Perplexity that could, as he put it, "help us accelerate a road map." Related: Apple looks to ditch Goldman Sachs for big bank rival Perplexity provides an AI chatbot similar to Google and OpenAI's ChatGPT, but there are key differences. It has its own in-house model, Sonar, that's built on Meta Platforms' Llama open source code. It's also leaned on rival chatbots, including DeepSeek's R1. Subscribers to its Pro tier can also toggle between other large language models, including OpenAI, Gemini, Anthropic's Claude, and Elon Musk's Grok. Acquiring Perplexity would instantly give Apple an established model for monetizing AI. Perplexity operates on a freemium model, with a no-cost introductory subscription and paid service. Perplexity prioritizes real-time insight with direct responses-a design that arguably matches Apple's deep focus on user experience. In short, Perplexity's desire for a better chatbot user experience aligns nicely with Apple's approach, historically. Cook says Apple has acquired seven companies this year, about one "every several weeks." Those deals, however, are small and haven't cost the company much of its war chest. Buying Perplexity would be a different story. Perplexity, which launched in 2022 around the same time as ChatGPT, has over 22 million monthly active users. Its annualized revenue could hit $150 million this summer, according to About Chromebooks data, up from an ARR of $63 million exiting last year. The company's rapid user growth translated into Perplexity answering 780 million queries in May, according to which was up from 230 million in August 2024. Also in May, its website recorded 153 million visits, about triple the number from March. Perplexity isn't publicly traded, is currently reportedly valued at $18 billion, and its AI search market share is about 6%. Related: Apple announces major store closing and new opening The Arena Media Brands, LLC THESTREET is a registered trademark of TheStreet, Inc.
