logo
Suspending police officers for Karnataka stampede looks like scapegoating: Think tank

Suspending police officers for Karnataka stampede looks like scapegoating: Think tank

Hindustan Times3 days ago

New Delhi, The suspension of five police officers before the completion of a detailed investigation into the RCB victory celebrations-linked stampede in Karnataka would be seen as "scapegoating" and may have a "demoralising" effect on the entire force, an independent think tank on policing has told the state chief minister.
The Delhi-based Indian Police Foundation has also said "isolating" the police force for "punitive" action, while other stakeholders escape scrutiny, distorts the reality of shared responsibility and "misses" the opportunity to draw "comprehensive" lessons for the future.
The June 4 stampede outside the Chinnaswamy Stadium in Bengaluru led to the death of 11 people, while 56 were injured, as a large number of people thronged to participate in the Royal Challenger Bengaluru team's IPL victory celebrations.
The Karnataka government has suspended Bengaluru Police Commissioner B Dayananda and four other senior police officials on the charge of dereliction of duty.
The state government has also appointed a one-man inquiry commission under retired Karnataka High Court judge John Michael Cunha to probe the incident.
The IPF, a private think tank on policing subjects with a number of retired police chiefs and civil servants on its panel, wrote a two-page letter to Karnataka Chief Minister Siddaramaiah on Monday.
The letter, accessed by PTI, said the suspension of the five police officials has raised "serious concerns" within the professional policing community across the country.
"Actions taken without establishing individual responsibility would be seen as scapegoating rather than principled accountability and may have a demoralising effect on the entire police force, while undermining institutional integrity," the IPF said.
Large public events of this nature, it said, especially when held at such a short notice and without adequate time for preparatory work, require "coordinated" efforts among multiple civic, administrative and political agencies.
The think tank urged the Karnataka government to "reinstate" the suspended officers and said disciplinary action, if warranted, should follow from the findings and not precede those.
The IPF also offered the services of its multi-disciplinary expert members for conducting a post-incident review and analysis of the stampede.
"This would be a non-adversarial, independent exercise, not intended for fault-finding, but focused on identifying systemic gaps, good practices and actionable lessons to guide police operations and training," it said.
The foundation offered condolences to the bereaved families and said it fully supports a fair, impartial and transparent inquiry into the tragedy.
Former Union home secretary G K Pillai, former Meghalaya governor and retired IPS officer R S Mooshahary, former HDFC chairman Deepak Parekh, former Uttar Pradesh DGP O P Singh and former CBI director Rishi Kumar Shukla are among the IPF members.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Girl runs away to meet BF, his parents alert her family
Girl runs away to meet BF, his parents alert her family

Time of India

timean hour ago

  • Time of India

Girl runs away to meet BF, his parents alert her family

Nagpur: Acting responsibly, an Azamgarh-based family in Uttar Pradesh alerted the parents of a 17-year-old standard X student from Nagpur, who had landed up at their residence after falling in love with their son. The minor girl had befriended the youngster from Azamgarh on a social media platform, and developed a relationship over the last few months ago. Sources said that the Azamgarh youngster had sponsored the minor girl's ticket to take a bus to his hometown on June 4. After she reached Azamgarh, the youngster took her to his home and expressed his desire to marry her. The youngster's family, realising the girl was still a minor, immediately alerted her parents, who were already searching for her. An offence had also been registered at Old Kamptee police station following the family's complaint. Immediately afterwards, the Azamgarh family ensured the girl returned to the city by train on June 6. She was taken into custody by senior inspector Lalita Todase's team of the anti-human trafficking unit of the crime branch. After counselling, the girl was reunited with her family, and accordingly, the Old Kamptee police station was also informed.

Three mule a/c holders held in 3cr matrimonial scam
Three mule a/c holders held in 3cr matrimonial scam

Time of India

time2 hours ago

  • Time of India

Three mule a/c holders held in 3cr matrimonial scam

Pune: Pimpri Chinchwad cybercrime police have arrested three mule bank account holders from New Delhi following an investigation into a complaint of a 45-year-old manager of a private firm in Pimpri Chinchwad, who lost Rs3.16 crore in a matrimonial scam between June 2023 and Sept 2024. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now The scam started when the woman, victim in the scam, came into contact with a 'US-based NRI' via a matrimonial website in May 2023. The man told her that he was running a business in Alaska and promised to marry her. They started talking and video-calling. Later, the man started requesting the woman to help him financially and told her that he was suffering losses in business. The woman started transferring money to him. He used to give different reasons including money for regularizing bank account in Dubai, medical treatment, repaying loans, and air-ticket expenditure from Dubai to New Delhi and New Delhi to Venezuela, the police said. At one point, he also asked money from the victim by claiming that he was detained at Istanbul airport in Turkey, police said, adding that the woman kept providing money and eventually transferred Rs3.16 crore between June 2023 and Sept 2024. When she came to realize that she was cheated, the woman suffered depression. It is only after her relative convicsed her to file a complaint in March 2025, she approached the police. Senior inspector Ravikiran Nale of the Pimpri Chinchwad cybercrime police said that two teams, led by assistant inspector Pravin Swami and sub-inspector Sagar Poman, were deployed to investigate. "The teams found that Rs 3.16 crore were transferred to 81 bank accounts and from these accounts, the money went into 400 accounts. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now Most of these accounts belonged to different banks in New Delhi," he said. The police investigations also revealed that 11 bank accounts were opened two years ago using a single rent agreement. "Sub-inspector Poman and his team reached New Delhi to trace people who opened these 11 accounts. The team found that the account holders had changed their cellphone numbers. With technical investigation, sub-inspector Poman took Sikandar Khan (21) into custody from Jonapur in Delhi. Khan then revealed names of two more suspects, Ranjit Yadav (27) and his brother Bablu Yadav (25), both from Jonapur. Ranjit Yadav had accepted Rs 36.96 lakh into his account," he said. The arrested people used to contact their handler using a mobile messenger application to avoid tracing. "We have ascertained the identity of their handler and our search is underway to find other suspects in the case," said Nale.

One held for robbing shopkeeper via dating app; Two absconding
One held for robbing shopkeeper via dating app; Two absconding

Time of India

time2 hours ago

  • Time of India

One held for robbing shopkeeper via dating app; Two absconding

Pune: The Faraskhana police on Wednesday arrested a 19-year-old man from Mangalwar Peth and searching for his two accomplices after the trio robbed a shopkeeper (33) after befriending the latter using a dating application. The shopkeeper is a resident of Shagun Chowk on Laxmi Road. He lodged a complaint with the police on Tuesday morning. According to the police, the victim had a dating application and one of the suspects contacted the victim over it. The suspect befriended the victim and asked the latter to visit a secluded spot in the June Bazaar area. "When the victim reached the spot, three accused threatened him of dire consequence and robbed his cellphone around 6.35am on Monday. The three accused, one of them with knife, used UPI application of the victimi and transferred Rs 60,000," said senior inspector Prashant Bhasme of Faraskhana police. "We have arrested Wahid Razzak Shaikh of Mangalwar Peth after analyzing the UPI transaction," he said. Shaikh was produced before a city court and the court remanded him in police custody until June 16, Bhasme said. "Shaikh was earlier arrested by the Bund Garden police in a similar crime where he and his accomplices robbed a Pimpri Chinchwad-based man near RTO Chowk. He was out on bail," he said.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store